<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" version="2.0" xmlns:itunes="http://www.itunes.com/dtds/podcast-1.0.dtd" xmlns:googleplay="http://www.google.com/schemas/play-podcasts/1.0"><channel><title><![CDATA[Free the Inquiry]]></title><description><![CDATA[Free The Inquiry is Heterodox Academy’s home for essays, expert commentary, and conversations about open inquiry in the academy.]]></description><link>https://www.freetheinquiry.com</link><generator>Substack</generator><lastBuildDate>Sat, 21 Nov 2026 06:05:33 GMT</lastBuildDate><atom:link href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml"/><copyright><![CDATA[Heterodox Academy]]></copyright><language><![CDATA[en]]></language><webMaster><![CDATA[heterodoxacademy@substack.com]]></webMaster><itunes:owner><itunes:email><![CDATA[heterodoxacademy@substack.com]]></itunes:email><itunes:name><![CDATA[Heterodox Academy]]></itunes:name></itunes:owner><itunes:author><![CDATA[Heterodox Academy]]></itunes:author><googleplay:owner><![CDATA[heterodoxacademy@substack.com]]></googleplay:owner><googleplay:email><![CDATA[heterodoxacademy@substack.com]]></googleplay:email><googleplay:author><![CDATA[Heterodox Academy]]></googleplay:author><itunes:block><![CDATA[Yes]]></itunes:block><item><title><![CDATA[How Might the Academy Undermine Democratic Legitimacy?]]></title><description><![CDATA[A philosopher argues that the academy's unaccountable influence over the people who shape public debate is a problem for democratic legitimacy.]]></description><link>https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/how-might-the-academy-undermine-democratic</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/how-might-the-academy-undermine-democratic</guid><dc:creator><![CDATA[Hrishikesh Joshi]]></dc:creator><pubDate>Thu, 19 Nov 2026 13:03:29 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://api.substack.com/feed/podcast/225545274/b422a76e23c246fa3aa8a0a48a53a108.mp3" length="0" type="audio/mpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Does the university shape public debate over the long run, with no democratic check on it? In this Heterodox Academy virtual colloquium, philosopher Hrishikesh Joshi argues that it does. Drawing on Foucault, Rawls, Scanlon, Joshua Cohen and Chomsky, Joshi turns arguments usually aimed at concentrated wealth onto the modern academy. Anyone who wants to join the elite must pass through it, and professors as a group shape the questions that the elite learn to ask.</em></p><p><em>That power, Joshi argues, is democratically unaccountable by design. And because departments lean the same way across institutions, exit is not a real option: a student who dislikes one sociology department will find the same leanings at the next. He closes by suggesting that wealthy patrons may be a small check on the academy&#8217;s influence, and that greater diversity or democratic accountability of the professoriate is needed. This is one philosopher&#8217;s argument, not a new study, and the views are his own. Joshi is an associate professor of philosophy at the University of Arizona. A transcript of his talk follows below.</em></p><div><hr></div><p><strong>Hrishikesh Joshi:</strong> Thanks for setting this up. And yeah, great to be able to share this work with you all. I&#8217;ve been interested in this question of the university system and its relation to democracy, which is, I think, relatively under-theorized. I wrote a paper on this, which came out in <em>Philosophy &amp; Public Affairs</em> in February, but I&#8217;m hoping to expand this into a book project, and I&#8217;ve written several sort of follow-up pieces on my Substack, which is called Desert Philosophy. So check those out if you&#8217;re interested in this topic.</p><p>So, okay, so I want to start with a quote from Michel Foucault, who says, &#8220;Power is tolerable only on condition that it masks a substantial part of itself. Its success is proportional to its ability to hide its own mechanisms.&#8221; And the thought is something like: in the modern context, power kind of hides itself. It doesn&#8217;t show itself. It&#8217;s not as in your face as it maybe used to be. So you think of the feudal system. Okay, you know who has the power. It&#8217;s the king and the nobles, and the serfs maybe don&#8217;t have power. And it&#8217;s obvious who has the power. The king has the power. But now power is much more subtle.</p><p>Okay, here&#8217;s an example. And this is just an example to get some intuitions going on what democracy is and what we mean by democracy, what we want from democracy. So here&#8217;s a hypothetical situation, and you can get at this in different ways, but there&#8217;s one way to get at it. So imagine there&#8217;s universal suffrage, one person, one vote. Everything gets counted perfectly accurately. There&#8217;s no gerrymandering. There&#8217;s no voter intimidation or anything like that. Everybody over 18 gets to vote. Okay, so in terms of the formal requirements of democratic decision-making, it&#8217;s satisfying that.</p><p>However, here&#8217;s the rub. All the politically relevant information, so be it about foreign relations, the economy, crime, poverty, whatever, has to be approved by the Information Board, capital I, capital B, which is appointed by the Great Leader. Again, capital letters. Is this a true democracy? You might think, okay, it&#8217;s democratic in one sense, that is, people get to vote. But look, the demos doesn&#8217;t get to make up their own minds about what information is relevant, right? So the real power here, you might think, is had by the Information Board. Okay, so that&#8217;s the kind of basic intuition I&#8217;m working off of.</p><p>Here&#8217;s John Rawls, and Rawls doesn&#8217;t talk about this particular example, but he would say, okay, so if we ask the question, is this a true democracy? Is this democratically legitimate? Is this what we want from democracy? I mean, we can use the word&#8212; I don&#8217;t want to get hung up on the word &#8220;democracy.&#8221; I mean, we can use our words however we want. But is this really what we want from democracy? And Rawls would say no. Rawls makes a big deal of the fair value of the political liberties. So the idea is something like this: democratic legitimacy will also depend on what happens before the voting booth, not just what happens at the voting booth.</p><p>This is something deliberative democrats have also defended. So there&#8217;s this rich tradition of deliberative democracy, Habermas and some others, and their idea is like, look, the voting booth is almost like an endpoint or the capstone. That&#8217;s not where the real democracy is. The real democracy is where we discuss issues with each other and so on. It&#8217;s a deliberative ideal. And another thought here is like, look, the demos must be able to decide what information is relevant. If some entity decides, look, this is the relevant information, this is the narrative, and then the demos makes its decision based on that narrative, that consent is going to be manufactured in some sense.</p><p>Here&#8217;s T. M. Scanlon, another sort of giant of Anglo-American political philosophy since World War II. And of course, Rawls is the biggest figure here. Scanlon says something very interesting. So he&#8217;s talking about economic inequality. And a lot of these authors are worried about economic inequality undermining democratic legitimacy, because the thought is something like this: if there&#8217;s a lot of economic inequality and some people are super wealthy, they&#8217;re going to get a megaphone, right? So they&#8217;re going to maybe own media companies. They&#8217;re going to have big social media platforms or what have you.</p><p>So here&#8217;s what Scanlon says: &#8220;The root problem is access to the main means of expression. Economic inequality leads to a situation in which the wealthy own and control the main means of expression,&#8221; so newspapers, what have you, &#8220;or to one in which access to those means is very expensive.&#8221; So if you want to start a newspaper, that&#8217;s very expensive, right? Only the wealthy are going to be able to do something like that. &#8220;As a result, the rich have more opportunity to influence public discussion of political questions.&#8221; That&#8217;s going to be key. &#8220;This is a problem not only for others who wish to influence political outcomes, but also for all citizens who need to be exposed to a wide range of opinion.&#8221; And this is key. So if you&#8217;re only&#8212; the Overton window is, like, restricted, and you can only ask questions or you can only operate in here, that&#8217;s going to undermine democracy, right? You need &#8220;to be exposed to a wider range of opinion in order to make up their minds how to vote and whom to support.&#8221;</p><p>Okay. Here&#8217;s Josh Cohen. He says equal opportunity for political influence. The opportunity is key because, of course, we&#8217;re not going to have equal influence, because some of us are going to be more charismatic than others or have bigger followings. Taylor Swift is going to have a bigger political influence if she says, &#8220;Go vote for this person.&#8221; More people are going to listen to her than me. Okay. But that&#8217;s fine as long as we have equal opportunity in some sense. Again, Cohen is worried about inequality of wealth, where, okay, the rich are going to have a greater opportunity for political influence. And so his recommendation is campaign finance regulations. So maybe put a cap on how much private donations. And I mean, why is that relevant? Because one of the main means that people think the rich can influence politics is by donating to politicians. You know, &#8220;Here&#8217;s a bunch of money for your campaign. Okay, but then you&#8217;ve got to listen to me or my lobbyists,&#8221; things like that.</p><p>Okay, here&#8217;s Noam Chomsky on manufacturing consent, and his worry there is something like this. Look, you know, you might say, well, people can&#8212; you know, legitimacy is based on the consent of the governed. But this consent is fake if it&#8217;s manufactured, right? If the consent is&#8212; I mean, this was his big idea, that the mass media manufacture consent by only allowing sort of a narrow range of opinion. And Chomsky is interested because he says, well, radical critique is made very unlikely or impossible in such a situation, because you turn on the TV and the Overton window is going to be here, so the radical critique over here, wherever, is not going to get a fair hearing.</p><p>Okay, so what I want to do is&#8212; okay, if all this is correct, and the focus here has been on economic inequality, what I want to do is say, turn this onto the modern university system. And I want to say&#8212; I mean, the provocative conclusion here is, if you take on board what Rawls, Scanlon, Chomsky and so on say, Cohen, there&#8217;s a real problem here. So here&#8217;s the problem. The modern academy wields enormous influence, especially over the long run. What is the reason? Well, if you want to join the ranks of the elite, you need to go through the university system.</p><p>So look at any major writer, journalist, CEO, politician, judge, lawyer, even teachers who&#8212; you know, even K&#8211;12 teachers who influence their students. They have to&#8212; you can&#8217;t be a K&#8211;12 teacher if you passed high school or whatever. And of course, yeah, journalists. If you look at the <em>New York Times</em>, people who write for the <em>New York Times</em>, do they have college degrees? Of course they do. And often they&#8217;ll have degrees from the elite institutions, you know, Dartmouth, Yale, Princeton, what have you. Okay, so college degrees are indispensable for joining the ranks of the elite. If you want to be a plumber or electrician, maybe you don&#8217;t have to. But if you want to join the ranks of the opinion shapers, the people who really wield long-term influence, those people have to go through the academy.</p><p>Even the billionaire, by the time the billionaire can influence public discourse, her worldview, and the way&#8212; even the way people ask questions, like if you look at society and you say, okay, what are the social problems here? What problems are relevant? The way you ask those questions is going to be shaped by your education. Okay. So the academy has this power to shape the Overton window, especially over the long run. And I think this influence is sort of hidden, which goes back to the Foucault thing. You think, well, who are the people who shape public discourse? You think, oh, maybe podcasters, maybe politicians, journalists. So that&#8217;s where the action lies. But really what I&#8217;m saying is, look, by the time they get to do that, they&#8217;ve already been shaped by the academy. So there&#8217;s a strong sense of power that lies beforehand with the academy.</p><p>Okay, I think professors have a lot of power. I don&#8217;t want to say individual professors have that much power, but the professoriate as a class, or as a guild, you might say, has this power. Why do they have this power? Well, students come to college in an epistemically vulnerable position. You know, you&#8217;re 18, 19. What do you know? You go to something like chemistry class. You can&#8217;t go to chemistry class and be like, &#8220;Well, I don&#8217;t believe in atoms. What are you talking about?&#8221; Right? You&#8217;ve got to take the professors at their word. And faculty are recognized experts. Like, who&#8217;s the expert at chemistry? It&#8217;s not some random person out there. It&#8217;s going to be the professor of chemistry or mathematics, what have you. So the deference is necessary, especially at the beginning.</p><p>Where this gets problematic is when it transfers over to&#8212; so chemistry is one thing, but when it transfers over to disciplines that deal with social and political issues, think sociology, anthropology, even philosophy, political philosophy, political science. If you transfer over that ethos of deference to sociology, then you have this&#8212; you know, that&#8217;s where the power lies.</p><p>Okay, you might think, well, you know, why do professors have a unique power? Don&#8217;t we get information from all kinds of sources? We listen to podcasts, we watch the TV. I think professors have a unique power because there&#8217;s all this social scientific research about, you know, if you read something multiple times, it becomes more plausible to you. So, you know, two equally plausible claims&#8212; two claims equally supported by the evidence. If I listen to one claim just once, if I hear it just once, whereas I hear the second claim, I don&#8217;t know, 30 times, the second claim is going to seep into my mind and feel more plausible.</p><p>Okay, there&#8217;s a bunch of other social science around this. There&#8217;s also stuff about the power of recall. So if you recall something for an exam, that&#8217;s a way of getting that information into your long-term memory. And that&#8217;s not true when you skim a Substack article or something, right? You&#8217;re not being tested on it. So exams and assignments are a way to get that information into your head in a way that just randomly listening to a podcast or something is not.</p><p>Okay, so now we&#8217;ve got shaping the elites. The second main issue is that this power is unaccountable, democratically unaccountable. So say sociology professors, for example, are not appointed by legislators or democratic representatives, or they&#8217;re not voted for by the demos. And that&#8217;s, in fact, guaranteed by the ideal of academic freedom. The ideal of academic freedom is meant to shield professors, especially after tenure, from donors or from political representatives and so on. So this is almost by design. So there&#8217;s a sort of unaccountability that&#8217;s there by design.</p><p>Okay. So there&#8217;s unaccountable power here. So yet the sociology professor wields enormous influence, especially over the long run. And there&#8217;s a sort of captive audience here, right? When you go to podcasts&#8212; I mean, there&#8217;s a million podcasts out there, but I have a choice as to what podcast to listen, or people have a choice. When you step into the class, you don&#8217;t have a choice as to what to read or what questions get asked, right? Those are determined by the syllabus.</p><p>Okay. Okay, now contrast this with the market. So in the market&#8212; so there&#8217;s this nice book by A. O. Hirschman called <em>Exit, Voice, and Loyalty</em>. So these are three ways in which we can respond to institutions. One is exit. So if you don&#8217;t like an institution, you can leave it. Another is voice. So if you don&#8217;t like the institution, you can try to change the institution with voice. So you can vote, or you can write op-eds, or you can, you know, write memos or whatever. And loyalty is like, maybe you like the institution, and then you&#8217;re loyal to it.</p><p>Notice, in a competitive market, so not in a monopoly but in a competitive market, you have robust exit. So suppose I like sandwiches, but I hate Subway. I don&#8217;t like how Subway makes its sandwiches. I may not get&#8212; I may not be able to&#8212; like, I&#8217;m one customer, after all. I may not be able to get them to change how they make their sandwiches. But I have exit. I can go to Jimmy John&#8217;s. There&#8217;s thousands of other sandwich shops I can go to. If I don&#8217;t like sandwiches, I can go get tacos, ramen, whatever, what have you.</p><p>Now, you might think, hey, isn&#8217;t this true of the academy? I mean, like, no one&#8217;s forcing you to go to Stanford. If you don&#8217;t like Stanford, you could go to Princeton. If you don&#8217;t like Princeton, you could go to Michigan or Harvard, wherever, assuming you get admission. That, I want to say, is illusory. So that would be true in a case where&#8212; to take sociology, for example, that would be true if&#8212; here&#8217;s an imaginary world, and we can just think how distant this world is from our current world. Imagine Stanford sociology leans libertarian, Michigan leans socialist, Harvard leans conservative, Princeton leans left liberal. Then you could say, hey, you don&#8217;t like this, you don&#8217;t like what they&#8217;re teaching at Stanford, go to Harvard.</p><p>That&#8217;s not true, because if you look at sociology departments, just to pick one&#8212; I mean, you could run this on other disciplines, anthropology&#8212; if you look at the sociology department at Stanford, Harvard, Princeton, Yale, wherever, they&#8217;re all going to lean the same way, right? They&#8217;re all going to lean the same way. So there is no choice of exit. There&#8217;s no exit. You know, there&#8217;s exit&#8212; I mean, these are not nominally distinct institutions. So you have, well, Yale is different from Stanford. But if you look at what is taught, the political valence of what is taught, it&#8217;s all roughly the same.</p><p>Here&#8217;s a graph to bring this out. And I know HxA members will be familiar with this graph. But this is just&#8212; and I don&#8217;t want to lean too heavily on these ratios of Democrats to Republicans. But I mean, the extent of these ratios is one thing, right? So it would be one thing if it&#8217;s like, okay, like, you know, Democrats outnumber Republicans, but it&#8217;s like 70% Democrats or something. Sociology, it&#8217;s like 43.8. So that means in a room of 100 sociologists, you&#8217;ll have like two Republicans, and they&#8217;re probably closeted. They would probably want to say, &#8220;I&#8217;m a Republican.&#8221; So, you know.</p><p>Okay, and you notice the most balanced fields are the ones that don&#8217;t deal with social issues. So engineering is the most balanced field, 1.6 Democrats to one Republican. But engineers are not talking about the root causes of poverty or capitalism or immigration or what have you, right? Those issues are going to be talked about here. And these ratios are just, like, you know, mind-blowing.</p><p>It&#8217;s not just&#8212; it&#8217;s a&#8212; party affiliation is one thing. And by the way, I just want to note that some people might say, well, it&#8217;s the recent populist moment that&#8217;s driving this. But I mean, there&#8217;s data from 2000. If you look at 2000, the ratios are similar, maybe not as skewed as now. But okay, this is faculty ideology. So this is not like, you know, are you Democrat or Republican, but like, are you&#8212; and FIRE, among others, has done a bunch of surveys like this. And you notice the&#8212; I forgot the x-axis here. Sorry about that. But the&#8212; yeah, the ratio&#8212; I mean, you don&#8217;t really need the x-axis to see the trend, right? There&#8217;s a trend here.</p><p>Okay, what is the cause of this homogeneity? Maybe it&#8217;s innocuous. So one innocuous hypothesis would be maybe reality has a&#8212; people say reality has a liberal or left-wing bias. Or maybe it&#8217;s self-selection or personality. Those would be innocuous. But there&#8217;s a lot of evidence of discrimination, especially at the hiring stage. So I can go into the details in the Q&amp;A, but there&#8217;s just mounting evidence that non-left applicants are discriminated against at the hiring stage.</p><p>There&#8217;s also other sorts of evidence. So it&#8217;s not just&#8212; forget the academy for a moment. We know that in a situation of affective polarization, people will reward their own side. So this is a study from 2015, again, well before the notorious election of 2016. So this is not just a new thing, right? 2015, right? So they say this experiment is just like two identical CVs of high school seniors, and you change the partisan affiliation, and it turns out that partisans will discriminate against out-party members. And this is symmetric, by the way, so Republicans will also discriminate. But given the academy, it&#8217;s not symmetric, because in the academy, the partisan affiliation is so skewed.</p><p>I won&#8217;t go into this too much here, but I argue in the paper that regardless of what kind of theory of democratic legitimacy you take, this is going to turn out to be problematic. So on any theory, on any plausible theory of democratic legitimacy, it&#8217;s going to turn out that the current system is not democratically legitimate. So if you want a sound clip or something, I would want to say that the most provocative way of putting this is&#8212; and by the way, this mirrors the critique from the left from the &#8216;60s, &#8216;70s onward. The critique is, look, you think you live in a liberal democracy, but you really don&#8217;t, because we&#8217;re not aware of how power actually works.</p><p>Just in closing, a couple of things. So I want to say, so in contrast to what a lot of people have been saying&#8212; look, wealth is a power problem for democratic legitimacy&#8212; I want to maybe turn that around. Maybe economic freedom, which results in wealth inequality, maybe is the only small check to the power of the academy. So Milton Friedman has this old paper, which is very much worth reading, on the relation between economic freedom, political freedom. I won&#8217;t go into it in detail, but he argues that economic freedom is a necessary, though not sufficient, condition for political freedom.</p><p>One thing he says that&#8217;s sort of underappreciated from that essay is&#8212; he says, &#8220;This is the role of inequality of wealth in preserving political freedom that is seldom noted: the role of the patron.&#8221; So the patron is a person who, you know&#8212; if you have an idea, if you want to do a radical critique, if there are wealthy patrons out there, at least that&#8217;s unchecked. You can go to the wealthy patron and say, &#8220;Okay, fund my ideas,&#8221; or something. And notice he says, well, Marx&#8212; how is Marx able to do his thing? Well, Marx wouldn&#8217;t have been able to do his thing without Engels, who was his wealthy patron. Right.</p><p>Okay, so what is the upshot here? So contrary to what many people have argued&#8212; they think, look, economic inequality undermines democratic legitimacy&#8212; I want to say, look, the homogeneity of the academy undermines legitimacy, and the only sort of small check&#8212; and I think it&#8217;s a small check because, as I mentioned, even the billionaires have to go through the&#8212; you know, how many billionaires don&#8217;t have a college degree? I mean, we can think of a couple, but most of them have a college degree, right? So the ability to convince even one wealthy patron can check the oligarchic power of the academy. Shout-out, you know, if any wealthy patrons are listening, I&#8217;m open for business here.</p><p>Okay, nonetheless, this is far from enough. I want to say what is needed is greater diversity and/or democratic accountability of the professoriate. So we have to rethink some of the ideas of academic freedom and the role of&#8212; you know, what is the purpose of the university system?</p><p class="button-wrapper" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/how-might-the-academy-undermine-democratic?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Share&quot;,&quot;action&quot;:null,&quot;class&quot;:null}" data-component-name="ButtonCreateButton"><a class="button primary" href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/how-might-the-academy-undermine-democratic?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share"><span>Share</span></a></p><div><hr></div><div class="subscription-widget-wrap-editor" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/subscribe?&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Subscribe&quot;,&quot;language&quot;:&quot;en&quot;}" data-component-name="SubscribeWidgetToDOM"><div class="subscription-widget show-subscribe"><div class="preamble"><p class="cta-caption"><em>Free The Inquiry</em> brings you essays, expert commentary, and conversations about open inquiry in the academy. Subscribe to stay up to date.</p></div><form class="subscription-widget-subscribe"><input type="email" class="email-input" name="email" placeholder="Type your email&#8230;" tabindex="-1"><input type="submit" class="button primary" value="Subscribe"><div class="fake-input-wrapper"><div class="fake-input"></div><div class="fake-button"></div></div></form></div></div><p></p>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[How Interpersonal Connection Could Treat Substance Use]]></title><description><![CDATA[A psychologist describes an Appalachian program in which church volunteers drive people in recovery to job training, and what its data do and don't show.]]></description><link>https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/how-interpersonal-connection-could</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/how-interpersonal-connection-could</guid><dc:creator><![CDATA[Andrea D Clements, PhD]]></dc:creator><pubDate>Fri, 13 Nov 2026 14:03:33 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://api.substack.com/feed/podcast/224668106/ccf22fd7451b2f0cd6146d80f79f9cf1.mp3" length="0" type="audio/mpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Could connection help someone in recovery? In this Heterodox Academy virtual colloquium, psychologist Andi Clements of East Tennessee State University describes <a href="https://www.uplifts.org/">Uplift Rides</a>, a volunteer rides program in northeast Tennessee. Volunteers from the faith community drive people in addiction recovery, recently out of incarceration, to job training. The ride meets a practical need, and the driver&#8217;s aim is to build a relationship. The riders live in sober living homes that require abstinence, and they are not required to attend church or express any faith.</em></p><p><em>Clements shares the first 17 months of data: 174 riders and more than 40,000 miles. In an early survey of 20 riders, all 20 said their drivers seemed to care about them, and none said they felt judged. She is clear about the limits. This is a program evaluation, not a formal research study; the samples are small, and she has not yet compared riders before and after, so the talk does not show whether the rides change outcomes. A transcript of Clements&#8217;s talk follows below.</em></p><div><hr></div><p><strong>Andi Clements:</strong> Thank you so much. I&#8217;m really tickled to be invited to be here. I&#8217;m going to talk today about&#8212; I have so much research in all of those areas that you just mentioned, and community activity, but I&#8217;m going to talk about one particular project that we&#8217;re working on that I have hot-off-the-presses data for. And as you said, we&#8217;re trying to mobilize the faith community to address addiction, mental health challenges, whatever life things are going on. This is a&#8212; it&#8217;s actually a paper that is under review. I&#8217;m hoping that it ends up being published. And some of my co-authors are listed up there. It&#8217;s me, a doctoral student who is now assistant director of a center here on campus, and then our executive director and our transportation coordinator and a woman with lived experience who runs a sober living house, set of houses here in the area.</p><p>And I&#8217;m going to first, introduce myself quickly, because it&#8217;s important who I am as to why I&#8217;m doing what I&#8217;m doing. I am a professor right now at East Tennessee State University. I&#8217;m about to transition to West Virginia University over the break. So early next year, I&#8217;ll be transitioning to a position there where we are&#8212; I&#8217;m going to be co-director. We&#8217;re developing a center called the Rockefeller Neuroscience Institute PRISM Center. PRISM stands for Practice, Research, and Integration of Spirituality in Medicine, which is, I got to write my dream job, which is: let&#8217;s actually integrate spirituality, religion, religiosity into how we care for people, with collaborative input from both sides as we develop materials and practices and so forth, and do the research on it, which is what I do.</p><p>And so what we do as an organization, the Uplift&#8212; I&#8217;m going to mention also the co-founder and president of Uplift Appalachia, which is a&#8212; and I do, up here, down here, I guess we say &#8220;Appalachia.&#8221; But what we do is we do a lot of the church equipping to be able to collaborate with people in&#8212; it could be in healthcare, it could be in recovery areas, it could be in mental health services, it could be job training, all of those kinds of things. And so right now we have funding to do two things. One is to co-train, or collaboratively train, community members, healthcare organizations and the faith community to work together. And so we do a lot of training in trauma-informed care, a lot of training in understanding addiction, a lot of training in why the church should even be involved in this and why you would want the church to be involved in caring for your patients or clients or whatever. The other piece is a transportation program that I will talk about in a minute, because that is the main thing that I&#8217;m going to talk about.</p><p>So one of the things that we are so interested in is&#8212; and I don&#8217;t know how familiar you are with particularly rural Appalachia, but we are in a rural area, northeast Tennessee, southwest Virginia. I&#8217;ll be going to West Virginia and so forth. And one of the greatest barriers is transportation, as far as social determinants of health go. And so that&#8217;s one of the biggest predictors, and maybe barriers, of flourishing and people in our area, because it keeps you from being able to get to work, get training for work, get to the store to buy food, get to court appointments to stay out of jail, whatever it is. There&#8217;s so many things that hinge on being able to get where you need to go, and we just do not have any kind of public transportation. Even the small town I live in, a town of about 70,000, we do have public transportation, but only during daylight hours and only on weekdays, you know? And so there are a lot of gaps there. And so I learned just recently we do have two taxis for 70,000 people. So you can kind of see the problem. We&#8217;re not a big Uber place.</p><p>So the other piece, though, that we&#8217;re looking at, and I&#8217;ll talk about this more in a minute, is looking at interpersonal connection. We know that a lot of people nowadays talk about &#8220;the opposite of addiction is connection,&#8221; and things like that. And so one of the things that we have been looking at, and I have particularly in my research, is even looking at a neurobiological explanation, I guess, for why interpersonal connection is so related to addiction. And so we do know that things that increase interpersonal connection are beneficial for staying in recovery, getting in recovery and so forth. And one of the things that we really want to study&#8212; we have not yet, but I&#8217;m fixing to go to a neuroscience center, so I hope I get to&#8212; is looking actually at the neurobiology of that connection and how that relates to substance use and so forth. I&#8217;m not going to go into the whole thing, but I have some writing on that if anybody&#8217;s interested in talking about it, or other things that we have written about for that. But that is what sparked this idea of ways to get the church involved in people&#8217;s lives so that they could increase the people&#8217;s availability of interpersonal connection.</p><p>And so, from where this came from, a little bit of history. Before 2019, this was a very serendipitous forming of a nonprofit. Before 2019, we had a little church plant and a high-need, high-homelessness, high-addiction, high-poverty area of Johnson City. And so we, in that process, we had found that as people came into the church, people with cars would give the people that were just, you know, walking through the neighborhood and happened to become involved in the church&#8212; were giving people rides. It might be to church, it might be to the grocery store, it might be to a doctor&#8217;s appointment or whatever. But what we saw was that the people that were getting the rides were getting better. They were getting jobs, they were getting housed, they were staying in recovery and so forth. And so the pastor said, &#8220;What if we just tried to actually multiply that and get other churches to try to do that?&#8221; Hence the name Uplift. It&#8217;s a play on the word &#8220;lift,&#8221; but we didn&#8217;t spell it with a Y, just for copyright things. But it was really based around this rides idea.</p><p>2023, &#8216;24, we did get some kind of seed funding to start really formalizing the organization. And then in &#8216;24 we got a grant, an opioid abatement grant through our state, to partner with an organization that I&#8217;ll describe in a minute. How about that? There we go. So what happened was this organization got a grant to form a partnership. They already had an existing program for people trying to prepare employers to employ people, second-chance employment, so people coming out of incarceration, to get them into jobs and prepare the workplaces for the people to work, so that they were more recovery- and incarceration-reentry-friendly. This grant that includes us was sort of a Caring Workplaces 2.0. And so it&#8217;s a collaboration between two different organizations that provide sober living. One has sober living for men; that&#8217;s Recovery Resources. And Bridge to Shore is sober living for women. TCAT is the Tennessee College of Applied Technology. It&#8217;s a tech school that is in a nearby town. We have a peer help program through our hospital system called Ballad PEERHelp. Caring Workplaces is the work development equipping part of it; that is the funded entity. And then the Addiction Science Center is doing the program evaluation.</p><p>We are, as Uplift Appalachia, doing the transportation to get people who have just recently come out of incarceration, are living in these sober living houses, and are going to training through this tech school. So some of it is long-term, like, you know, 12-month, 18-month, whatever, full-blown tech programs. Some of it is just short-term special industry training: OSHA training, multimeter training, just forklift training, things like that, where they go for just a few weeks and get those trainings. But what we do is we get volunteers from the faith community to give the rides. That is the goal. But what we want is not just that the volunteer would give them a ride, although they do, and they get where they need to go, which is the first piece. They don&#8217;t get the training if they don&#8217;t get to where they&#8217;re trying to go. But the ulterior motive of the driver is to build a relationship with the people that they&#8217;re driving. And so what we&#8217;re trying to do is build a supportive community. So the ride provides the practical need.</p><p>We do equip the drivers. We would love to say that we started out years ago, when we first started, &#8220;Let&#8217;s do some training, let&#8217;s inspire the church,&#8221; and they&#8217;ll say, &#8220;Oh, what can I do?&#8221; And we&#8217;ll say, &#8220;Oh, you could give people rides,&#8221; and this will work wonderfully. But that didn&#8217;t really&#8212; the training was there and they would do it, but they didn&#8217;t do the next piece. And so it was only when we ended up contracted, and we have to get these people from here to there, that we started begging people hard enough to get them to actually do the rides. So now we are doing that. But the idea&#8212; and so we do some of that training, some of the drivers go to that training, but the way our training really looks most of the time is much more organic than that, and I&#8217;ll talk about that in a minute.</p><p>So just to give a snapshot of this: we have two programs that we take them to, the regular training or the short-term industry training. We&#8217;re going among three towns. We&#8217;re called Tri-Cities, but one of the towns is actually a fourth one, so two of the Tri-Cities and then another town. Two trips a day for each of those programs, four days a week, so up to 48 rides a week. We&#8217;ve never had to do 48 rides a week, thank the Lord. So some of them actually drive, some of them carpool, some of them don&#8217;t go every day and so forth. But in essence, we could have that many a day. All of the people that are being given rides live in sober living. They&#8217;re regularly drug screened, they have mandatory meetings, so forth. It is an abstinence-based program, so they&#8217;re all abstinent from mind-altering substances. They did&#8212; mental health meds they could still use, but it doesn&#8217;t include MOUD.</p><p>The drivers can drive as much or little as they want. They can do one time every six months; they can do four days a week if they want to. They all drive in their own cars. Sometimes we do have people with church vans that will drive a church van if we have several riders or something like that. We do have a full-time coordinator that does this. We have contracted a few part-time paid drivers to fill in the rides, because one of these is&#8212; it&#8217;s in a nearby town, and they have to be in another town by 7:30 in the morning. So you&#8217;ve got a driver getting up at 6 o&#8217;clock in the morning to go pick people up. That&#8217;s a really hard one to do with volunteers, so we usually pay for that one. But so we do sometimes drive, and then some of the staff drive at times.</p><p>So we do want people to be equipped in both trauma-informed care training and understanding addiction. We recruit them. Most of the time, what we end up doing is somebody rides with somebody and trains them on the way. It&#8217;s like, &#8220;Come ride with me. I&#8217;ll show you how it works, and we&#8217;ll talk through this,&#8221; and then coach them as we go, instead of having them come sit in a classroom and take notes and things like that. But we do also have training videos if people want to watch through: here&#8217;s what we&#8217;re trying to do, and here are the things to watch for, and so forth. Most of the time, the people that have volunteered so far are already quite equipped in that. They&#8217;re ready for it. They want to do it. And so they&#8217;ve already kind of explored what they need to know there.</p><p>At this point, the evaluations that we&#8217;ve done: we evaluate the drivers. Yes, you&#8217;ll see the response rate as of the time this was written was four. I think we&#8217;ve had a few more since then. Riders, about 20. So this is very preliminary. We have a lot more folks that have been doing this since, but we just haven&#8217;t analyzed the next set of data. We&#8217;ve had 119 attend those trainings that are included here, but we&#8217;ve done a lot more training. Then we&#8217;ve just got the records of doing this. So this is on the first 17 months of the program, which started January of &#8216;25. And then we did some interviews with our community partners as we were getting ready to submit this article.</p><p>So in that first 17 months, we had 174 unique riders. A lot of them ride multiple times, but unique riders. 1,900 trips. As far as how many per month, two to 24, depending on what programs are going on. This is the big one: 40,000, over 40,000 miles in that first 17 months. And when you see the number of drivers, which is not many, we have 13 volunteer drivers, and a few part-time folks that do some. And so this, the darker line here is the&#8212; the darker bottom part is the proportion of rides being covered by volunteers, as opposed to the paid drivers. And that has gotten better. We&#8217;ve gotten a lot more volunteers since then. And so it&#8217;s improving, but it&#8217;s slow.</p><p>But then some of the&#8212; we wanted to find out what the riders are thinking about this, because the whole idea is we&#8217;re going to&#8212; you know, they&#8217;re going to feel loved and cared for, and hopefully it would reduce stigma and so forth and so on. And so 100% of them: drivers care about me. And zero feel judged. Those, to me, are the two pivotal questions there. You know, we&#8217;ve got, like, how safe is it, and things like that. Most people enjoy the ride, so forth. The other thing is, 15% have attended the driver&#8217;s church, one of the drivers&#8217; churches. That&#8217;s not a requirement at all. You don&#8217;t have to express faith. You don&#8217;t have to buy in or whatever, but you&#8217;re welcome. And so some of them have attended church with them. Some of them just feel cared for and go on about their way and don&#8217;t get involved and so forth.</p><p>But this&#8212; when we looked at the before, we had some of the drivers thinking, &#8220;I don&#8217;t know about the people in my car.&#8221; And the drivers saying&#8212; I mean, the riders saying, &#8220;Oh, those church folks are going to judge me.&#8221; And that just evaporated when we first started doing it. It was just like, that was not even an issue. It&#8217;s like, they&#8217;re just people. We&#8217;re friends. We care about each other. We check on each other and so forth. We did ask about what the current life concerns were, and transportation, as we knew it would be, was the top. And so we&#8217;re meeting a need that is just always there. It&#8217;s always there. We would love to solve that. We have enough churches that one day, maybe.</p><p>And then we want to talk a little bit about the training, since we had so few drivers to respond. The trainings that we do with the&#8212; and I call this the pool of potential drivers, because when we have churches that come to training, those theoretically are people that will end up driving, I would hope. But we look at: does our training have an effect on the views of the people that come to the training? And we&#8217;ve seen that they really do learn about how trauma can affect people. They really have learned about drug and alcohol misuse, and they are willing to work with people who have these challenges. But we have found that the barrier, which probably is what&#8217;s preventing a lot of the volunteering, is lack of time, and the emotionally challenging nature of the work, which it is. So emotionally challenging. I mean, it just&#8212; if you&#8217;re working with an addicted population, it just is. And then the feeling unprepared. But we are all about preparing somebody. If that&#8217;s your barrier, we will get you prepared.</p><p>And so then the drivers that we have are very empathetic. They said that the driving did not change that, but they&#8217;re the ones who were already ready, so I think they were already empathetic. And so either good, better, a lot of empathy for people who struggle with drugs and alcohol. And then when we talked to the community partners, they were just so, so encouraging. And I have a little quote at the end.</p><p>But the main thing that we end up doing is hours and hours and hours and hours and hours and hours of relationship building: between church leaders and the organizations, between the churchgoers and the leaders, among the partners, among the people and the people. You know, it&#8217;s just, there&#8217;s so much. I tell people, &#8220;17 coffees and three meals just to do a training.&#8221; And then, you know, how many coffees you have with somebody before you can say, &#8220;Okay, get in the car with me and let&#8217;s go for a ride,&#8221; or whatever, to potentially drive. So there&#8217;s lots of this relationship building and trust building, particularly between the church and the treatment community. So we do a lot of liaising among those.</p><p>Some of our limitations right now: it&#8217;s not a formal research study. Hopefully when I go to West Virginia&#8212; that&#8217;s a big part of what my job is going to be, is studying some of these programs that can be effective. And so hopefully I&#8217;ll have the capacity to begin more formalizing data collection and so forth and so on. We have small samples right now. The survey distribution&#8212; we wrote a grant last year to actually pay someone to do our data collection and make sure it&#8217;s happening. The thing is, we didn&#8217;t get it. The thing that has happened is our transportation coordinator has been the one that&#8217;s also making sure the data are getting collected, and she is busy filling slots all the time, and that is, like, the 13th thing on her mind, not getting those out. So it&#8217;s been kind of spotty data collection, but hopefully that will ramp up too, as we get some bandwidth to do that.</p><p>We would love to&#8212; right now, we have not looked at the pre-post change in the riders and the drivers. That&#8217;s the thing that I&#8217;m really interested in, in the long run, as seeing: is this thing actually changing both of them? Which I think it is, and anecdotally, I would say I really trust that it is. But we haven&#8217;t been able to show that yet empirically. Hope to one day.</p><p>This is what one of our community partners said: that &#8220;what makes Uplift Rides model unique, it goes far beyond simply providing a ride from one place to another. Yes, it creates meaningful connections between our participants and members of the faith-based community in a natural, informal setting.&#8221; And they&#8212; this is such a great set of partners working on this. Everybody is trying to help everybody to do it well, because everybody has, as the main goal, helping the people that we&#8217;re helping. It&#8217;s not like, &#8220;Let&#8217;s get the next grant,&#8221; or &#8220;Let&#8217;s make sure we look good,&#8221; or whatever. It&#8217;s&#8212; everybody is kind of teaming up to help the actual participants, which I love being a part of.</p><p>I just want to say thank you to&#8212; those are our funders and our other partners and so forth. There are some email addresses and all of the folks that you might want to connect with to find out more about this. And then, and I&#8217;m happy to share this, I don&#8217;t know if you share the PowerPoints, but&#8212; and there&#8217;s my&#8212; some of the references, just to prove that it&#8217;s science.</p><p class="button-wrapper" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/how-interpersonal-connection-could?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Share&quot;,&quot;action&quot;:null,&quot;class&quot;:null}" data-component-name="ButtonCreateButton"><a class="button primary" href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/how-interpersonal-connection-could?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share"><span>Share</span></a></p><div><hr></div><div class="subscription-widget-wrap-editor" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/subscribe?&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Subscribe&quot;,&quot;language&quot;:&quot;en&quot;}" data-component-name="SubscribeWidgetToDOM"><div class="subscription-widget show-subscribe"><div class="preamble"><p class="cta-caption"><em>Free The Inquiry</em> brings you essays, expert commentary, and conversations about open inquiry in the academy. Subscribe to stay up to date.</p></div><form class="subscription-widget-subscribe"><input type="email" class="email-input" name="email" placeholder="Type your email&#8230;" tabindex="-1"><input type="submit" class="button primary" value="Subscribe"><div class="fake-input-wrapper"><div class="fake-input"></div><div class="fake-button"></div></div></form></div></div><p></p>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Veterans in the Seminar Room]]></title><description><![CDATA[&#8220;Those who were in uniform are not uniform.&#8221;]]></description><link>https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/veterans-in-the-seminar-room</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/veterans-in-the-seminar-room</guid><dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Regnier]]></dc:creator><pubDate>Wed, 11 Nov 2026 13:03:38 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!A8_v!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F78ac269c-1ce1-4bc8-adec-506e20022f3a_6000x4000.jpeg" length="0" type="image/jpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="captioned-image-container"><figure><a class="image-link image2 is-viewable-img" target="_blank" href="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!A8_v!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F78ac269c-1ce1-4bc8-adec-506e20022f3a_6000x4000.jpeg" data-component-name="Image2ToDOM"><div class="image2-inset"><picture><source type="image/webp" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!A8_v!,w_424,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F78ac269c-1ce1-4bc8-adec-506e20022f3a_6000x4000.jpeg 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!A8_v!,w_848,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F78ac269c-1ce1-4bc8-adec-506e20022f3a_6000x4000.jpeg 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!A8_v!,w_1272,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F78ac269c-1ce1-4bc8-adec-506e20022f3a_6000x4000.jpeg 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!A8_v!,w_1456,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F78ac269c-1ce1-4bc8-adec-506e20022f3a_6000x4000.jpeg 1456w" sizes="100vw"><img src="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!A8_v!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F78ac269c-1ce1-4bc8-adec-506e20022f3a_6000x4000.jpeg" width="1456" height="971" data-attrs="{&quot;src&quot;:&quot;https://substack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/78ac269c-1ce1-4bc8-adec-506e20022f3a_6000x4000.jpeg&quot;,&quot;srcNoWatermark&quot;:null,&quot;fullscreen&quot;:null,&quot;imageSize&quot;:null,&quot;height&quot;:971,&quot;width&quot;:1456,&quot;resizeWidth&quot;:null,&quot;bytes&quot;:17106405,&quot;alt&quot;:null,&quot;title&quot;:null,&quot;type&quot;:&quot;image/jpeg&quot;,&quot;href&quot;:null,&quot;belowTheFold&quot;:false,&quot;topImage&quot;:true,&quot;internalRedirect&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/i/224383316?img=https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F78ac269c-1ce1-4bc8-adec-506e20022f3a_6000x4000.jpeg&quot;,&quot;isProcessing&quot;:false,&quot;align&quot;:null,&quot;offset&quot;:false}" class="sizing-normal" alt="" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!A8_v!,w_424,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F78ac269c-1ce1-4bc8-adec-506e20022f3a_6000x4000.jpeg 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!A8_v!,w_848,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F78ac269c-1ce1-4bc8-adec-506e20022f3a_6000x4000.jpeg 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!A8_v!,w_1272,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F78ac269c-1ce1-4bc8-adec-506e20022f3a_6000x4000.jpeg 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!A8_v!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F78ac269c-1ce1-4bc8-adec-506e20022f3a_6000x4000.jpeg 1456w" sizes="100vw" fetchpriority="high"></picture><div class="image-link-expand"><div class="pencraft pc-display-flex pc-gap-8 pc-reset"><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container restack-image buttonBase-tqxFUX" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg aria-hidden="true" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 20 20" fill="none" stroke-width="1.5" stroke="var(--color-fg-primary)" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="icon-noB79L"><g><path d="M2.53001 7.81595C3.49179 4.73911 6.43281 2.5 9.91173 2.5C13.1684 2.5 15.9537 4.46214 17.0852 7.23684L17.6179 8.67647M17.6179 8.67647L18.5002 4.26471M17.6179 8.67647L13.6473 6.91176M17.4995 12.1841C16.5378 15.2609 13.5967 17.5 10.1178 17.5C6.86118 17.5 4.07589 15.5379 2.94432 12.7632L2.41165 11.3235M2.41165 11.3235L1.5293 15.7353M2.41165 11.3235L6.38224 13.0882"></path></g></svg></button><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container view-image buttonBase-tqxFUX" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="2" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" class="lucide lucide-maximize2 lucide-maximize-2 icon-noB79L"><polyline points="15 3 21 3 21 9"></polyline><polyline points="9 21 3 21 3 15"></polyline><line x1="21" x2="14" y1="3" y2="10"></line><line x1="3" x2="10" y1="21" y2="14"></line></svg></button></div></div></div></a></figure></div><p>In 1944, Robert Maynard Hutchins looked at the GI Bill and saw ruin. The president of the University of Chicago warned that colleges would become &#8220;<a href="https://www2.ljworld.com/news/2004/nov/18/hobo_jungles/">educational hobo jungles</a>,&#8221; overrun by men who wanted a stipend more than an education. Harvard&#8217;s James Conant <a href="https://www.thecrimson.com/article/1945/1/23/conant-suggests-gi-bill-revision-pother/">had his own doubts</a>.</p><p>They were wrong. Veterans flooded campuses after the war, and by 1956 more than a million of them had attended college. People now quote Hutchins mostly to show how badly elite educators can misjudge students who arrive by an unfamiliar route.</p><p>I bring it up on Veterans Day because colleges still haven&#8217;t fully answered the question behind his worry. What does someone who has carried a rifle or a medic&#8217;s bag bring to a seminar on Thucydides? At HxA we usually answer questions like that by talking about viewpoint diversity. So I went looking for what veterans have said about it. Their comments are more surprising than I expected. As Mark Street, a film professor at Fordham, <a href="https://www.chronicle.com/article/military-veterans-bring-value-to-the-classroom/">once wrote</a>, &#8220;those who were in uniform are not uniform.&#8221;</p><p>I&#8217;ve organized what I found into four parts: who student veterans are, what they add, what gets in their way, and what helps.</p><h2><strong>Who they are</strong></h2><p>Student veterans make up <a href="https://pnpi.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/PNPI_Veterans_FactSheet_Jan26.pdf">3.7 percent of undergraduates</a> nationally. Most are over 30, and on average they enroll nine and a half years after high school. Nearly half have children or other dependents, and more than half work full-time while they study. They are overrepresented at community colleges and still scarce at selective schools, where they often <a href="https://www.insidehighered.com/opinion/views/2023/11/14/some-good-news-campus-veterans-amid-discouraging-opinion">number in the dozens</a>.</p><p>They have also done things most of their classmates haven&#8217;t. They have worked inside a large, rule-bound institution and served alongside people from every religious and ethnic background and every region in the country. Some have seen what a policy debated in a seminar looks like on the ground.</p><h2><strong>What they add</strong></h2><p><strong>Politics that don&#8217;t sort neatly.</strong> Voters who are veterans lean Republican, 63 percent to 35, <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2024/09/30/military-veterans-remain-a-republican-group-backing-trump-over-harris-by-wide-margin/">according to Pew</a>. So it&#8217;s tempting to cast veterans as a conservative counterweight on liberal campuses, and Wesleyan president Michael Roth <a href="https://newsletter.blogs.wesleyan.edu/2017/05/12/president-roth-calls-for-an-affirmative-action-program-for-conservative-ideas-on-college-campuses/">made a version of that case</a> in the <em>Wall Street Journal</em> in 2017. But that can vary by issue; in 2019, for instance, <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2019/07/10/majorities-of-u-s-veterans-public-say-the-wars-in-iraq-and-afghanistan-were-not-worth-fighting/">64 percent of veterans told Pew</a> the Iraq war was not worth fighting, about the same share as the general public. At UC Santa Barbara, the veterans coordinator called the Veterans Resource Center &#8220;<a href="https://thebottomline.as.ucsb.edu/?p=44864">the most diverse place</a>&#8221; on campus, with students ranging from far-left to far-right.</p><p><strong>Firsthand knowledge.</strong> <a href="https://ucf.edu/news/veterans-university-offer-different-perspectives-students-faculty">Jim Clark</a>, who teaches history at the University of Central Florida, says veterans &#8220;can turn a dry lecture about Iraq or Afghanistan into an exciting discussion,&#8221; and that he can count on one to correct him when he gets a fact wrong. At Harvard, <a href="https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2026/4/17/veterans-talk-college-life/">Ed Somuk</a>, a retired Marine master sergeant, reminds classmates what many of them may end up doing after they graduate: &#8220;The people that do send us into conflict are usually graduates from Ivy League institutions like Harvard.&#8221; A future policymaker should hear that from someone who was sent.</p><p>Daniel Byman, who teaches security studies at Georgetown, <a href="https://www.brookings.edu/opinions/veterans-and-colleges-have-a-lot-to-offer-each-other">wrote years ago</a> that &#8220;discussions of life-or-death questions are far more real when veterans are in the classroom.&#8221; That holds in a community college ethics course as much as in a Georgetown seminar.</p><h2><strong>What gets in their way</strong></h2><p>The good news first: many veterans find campus friendlier than they expected. <a href="https://www.brownalumnimagazine.com/articles/2018-11-05/the-03-percent">Michael Muir&#8217;s Marine friends</a> warned him that Brown was &#8220;full of crazy snowflakes.&#8221; He found students &#8220;very open to asking me questions.&#8221; Ellen Moore, who interviewed student veterans for her book <em>Grateful Nation</em>, <a href="https://alumni.berkeley.edu/california-magazine/fall-2018-culture-shift/5-questions-ellen-moore-veterans-higher-education/">said none of them told her</a> they felt unwelcome because of their service. Jimmy Hatch, <a href="https://www.mediaite.com/politics/navy-veteran-and-yale-student-pens-op-ed-dispelling-college-campus-snowflake-narrative">a former Navy SEAL who enrolled at Yale at 52</a>, wrote, &#8220;If this place is peopled by &#8216;snowflakes&#8217; I&#8217;m proudly one of them.&#8221;</p><p>Still, veterans describe some recurring problems.</p><p><strong>Not being asked.</strong> There are ugly episodes, like the Columbia students who <a href="https://www.dnainfo.com/new-york/20110220/manhattan/students-jeer-iraq-war-vet-at-columbia-university-rotc-meeting">jeered a wounded Iraq veteran</a> at a 2011 town hall on ROTC, or the Brown students who in 2016 <a href="https://www.brownalumnimagazine.com/articles/2018-11-05/the-03-percent">tore up flags veterans had planted</a> for Veterans Day. More often, veterans simply aren&#8217;t asked what they think. <a href="https://taskandpurpose.com/?p=199295">Don Gomez</a>, an Army veteran who studied at the City College of New York, heard professors casually treat the Iraq war as a &#8220;self-evident failure.&#8221; He found it painful, but he wasn&#8217;t asking professors to stop. <br><br>&#8220;Veterans certainly don&#8217;t need a trigger warning,&#8221; he wrote; &#8220;the idea of being warned before they&#8217;re offended is comical.&#8221; However, &#8220;not once did any of my professors ever ask, &#8216;Are there any veterans in the class?&#8217;&#8221; Gomez wanted &#8220;a fair chance at being heard.&#8221;<br><br><strong>Pigeonholing.</strong> Once Gomez &#8220;outed&#8221; himself as a veteran, he wrote, he became the &#8220;Army guy.&#8221; Whenever the war or the military came up in class, &#8220;all eyes fall on you.&#8221;<br><br><strong>Self-censorship.</strong> <a href="https://www.insidehighered.com/advice/2012/11/12/essay-teaching-veterans">Nate Kreuter</a>, a professor who has taught many veterans, wrote that some stayed quiet because classmates talked about war in &#8220;oversimplified, na&#239;ve terms,&#8221; or because they worried classmates &#8220;couldn&#8217;t handle&#8221; their views. Kreuter had other veteran students who, accustomed to the chain of command, deferred to him as instructor and needed explicit permission before they would disagree.</p><p><strong>Too much deference.</strong> <a href="https://alumni.berkeley.edu/california-magazine/fall-2018-culture-shift/5-questions-ellen-moore-veterans-higher-education/">Moore found campus guidelines</a> that &#8220;advised against holding classroom discussions about the wars&#8221; to avoid offending veterans. Some schools, including <a href="https://insidehighered.com/node/78015">Ohio State</a> and <a href="https://wgbh.org/news/education-news/2018-04-26/can-homer-attract-veterans-to-college">the University of Vermont</a>, have set up special class sections that only veterans can take, going back to 2009. A Marine in a different section of that Ohio State course supported the idea, since with only veterans in the room, &#8220;we [veterans] could&#8217;ve been a little freer&#8221; in class discussions. That&#8217;s understandable. But when veterans talk about war only with each other, the civilian students down the hall never hear them.</p><h2><strong>What helps</strong></h2><p>Faculty can improve the situation by remembering to do a few simple things. For starters, ask whether there are veterans in the room. Tell them out loud that you want them to feel free to disagree with anything, since many spent years in jobs where contradicting the boss could cost them. And don&#8217;t ask any one of them to speak for the armed forces. As <a href="https://www.aaup.org/academe/issues/104-3/what-do-you-know-about-veterans">Marshall Thomas</a>, a Marine veteran who runs veterans affairs for the Cal State system, says, &#8220;If you&#8217;ve met a veteran, you&#8217;ve met <em>one</em> veteran.&#8221;</p><p>Hatch, the former Navy SEAL, shows what it looks like when it works. He went on to <a href="https://admissions.yale.edu/bulldogs-blogs/jimmy/2025/02/25/seminar-and-courage">help teach a Yale seminar</a> on what war does to the people caught up in it. A student once told him, in a room that included ROTC cadets, &#8220;Jimmy, I do not support the U.S. military.&#8221; He took it as proof the seminar was working, because she felt safe saying it to his face. &#8220;I&#8217;ve seen courage on the battlefield,&#8221; he wrote, &#8220;and I now see it in GLBL 339.&#8221;</p><p>Hutchins worried that veterans would lower the tone of the university. He should have worried about what a university loses without them. A seminar on war where no one has seen one is missing a crucial viewpoint. So is a policy school where no one has carried out the kind of military policy its students will someday write.</p><p>So on Veterans Day, give veterans a seat at the table. Then listen to what they have to say, and feel free to disagree.</p><p class="button-wrapper" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/veterans-in-the-seminar-room?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Share&quot;,&quot;action&quot;:null,&quot;class&quot;:null}" data-component-name="ButtonCreateButton"><a class="button primary" href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/veterans-in-the-seminar-room?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share"><span>Share</span></a></p><div><hr></div><div class="subscription-widget-wrap-editor" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/subscribe?&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Subscribe&quot;,&quot;language&quot;:&quot;en&quot;}" data-component-name="SubscribeWidgetToDOM"><div class="subscription-widget show-subscribe"><div class="preamble"><p class="cta-caption"><em>Free The Inquiry</em> brings you essays, expert commentary, and conversations about open inquiry in the academy. Subscribe to stay up to date.</p></div><form class="subscription-widget-subscribe"><input type="email" class="email-input" name="email" placeholder="Type your email&#8230;" tabindex="-1"><input type="submit" class="button primary" value="Subscribe"><div class="fake-input-wrapper"><div class="fake-input"></div><div class="fake-button"></div></div></form></div></div><p></p>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Open Inquiry News: A Blue Wave Crashes on Campus]]></title><description><![CDATA[The midterms, a worried free speech movement, and what it takes for scholars to resist tribal politics]]></description><link>https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/open-inquiry-news-a-blue-wave-crashes</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/open-inquiry-news-a-blue-wave-crashes</guid><dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Regnier]]></dc:creator><pubDate>Tue, 10 Nov 2026 12:01:37 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!1G-t!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ffa6dc585-2b5d-4fd1-b4f9-363b8f5926d0_3600x2403.jpeg" length="0" type="image/jpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="captioned-image-container"><figure><a class="image-link image2 is-viewable-img" target="_blank" href="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!1G-t!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ffa6dc585-2b5d-4fd1-b4f9-363b8f5926d0_3600x2403.jpeg" data-component-name="Image2ToDOM"><div class="image2-inset"><picture><source type="image/webp" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!1G-t!,w_424,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ffa6dc585-2b5d-4fd1-b4f9-363b8f5926d0_3600x2403.jpeg 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!1G-t!,w_848,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ffa6dc585-2b5d-4fd1-b4f9-363b8f5926d0_3600x2403.jpeg 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!1G-t!,w_1272,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ffa6dc585-2b5d-4fd1-b4f9-363b8f5926d0_3600x2403.jpeg 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!1G-t!,w_1456,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ffa6dc585-2b5d-4fd1-b4f9-363b8f5926d0_3600x2403.jpeg 1456w" sizes="100vw"><img src="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!1G-t!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ffa6dc585-2b5d-4fd1-b4f9-363b8f5926d0_3600x2403.jpeg" width="1456" height="972" data-attrs="{&quot;src&quot;:&quot;https://substack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/fa6dc585-2b5d-4fd1-b4f9-363b8f5926d0_3600x2403.jpeg&quot;,&quot;srcNoWatermark&quot;:null,&quot;fullscreen&quot;:null,&quot;imageSize&quot;:null,&quot;height&quot;:972,&quot;width&quot;:1456,&quot;resizeWidth&quot;:null,&quot;bytes&quot;:5636402,&quot;alt&quot;:null,&quot;title&quot;:null,&quot;type&quot;:&quot;image/jpeg&quot;,&quot;href&quot;:null,&quot;belowTheFold&quot;:false,&quot;topImage&quot;:true,&quot;internalRedirect&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/i/224236024?img=https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ffa6dc585-2b5d-4fd1-b4f9-363b8f5926d0_3600x2403.jpeg&quot;,&quot;isProcessing&quot;:false,&quot;align&quot;:null,&quot;offset&quot;:false}" class="sizing-normal" alt="" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!1G-t!,w_424,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ffa6dc585-2b5d-4fd1-b4f9-363b8f5926d0_3600x2403.jpeg 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!1G-t!,w_848,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ffa6dc585-2b5d-4fd1-b4f9-363b8f5926d0_3600x2403.jpeg 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!1G-t!,w_1272,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ffa6dc585-2b5d-4fd1-b4f9-363b8f5926d0_3600x2403.jpeg 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!1G-t!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ffa6dc585-2b5d-4fd1-b4f9-363b8f5926d0_3600x2403.jpeg 1456w" sizes="100vw" fetchpriority="high"></picture><div class="image-link-expand"><div class="pencraft pc-display-flex pc-gap-8 pc-reset"><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container restack-image buttonBase-tqxFUX" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg aria-hidden="true" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 20 20" fill="none" stroke-width="1.5" stroke="var(--color-fg-primary)" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="icon-noB79L"><g><path d="M2.53001 7.81595C3.49179 4.73911 6.43281 2.5 9.91173 2.5C13.1684 2.5 15.9537 4.46214 17.0852 7.23684L17.6179 8.67647M17.6179 8.67647L18.5002 4.26471M17.6179 8.67647L13.6473 6.91176M17.4995 12.1841C16.5378 15.2609 13.5967 17.5 10.1178 17.5C6.86118 17.5 4.07589 15.5379 2.94432 12.7632L2.41165 11.3235M2.41165 11.3235L1.5293 15.7353M2.41165 11.3235L6.38224 13.0882"></path></g></svg></button><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container view-image buttonBase-tqxFUX" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="2" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" class="lucide lucide-maximize2 lucide-maximize-2 icon-noB79L"><polyline points="15 3 21 3 21 9"></polyline><polyline points="9 21 3 21 3 15"></polyline><line x1="21" x2="14" y1="3" y2="10"></line><line x1="3" x2="10" y1="21" y2="14"></line></svg></button></div></div></div></a></figure></div><p>The past two weeks brought a blue wave in the midterms, a gathering of free speech defenders in Philadelphia, and an inside account of how writers lost faith in the principle of free expression. Underneath all of it is a question that matters for academia: when professional norms run up against political loyalties, which one gives?</p><p>Here are the stories we&#8217;re following at HxA.</p><div><hr></div><h2><strong>In flipped states, &#8220;sayonara&#8221; to an era?</strong></h2><p>The &#8220;blue wave&#8221; washed ashore on election day. What will that mean for open inquiry? Education pundit Rick Hess <a href="https://www.educationnext.org/judging-education-reactions-and-overreactions-to-the-big-blue-wave/">predicts one consequence</a>:</p><blockquote><p>A signature Republican higher ed reform has been the push to establish civic centers at flagship universities. Several newish centers are in red states that elected Democratic governors, including those at the University of Texas, the University of Iowa, and Ohio State University. These programs may be in hot water. &#8230; While it&#8217;s not clear that new governors or legislators will target these programs, the centers will surely have fewer allies and more critics as new appointees are named to state agencies and boards over time.</p></blockquote><p>In Texas, Republicans in power supported new civics programs, but also &#8212; as <em>Free the Inquiry</em> readers know &#8212; ushered in new <a href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/the-weekly-the-education-department">bans</a> on teaching certain topics and concepts, as well as an unexplained <a href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/the-weekly-course-cuts-and-tenure">tenure denial</a>, and academic <a href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/the-weekly-can-higher-ed-explain">programs</a> phased out with little explanation.</p><p><em><a href="https://www.insidehighered.com/news/government/politics-elections/2026/11/04/democrats-texas-takeover-could-reshape-boards-and?utm_source=Inside+Higher+Ed&amp;utm_campaign=1d6d96930b-DNU_2021_COPY_03&amp;utm_medium=email&amp;utm_term=0_1fcbc04421-1d6d96930b-712289939&amp;mc_cid=1d6d96930b&amp;mc_eid=457eb17b46">Inside Higher Ed</a></em> recalls that last year, after the Legislature put faculty senates under the control of boards and presidents, Texas Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick told &#8220;looney Marxist UT professors&#8221; to find a blue state: &#8220;Yippie Ki Yay! Adios! Sayonara! Auf Wiedersehen! Au Revoir! In every language you can possibly think of: Goodbye!&#8221; The day after the election, UT Austin drama professor Charlotte Canning quoted that last line back to him.</p><p>Trash talk aside, there is reason to be hopeful and still cautious. We sincerely hope that externally imposed taboos, and the broader chilling effects they create, will no longer be choosin&#8217; Texas. But we&#8217;ll have to stay vigilant, since some of the sharpest threats to open inquiry for faculty and students have always come from other faculty and students.</p><div><hr></div><h2><strong>Intellectual freedom, not just on paper</strong></h2><p>In the field of literature, George Packer writes in <em>The Atlantic</em> that threats to expression can come <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/11/philip-roth-political-novelists/689337/">&#8220;from inside the house&#8221;</a> like a horror movie villain. As he saw it during a period of controversy at the advocacy group PEN America, for some stakeholders &#8220;literary freedom was never the real concern. What mattered was whether PEN helped or harmed their political cause.&#8221;</p><p>In academia as in the literary world, when one&#8217;s <em>peers</em> have the ability to shun and punish under the banner of their expert judgment, formal protections for freedom can only go so far. There&#8217;s something else needed that is less formal and harder to measure, but no less important. We could extend to academic open inquiry what Packer says about free speech:</p><blockquote><p>[F]ree speech depends on more than the law. It needs a <em>culture</em> of free expression&#8212;a set of widely shared habits and expectations that guide daily life, an ability to tolerate disagreement, a willingness to listen even, or especially, when we don&#8217;t like what we hear. The First Amendment stands there like a block of stone against the efforts of would-be government censors, but a culture of free expression is a delicate thing that has to be trained and tended. It can bloom and fade. It lives or dies in the inner recesses of our minds, releasing or smothering thoughts and words regardless of the protections of the First Amendment. &#8230; In other words, a culture of free expression is up to us.</p></blockquote><p>The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE) is a leading advocate for expressive freedoms, both in law and in practice. HxA was proud to be a sponsor of FIRE&#8217;s Soapbox conference in Philadelphia this past week, where the state of intellectual freedom in higher education was a prominent topic.</p><p>Independent journalist <a href="https://www.racket.news/p/free-speech-will-survive">Matt Taibbi</a> was in Philadelphia too, and came away uneasy. &#8220;Supporters of civil liberties are becoming a subculture,&#8221; he writes. One longtime donor told him, &#8220;Everyone was for free speech then. Where have all my friends gone?&#8221; FIRE&#8217;s Will Creeley and Nico Perrino offered some comfort: across American history, free speech has often depended on a small, stubborn community. But Taibbi&#8217;s larger point is that lawsuits can only do so much. Free speech culture, he writes, &#8220;is about far more than the right to say unpleasant things. It&#8217;s a way of life.&#8221;</p><div><hr></div><h2><strong>Can scholarly norms resist the call of politics?</strong></h2><p>At one discussion at the Soapbox event, panelists (including HxA board chair Jeffrey Flier and HxA member Evan Morris) decried examples of politicization in the field of medicine &#8212; but constructively disagreed about how to quantify the relative size of the problem in a field that continues to steadily make life-saving discoveries, far from the publicity on topics such as youth transgender medicine.</p><p>There certainly is a danger, especially in advocacy circles, of talking as if the worst scandals in an academic field are typical of it. Science is built on the constant correction of errors, and overstating a problem for the public may be as damaging as understating it. </p><p>At the same time, it is not entirely comforting to think that scholarly norms are what scholars hold dear, <em>except</em> in the moments, and on the topics, when their fields are most politically relevant. If we follow the best evidence in the cognitive science of reading <em>except </em>when we train teachers, for example, or adhere to the longstanding public health views on pandemic responses <em>except </em>in an actual pandemic, what does that say about the academy&#8217;s true priorities?</p><p>Of course, complaining about a culture is not the same as fixing it. Cultures are built on practices, in this case academic practices, that usually don&#8217;t require permission from any statehouse. To build a culture of open inquiry, host a <a href="https://heterodoxacademy.org/resources/heterodox-conversations-%EF%B8%8F-organizers-guide/">Heterodox Conversation</a>. Study a <a href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/topics-non-grata">taboo topic</a>. Start an <a href="https://heterodoxacademy.org/resources/the-adversarial-collaboration-method-for-research-and-scholarship/">adversarial collaboration</a>. Help students <a href="https://heterodoxacademy.org/resources/launch-a-disagree-with-a-professor-program-on-your-campus/">disagree with a professor</a>, maybe for the first time.</p><p>Waves come and waves go. Universities can still decide to run a tighter ship.</p><div><hr></div><p><em>Have campus news related to open inquiry that we should be aware of? Send it to <a href="mailto:communications@heterodoxacademy.org">communications@heterodoxacademy.org</a></em></p><p class="button-wrapper" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/open-inquiry-news-a-blue-wave-crashes?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Share&quot;,&quot;action&quot;:null,&quot;class&quot;:null}" data-component-name="ButtonCreateButton"><a class="button primary" href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/open-inquiry-news-a-blue-wave-crashes?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share"><span>Share</span></a></p><div><hr></div><div class="subscription-widget-wrap-editor" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/subscribe?&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Subscribe&quot;,&quot;language&quot;:&quot;en&quot;}" data-component-name="SubscribeWidgetToDOM"><div class="subscription-widget show-subscribe"><div class="preamble"><p class="cta-caption"><em>Free The Inquiry</em> brings you essays, expert commentary, and conversations about open inquiry in the academy. Subscribe to stay up to date.</p></div><form class="subscription-widget-subscribe"><input type="email" class="email-input" name="email" placeholder="Type your email&#8230;" tabindex="-1"><input type="submit" class="button primary" value="Subscribe"><div class="fake-input-wrapper"><div class="fake-input"></div><div class="fake-button"></div></div></form></div></div><p></p>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Culture's Role in Explaining Poverty and Inequality]]></title><description><![CDATA[A cultural anthropologist argues that culture belongs alongside structure and the individual in any explanation of poverty, inequality and health.]]></description><link>https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/cultures-role-in-explaining-poverty</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/cultures-role-in-explaining-poverty</guid><dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Jindra]]></dc:creator><pubDate>Thu, 05 Nov 2026 13:03:34 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://api.substack.com/feed/podcast/223526508/f323ba994b5a00e7e0fd6700ce8058c1.mp3" length="0" type="audio/mpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Why do people live so differently, and what does that mean for poverty and health? In this Heterodox Academy virtual colloquium, cultural anthropologist Michael Jindra argues that culture belongs in the answer. He starts from a three-part model of any social problem: structure (jobs, discrimination, the tax system), culture (lifestyles, habits, values) and the individual (biology, personality). Updating the culture of poverty debates of the 1960s with newer work in anthropology and sociology, he argues that academics lean on structural explanations and give the other two parts less attention, partly from wariness about blaming the victim.</em></p><p><em>Jindra then asks what pulls people in different directions: wealth, power, meaning, family and the search for experience, from extreme jobs and thrill-seeking to downshifting and simple living. Along the way he covers spending, saving and inheritance habits, ethnographic studies of subcultures from bicycle couriers and surfers to homeschoolers and nomadic groups, and the life course, before closing with what it all means for mentoring, parenting and schools. Jindra is a cultural anthropologist at the Institute on Culture, Religion and World Affairs and a Visiting Research Scholar at Boston University. A transcript of Jindra&#8217;s talk follows below.</em></p><div><hr></div><p><strong>Michael Jindra:</strong> We&#8217;re doing a classic topic here: culture and social problems, really, is what I&#8217;m looking at. But I&#8217;m going to update it. I mean, you know, there&#8217;s a long history of that. I won&#8217;t get into all the details, going back to the poverty of culture, sorry, the culture of poverty debates back into the &#8216;60s. But what I want to do is update it a bit and look at how some of the more recent research in both anthropology and sociology really can add to this, especially looking at subcultures and lifestyle diversity and how that&#8217;s increased, especially in Western countries and in the U.S., over the years.</p><p>So what I have in front of you is kind of the basic model of the big picture of how this fits in, I would say, theoretically, as far as how do you understand any social problem? What do you have to look at? And this is where you see, I think, a lot of the problems and the one-sidedness in academia among anthropologists and sociologists that look at some of these problems. They love the structural explanations there. My argument is you need to consider structure, cultural, and individual especially. I mean, especially all of them. Sociologists, anthropologists probably focus more on the structures and the cultures. Individuals, that gets more, of course, into things like psychology. But they all overlap and they all influence each other, of course, right? Structural and cultural is this back and forth. They influence each other. And individuals, of course, make up cultures and make up structures. And so you have these mutual interactions going on.</p><p>So which social problems, mentioned quickly at the top there? I mean, poverty is probably the main one I look at, and overlaps into research I&#8217;ve been doing with my wife, for instance, on how nonprofits help the poor. I&#8217;ve done some volunteer work; we&#8217;ve published in that area also. But this also applies to other things like crime, education disparities, health. Lots of research going on in a lot of those areas, again, with a focus usually on structural stuff. But over the years, as I&#8217;ve worked on this project, I find nice little nuggets, I would say, in all of these areas of people looking at other people, at cultures, at groups, at how people have agencies. And so I&#8217;ll look more at the model of that too.</p><p>So culture has, of course, traditionally been left out often of issues of poverty. People are wary of that. They&#8217;re wary of things like blaming the victim, things like that. But I don&#8217;t think that&#8217;s&#8212; if you want to tackle these problems, if you want to try to resolve them, you have to include that, of course. A lot of times people will only focus on structures when they write about. They don&#8217;t even mention cultures or individuals. If you mention poverty and you talk only about cultures and influence and you don&#8217;t mention structures, you&#8217;re going to get nailed by the reviewers. There&#8217;s really kind of a double standard going on there. So I always&#8212; one of the things I look at any analysis is, are they at least acknowledging all three, even if a person will focus on one over the other?</p><p>Let&#8217;s see. And there&#8217;s other people. I, you know, just referring to sociologist Orlando Patterson, uses something kind of like this in his <em>Cultural Matrix</em> book and in some of his other books there. So that&#8217;s kind of where I&#8217;m coming from, focusing on the cultural side here.</p><p>So putting it structural, if people don&#8217;t understand what structural means, could be a number of things: structures in the economy, low-paying, high-paying jobs, lots of debate over that, the hollowing out of working-class jobs, high-paying working-class jobs, for instance. Discrimination is another factor. Some people in structure will look at the political system and maybe how the tax system or how politics are built in to help the wealthier and hurt the poor. Those are all kind of put in the structural side of things.</p><p>What I want to look at is cultural explanations. I like to focus, as an anthropologist&#8212; I&#8217;m a cultural anthropologist, you know, I like to get kind of down and dirty, talk to people, find out what&#8217;s going on in their lives. Kind of from the bottom up has always been my interest, to look at what are they actually doing in their life? What are their lifestyles? What are their habits? And then how has that shifted over time? How has leisure work shifted, the consumption side of things and the work side shifted?</p><p>So from looking at poverty, for instance, you know, the work side of things, the income side of things, the consumption side of things, the expense side of things. So if people are consuming a lot of money, not working much, they&#8217;re getting gradually more into debt. And of course we know credit card debt, and a lot of people have a lot of debt issues, especially in our very high consumer-oriented society. So these processes, I think, are very, very important. And then how they are different between different groups, not just ethnic groups, but subcultural groups and lifestyle groups, and I&#8217;ll get into that a little bit. So then there&#8217;s also&#8212; and then, of course, social class is important here, too, and family processes, things that diverge. So even you see differences among groups and how different kind of groups use the internet, how much certain groups watch TV and how much they read, what they focus on, schooling, focus on consumption, things like that. There&#8217;s all these differential patterns that are interesting to look at that certainly play a role in things like poverty and some of the other social problems.</p><p>Okay. And then going back even more basic, I think to understand these issues and divergences in that, I think you really have to look at what are some of the major human motivations. So why do people go off in different directions? How are we pulled in different directions? Well, different people will have different motivations for doing things. Some of the classic ones are on top, right? I mean, think of social theory, Marxian, Weberian explanations, whether it&#8217;s wealth, power, people after power, groups are protecting their interests, or people after meaning. They do things because they find it meaningful, right?</p><p>A lot of people focus more on family. So if you look at some of the patterns, for instance, Latino groups like to keep their kids at home. They don&#8217;t necessarily hunt out the most selective college. They&#8217;ll look more for the college that&#8217;s closer to home because they&#8217;ll focus more on family. And again, these are general patterns. There&#8217;s always exceptions, of course, among groups, but you can see these general differences. And people have written about all these things in general. Asian American groups tend to focus more on getting into the best selective college, even if it&#8217;s far from home, Ivy League especially, right? So even though they&#8217;re focused on family, they&#8217;re also focused a lot more on education and the highest attainment of education. So these are patterns you find among groups, too.</p><p>The one that I find most interesting there is the fourth one that&#8217;s listed. It&#8217;s not the one that&#8217;s necessarily found in classic social theory very, very much. But I think it&#8217;s one that really drives a lot of people, especially nowadays in a consumer society. And I kind of, you know, compile all the experiences, kind of the general term I use. But, you know, including a lot in that: fantasy, fun, flow. Edgework is a sociological term, how people&#8212; it&#8217;s kind of the adrenaline. You know, there&#8217;s certain subculture of guys that are adrenaline-filled. I have one son like that right now, actually. The search for emotional energy is a sociological term that you find. Gosh, his name is escaping me. Famous anthropologist that focuses&#8212; sorry, famous sociologist that focuses on that a lot.</p><p>And of course, then it can get into some troubling things, things like addictions, drugs, gaming, gambling, gang work. You know, search for what is&#8212; why do people join gangs, right? Is that kind of a search for family? Not necessarily for wealth or power. It&#8217;s often they&#8217;re looking more for a group. Or for some things, it&#8217;s people are doing things for the thrill of things. I became aware about 20 years ago of a little subset of sociologists that are doing cultural criminology. And their main point is that people don&#8217;t steal a car for the value of the car. A lot of times they don&#8217;t steal it to sell it. They&#8217;ll steal it, take it for a joyride, totally trash it. They&#8217;ll do it for the thrill of things. A lot of people violate norms for the thrill of violating norms. These are not motivations, kind of the classic motivations, that you&#8217;re doing it for wealth or for the money, but you&#8217;re doing it for often other reasons.</p><p>So, you know, the fourth category, I mean, people spend a lot. I mean, sports is a fascinating subset of&#8212; look at what happened, what&#8217;s happening in college football now, the billions and billions of dollars that we&#8217;re throwing at that, that people are giving the universities for their sports teams, right? Something&#8217;s going on there, basic about human motivation, that we become attached to these organizations, these institutions, your home university, your favorite team, and you will divest lots of money.</p><p>Just the other day, I was with a friend in a cemetery. I&#8217;m from Wisconsin. I&#8217;m actually visiting back there right now, even though we&#8217;re living out West right now. But you go to a cemetery and you see Packer flags in Wisconsin in the cemetery. That says something. Having studied funeral rituals in Africa, you know, that the death rites are something that really shows you what society is really concerned about, what they think is very important. And that&#8217;s, again, a kind of a quasi-religious motivation, that people will devote themselves to things like that.</p><p>So the inequality research&#8212; the dissatisfaction I&#8217;ve had with a lot of the inequality research is it&#8217;s kind of, I call it there on the bottom, a limited, warped view of human life, because they&#8217;ll focus maybe on the primary ones before. They focus on interest groups, they focus on the structural reasons, and they really kind of neglect these other ones, which I think are just as important, or perhaps even more important. So you have to look at the consumption side of things, not just the production side of things.</p><p>This is a way to summarize some of this, right? It&#8217;s not just about income, it&#8217;s about how people are also spending money, getting into debt, not building savings, not building inheritances that they pass on to their children. That&#8217;s a good middle and upper-middle-class habit, right? You save money, you buy a house, you build equity in that, you end up passing that on to your kids. Well, a lot of groups aren&#8217;t doing that. African Americans, much lower. And there&#8217;s various reasons for that. Maybe some of that is structural, probably, but some of that is certainly cultural, and it&#8217;s the combination between that. They don&#8217;t pass nearly as much on in inheritances. Their savings rates tend to be lower. Asian Americans&#8217; savings rates tend to be higher. And so you can look at some of the data from the Consumer Expenditure Survey and things like that and see some of these patterns between groups and how both they work&#8212; some groups work more than others&#8212; and how they spend. So all of these things kind of enter into understanding things like income and other social problems.</p><p>So looking specifically, I&#8217;ve got examples here of the ethnographic work that I have noticed over the years. Very interesting stuff, I think, going on, especially on subcultures, leisure studies, occupations. You&#8217;ve got work on occupational devotees, right? People that devote their lives to their jobs, or extreme jobs: people who love jobs, they take little vacations, they get their&#8212; and again, this is a mix of motives, right? So it could be for income, they want to make a lot of money, but for some people their jobs are their identity. That&#8217;s where they get their meaning from. And so it&#8217;s hard to generalize exactly what the motive is. It&#8217;s often mixed motives in lots of these different things.</p><p>Subcultures of experience, getting back to that experience motivation again. Both work subcultures, like the bicycle couriers&#8212; of course, that&#8217;s kind of going down a little bit, I think, with&#8212; well, you&#8217;ve got the delivery drivers now too. But edgework is a term Stephen Lyng, I think, uses that. I&#8217;ve got citations there, and I can send people, you know, citations too if they want specifics about this. But pop culture, surfers. Tango is a subculture; my wife is going to a tango meeting tonight, actually. Postmaterialists are a general term that you often find: people that want to experience life and don&#8217;t focus a lot on just climbing the corporate ladder, necessarily, getting income.</p><p>So you have a lot of different diversity of subcultures amongst these different groups. Downshifters, simple livers: some people intentionally get out of consumer society. They want to downshift from high-paying jobs, or they simply want a simple living agrarian lifestyle. I thought of that recently when&#8212; those of you who know Wendell Berry, he passed away recently. Very much a strong representative of that agrarian, stick-to-the-land, you-don&#8217;t-need-income. Things like family and meaning are much more important in that kind of subculture.</p><p>You have itinerants. The homeless subculture is interesting. Again, a number of reasons for that. Some of that is structural, high prices, lack of housing, but more of it than you would think tends to be people that don&#8217;t want to be tied down. In anthropology, there&#8217;s a whole study on nomadic cultures and the appeal of nomadism, of not having a lot of things that you own that you have to drive around. The groups in Europe, too, that used to be called Gypsies and now called Roma are a group that you could fit into that a little bit, that tend to be semi-nomadic. Some of them are settling down, but they do not get themselves sucked into the modern corporate complex institutional worlds that most of us have chosen and most of us have been socialized into working effectively in. There are a lot of groups that simply prefer to stay outside of that complex group.</p><p>And then, you know, more on the meaning side of things, the normative side of things, the political side of things: environmentalists, communitarian groups, people for political reasons, whether on the political left or on the&#8212; you can find groups in the political left and the political right that form their own kind of subcultures that drive them in different ways economically. You have things like homeschoolers, too, that form.</p><p>And the groups and the motivations that I looked at&#8212; so the motivations, you know, there&#8217;s a lot of different motivations for why people do what they do. I summarize that, generalize that, to look at especially those motivations that affect people&#8217;s lifestyles and habits, that might enter into calculations of whether they make a lot of money or don&#8217;t make a lot of money, or whether they enter a life of crime, or related even to health issues, right? Consumer&#8212; you have the people that are the fitness people, and then you have a lot of Americans that struggle with overeating and with poor health, because we&#8217;re not a culture, compared to the European cultures, that tend to walk and bike and things like that more. We tend to be much more sedentary in our cars, things like that. So those daily habits are really kind of interesting. And then, of course, I mean, there&#8217;s an ethnic component, a religious subculture component to all of these things too. Patterns that vary among these different groups here.</p><p>So let me just take a peek at the time here, and okay. So, yeah, I&#8217;ll start winding this up a little bit, getting towards the end, just of the introduction. We&#8217;ll open it up to questions, but we&#8217;ve got&#8212; this is, I like this life course approach. So another way to look at how this process happens is the life course approach, right? You start out as an individual, you&#8217;re born, you&#8217;ve got a certain biology, and I don&#8217;t want to neglect my biology here. I do think that&#8217;s important, but again, it&#8217;s more on the individual side. Anthropology, I think there is good work now that&#8217;s interdisciplinary, that&#8217;s trying to combine all these things together. But our biology, our neurodiversity is another term, our personality, things like that: the individual.</p><p>As you go through your life, of course, you gradually get exposed. Your family is your first influence, then your neighborhood, then your schools. And then you become more aware or influenced also at the same time by your socioeconomic class patterns. Think of Annette Lareau&#8217;s work on&#8212; what&#8217;s the term is&#8212; how you, anyway, it&#8217;s the concerted cultivation. That&#8217;s it, concerted cultivation: how certain middle and upper-middle-class families really focus on having their kids do well in school and cultivate their kids much more, in a way, in order to be successful economically, is fitting in that middle. And then, of course, all these things are influenced by regional, ethnic, religious traditions, immigrant traditions, some more upwardly mobile, some more family-oriented, some more religious-oriented, that will tend to kind of push or pull people off in different directions.</p><p>Then we have the overall structural environment, too, that we&#8217;re exposed to, especially once we&#8217;re adults. We have technologies, the influence of screens, of the internet, of course. We&#8217;re trying to figure out what&#8217;s that doing to our minds and how that&#8217;s affecting also patterns now, both in mental health and in other social issues involving economic mobility or immobility, or in crime and things like that. And the overall structure, of course, of the political economy, the availability of jobs, things like that. So that&#8217;s all structural, kind of cultural, individual. Another snapshot of how those three things interact through this life course approach right here.</p><p>Just another example of interesting work that really is not touched on a lot by a lot of sociologists or anthropologists that are looking at this is just the different patterns and oversavers and overspenders. So there&#8217;s a whole literature of people that talk about financial literacy. It&#8217;s kind of more in the nonprofits world. I&#8217;ve been a volunteer at a nonprofit that helps people understand their spending and saving habits and how those are really influential. If you can shift your habits, you can actually start building wealth. What you&#8217;re doing is you&#8217;re basically trying to shift from often a generational poverty pattern of spending money as soon as you get it to one that kind of plans for the future.</p><p>Bridges Out of Poverty, if any of you have heard of that nonprofit, national nonprofit. Well, they&#8217;re not a nonprofit, they&#8217;re a for-profit. But anyway, they put on seminars for people that are really a good social class analysis of how we&#8217;ve all been socialized into these different kinds of groups. So people from generational poverty have not often been exposed to middle-class values and ethics. We often forget how unique and specialized these middle-class habits are, of planning and working and understanding this complex society. So these are another way of looking at it.</p><p>I&#8217;ll kind of end it here. I mean, lifestyle diversity and how people&#8212; even Weber looked at it, <em>Lebensf&#252;hrung</em>, life conduct. There is some of this in classic social theory. Different people have looked at lifestyle and habits and things like that, so you find nice nuggets in there. There are implications to mentoring, parenting classes, family influences, schools and education, certain culture of schools that you knew. An example, like &#8220;no excuses&#8221; schools: certain schools seem to be doing better now, like even in Mississippi, that&#8217;s, if you&#8217;re reading the literature there, to a certain kind of cultural pattern and how that interacts with family involvement in schools, things like that.</p><p class="button-wrapper" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/cultures-role-in-explaining-poverty?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Share&quot;,&quot;action&quot;:null,&quot;class&quot;:null}" data-component-name="ButtonCreateButton"><a class="button primary" href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/cultures-role-in-explaining-poverty?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share"><span>Share</span></a></p><div><hr></div><div class="subscription-widget-wrap-editor" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/subscribe?&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Subscribe&quot;,&quot;language&quot;:&quot;en&quot;}" data-component-name="SubscribeWidgetToDOM"><div class="subscription-widget show-subscribe"><div class="preamble"><p class="cta-caption"><em>Free The Inquiry</em> brings you essays, expert commentary, and conversations about open inquiry in the academy. Subscribe to stay up to date.</p></div><form class="subscription-widget-subscribe"><input type="email" class="email-input" name="email" placeholder="Type your email&#8230;" tabindex="-1"><input type="submit" class="button primary" value="Subscribe"><div class="fake-input-wrapper"><div class="fake-input"></div><div class="fake-button"></div></div></form></div></div><p></p>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[The Progressive Monoculture on Campus Is Eroding Public Trust]]></title><description><![CDATA[Restoring public trust in higher education requires a new commitment to intellectual pluralism]]></description><link>https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/how-universities-can-break-out-of</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/how-universities-can-break-out-of</guid><dc:creator><![CDATA[Heather McGrew]]></dc:creator><pubDate>Wed, 04 Nov 2026 16:02:07 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!5sZN!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fc4c5f210-c721-4540-b644-50a55a1a3b89_1456x1048.jpeg" length="0" type="image/jpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="captioned-image-container"><figure><a class="image-link image2 is-viewable-img" target="_blank" href="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!5sZN!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fc4c5f210-c721-4540-b644-50a55a1a3b89_1456x1048.jpeg" data-component-name="Image2ToDOM"><div class="image2-inset"><picture><source type="image/webp" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!5sZN!,w_424,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fc4c5f210-c721-4540-b644-50a55a1a3b89_1456x1048.jpeg 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!5sZN!,w_848,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fc4c5f210-c721-4540-b644-50a55a1a3b89_1456x1048.jpeg 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!5sZN!,w_1272,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fc4c5f210-c721-4540-b644-50a55a1a3b89_1456x1048.jpeg 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!5sZN!,w_1456,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fc4c5f210-c721-4540-b644-50a55a1a3b89_1456x1048.jpeg 1456w" sizes="100vw"><img src="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!5sZN!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fc4c5f210-c721-4540-b644-50a55a1a3b89_1456x1048.jpeg" width="1456" height="1048" data-attrs="{&quot;src&quot;:&quot;https://substack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/c4c5f210-c721-4540-b644-50a55a1a3b89_1456x1048.jpeg&quot;,&quot;srcNoWatermark&quot;:null,&quot;fullscreen&quot;:null,&quot;imageSize&quot;:null,&quot;height&quot;:1048,&quot;width&quot;:1456,&quot;resizeWidth&quot;:null,&quot;bytes&quot;:1200896,&quot;alt&quot;:null,&quot;title&quot;:null,&quot;type&quot;:&quot;image/jpeg&quot;,&quot;href&quot;:null,&quot;belowTheFold&quot;:false,&quot;topImage&quot;:true,&quot;internalRedirect&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/i/213023411?img=https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fc4c5f210-c721-4540-b644-50a55a1a3b89_1456x1048.jpeg&quot;,&quot;isProcessing&quot;:false,&quot;align&quot;:null,&quot;offset&quot;:false}" class="sizing-normal" alt="" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!5sZN!,w_424,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fc4c5f210-c721-4540-b644-50a55a1a3b89_1456x1048.jpeg 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!5sZN!,w_848,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fc4c5f210-c721-4540-b644-50a55a1a3b89_1456x1048.jpeg 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!5sZN!,w_1272,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fc4c5f210-c721-4540-b644-50a55a1a3b89_1456x1048.jpeg 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!5sZN!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fc4c5f210-c721-4540-b644-50a55a1a3b89_1456x1048.jpeg 1456w" sizes="100vw" fetchpriority="high"></picture><div class="image-link-expand"><div class="pencraft pc-display-flex pc-gap-8 pc-reset"><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container restack-image buttonBase-tqxFUX" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg aria-hidden="true" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 20 20" fill="none" stroke-width="1.5" stroke="var(--color-fg-primary)" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="icon-noB79L"><g><path d="M2.53001 7.81595C3.49179 4.73911 6.43281 2.5 9.91173 2.5C13.1684 2.5 15.9537 4.46214 17.0852 7.23684L17.6179 8.67647M17.6179 8.67647L18.5002 4.26471M17.6179 8.67647L13.6473 6.91176M17.4995 12.1841C16.5378 15.2609 13.5967 17.5 10.1178 17.5C6.86118 17.5 4.07589 15.5379 2.94432 12.7632L2.41165 11.3235M2.41165 11.3235L1.5293 15.7353M2.41165 11.3235L6.38224 13.0882"></path></g></svg></button><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container view-image buttonBase-tqxFUX" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="2" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" class="lucide lucide-maximize2 lucide-maximize-2 icon-noB79L"><polyline points="15 3 21 3 21 9"></polyline><polyline points="9 21 3 21 3 15"></polyline><line x1="21" x2="14" y1="3" y2="10"></line><line x1="3" x2="10" y1="21" y2="14"></line></svg></button></div></div></div></a><figcaption class="image-caption">"Narcissus" by Caravaggio, 1597&#8211;1599. Wikimedia Commons, Public Domain.</figcaption></figure></div><p>Until recently, college was almost unquestionably valued as a natural next step for graduating high school seniors: an opportunity to expand their knowledge, gain valuable soft and hard skills, and learn about adulthood. But in the last decade or so, these perceptions have changed significantly.</p><p><a href="https://www.forbes.com/sites/mattscogin/2026/06/22/the-collapse-of-trust-in-higher-ed-why-pr-wont-fix-systemic-failure/">Recent surveys of Americans</a> show that our institutions of higher education now have a serious trust problem. A number of factors have contributed to this loss of trust, but perhaps the most important is the perception of ideological capture and indoctrination, specifically that most universities have become left-wing echo chambers that encourage adherence to one set of views at the expense of open inquiry and viewpoint diversity.</p><p>The dynamics that create such an environment are admittedly varied and complex. But the fact is, on most American campuses today there are real reputational, academic, and societal risks involved in sharing heterodox viewpoints in the classroom even though learning is supposed to be about openly exploring, investigating, and interrogating competing ideas.</p><h3><strong>The Progressive Professoriate</strong></h3><p>Earlier this year, Heterodox Academy&#8217;s Erin Shaw and Shiri Spitz Siddiqi performed a <a href="https://acrobat.adobe.com/id/urn:aaid:sc:US:3e3509cc-049d-4e48-946f-8610f2c23146">critical review of surveys and studies</a> to investigate the political affiliations of faculty in higher education in the United States. Their work confirms that while statistics and percentages vary based on institution and discipline, in general left-leaning faculty are significantly overrepresented in academia. The researchers refer to <a href="https://www.fire.org/facultyreport">FIRE&#8217;s large-scale 2024 survey</a>, which found that at 55 private colleges and public flagship universities 62% of respondents identified as Democrats, a mere 13% as Republicans, and 24% as other.</p><p>Some fields of study had much higher ratios of Democratic-to-Republican faculty than others. For instance, there was a 42 to 1 Democrat-to-Republican ratio in the field of anthropology. Indeed, the report found that even in the more ostensibly objective STEM fields, there was a significant liberal leaning. In biology, for example, the ratio of Democrats to Republicans was 9 to 1.</p><p>All of this means that in many fields, conservative or even moderate viewpoints easily go unheard entirely or, at the very least, remain marginalized, while accepted viewpoints and narratives are unchallenged or prioritized. This inevitability carries over to the classroom, where faculty determine readings, unit topics, and lecture themes that advance these &#8220;acceptable&#8221; viewpoints. This limits students&#8217; exposure to perspectives that may carry legitimacy more broadly but are unpopular in academia.</p><p>Indeed, the well-intentioned and understandably revered commitment to academic freedom means that professors can curate their curriculum carefully to reflect their ideological biases. Meanwhile, conservative students may abandon academic disciplines in which their views are mocked, minimalized, or just ignored, helping to perpetuate a vicious cycle that promotes a monoculture.</p><p>Some in higher education dismiss, downplay, or even deny that this indoctrination occurs. But <a href="https://www.nas.org/report/the-ideological-capture-of-general-education/full-report/">a recent nationwide report by the National Association of Scholars</a> (NAS) examining the general education requirements at 100 elite private and state institutions of higher education found that at most of these institutions progressive ideology is now an integral part of the curriculum.</p><p>In fact, over half of the universities in the NAS study included a progressive ideology requirement, most often under the umbrella of identity politics or a new version of civics rooted in the progressive political activism of the 1960s that supports the left&#8217;s plan to fundamentally transform America. The report also found that the vast majority of higher education institutions offer courses that use social justice, feminist, and gender studies frameworks in lieu of classical or traditional classes that focus on Western civilization.</p><h3><strong>A Progressive Assumption</strong></h3><p>Meanwhile, stroll around an average college campus in the United States, and what you will observe is the way literature, flyers, communications, and faculty offices will confirm the overwhelming progressive bias discussed here. An occasional posting about a college Republican group or conservative small group meeting will be dwarfed by dozens of postings, papers, and advertisements for the Young Democratic Socialists of America, environmental action coalitions, pro-Palestinian groups, and various other left-wing &#8220;resistance&#8221; movements.</p><p>Professors&#8217; doors are often papered with such materials as well, leaving passersby and visitors with no doubt of their political affiliations. Having spent over two decades in higher education, I have become used to seeing mostly progressive messaging throughout hallways, in classrooms, and in break rooms.</p><p>In addition, there is a consensus in meetings, group chats, and water cooler conversations that assumes everyone at the university is on the same page politically. In a recent Heterodox STEM Substack titled &#8220;<a href="https://hxstem.substack.com/p/five-rules-for-conservative-faculty">Five Rules for Conservative Faculty in a Liberal Academy,</a>&#8221; James Shuls offers an example of what I&#8217;m talking about: &#8220;The day after Donald Trump&#8217;s surprising 2016 victory, I sat in a committee meeting. The chair began somberly: &#8216;I know we are all very upset about what happened yesterday&#8230;&#8217; I, for one, was not. While not a fervent Trump supporter, that election brought Republican victories down the ticket in every major office in my state.&#8221;</p><p>These are not isolated incidents but regular occurrences in the workplace for those who work in academia. And this progressive monoculture is undergirded by everything from performative Indigenous land acknowledgement statements to pronouns in bios.</p><p>Norms and expectations like these shut down genuine opportunities for open inquiry and healthy, respectful debate. This affects all constituents of the university. Students wonder if their grades will be negatively affected if they express unpopular or conservative viewpoints. Faculty have legitimate concerns that they may compromise opportunities for promotion or tenure if they express heterodox views or engage in&#8212;or publish&#8212;research that doesn&#8217;t advance approved narratives. Faculty, staff, and students all wonder about reputational risk.</p><p>These concerns are not unfounded, and they have real impacts on the way students and faculty conduct themselves. In an <a href="https://thehill.com/opinion/education/5446702-performative-virtue-signaling-has-become-a-threat-to-higher-ed/">article last year for </a><em><a href="https://thehill.com/opinion/education/5446702-performative-virtue-signaling-has-become-a-threat-to-higher-ed/">The Hill</a></em>, psychologists Forest Romm and Kevin Waldman discuss confidential interviews with 1,500 students at the University of Michigan and Northwestern University in which 88% of students admitted to pretending to hold more progressive views than they actually do. The study also shows that many faculty understand that a conservative viewpoint could hinder their opportunities to secure a job in academia or achieve tenure.</p><p>Other studies make the same point in different ways. For instance, in <a href="https://www.fire.org/facultyreport">the largest survey ever conducted</a> on the topic of faculty self-censorship, FIRE found that a mere 20% of faculty thought a conservative would be a good fit for their department. The FIRE study also found that three times&#8239;as many&#8239;conservative versus liberal faculty keep quiet about their political beliefs for fear of losing their jobs.</p><p>Finally, at many universities, DEI statements (which faculty and others are often required to write to show their commitment to diversity, equity, and inclusion) are sometimes used as ideological litmus tests for hiring as well as advancing research in certain fields. In an examination of over 10,000 faculty job announcements from the 2024-2025 hiring cycle, <a href="https://acrobat.adobe.com/id/urn:aaid:sc:US:e57641fe-182b-4625-a5c9-69df959a800e">a Heterodox Academy study</a> found that nearly one-quarter (22.3%) of those ads requested DEI statements from their applicants. One example of such a requirement is a statement of commitment to &#8220;equity&#8221; in the classroom.</p><div class="pullquote"><p>On most American campuses today there are real reputational, academic, and societal risks involved in sharing heterodox viewpoints in the classroom even though learning is supposed to be about openly exploring, investigating, and interrogating competing ideas.</p></div><p>Such statements force some applicants to craft a narrative that isn&#8217;t in line with their beliefs about how to help students succeed in the classroom. Though every good educator supports making mentoring and tutoring opportunities and other resources available to students who need them, not everyone agrees that all students will, or even should, end up in the same place. Furthermore, some faculty members report that in their role on search committees, they&#8217;ve seen incredibly competitive and deserving applicants dismissed due to DEI statements that are perceived as not being sufficiently enthusiastic.</p><p>So we are left with a preponderance of left-leaning faculty, the over-representation of progressive courses and curricula, and an environment that assumes and promotes progressive perspectives almost exclusively. The average citizen must weigh these realities alongside the high cost of attending (or sending one&#8217;s children to) university as well as the reality that many newly minted college graduates struggle to find meaningful employment. These factors and more have left higher education in a precarious place.</p><p><strong>Where Do We Go From Here?</strong></p><p>As we look to the future, we must acknowledge that there is much hard work to be done. For starters, we need a genuine commitment to viewpoint diversity from the top down and all across campus. Admittedly, this is no easy task, as many administrators and academics aren&#8217;t interested in giving a platform of any kind to certain views, even if a sizable share of their fellow citizens hold those views.</p><p>To see how daunting the challenge is, look no further than the recent example of the cancellation of CBS News president Bari Weiss&#8217; talk originally scheduled for Feb. 27, 2026, at UCLA. Although Weiss herself ultimately decided to cancel the event, the decision was precipitated by security concerns resulting from an organized campaign to &#8216;deplatform&#8217; her, as evidenced by <a href="https://dailybruin.com/2026/02/18/cbs-editor-in-chief-bari-weiss-ucla-on-campus-lecture-canceled">a petition</a> signed by nearly 11,000 faculty, students, and others in the campus community. In one notable case, a faculty member threatened to resign if Weiss&#8217; lecture occurred.</p><p>Unfortunately, this example is not unique or even that rare. But honest, open, and difficult conversations cannot happen if people on campus are unwilling to even listen to certain voices.</p><p>Another positive step would be to better define terms. As George Orwell and others have taught us, those who control definitions control the conversation. To be intellectually responsible, we must take time to carefully craft shared definitions of terms used on our campuses for concepts such as civil discourse, viewpoint diversity, and open inquiry. Without a shared understanding of terminology, we cannot productively move forward.</p><p>Moving into the classroom, we must actively work to embed into course curricula diverse viewpoints, with the intention of discussing all of them in a fair manner. It&#8217;s perfectly acceptable, of course, to discuss why some viewpoints are not as popular as others or why some opinions are embraced in certain contexts for specific reasons, but unpopular or heterodox opinions should be discussed and considered honestly and openly.</p><p>This requires a diversification of the curriculum and reading lists. Students who graduate with a robust, wide-reaching knowledge of scholars in their field should know about such important figures as Thomas Sowell (economics), Jonathan Haidt (social psychology), Jordan Peterson (clinical psychology), and many others who currently are outside the intellectual mainstream on campus. If we are graduating students without a full range of exposure to scholars across the political spectrum, we are cheating them by severely limiting their intellectual development and educational experience.</p><p>Although it may be unpopular with many practicing academics, it also would behoove us to consider instituting some accountability measures. Of course we want to preserve academic freedom to the fullest extent possible, but we need to balance that with the assurance that our students are getting a comprehensive, diverse education that doesn&#8217;t overtly favor certain narratives.</p><p>In addition, we need a commitment to genuine&#8212;not simply performative&#8212;dialogue. Martha McCaughey&#8217;s article &#8220;<a href="https://inquisitivemag.org/articles/theme-essay/next-time-try-dialogue/">Next Time, Try Dialogue</a>&#8221; in the June 2026 issue of <em>inquisitive</em> discusses a recent practice on some campuses to pass along beach balls for students to draw or write on as a form of expression. Although framed as a way to safely express oneself, this practice has reportedly devolved into acts of incendiary performance, as students intentionally write or draw &#8220;political slogans, insults, and provocative symbols&#8221; to elicit shock and outrage.</p><p>Campuses must instead commit to doing everything they can to foster meaningful opportunities for dialogue. One example is Stanford University&#8217;s recent &#8220;<a href="https://www.thecollegefix.com/independent-minded-stanford-scholars-host-disagree-with-a-professor-event-tackle-hot-button-topics/">Disagree with a Professor</a>&#8221; event series (an idea that started as a student-led podcast at the University of Virginia), which invites students to actively contend with positions presented by professors by using precise, evidence-based arguments rather than just knee-jerk reactions. This format mitigates the power dynamic, as students are not being graded by the professor; as a result, it allows for a more open and honest exchange.</p><p>Another great option for faculty or staff is to start a Heterodox Campus chapter at their institution or, if possible, join an already established one. Administrators who are committed to civil dialogue should encourage and promote such practices, as well as make funds available for faculty or student leaders who wish to receive training.</p><p>There are other opportunities as well. For instance, <a href="https://braverangels.org/">Braver Angels</a> brings people together to practice dialogue across differences; <a href="https://constructivedialogue.org/">the Constructive Dialogue Institute</a> takes a research-based approach to practicing civil discourse; and <a href="https://discussion.education.wisc.edu/">The Discussion Project</a> works with campuses to create spaces where productive dialogue can occur.</p><p>Ultimately, if higher education is going to regain lost trust and thrive in these rapidly changing times, it will require, among other things, a genuine commitment to the principles of intellectual diversity and pluralism. When we openly share, debate, and defend positions on nuanced, complex topics, we leave the echo chamber that is prevalent on so many college campuses and instead engage in the type of learning that produces responsible, well-rounded citizens with dignity, character, and conviction.</p><p class="button-wrapper" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/how-universities-can-break-out-of?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Share&quot;,&quot;action&quot;:null,&quot;class&quot;:null}" data-component-name="ButtonCreateButton"><a class="button primary" href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/how-universities-can-break-out-of?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share"><span>Share</span></a></p><div><hr></div><div class="subscription-widget-wrap-editor" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/subscribe?&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Subscribe&quot;,&quot;language&quot;:&quot;en&quot;}" data-component-name="SubscribeWidgetToDOM"><div class="subscription-widget show-subscribe"><div class="preamble"><p class="cta-caption">Subscribe to stay <em>inquisitive.</em></p></div><form class="subscription-widget-subscribe"><input type="email" class="email-input" name="email" placeholder="Type your email&#8230;" tabindex="-1"><input type="submit" class="button primary" value="Subscribe"><div class="fake-input-wrapper"><div class="fake-input"></div><div class="fake-button"></div></div></form></div></div>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[How Universities Can Promote Viewpoint Diversity Through Admissions]]></title><description><![CDATA[Universities would do well to select for students who support open inquiry]]></description><link>https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/how-universities-can-promote-viewpoint</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/how-universities-can-promote-viewpoint</guid><dc:creator><![CDATA[Dylan Selterman]]></dc:creator><pubDate>Tue, 03 Nov 2026 14:01:28 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!u0h3!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F37b086d2-6a90-494a-9b1e-580d997fd2fa_3504x2336.jpeg" length="0" type="image/jpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="captioned-image-container"><figure><a class="image-link image2 is-viewable-img" target="_blank" href="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!u0h3!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F37b086d2-6a90-494a-9b1e-580d997fd2fa_3504x2336.jpeg" data-component-name="Image2ToDOM"><div class="image2-inset"><picture><source type="image/webp" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!u0h3!,w_424,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F37b086d2-6a90-494a-9b1e-580d997fd2fa_3504x2336.jpeg 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!u0h3!,w_848,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F37b086d2-6a90-494a-9b1e-580d997fd2fa_3504x2336.jpeg 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!u0h3!,w_1272,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F37b086d2-6a90-494a-9b1e-580d997fd2fa_3504x2336.jpeg 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!u0h3!,w_1456,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F37b086d2-6a90-494a-9b1e-580d997fd2fa_3504x2336.jpeg 1456w" sizes="100vw"><img src="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!u0h3!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F37b086d2-6a90-494a-9b1e-580d997fd2fa_3504x2336.jpeg" width="1456" height="971" data-attrs="{&quot;src&quot;:&quot;https://substack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/37b086d2-6a90-494a-9b1e-580d997fd2fa_3504x2336.jpeg&quot;,&quot;srcNoWatermark&quot;:null,&quot;fullscreen&quot;:null,&quot;imageSize&quot;:null,&quot;height&quot;:971,&quot;width&quot;:1456,&quot;resizeWidth&quot;:null,&quot;bytes&quot;:3378551,&quot;alt&quot;:null,&quot;title&quot;:null,&quot;type&quot;:&quot;image/jpeg&quot;,&quot;href&quot;:null,&quot;belowTheFold&quot;:false,&quot;topImage&quot;:true,&quot;internalRedirect&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/i/222835447?img=https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F37b086d2-6a90-494a-9b1e-580d997fd2fa_3504x2336.jpeg&quot;,&quot;isProcessing&quot;:false,&quot;align&quot;:null,&quot;offset&quot;:false}" class="sizing-normal" alt="" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!u0h3!,w_424,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F37b086d2-6a90-494a-9b1e-580d997fd2fa_3504x2336.jpeg 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!u0h3!,w_848,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F37b086d2-6a90-494a-9b1e-580d997fd2fa_3504x2336.jpeg 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!u0h3!,w_1272,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F37b086d2-6a90-494a-9b1e-580d997fd2fa_3504x2336.jpeg 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!u0h3!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F37b086d2-6a90-494a-9b1e-580d997fd2fa_3504x2336.jpeg 1456w" sizes="100vw" fetchpriority="high"></picture><div class="image-link-expand"><div class="pencraft pc-display-flex pc-gap-8 pc-reset"><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container restack-image buttonBase-tqxFUX" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg aria-hidden="true" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 20 20" fill="none" stroke-width="1.5" stroke="var(--color-fg-primary)" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="icon-noB79L"><g><path d="M2.53001 7.81595C3.49179 4.73911 6.43281 2.5 9.91173 2.5C13.1684 2.5 15.9537 4.46214 17.0852 7.23684L17.6179 8.67647M17.6179 8.67647L18.5002 4.26471M17.6179 8.67647L13.6473 6.91176M17.4995 12.1841C16.5378 15.2609 13.5967 17.5 10.1178 17.5C6.86118 17.5 4.07589 15.5379 2.94432 12.7632L2.41165 11.3235M2.41165 11.3235L1.5293 15.7353M2.41165 11.3235L6.38224 13.0882"></path></g></svg></button><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container view-image buttonBase-tqxFUX" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="2" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" class="lucide lucide-maximize2 lucide-maximize-2 icon-noB79L"><polyline points="15 3 21 3 21 9"></polyline><polyline points="9 21 3 21 3 15"></polyline><line x1="21" x2="14" y1="3" y2="10"></line><line x1="3" x2="10" y1="21" y2="14"></line></svg></button></div></div></div></a></figure></div><p>It&#8217;s college application and admission season! All across the country, students are submitting their applications to universities, and colleges will soon be reading lots of essays by hopeful future freshmen.</p><p>At HxA, we are taking this moment as an opportunity to examine how admissions policies and procedures could contribute to a pluralistic campus environment by recruiting and admitting students from across all spectra of society. Conversely, admissions processes could do the opposite &#8212; effectively signaling to students an ideological monoculture and filtering out those who might challenge it. Admissions is a vital lever for creating true academic pluralism.</p><p>My personal view on college admissions is that they are opaque. Many campuses explicitly describe a firewall between their admissions offices and the rest of campus, thus limiting the impact that faculty can have on the types of qualities they&#8217;d like to see in their students. Obviously, universities want to attract and admit the best students they can find. But admissions offices also have other priorities they&#8217;re selecting for, including demographic diversification efforts and a commitment to the university&#8217;s values. On the former, we have seen some evidence that admissions essay prompts for American campuses <a href="https://www.insidehighered.com/news/admissions/traditional-age/2025/11/26/some-colleges-cut-diversity-essays-they-remain-popular">are changing</a> in the wake of recent political and cultural shifts, with some colleges revising or eliminating diversity essay prompts.</p><p>My colleague McKay Stangler recently <a href="https://heterodoxacademy.org/events/what-happened-to-college-a-conversation-with-neil-gross-about-his-latest-book/">interviewed</a> sociologist Neil Gross about his new book, <em><a href="https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0G3553JWM?lv=shuf&amp;channelId=500&amp;plpRedirect=mhFallback">What Happened to College?</a></em></p><div id="youtube2-QFNNf6eQfkA" class="youtube-wrap" data-attrs="{&quot;videoId&quot;:&quot;QFNNf6eQfkA&quot;,&quot;startTime&quot;:null,&quot;endTime&quot;:null}" data-component-name="Youtube2ToDOM"><div class="youtube-inner"><iframe src="https://www.youtube-nocookie.com/embed/QFNNf6eQfkA?rel=0&amp;autoplay=0&amp;showinfo=0&amp;enablejsapi=0" frameborder="0" loading="lazy" gesture="media" allow="autoplay; fullscreen" allowautoplay="true" allowfullscreen="true" width="728" height="409"></iframe></div></div><p>Like McKay, I read the book and thought it was filled with strong ideas that have echoed some of my own thinking about admissions. Gross argues that universities can adjust admissions criteria so that students&#8217; expressed desire for open, reasoned debate is selected for. He notes that starting in 2024, in the wake of protest turmoil on many campuses, Harvard refined its admissions essay prompt, asking students to reflect on a time in which they disagreed with someone and what they took away from that experience. Other schools followed suit the following year (Gross highlights Yale, Columbia, and Duke). This is a big step in the right direction for universities to promote campus cultures of open inquiry.</p><p>Aside from this, I have some more suggestions for what campuses can do as far as admissions is concerned.</p><p>First, colleges should focus on merit, academic excellence, and critical thinking as paramount in the admissions process. If universities want to emphasize other values beyond academic merit, including progressive political values, then <a href="https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/08/24/dear-progressive-universities-dont-want-be-neutral-admit-it/">they should state so publicly</a>, though ideally keeping the university&#8217;s truth-seeking mission paramount.</p><p>Second, colleges can also use this as an opportunity to increase viewpoint diversity through admissions. By this, I do <em>not</em> suggest some kind of quota system or litmus test. I don&#8217;t think that campuses should inquire about applicants&#8217; political or religious views and admit more people with right-of-center views. Rather, I suggest targeted recruitment efforts along with clear signals that viewpoint diversity and academic pluralism are core institutional values. Colleges can do outreach to more conservative and religious pockets of the country and encourage high schoolers to apply.</p><p>Third, changing admissions standards without also changing norms for campus dialogue could backfire, especially if new students come in expecting a certain set of norms surrounding constructive disagreement and the free exchange of ideas, only to find that administrators put up barriers to those in the name of <a href="https://www.thecoddling.com/">safetyism</a>.</p><p>Relatedly, even if admissions officers select for students who are open-minded and willing to engage across ideological lines, what if the freshmen housing office then allows students to opt-in for roommate assignments with those who have similar worldviews? Doesn&#8217;t that defeat the purpose of attempts to recruit students from a diversity of backgrounds? Schools should signal to prospective students that their campus is set up to <em>require</em> them to come into contact with others who have different viewpoints.</p><p>Of course, there is a risk that as admissions essays prompt students to explain how open-minded they are, then the only thing that will change is students&#8217; essay content. That is, changing an essay prompt won&#8217;t effectively screen for a more tolerant student body, because applicants will just look to game the system and brag about how much they love pluralism, which is a fairly easy thing to do on an essay. But admissions offices can more effectively screen for such traits by selecting based on variables that are much harder to fake. Colleges can admit students with demonstrated behavioral commitment to pluralism, through extracurricular activities, including clubs and organizations (such as a group that invites speakers across the political spectrum to discuss and debate important issues), and through recommendation letters in which referees speak to applicants&#8217; performance when faced with disagreement and their sincere desire to engage with opposing viewpoints. And, while it is certainly the case that some students will try to game the system, we&#8217;re also seeing the exact opposite phenomenon playing out, as students opt to apply and enroll in colleges with like-minded peers. Some high school seniors will see essay prompts about constructive disagreement and feel turned off. To that I say, good!</p><p>If universities implement these changes successfully, the effects may be far-reaching. In his book, Gross speculates that making changes to admissions criteria to filter for and admit a certain type of open-minded student body may make it easier for students on campus to effectively debate competing ideas, make friends across ideological lines, and seek common ground, all while being less likely to &#8220;cancel&#8221; each other for expressing disfavored opinions. It&#8217;s a nice vision for college campuses. But the positive effects would theoretically extend forward in time, as graduates of these schools practice constructive disagreement in their communities and extend a spirit of collegiality toward their fellow citizens. Gross also suggests that perhaps high schools, upon seeing what top colleges are searching for in their applicants, will make their own set of reforms to create a more pluralistic and tolerant climate, such that teenagers&#8217; academic experiences will be improved even if they never set foot on a college campus. Wouldn&#8217;t that be an amazing accomplishment?</p><p class="button-wrapper" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/how-universities-can-promote-viewpoint?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Share&quot;,&quot;action&quot;:null,&quot;class&quot;:null}" data-component-name="ButtonCreateButton"><a class="button primary" href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/how-universities-can-promote-viewpoint?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share"><span>Share</span></a></p><div><hr></div><div class="subscription-widget-wrap-editor" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/subscribe?&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Subscribe&quot;,&quot;language&quot;:&quot;en&quot;}" data-component-name="SubscribeWidgetToDOM"><div class="subscription-widget show-subscribe"><div class="preamble"><p class="cta-caption"><em>Free The Inquiry</em> brings you essays, expert commentary, and conversations about open inquiry in the academy. Subscribe to stay up to date.</p></div><form class="subscription-widget-subscribe"><input type="email" class="email-input" name="email" placeholder="Type your email&#8230;" tabindex="-1"><input type="submit" class="button primary" value="Subscribe"><div class="fake-input-wrapper"><div class="fake-input"></div><div class="fake-button"></div></div></form></div></div><p></p>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Heterodox Research Roundup, October 2026]]></title><description><![CDATA[Opposition to &#8220;harm-based&#8221; retractions; tracking intellectual drift across dissertations; a deep dive into the UT Austin curriculum; praise for Mertonian norms in science.]]></description><link>https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/heterodox-research-roundup-october</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/heterodox-research-roundup-october</guid><dc:creator><![CDATA[Dylan Selterman]]></dc:creator><pubDate>Mon, 02 Nov 2026 16:06:11 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!9fWY!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F9d053b92-dd75-41bd-bc30-a18f3438d4ae_1458x808.png" length="0" type="image/jpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>No tricks here &#8212; just treats for your brain. Creep away from the horrors of chilling effects, zombie-like ideological homogeneity, and the eerie silence of self-censorship &#8212; and dive straight into this month&#8217;s research roundup.</p><div><hr></div><h2><strong>Most don&#8217;t actually favor harm-based article retractions</strong></h2><p>Readers of Free the Inquiry are likely aware of concerns that journal articles are at least occasionally retracted due to perceived misdeeds of the moral kind, rather than the methodological kind. A <a href="https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/10755470261486044">new study</a> sheds light on what both academics and everyday people think of these &#8220;harm-based&#8221; retractions. Brown et al. ran four different experiments, two with lay people (undergraduates, naturally) and two with federally funded research scientists, all of which point to the relative unpopularity of retractions of controversial articles over other possible actions.</p><p>In Study 1, undergraduates read one of two vignettes about a researcher campaigning to retract a journal article either over &#8220;information hazards&#8221; (a harm-based retraction) or over suspected research misconduct. Participants were warmer toward the researcher pursuing the misconduct-based retraction than the one pursuing the hazard-based retraction, as indicated through perceptions of the researcher&#8217;s trustworthiness, their likeability, the appropriateness of their retraction campaign, and agreement with the campaign. They also saw the researcher as valuing science more and having science&#8217;s best interest in mind. The journal in the scenario fared better too, with participants more likely to believe that the journal &#8220;did the right thing&#8221; when it retracted the article accused of misconduct, compared to the one accused of harm.</p><div class="captioned-image-container"><figure><a class="image-link image2 is-viewable-img" target="_blank" href="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!fR-Y!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff706b132-818c-4465-97d2-ecf46ed03982_799x445.png" data-component-name="Image2ToDOM"><div class="image2-inset"><picture><source type="image/webp" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!fR-Y!,w_424,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff706b132-818c-4465-97d2-ecf46ed03982_799x445.png 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!fR-Y!,w_848,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff706b132-818c-4465-97d2-ecf46ed03982_799x445.png 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!fR-Y!,w_1272,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff706b132-818c-4465-97d2-ecf46ed03982_799x445.png 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!fR-Y!,w_1456,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff706b132-818c-4465-97d2-ecf46ed03982_799x445.png 1456w" sizes="100vw"><img src="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!fR-Y!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff706b132-818c-4465-97d2-ecf46ed03982_799x445.png" width="799" height="445" data-attrs="{&quot;src&quot;:&quot;https://substack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/f706b132-818c-4465-97d2-ecf46ed03982_799x445.png&quot;,&quot;srcNoWatermark&quot;:null,&quot;fullscreen&quot;:null,&quot;imageSize&quot;:null,&quot;height&quot;:445,&quot;width&quot;:799,&quot;resizeWidth&quot;:null,&quot;bytes&quot;:null,&quot;alt&quot;:null,&quot;title&quot;:null,&quot;type&quot;:null,&quot;href&quot;:null,&quot;belowTheFold&quot;:false,&quot;topImage&quot;:true,&quot;internalRedirect&quot;:null,&quot;isProcessing&quot;:false,&quot;align&quot;:null,&quot;offset&quot;:false}" class="sizing-normal" alt="" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!fR-Y!,w_424,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff706b132-818c-4465-97d2-ecf46ed03982_799x445.png 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!fR-Y!,w_848,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff706b132-818c-4465-97d2-ecf46ed03982_799x445.png 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!fR-Y!,w_1272,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff706b132-818c-4465-97d2-ecf46ed03982_799x445.png 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!fR-Y!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff706b132-818c-4465-97d2-ecf46ed03982_799x445.png 1456w" sizes="100vw" fetchpriority="high"></picture><div class="image-link-expand"><div class="pencraft pc-display-flex pc-gap-8 pc-reset"><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container restack-image buttonBase-tqxFUX" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg aria-hidden="true" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 20 20" fill="none" stroke-width="1.5" stroke="var(--color-fg-primary)" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="icon-noB79L"><g><path d="M2.53001 7.81595C3.49179 4.73911 6.43281 2.5 9.91173 2.5C13.1684 2.5 15.9537 4.46214 17.0852 7.23684L17.6179 8.67647M17.6179 8.67647L18.5002 4.26471M17.6179 8.67647L13.6473 6.91176M17.4995 12.1841C16.5378 15.2609 13.5967 17.5 10.1178 17.5C6.86118 17.5 4.07589 15.5379 2.94432 12.7632L2.41165 11.3235M2.41165 11.3235L1.5293 15.7353M2.41165 11.3235L6.38224 13.0882"></path></g></svg></button><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container view-image buttonBase-tqxFUX" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="2" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" class="lucide lucide-maximize2 lucide-maximize-2 icon-noB79L"><polyline points="15 3 21 3 21 9"></polyline><polyline points="9 21 3 21 3 15"></polyline><line x1="21" x2="14" y1="3" y2="10"></line><line x1="3" x2="10" y1="21" y2="14"></line></svg></button></div></div></div></a></figure></div><p>Studies 2 and 3 went on to assess undergraduates&#8217; (Study 2) and academics&#8217; (Study 3) views on how a fictitious journal handled a controversial paper. In the vignette, controversial papers could be handled one of four ways: through a retraction, a replication, <a href="https://heterodoxacademy.org/resources/the-adversarial-collaboration-method-for-research-and-scholarship/">adversarial collaboration</a>, or commentary. The undergrads in Study 2 viewed adversarial collaboration as a more credible outcome than both retraction and commentary, while the academics preferred commentary as the most credible route. (Perhaps, as the authors suggest, this is because academics have keen insight into the effort required to undertake a new collaborative study and view commentary as a more realistic approach.)</p><p>Finally, in Study 4, academic researchers were presented with a controversial journal paper vignette &#8212; now with new details to emphasize that the original article was statistically robust and peer-reviewed &#8212; with the addition of a fifth possible outcome: inaction on the part of the journal. Participants viewed inaction as no more or less credible or damaging to science than the more active alternatives. Retractions were the least popular outcome for nearly all measures, including credibility, consistency with scientific values, and damage to science.</p><p>The finding that academics and non-academics both oppose retraction on &#8220;harm-based&#8221; grounds is reassuring, although a successful retraction campaign only needs a handful of impassioned individuals. Still, these public scuffles over controversial articles often surface only after an article has cleared peer review. Team HxA frequently ponders how many potentially controversial articles never make it past that hurdle in the first place &#8212; a future research question, perhaps?</p><div><hr></div><h2><strong>Whither the dissertation?</strong></h2><p>Recent attempts to measure intellectual drift in the social sciences and humanities (SSH) tend to look at published <a href="https://www.progressivepolicy.org/the-distortion-of-american-studies/">journal articles</a>, <a href="https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11186-026-09690-2">abstracts</a>, <a href="https://jacob-light.github.io/college-politics.pdf">course catalogs</a> and <a href="https://www.hoover.org/sites/default/files/2025-12/Closed%20Classrooms.pdf">syllabi</a>. A <a href="https://academysciencesletters.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/humanities_in_crisis_circulation_report.pdf">new report</a> from the American Academy of Sciences and Letters analyzes the full text of 443,543 doctoral dissertations in the SSH written at 678 U.S. universities between 1960 and 2025 and shared on <a href="https://about.proquest.com/en/products-services/TDM-Studio/">ProQuest</a>. The authors&#8217; rationale: &#8220;PhD dissertations, written within a given field at a given time, provide a uniquely clear window into the language and underlying conceptual assumptions dominant in that field at that time.&#8221;</p><p>The authors built five &#8220;baskets&#8221; of 60 to 105 words each and counted how often each appeared, year by year and field by field.</p><ul><li><p><em>Facts/Truth Claims</em> holds the vocabulary of evidence and inference (fact, archive, empirical, hypothesis, proof).</p></li><li><p><em>Power Dynamics</em> covers authority and hierarchy (hegemony, oppression, resistance, subaltern).</p></li><li><p><em>Evaluation</em> is the language of judgment (good, wrong, moral, persuasive).</p></li><li><p><em>Aesthetics</em> is beauty and form (sublime, composition, genre).</p></li><li><p><em>Identity</em> is the critical-theory lexicon (intersectionality, positionality, whiteness, decolonization).</p></li></ul><div class="captioned-image-container"><figure><a class="image-link image2 is-viewable-img" target="_blank" href="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!9fWY!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F9d053b92-dd75-41bd-bc30-a18f3438d4ae_1458x808.png" data-component-name="Image2ToDOM"><div class="image2-inset"><picture><source type="image/webp" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!9fWY!,w_424,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F9d053b92-dd75-41bd-bc30-a18f3438d4ae_1458x808.png 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!9fWY!,w_848,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F9d053b92-dd75-41bd-bc30-a18f3438d4ae_1458x808.png 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!9fWY!,w_1272,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F9d053b92-dd75-41bd-bc30-a18f3438d4ae_1458x808.png 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!9fWY!,w_1456,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F9d053b92-dd75-41bd-bc30-a18f3438d4ae_1458x808.png 1456w" sizes="auto, 100vw"><img src="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!9fWY!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F9d053b92-dd75-41bd-bc30-a18f3438d4ae_1458x808.png" width="1456" height="807" data-attrs="{&quot;src&quot;:&quot;https://substack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/9d053b92-dd75-41bd-bc30-a18f3438d4ae_1458x808.png&quot;,&quot;srcNoWatermark&quot;:null,&quot;fullscreen&quot;:null,&quot;imageSize&quot;:null,&quot;height&quot;:807,&quot;width&quot;:1456,&quot;resizeWidth&quot;:null,&quot;bytes&quot;:null,&quot;alt&quot;:null,&quot;title&quot;:null,&quot;type&quot;:null,&quot;href&quot;:null,&quot;belowTheFold&quot;:true,&quot;topImage&quot;:false,&quot;internalRedirect&quot;:null,&quot;isProcessing&quot;:false,&quot;align&quot;:null,&quot;offset&quot;:false}" class="sizing-normal" alt="" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!9fWY!,w_424,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F9d053b92-dd75-41bd-bc30-a18f3438d4ae_1458x808.png 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!9fWY!,w_848,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F9d053b92-dd75-41bd-bc30-a18f3438d4ae_1458x808.png 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!9fWY!,w_1272,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F9d053b92-dd75-41bd-bc30-a18f3438d4ae_1458x808.png 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!9fWY!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F9d053b92-dd75-41bd-bc30-a18f3438d4ae_1458x808.png 1456w" sizes="auto, 100vw" loading="lazy"></picture><div class="image-link-expand"><div class="pencraft pc-display-flex pc-gap-8 pc-reset"><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container restack-image buttonBase-tqxFUX" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg aria-hidden="true" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 20 20" fill="none" stroke-width="1.5" stroke="var(--color-fg-primary)" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="icon-noB79L"><g><path d="M2.53001 7.81595C3.49179 4.73911 6.43281 2.5 9.91173 2.5C13.1684 2.5 15.9537 4.46214 17.0852 7.23684L17.6179 8.67647M17.6179 8.67647L18.5002 4.26471M17.6179 8.67647L13.6473 6.91176M17.4995 12.1841C16.5378 15.2609 13.5967 17.5 10.1178 17.5C6.86118 17.5 4.07589 15.5379 2.94432 12.7632L2.41165 11.3235M2.41165 11.3235L1.5293 15.7353M2.41165 11.3235L6.38224 13.0882"></path></g></svg></button><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container view-image buttonBase-tqxFUX" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="2" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" class="lucide lucide-maximize2 lucide-maximize-2 icon-noB79L"><polyline points="15 3 21 3 21 9"></polyline><polyline points="9 21 3 21 3 15"></polyline><line x1="21" x2="14" y1="3" y2="10"></line><line x1="3" x2="10" y1="21" y2="14"></line></svg></button></div></div></div></a></figure></div><p>What they found: <em>Facts/Truth</em> words were the most common category in every field and every decade, and their frequency rose over time. <em>Power Dynamics</em> vocabulary jumped around 1988, led by literature and language programs. <em>Identity</em> vocabulary grew fastest of all, roughly 5 to 8 percent a year after adjusting for differences between universities (a doubling every 8 to 12 years). <em>Aesthetics</em> declined modestly and steadily. Philosophy and theology was the one subfield where <em>Evaluation</em> still outranked <em>Power Dynamics</em>.</p><p>&#8220;Depending on one&#8217;s perspective, the situation for the humanities can appear either quite dire or in a state of renewal and vitality,&#8221; the American Academy of Arts and Sciences&#8217; Robert Townsend and Norman Bradburn <a href="https://www.amacad.org/publication/daedalus/state-humanities-circa-2022">wrote</a> in 2022. On the numbers, the report says both: humanities dissertations fell 49 percent from their 2015 peak, while social sciences fell 4.5 percent (the authors caution that both declines are overstated in part by a ProQuest registration lag that undercounts 2023 to 2025), and the fastest-growing fields are anthropology, psychology, and communications, which the authors call a possible &#8220;functional successor to the traditional Humanities.&#8221; On what it all adds up to, the authors are similarly equivocal: &#8220;The evidence here supports neither the most alarming nor the most dismissive version of these claims.&#8221;</p><div><hr></div><h2><strong>At UT Austin, contemporary issues are mostly framed through one lens &#8211; but at least the philosophical canon is still going strong</strong></h2><p>A <a href="https://curricularreview.org/reports/ut-austin-2025.pdf">new report</a> by The Curricular Review Council maps UT Austin&#8217;s curriculum, focusing on the American civics and great books. The authors were interested in how well the curriculum covers &#8212; and exposes students to disagreement about &#8212; issues of central public importance. Using Syllabus Lens, an AI tool they built, they extracted readings from syllabi, counted how often authors and texts are assigned, and examined how they were paired together.</p><p>The authors first looked at texts on American history, politics, and literature. Breaking the syllabi into three 5-year periods (2011-2015, 2016-2020, and 2021-2025), they found that the mix of texts grew more focused on racial oppression and inequality over time. During 2011-2015, 10 of the top 20 assigned texts addressed race, rising to 13 in 2021-2025. The curriculum didn&#8217;t elevate all Black perspectives, however. Critical works by Black authors were among the most frequently assigned (Michelle Alexander&#8217;s <em>The New Jim Crow</em> was assigned 84 times; Ta-Nehisi Coates&#8217; <em>Between the World and Me</em>, 38 times), while influential works by non-critical Black authors were assigned relatively rarely if at all (Orlando Patterson&#8217;s <em>Slavery and Social Death</em>, cited 9,414 times, was assigned 18 times; William J. Wilson&#8217;s <em>When Work Disappears</em>, cited 11,651 times, was never assigned).</p><p>The authors further critique how UT&#8217;s curriculum handled controversial topics in this period. According to their analysis, the most assigned titles addressing police and the criminal justice system from a critical perspective (<em>The New Jim Crow</em> and Simone Browne&#8217;s <em>Dark Matters</em>) were assigned 84 and 41 times, respectively, between 2021 and 2025, while the most assigned titles presenting an &#8220;alternative perspective&#8221; (Wilson and Kelling&#8217;s &#8220;Broken Windows&#8221; essay and Patrick Sharkey&#8217;s <em>Uneasy Peace</em>) were assigned six times and twice, respectively. They find similarly one-sided treatment of issues like the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and only the faintest trace of influential-but-heterodox social science (e.g., Cherlin&#8217;s <em>The Marriage-Go-Round</em>, which critiques divorce, cited nearly 2,000 times but assigned twice; Waite &amp; Gallagher&#8217;s<em> The Case for Marriage</em>, on marriage&#8217;s societal benefits, cited over 3,000 times but never assigned).</p><p>As for the great books, the authors partly refute the idea that the traditional canon is in trouble at UT Austin. Shakespeare and Plato remain the most frequently assigned canonical authors at the university, with each assigned hundreds of times between 2021 and 2025. Although Western canonical literature declined in frequency between 2011 and 2025 (with Enlightenment and Renaissance texts experiencing declines of 42% and 38%, respectively), Western works of philosophy and social theory were assigned 15-28% <em>more </em>often, depending on the specific historical period. (Classical philosophy was an exception to this trend, with a 17% decline over the same period.) At the same time, UT&#8217;s canon is diversifying, with world literature seeing a particular surge in frequency (an increase of 93% across the 2011-2025 period). Students also have a fair shot at encountering thought-provoking pairings of authors, for instance in courses co-assigning founding-era thinkers like Locke and Madison alongside later scholars of racial politics like Frederick Douglass and W.E.B. Du Bois.</p><p>The report arrives as UT adopts a revised <a href="https://www.utexas.edu/academics/core">core curriculum</a> to provide undergraduates across campus a more consistent learning experience, with the task force <a href="https://www.utexas.edu/sites/default/files/documents/core-curriculum-task-force-report_ay2025-26.pdf">recommending</a> special emphasis on the Great Books and Western canon. The new core will be stewarded by a newly announced <a href="https://universitycollege.utexas.edu/">University College</a> (housing a <a href="https://humanities.utexas.edu/">Center for Humanities</a>, separate from the School of Civic Leadership).</p><div><hr></div><h2><strong>A call to resurrect Mertonian norms</strong></h2><p>In a <a href="https://muse.jhu.edu/pub/1/article/1002388/summary">commentary article</a>, Urs and Clark make the case for <em><a href="https://theconversation.com/scientific-norms-shape-the-behavior-of-researchers-working-for-the-greater-good-255159">Mertonian norms</a></em> in scientific practice. These norms were developed by sociologist and philosopher of science Robert Merton in the 1940s, who argued that for science to effectively make true discoveries about the world, scientists needed strong institutional norms to guide their work. These norms include <em>universalism, </em>or the idea that scientific ideas need to be evaluated on their own merits, rather than the characteristics of those who developed the ideas (thus, not privileging some people&#8217;s ideas over others), as well as <em>disinterestedness </em>and <em>organized skepticism</em>, which serve as checks against <a href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/scientists-are-people-and-their-politics">psychological biases</a> and conflicts of interest.</p><p>Urs and Clark argue that these norms guide good scientific practices and are important to uphold, and that recent efforts by some scholars to inject ideological commitments into science is a threat to Mertonian standards. They point to proposals like citation justice (citing papers based on the ethnicity or gender of the author, independent of the papers&#8217; relevance or merit), positionality statements (authors describing their own attributes in the context of the research they&#8217;re conducting), and harm-based editorial standards (rejecting or retracting manuscripts based on concerns about unintended consequences, such as stigmatization of vulnerable groups) as all undermining the scientific enterprise.</p><p>Then the paper takes an interesting turn, as the authors argue that treating viewpoint diversity as an explicit goal is also a departure from Mertonian norms. The authors argue that if universities and academic disciplines attempt to balance faculty based on political viewpoints, they risk violating disinterestedness, since ideas should be judged on their merits, not on the identities of who hold them. The authors draw a comparison between viewpoint diversity initiatives and DEI, which they argue similarly privileges researcher identity characteristics above merit. Moreover, they also suggest that hiring scholars through viewpoint diversity efforts risks those scholars being labeled as out-group members.</p><p>But the authors also see value in viewpoint diversity. Rather than place it as the goal or outcome to strive for, they instead position viewpoint diversity as an indicator of the health of a field. Essentially, when a field lacks viewpoint diversity, that&#8217;s a sign that something has gone awry. But increasing viewpoint diversity should not be the target for reform efforts. Instead, scholars should reorient themselves to Mertonian standards, which would make the scientific enterprise function better and thus make fields more hospitable to scholars with diverse viewpoints.</p><p class="button-wrapper" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/heterodox-research-roundup-october?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Share&quot;,&quot;action&quot;:null,&quot;class&quot;:null}" data-component-name="ButtonCreateButton"><a class="button primary" href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/heterodox-research-roundup-october?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share"><span>Share</span></a></p><div><hr></div><p>That wraps up October&#8217;s roundup. Got interesting research to share? Drop us a line at <a href="mailto:research@heterodoacademy.org">research@heterodoxacademy.org</a>.</p><div><hr></div><div class="subscription-widget-wrap-editor" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/subscribe?&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Subscribe&quot;,&quot;language&quot;:&quot;en&quot;}" data-component-name="SubscribeWidgetToDOM"><div class="subscription-widget show-subscribe"><div class="preamble"><p class="cta-caption"><em>Free The Inquiry</em> brings you essays, expert commentary, and conversations about open inquiry in the academy. Subscribe to stay up to date.</p></div><form class="subscription-widget-subscribe"><input type="email" class="email-input" name="email" placeholder="Type your email&#8230;" tabindex="-1"><input type="submit" class="button primary" value="Subscribe"><div class="fake-input-wrapper"><div class="fake-input"></div><div class="fake-button"></div></div></form></div></div><p></p>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Using American History and Culture to Promote Dialogue on Campus]]></title><description><![CDATA[Focusing on our shared experience can go a long way in helping faculty and students resist unhelpful binaries | Online exclusive inquisitive]]></description><link>https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/using-american-history-and-culture</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/using-american-history-and-culture</guid><dc:creator><![CDATA[Natalia Mehlman Petrzela]]></dc:creator><pubDate>Fri, 30 Oct 2026 12:02:57 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!DxMo!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe49781a2-4091-4398-a181-08e432f50af3_1456x1048.jpeg" length="0" type="image/jpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="captioned-image-container"><figure><a class="image-link image2 is-viewable-img" target="_blank" href="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!DxMo!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe49781a2-4091-4398-a181-08e432f50af3_1456x1048.jpeg" data-component-name="Image2ToDOM"><div class="image2-inset"><picture><source type="image/webp" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!DxMo!,w_424,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe49781a2-4091-4398-a181-08e432f50af3_1456x1048.jpeg 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!DxMo!,w_848,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe49781a2-4091-4398-a181-08e432f50af3_1456x1048.jpeg 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!DxMo!,w_1272,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe49781a2-4091-4398-a181-08e432f50af3_1456x1048.jpeg 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!DxMo!,w_1456,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe49781a2-4091-4398-a181-08e432f50af3_1456x1048.jpeg 1456w" sizes="100vw"><img src="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!DxMo!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe49781a2-4091-4398-a181-08e432f50af3_1456x1048.jpeg" width="1456" height="1048" data-attrs="{&quot;src&quot;:&quot;https://substack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/e49781a2-4091-4398-a181-08e432f50af3_1456x1048.jpeg&quot;,&quot;srcNoWatermark&quot;:null,&quot;fullscreen&quot;:null,&quot;imageSize&quot;:null,&quot;height&quot;:1048,&quot;width&quot;:1456,&quot;resizeWidth&quot;:null,&quot;bytes&quot;:557666,&quot;alt&quot;:null,&quot;title&quot;:null,&quot;type&quot;:&quot;image/jpeg&quot;,&quot;href&quot;:null,&quot;belowTheFold&quot;:false,&quot;topImage&quot;:true,&quot;internalRedirect&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/i/222692076?img=https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe49781a2-4091-4398-a181-08e432f50af3_1456x1048.jpeg&quot;,&quot;isProcessing&quot;:false,&quot;align&quot;:null,&quot;offset&quot;:false}" class="sizing-normal" alt="" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!DxMo!,w_424,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe49781a2-4091-4398-a181-08e432f50af3_1456x1048.jpeg 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!DxMo!,w_848,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe49781a2-4091-4398-a181-08e432f50af3_1456x1048.jpeg 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!DxMo!,w_1272,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe49781a2-4091-4398-a181-08e432f50af3_1456x1048.jpeg 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!DxMo!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe49781a2-4091-4398-a181-08e432f50af3_1456x1048.jpeg 1456w" sizes="100vw" fetchpriority="high"></picture><div class="image-link-expand"><div class="pencraft pc-display-flex pc-gap-8 pc-reset"><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container restack-image buttonBase-tqxFUX" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg aria-hidden="true" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 20 20" fill="none" stroke-width="1.5" stroke="var(--color-fg-primary)" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="icon-noB79L"><g><path d="M2.53001 7.81595C3.49179 4.73911 6.43281 2.5 9.91173 2.5C13.1684 2.5 15.9537 4.46214 17.0852 7.23684L17.6179 8.67647M17.6179 8.67647L18.5002 4.26471M17.6179 8.67647L13.6473 6.91176M17.4995 12.1841C16.5378 15.2609 13.5967 17.5 10.1178 17.5C6.86118 17.5 4.07589 15.5379 2.94432 12.7632L2.41165 11.3235M2.41165 11.3235L1.5293 15.7353M2.41165 11.3235L6.38224 13.0882"></path></g></svg></button><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container view-image buttonBase-tqxFUX" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="2" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" class="lucide lucide-maximize2 lucide-maximize-2 icon-noB79L"><polyline points="15 3 21 3 21 9"></polyline><polyline points="9 21 3 21 3 15"></polyline><line x1="21" x2="14" y1="3" y2="10"></line><line x1="3" x2="10" y1="21" y2="14"></line></svg></button></div></div></div></a><figcaption class="image-caption">Richard Caton Woodville (after), <em>Politics in an Oyster House</em>, 1851. The Walters Art Museum (CC0).</figcaption></figure></div><p>One of the few things many on the political left and right can agree on these days, even if for different reasons, is that higher education is in crisis. Progressives often decry the &#8220;corporatization&#8221; of the academy, while conservatives denounce its ideological capture by &#8220;woke radicals.&#8221;</p><p>Many academics, who as a group tend to be politically progressive, continue to insist that higher education&#8217;s leftward tilt is nothing to worry about. Meanwhile, other faculty point to the recent attacks by the Trump administration and argue that &#8220;now is not the time&#8221; for self-reflection, let alone self-criticism. Over the last several years, however, a <a href="https://www.insidehighered.com/news/institutions/research-universities/2026/09/23/how-cornell-committee-wants-university-change">growing group</a> of scholarly voices have acknowledged that <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2026/04/15/us/yale-report-colleges-unversities-trust.html">trust in higher education is cratering</a>, due at least in part to an <a href="https://www.vanderbilt.edu/principles/state-of-scholarship-report/">apparent political monoculture</a> that faculty and administrators must take <a href="https://www.progressivepolicy.org/the-distortion-of-american-studies/">responsibility for enabling.</a></p><p>As two academics who see an urgent need for change on campus, we welcome the rise of this long overdue introspection and believe that it is incumbent upon us and other faculty to move to repair this breach of trust before those outside the academy do it for us. Yet in true academic form, this new introspective wind blowing through higher education is longer on diagnoses than cures, probably because the path forward is so fraught.</p><p>Indeed, at a time when the White House is attempting to control and even punish universities in the name of anti-wokeness, conceding that political orthodoxy is a problem in some parts of academia can risk further retribution by the Trump administration. And while advocating for &#8220;viewpoint diversity&#8221; is an admirable goal, it can be very hard to put it into practice without caricaturing or tokenizing political positions.</p><p>Meanwhile, even broaching the question of whether we academics have played a role in alienating ourselves and our institutions from the larger society can exact a professional price from our colleagues, given that many of them still vehemently deny any responsibility for the problems we face. We know this to be true, as we&#8217;ve both been accused of being complicit in a right-wing assault on universities just for insisting these issues deserve attention. This is the case even though one of us, who is originally from Hungary, has been <a href="https://www.ms.now/opinion/viktor-orban-hungary-election-loss-peter-magyar">a vocal critic of Viktor Orban</a> (until recently, the country&#8217;s conservative populist prime minister) while the other has had her <a href="https://newrepublic.com/article/193628/trump-grantee-termination-letters-education">research funding clawed back</a> by the Trump administration for being &#8220;at odds with the interests of the federal government.&#8221;</p><p>At the same time, refusing to acknowledge that academics must work to regain public esteem, or hand-wringing about the risks of taking action, only clears the way for those who simply want to barge ahead unchallenged. Whether they are the government, or activists who want to &#8220;burn it all down,&#8221; or faculty and others who proclaim that everything is fine, the future of the academy cannot be left to the loudest voices. The answer, however, is <em>not </em>some milquetoast compromise or even much-touted efforts at &#8220;dialogue across difference.&#8221;</p><p>For us, the answer is our new <a href="https://cae.newschool.org">Center for the American Experience at The New School, </a>which was born out of our twin commitments to introspection and action. Unlike &#8220;civil discourse&#8221; or &#8220;civics&#8221; initiatives on many other campuses that often operate within a narrow band of topic areas, such as philosophy, political science, and history, our center brings together design, the performing arts, the humanities, and the social sciences to explore the past and present of the United States and its role in the world. We host conversations, panels, concerts, theater, film screenings, and other artistic exhibitions. We also organize reading groups that gather students and neighbors together to discuss foundational texts of American history and culture. All our events are free and open to the public. What&#8217;s more, we are faculty-led, not established by a state legislature.</p><p>All of our events are held in person, a commitment that grows out of our post-Covid experience observing how challenging it has recently become for students and academics alike to engage in civil, face-to-face interactions, not to mention spending a few hours immersed in a lecture or concert with a room full of unfamiliar people. And since curiosity is one of our organizing principles, our events bring together different perspectives and disciplines in open dialogue, not to deepen divisions, but to explore the many possibilities for a shared future.</p><p>We focus on the &#8220;American experience&#8221; because, <a href="https://www.goacta.org/2026/04/american-students-lack-of-basic-civics-knowledge-alarms-education-advocates/">like many people in the United States</a>, a significant number of our students are unfamiliar with this country&#8217;s ideals, politics, institutions, history, and cultures. As a result of this lack of basic historical and civic literacy, students often have little understanding of how this country became so powerful, let alone the complex way its attendant mystique &#8212; from &#8220;the American Dream&#8221; to &#8220;the melting pot&#8221; to &#8220;the self-made man&#8221; &#8212; operates. We try to fill in some of these gaps because otherwise they can easily be filled by simplified political narratives.</p><p>In a recent history class, for example, when reading the 1912 diary of a Russian Jewish immigrant girl, <a href="https://digital.library.upenn.edu/women/antin/land/land.html">who wrote breathlessly</a> of the opportunity to &#8220;shed her impossible Hebrew name&#8221; and learn English at school, and of her &#8220;despised immigrant clothing,&#8221; students were skeptical that such patriotic emotions could be anything but &#8220;internalized oppression.&#8221; The possibility that an &#8220;American dream&#8221; of economic mobility continues to inspire immigrants who come to this country, often at enormous risk, was also not an idea that they took seriously until we began to explore it through memoir, oral history, ethnography, and analyses of political campaigns.</p><p>Instilling uncritical patriotism is not our aim. Even to effectively critique American exceptionalism, however, one must understand the power of this place and its professed &#8212; and often unfulfilled &#8212; ideals, including as a source of sincere inspiration rather than only oppression. At the same time, we take on &#8220;the American experience&#8221; against a frightening national backdrop in which legislation restricting the right to teach honestly about much of our nation&#8217;s past &#8212; slavery, sexuality, indigenous expropriation, and racism &#8212; threatens a full understanding of America from the opposite end of the ideological spectrum.</p><p>Troubled by these dynamics, we began to imagine how we might better serve our students and our broader community. For years, we have found that some of the most productive intellectual experiences stem from collectively exploring questions of culture and aesthetics quite apart from the familiar controversial issues that lend themselves to predictable polarization. Closely reading a popular 19th-century children&#8217;s literacy primer, analyzing the rise of the department store, unpacking a 1970s Supreme Court case around boys&#8217; hairstyles, or discussing the polarized social media reactions to the televised Lindsay Clancy trial, for example, all allow students to grapple with the complexities of American experience by organizing class discussions around issues in which the &#8220;right&#8221; or &#8220;wrong&#8221; (or &#8220;right&#8221; and &#8220;left&#8221;) interpretation may not immediately be apparent. Students seem to be more open to considering what  &#8220;America&#8221; might mean through art, design, fashion, and music, rather than only through the conventional political analysis that is so common today. A student hesitant to debate climate change or gentrification &#8212; or who is too ready with talking points on these hot-button issues &#8212; might engage in unexpected ways with a photography exhibit on the natural environment or oral histories of an evolving neighborhood.</p><p>Focusing on culture can go a long way to soften unhelpful binaries &#8212; whether they be right/left or oppressor/oppressed &#8212; and is integral to opening minds in a way that builds community and lessens polarization. Contrary to caricatures of intolerant students, we find that in the intimate seminar rooms core to the humanities and social sciences where we have spent most of our careers, students <em>do </em>display intellectual humility and generosity with one another. What&#8217;s more, this is true even when ideas that would be bombshells online &#8212; for example, whether the &#8220;missing&#8221; posters of Israeli hostages are propaganda, or why many low-income people of color want greater police presence in their neighborhoods &#8212; are aired. For this reason, rather than frame our efforts around &#8220;civil discourse&#8221; or &#8220;dialogue across difference,&#8221; or pit strong voices on controversial issues against one another, we instead lean into this kind of in-person inquiry across texts, performances, art, speakers, and activities focused on the country in which we are all living and learning.</p><p>It is our job as professors to ensure students are exposed to a wide range of perspectives on a given subject, not a list curated to bolster their, or our, preconceived notions. One of the most gratifying comments we&#8217;ve received is that students are not sure where we personally stand on controversial issues, because we entertain a range of perspectives in our course materials and encourage their expression &#8212; even the noxious ones &#8212; as long as they are made in good faith. The richness of these interactions depends on our fundamental commitment to do our best to teach students <em>how </em>to articulate their ideas and think through urgent questions such as &#8220;What is America?&#8221;, not <em>what </em>to think about them, or whether certain honest questions are out of bounds.</p><p>Much of our work at the Center involves taking these lessons beyond the classroom. We convene community reading groups to discuss primary sources, from the Declaration of Independence to a narrative by a Native American girl to Langston Hughes&#8217; poetry, bringing together international students, activists, professors, and other New Yorkers from different walks of life in spirited discussions. We also host public talks with eminent speakers such as Walter Isaacson to reflect on what makes an &#8220;American story&#8221; and Jill Lepore to contemplate the relationship between artificial intelligence and civic health. To mark the 25th anniversary of the 9/11 terror attacks, we screened a documentary on the participatory process of rebuilding Lower Manhattan, followed by a conversation &#8212; moderated by our university president &#8212; with architectural critic Paul Goldberger, community organizer Carolyn Lukensmeyer (who were both integral to this process) and Jeremy Varon, a historian of the post-9/11 peace movement. We have also launched a series on the future of American higher education, with the first panel focusing on intellectual pluralism. The center&#8217;s student fellows from across disciplines &#8212; from the social sciences to design to the performing arts &#8212; help to plan and take part in these events.</p><p>Some people, academics and otherwise, are surprised to hear of our &#8220;American experience&#8221; initiative, as in some quarters, the New School has a reputation as a hotbed of the sort of intense political activism that can easily veer into anti-Americanism. The reaction is understandable, since it is not uncommon at our institution to hear the United States dismissed primarily as a project of &#8220;settler colonialism&#8221; or capitalism run amok, or North America referred to by the name given to it by some Native American tribes: Turtle Island.</p><p>At the same time, the Center is aligned with other campus traditions. For instance, one of our north stars is the work of one of The New School&#8217;s earliest faculty members, philosopher Horace Kallen, who conceptualized the theory of &#8220;cultural pluralism,&#8221; which balances difference and unity in a diverse society. Similarly, Jewish intellectuals persecuted during the Third Reich found refuge at The New School, which took great risk to protect them. Perhaps most fundamentally, and in contrast to more traditional institutions, straddling the line between community and campus in response to social and political issues is baked into The New School&#8217;s founding &#8212; as it is into the Center&#8217;s as well.</p><p>These sensibilities are not just relics of the past &#8212; on our campus or in the academy at large. Despite the protestations of the loudest voices, our quieter conversations with faculty, students, and other community members consistently reveal that there is a real curiosity and desire to understand this fractured moment in American history and how we arrived here, and to contribute to charting a better future. Our work thus far &#8212; conversations, community reading groups, lectures, performances, and student fellowships &#8212; is just the beginning of a vision that takes root on college campuses but that we hope will ultimately bloom in the wider world. The stakes are simply too high not to try.</p><p class="button-wrapper" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/using-american-history-and-culture?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Share&quot;,&quot;action&quot;:null,&quot;class&quot;:null}" data-component-name="ButtonCreateButton"><a class="button primary" href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/using-american-history-and-culture?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share"><span>Share</span></a></p><div><hr></div><div class="subscription-widget-wrap-editor" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/subscribe?&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Subscribe&quot;,&quot;language&quot;:&quot;en&quot;}" data-component-name="SubscribeWidgetToDOM"><div class="subscription-widget show-subscribe"><div class="preamble"><p class="cta-caption">Subscribe to stay <em>inquisitive.</em></p></div><form class="subscription-widget-subscribe"><input type="email" class="email-input" name="email" placeholder="Type your email&#8230;" tabindex="-1"><input type="submit" class="button primary" value="Subscribe"><div class="fake-input-wrapper"><div class="fake-input"></div><div class="fake-button"></div></div></form></div></div>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Rebecca Tuvel of Rhodes College on the Ethical Limits of Philosophical Inquiry]]></title><description><![CDATA[A philosopher once targeted by a retraction campaign argues that defending &#8220;radioactive" views in academic philosophy isn&#8217;t wrong.]]></description><link>https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/rebecca-tuvel-of-rhodes-college-on</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/rebecca-tuvel-of-rhodes-college-on</guid><pubDate>Thu, 29 Oct 2026 12:02:09 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://api.substack.com/feed/podcast/222549527/96cf09aadff0c095767fe0f7b2db3f85.mp3" length="0" type="audio/mpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>When does philosophical inquiry cross an ethical line? In this Heterodox Academy virtual colloquium, Rebecca Tuvel, Associate Professor of Philosophy at Rhodes College, offers an answer. She opens with the backlash when her department hosted Peter Singer for a 2021 webinar on pandemic ethics, and with other philosophers whose work drew calls for retraction or cancellation, including her own 2017 article &#8220;In Defense of Transracialism.&#8221; Some critics say such views should be silenced because of the harm they might do; others accept that academic freedom protects them but say advancing them is still wrong.</em></p><p><em>Tuvel lays out the Institutional Model she developed with Eric Sampson of Purdue University: academic philosophy is a legitimate institution, and its members may advance views that turn out to be mistaken, or even unintentionally harmful, in service of its core aim of advancing philosophical understanding. She compares it with the adversarial legal system, investigative journalism, and markets, and answers three objections: that the model overgeneralizes, that philosophy is a non-ideal institution, and that it permits too much harm to marginalized groups. Her conclusion: silence a view on harm grounds only when there is excellent evidence of imminent harm. A transcript of Tuvel&#8217;s talk follows below.</em></p><div><hr></div><p><strong>Dylan Selterman:</strong> Now I&#8217;d like to nominate Rebecca Tuvel. She is an associate professor of philosophy at Rhodes College. She works on the philosophy of race, sex, and gender, the ethics of identity, and the ethics of academic inquiry. She&#8217;s here to talk with us about how addressing controversial topics in academic philosophy can be kept in balance with our other values. In this case, she poses the question, what are the ethical limits of philosophical inquiry? So without further ado, I&#8217;m going to hand things off to Rebecca. She is going to give her presentation, after which we&#8217;ll switch gears to discussion and live audience Q&amp;A. So please use the hand-raised feature on Zoom to speak up when we get to the Q&amp;A portion. If you must stay off camera and microphone, then you have the option to type questions into the chat. All right, Rebecca, take it away.</p><p><strong>Rebecca Tuvel:</strong> Thanks so much. Thanks, everyone, for being here. It&#8217;s encouraging to see so many people. So, okay, so I can no longer see what you&#8217;re seeing, but I think that this is going to be better. So, &#8220;Ethical Limits of Philosophical Inquiry.&#8221; And this is a co-authored project.</p><p>So I started to write on the ethical limits of philosophical inquiry when there was an event at my college with my then-postdoctoral fellow in philosophy, Eric Sampson. So Eric Sampson is now at Purdue University. But what happened in 2021 when I was chairing the department sparked our interest in this topic.</p><p>So we had a bunch of different moving parts at the college. Some folks from poli sci came into philosophy. We basically rebranded our department, built a new curriculum, and we thought, wouldn&#8217;t it be great to launch our new department with some sort of exciting event, 2021, like right in the wake of the pandemic. We thought, what if we could get Peter Singer, you know, the world&#8217;s most famous ethicist, to come and talk about pandemic ethics? And he kindly agreed. And so we had a webinar on pandemic ethics with Singer.</p><p>We thought that we would be praised for this, but in fact, there was quite a bit of faculty blowback. So it started with one faculty member at Rhodes kind of expressing his extreme displeasure and offense that we organized this event. That followed with faculty, angry faculty emails. There was a student protest on campus, calls for us to cancel the event. I was called into the interim president&#8217;s office at the time. So this was a big to-do. And it led us to start thinking about these questions of the appropriate limits of philosophical inquiry.</p><p>I&#8217;ll just note that this is, as many people in this room are no doubt familiar, very much not a one-off case. So there are all kinds of cases wherein a philosopher makes an argument on some morally serious topic, and there are people who experience, you know, extreme offense or might make claims about being harmed in response to that work.</p><p>So I won&#8217;t go through every single one of these, but we probably are all familiar with the gender-critical philosophers, Kathleen Stock, Alex Byrne, and Holly Lawford-Smith, who have argued variously that women are adult human females, who have been accused of causing harm to transgender people. Nathan Cofnas, which is a name that&#8217;s been in the news recently over the whole Jason Arday affair, but he&#8217;s familiar to those of us in philosophy previously for defending the idea that research on group differences in intelligence should be freely pursued. Jonny Anomaly. I mentioned Peter Singer.</p><p>Worth noting that, you know, Singer&#8217;s views are controversial and, you know, we understand how, you know, if you are, you know, a person with a disability or a member of the disability community, Singer&#8217;s argument that it can be permissible in some cases to euthanize a severely disabled newborn when doing so leads to a better outcome for all affected, with parental consent, would, you know, be an upsetting, threatening view to hear. Steve Kershnar, controversial views about adult-child sex, has been said to threaten the safety of people who were victims of sexual abuse. Richard Swinburne has argued that homosexuality is a kind of disability.</p><p>And it&#8217;s not, you know, only people on the left who have been upset by various views. Tommy Curry argued that Black people have a right to lethal self-defense against racial violence and this kind of caused a huge negative reaction from corners of the right. And then myself, as you may or may not know, I published an article in 2017 called &#8220;In Defense of Transracialism,&#8221; which I argued that considerations in support of transgender identities extend to transracial identities. And, you know, there was an open letter calling for the retraction of my article. It ultimately wasn&#8217;t retracted, but, you know, I was stated to have done harm to trans individuals and to Black people.</p><p>So in all of these cases, basically, we have instances of philosophers who are working on, talking about some, you know, radioactive moral, political topic and said to be kind of doing harm in doing so.</p><p>All kinds of reactions, so from disinvitations to article retractions or calls for retraction, book contracts rescinded. This happened with the gender-critical folks, like OUP had invited Alex Byrne and then ultimately, you know, denied his book contract. Calls to fire people, refusals to hire people. There have been academic publications kind of defending the idea that we should try to institutionally delegitimize certain views that are harmful or taken to be harmful. Others who&#8217;ve argued that maybe we need something like IRB oversight of philosophical research. So the same way that we have institutional review boards in the sciences, maybe we could have something like that in philosophy. Moral condemnation of speakers, banning speakers from campus. Interestingly, Kershnar was actually banned from his own campus. It was claimed that it was also for his own safety. No-platforming, moral condemnation on professional blogs. So lots of different kinds of reactions here.</p><p>And I really want to emphasize that my co-author and I take these reactions seriously. And we just think that they lead to a genuine puzzle. So I do want to emphasize that again, we think it makes sense that some find, say, Singer&#8217;s views on disability deeply upsetting. It makes sense that such views are experienced as harmful or deeply distressing, especially to people with disabilities. And yet we ultimately think that all of the above listed reactions are misguided. And so this led to the puzzle of our paper and to our attempt to defend a position on the ethical limits of philosophical inquiry.</p><p>Okay, so just quickly, we want to say that we think that there are two kind of common extreme responses that people have to these various kinds of cases, and we think both are mistaken.</p><p>So the first one is something like keep quiet. Philosophers just morally should avoid publishing or speaking publicly on complex, high-stakes topics to just avoid the risk of serious harm. Just, you know, it&#8217;s too risky, just don&#8217;t do it. We think that this response is misguided for a few reasons. The main one is that if the mere risk of harm were sufficient to, you know, leave philosophers to stop publishing or speaking on complex topics for moral reasons, that would also mean that basically every interesting moral, political, and religious question would be off-limits, because you can&#8217;t really discuss, you know, the ethics of immigration, abortion, gun control, distributive justice, whatever it may be, without incurring some risk of harm, right? Like these topics are interesting and difficult in part because they are morally risky, right? If you get it wrong, there could be bad effects.</p><p>Also, we think, you know, if the thought is, well, philosophers shouldn&#8217;t weigh in, then we wonder who should weigh in, right? Somebody will weigh in. And we think, why not the people who are trained to, you know, analyze and assess better and worse arguments in the realm of moral and political philosophy?</p><p>Second extreme response is something very permissive. Like, anything goes. Philosophers are just permitted to say whatever they like, however harmful or risky, as they perform their characteristic professional duties. And, you know, we think that the truth is important or philosophical understanding is important. And yet this view goes too far because certainly it&#8217;s not the only thing that matters, right? So morality doesn&#8217;t just magically cease to apply in the academic context or any context just because, you know, we also value the truth. So it can&#8217;t just be that there&#8217;s no weight whatsoever to give to the moral views.</p><p>So for instance, if we were to have received credible evidence that having this Peter Singer webinar on campus was going to actually lead to some disabled students being seriously harmed in some way, we would have been the first ones to shut it down. You know, so morality doesn&#8217;t cease to exist. So those are the two extreme responses.</p><p>And what we propose is an institutional model that we think walks a line kind of somewhere between these, not quite as extreme as anything goes, although it is, you know, certainly more permissive than keep quiet. So our goal is we just defend a general theory on the ethical limits of philosophical inquiry called the institutional model. And I think that the core idea will probably strike you as pretty intuitive. What do we do? We got to think first and foremost about an institution&#8217;s legitimate goal. And that is what sets the bounds for permissible or impermissible activity within that institution.</p><p>So on our view, it follows that none of the philosophers discussed above have done anything morally wrong by publicly defending their views. So there&#8217;s little to be said in favor of silencing them, you know, by, you know, trying to block or prevent or otherwise their academic publications, colloquia, keynotes, or whatever.</p><p>Okay, so quick point before I say a little more about the view itself. Importantly, like, we are talking about the ethics of philosophical inquiry here. And that question is, does morality permit defending certain views in academic settings? Importantly, this question is distinct from standard questions about academic freedom. So academic freedom questions are more asking like, ought laws or institutions permit the defense of certain views?</p><p>So a common view, for instance, in academic freedom literature is something like, well, academics have a right to do wrong. In other words, like there&#8217;s institutional protection of their views, even if they&#8217;re morally mistaken, right? Our view is that, is stronger in that it&#8217;s saying defending radioactive views is actually not wrong at all. Also, it&#8217;s a moral argument, not a policy proposal. So just wanted to flag some distinctions there. We&#8217;re just denying that there&#8217;s even any wrong being done here.</p><p>All right, the institutional model. So take another institution, take the adversarial legal system, for instance. You can think about what its legitimate goal is. You might think justice is the legitimate goal of the adversarial legal system. Who plays roles in the adversarial legal system? We have defense attorneys and prosecutors, right? What are they trying to do? Well, they&#8217;re trying to, you know, convict guilty people and acquit innocent people, all with a view toward justice.</p><p>And this does involve harmful or dangerous behavior, right? I mean, there&#8217;s defense attorneys know, like, at some point in their career, they will defend rapists and murderers, and prosecutors know at some point in their career that we did, you know, prosecuting innocent people and all of that, right? So we don&#8217;t deny that there&#8217;s, you know, harm and risk of harm here. However, we understand that, you know, when these role players play their roles well within the larger system, we collectively with our coordinated behavior achieve justice better than any obvious feasible alternatives.</p><p>So if you could imagine a high school student going to watch a murder trial or something and being totally enraged, like, why is this person defending a murderer? This is a terrible thing to do. This is supposed to be a justice system. And we would say that they&#8217;re missing the larger picture. It&#8217;s actually this coordinated behavior that together serves this larger goal of justice.</p><p>So, of course, there are limits, and we argue that, you know, it&#8217;s helpful to understand the limits of what role players can do in any given institution by referring back to its goal. So what is it that lawyers can&#8217;t do? They can&#8217;t lie, fabricate evidence, intentionally elicit false confessions, prosecute all and only their political enemies, prosecute only if they&#8217;re guaranteed to win, you know? And the reason they can&#8217;t do those things is because doing so, you know, blocks our larger goal of justice.</p><p>So hopefully you get the idea here. For the sake of time, I won&#8217;t necessarily run through every institution, but, you know, we talk about how analogous cases with, like, investigative journalism, with airport security, where we have airport security agents doing all kinds of things, performing random searches on innocent passengers, but for the larger goal of security.</p><p>We talk also about markets. So what&#8217;s the legitimate goal of markets? Economic efficiency, wealth creation, waste minimization. Market participants are the role players. And there are harmful behaviors there, threatening livelihoods by out-competing rivals, putting them out of business, buying from the best merchant, not the neediest and all that. But again, the larger goal serves creating wealth, cutting waste better than any feasible alternative. But of course, again, there are limits. You can&#8217;t lobby competitors out of existence, dump radioactive chemicals in the river, even if it&#8217;s legal, falsely advertise or steal wages, right? So hopefully you get the idea there.</p><p>And so this is the same view that we should take when it comes to academic philosophy. Here&#8217;s a couple philosophy journals on the right-hand side. What is the goal? We think of it broadly in terms of, like, epistemic improvement or advancing philosophical understanding. You know, you could have a lot of different views about what it is that philosophy is doing, whether or not it&#8217;s, like, seeking the truth or knowledge, but we think advancing philosophical understanding kind of broadly captures the general epistemic enterprise. That&#8217;s the legitimate goal of this institution.</p><p>Who are the role players? Professional philosophers. And again, there are risky, harmful, and dangerous behaviors, right? Presenting the best arguments, theories, and objections as philosophers see them, even when those views are in fact morally heinous, right? And even when those views, you know, could, you know, lead people possibly to enact harm in the real world. Why is this justified? Because, again, with respect to the larger institution, when trained philosophers weigh in on difficult questions, including radioactive ones, we understand those questions better, can better judge which answers are true.</p><p>And yet there are still limits. You aren&#8217;t morally permitted to insult your interlocutors, misquote authors, call for physical attacks, accept or reject papers based on institutional affiliation, accept or reject papers based on age, race, sex, etc. Also may publish only Rawls content in political philosophy journals, ideological capture in general. So again, all of these limits or these things that we think that you&#8217;re, you know, morally not permitted to do as professional philosopher can be understood by reference back to the larger goal. So, you know, insulting your interlocutors doesn&#8217;t help advance philosophical understanding, for instance, and neither does any of the other things on this list.</p><p>Okay. Three objections. How am I doing on time? Sorry, I don&#8217;t have my little timer anymore.</p><p><strong>Dylan Selterman:</strong> You&#8217;re good. Keep going.</p><p><strong>Rebecca Tuvel:</strong> Okay, cool. Three objections. There&#8217;s Lionel Hutz: objections. I&#8217;m going to kind of talk about three major objections we think to the view. One is like the overgeneralization objection. The second is what we call the non-ideal institution objection. And the third is the moral emergency objection.</p><p>Overgeneralization, like it sounds, if this model is correct, it looks like it&#8217;s going to really overgeneralize. It&#8217;s going to be morally permissible to defend all kinds of heinous views, Nazism, chattel slavery, white supremacy, in academic research venues. So this person thinks, you know, you said before that, you know, you&#8217;re walking a kind of middle line between these views, but actually your view sounds super permissive. Looks like it would defend most, allow the defense of most anything, even the most heinous views. Second premise, plainly, it&#8217;s not permissible to defend those views in academic research contexts. Therefore, the institutional model is not correct, right? So that&#8217;s essentially how that objection would run. Something&#8217;s gone wrong here in the reasoning.</p><p>And, you know, our reply is, look, if there are good understanding-based reasons to hear philosophical defenses of those views, then it is permissible to publish them. Now we think in fact, there aren&#8217;t good understanding-based reasons to hear philosophical defenses of Nazism and chattel slavery. So you may exclude them, but it&#8217;s not because they&#8217;re immoral. It&#8217;s just because they are implausible.</p><p>So, you know, if you actually start to think about some of those views, like, you know, what would a philosophical defense of Nazism involve, right? So you would have to presumably identify some feature that all or most all Jews share, let&#8217;s say, to the exclusion of other groups, other favored groups. And then you would have to have some premise like justifying uniquely bad treatment for that group. So, you know, our thought is that it is difficult to really imagine what, like, a plausible argument for such a conclusion would look like.</p><p>Now, you might think, well, but what if someone finds an argument for Nazism, chattel slavery or whatever with plausible premises that leads to that conclusion that Nazism is correct or chattel slavery, you know, is morally defensible? Then we bite the bullet here. We say publish it, right? The moral truth is at stake, or philosophical understanding is at stake. Of course, we&#8217;re now in a thought experiment wherein, you know, we&#8217;re picturing views with, like, plausible premises that imply their conclusion for, you know, morally heinous things. So we don&#8217;t think we&#8217;re in that world, but we&#8217;re now imagining that we are in a world where you could actually establish such arguments.</p><p>You might also think, well, what if maybe it&#8217;s a bad argument, but it just gets judged plausible and published? Won&#8217;t that legitimize the bad thing? And we think that, you know, the institution at large relies on people refuting bad views. We think that, you know, philosophers will almost certainly reject bad views for the right reasons. And someone might think, well, what if philosophers are terrible at this? They can&#8217;t tell good arguments from bad ones. Our answer is they can&#8217;t be trusted to decide which views should be excluded then either, right? So either, you know, either you think that they can be trusted to figure out good from bad arguments, or they can&#8217;t, you know, be trusted to have any authority of any kind on what views should be published.</p><p>Second objection is the non-ideal institution objection, and that basically says, look, your model sounds great in an ideal world, but we&#8217;re not in an ideal world. Academic philosophy, as it&#8217;s currently practiced, excludes all kinds of important marginalized views, whether trans-affirming views or disability advocates&#8217; views, views common among racial minorities. So airing more dominant views just takes us further away from the truth rather than toward the truth, because there are just people who are silenced. They&#8217;re not welcome in the room.</p><p>And, you know, I think this is a serious objection. We take seriously the concerns at the heart of this objection. But we hold that the best reply, the proper solution is not to just level down by blocking arguments from the better-represented side. It&#8217;s to level up. We have to remove barriers facing the wrongly excluded side, right? Again, the goal is philosophical understanding, and we don&#8217;t get any closer to that goal by blocking more views, right? In fact, philosophical understanding requires getting all the very best reasons for and against each view on the table, and if one side&#8217;s arguments have been unjustly blocked, the solution is not to block the other side. It is to unblock the side that&#8217;s been shut off, right?</p><p>So this means taking different measures to ensure that, like, views that have been previously excluded or marginalized in the profession have a place. And I think academic philosophy has certainly taken strides in the last 30 years to try to remedy some of these exclusions, you know, work on, like, race, sex, and gender, and decolonial thought, things that were, like, you know, considered laughable not that long ago, are now, like, part of the philosophical canon. So, you know, and we think that that is the right response.</p><p>By analogy, going back to the other institution, you might think, you might hear people say, like, rich people get good lawyers and poor people get bad ones. And if someone were to say, well, let&#8217;s deny rich people good lawyers, we&#8217;d say, well, no, that&#8217;s not the right answer, right? Denying good lawyers to rich people will just make them worse off and nobody better off. That&#8217;s not going to serve justice. We should rather try to get good lawyers for poor people.</p><p>Okay. Final objection, moral emergency objection says, look, if we don&#8217;t prevent some philosophers from expressing their views on campus or in print, someone will be harmed, whether trans people, people with disabilities, racial minorities, young children. And these are all the kinds of different groups that have been said to be harmed when, in response to what these various philosophers have said.</p><p>And we think, first, you&#8217;ve got to unpack what kind of harm we&#8217;re talking about. There&#8217;s, like, at least three versions we can identify. One is imminent physical harm, one is severe psychological harm, and one is a sort of diffused downstream harm.</p><p>Imminent physical harm basically says, you know, as I noted, that having these views published or aired on campus could cause imminent physical harm. First off, you know, we grant the principle again. So I sort of mentioned this earlier, but imagine that critics credibly threatened to riot if a philosopher presented her research, making severe injury likely. It would be wrong for her to proceed and permissible for others to stop her, right? She can postpone, relocate, or publish instead. Again, morality doesn&#8217;t just cease to exist because the truth is at stake. We have to take seriously these sorts of concerns.</p><p>In practice, though, we think the evidence that imminent physical harm takes place on campuses or elsewhere in response to these sorts of views is exceedingly rare. So people like Singer, or Stock, Kershnar, maybe not Cofnas, I don&#8217;t know how much he&#8217;s spoken on campuses, but the other ones have spoken on campuses for years, some for decades. We know of no recorded incident of violence against any of the groups said to be endangered. Also, there&#8217;s just not often specificity about who would be, you know, committing the violent acts against whom, like it&#8217;s often just people expressing these concerns without adequate evidence.</p><p>Imminent psychological harm, I think, is much more commonly what people have in mind when they speak about harm, things like offense, betrayal, sadness, anger. And we think this gets something right, right? We think in ordinary settings, you know, it really can be wrong and sometimes is wrong to kind of casually debate race and IQ, adult-child sex, whether trans women are really women, right? In some contexts, it could be that that harm is gratuitous, and depending on where it is that you&#8217;re discussing this, this might very well be something that you ought not to do.</p><p>However, it doesn&#8217;t follow that philosophers act wrongly in doing this in a research context for a few reasons. One, because it&#8217;s not gratuitous. Research reliably advances philosophical understanding, so the harms kind of come with these real benefits. Also, we think that these kinds of harms are unintended and unavoidable. Like, silencing these views wouldn&#8217;t prevent the harm. It would just leave those questions to less careful voices. So responsible inquiry in general just can&#8217;t avoid hard questions.</p><p>It&#8217;s also unexceptional, right? So, you know, conservatives also will claim experiencing psychological distress, for instance, when people defend abortion or same-sex marriage, atheism or gender transition for children, for instance. People have very strong feelings about this, but few think that that makes anti-conservative philosophical defenses wrong. So we think the same applies when the harmed party is a member of a marginalized group, and for consistency&#8217;s sake, you have to tolerate this, again, for the larger sake of philosophical understanding.</p><p>So we think once philosophers take reasonable care to minimize needless harm, responsible inquiry into important questions is not morally wrong and is indeed morally permissible.</p><p>Final concern would be something like not, you know, immediate psychological or physical harm, but a more diffused distant harm. You know, down the line, this could have negative effects on, you know, whatever marginalized group is said to be at risk.</p><p>And our reply here is that, first, it&#8217;s really difficult to predict the long-term effects of academic expression. It&#8217;s highly speculative. Academics have really not been good at it in the past, and had past philosophers suppressed views that they thought were false and harmful, like atheism or interracial marriage or same-sex marriage, gender transition, none would have gained a hearing. And we don&#8217;t think we&#8217;re any less fallible, right? There&#8217;s no reason to think that, you know, we know nowadays, right, what views are, you know, morally correct and which ones are likely to actually lead to long-term harm as opposed to benefit.</p><p>Okay, upshot, big idea. Look to the institution&#8217;s legitimate goal to set the limits of what people may permissibly do within that institution. The goal of academic philosophy: advancing philosophical understanding. Defending radioactive views serves that goal. So none of the philosophers discussed did anything wrong. And again, we limit, look at the limits: reject a view because it&#8217;s implausible, not because it is immoral. Where views are wrongly excluded, we should level up and not level down. We should silence on harm grounds only when there&#8217;s, like, really excellent evidence of imminent harm. Okay, that is, that&#8217;s the gist of it. I hope I didn&#8217;t take too much time there. But thank you so much for listening.</p><p class="button-wrapper" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/rebecca-tuvel-of-rhodes-college-on?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Share&quot;,&quot;action&quot;:null,&quot;class&quot;:null}" data-component-name="ButtonCreateButton"><a class="button primary" href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/rebecca-tuvel-of-rhodes-college-on?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share"><span>Share</span></a></p><div><hr></div><div class="subscription-widget-wrap-editor" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/subscribe?&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Subscribe&quot;,&quot;language&quot;:&quot;en&quot;}" data-component-name="SubscribeWidgetToDOM"><div class="subscription-widget show-subscribe"><div class="preamble"><p class="cta-caption"><em>Free The Inquiry</em> brings you essays, expert commentary, and conversations about open inquiry in the academy. Subscribe to stay up to date.</p></div><form class="subscription-widget-subscribe"><input type="email" class="email-input" name="email" placeholder="Type your email&#8230;" tabindex="-1"><input type="submit" class="button primary" value="Subscribe"><div class="fake-input-wrapper"><div class="fake-input"></div><div class="fake-button"></div></div></form></div></div><p></p>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Colleges Should Have to Prove They Teach Students to Think]]></title><description><![CDATA[Higher education can only restore trustworthiness through accountability]]></description><link>https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/what-higher-education-owes-the-public</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/what-higher-education-owes-the-public</guid><dc:creator><![CDATA[K e v i n W a l l s t e n]]></dc:creator><pubDate>Wed, 28 Oct 2026 15:01:33 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!2DqG!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0b5151bf-daa1-458f-8e53-63beecb04797_1456x1048.jpeg" length="0" type="image/jpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="captioned-image-container"><figure><a class="image-link image2 is-viewable-img" target="_blank" href="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!2DqG!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0b5151bf-daa1-458f-8e53-63beecb04797_1456x1048.jpeg" data-component-name="Image2ToDOM"><div class="image2-inset"><picture><source type="image/webp" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!2DqG!,w_424,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0b5151bf-daa1-458f-8e53-63beecb04797_1456x1048.jpeg 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!2DqG!,w_848,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0b5151bf-daa1-458f-8e53-63beecb04797_1456x1048.jpeg 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!2DqG!,w_1272,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0b5151bf-daa1-458f-8e53-63beecb04797_1456x1048.jpeg 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!2DqG!,w_1456,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0b5151bf-daa1-458f-8e53-63beecb04797_1456x1048.jpeg 1456w" sizes="100vw"><img src="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!2DqG!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0b5151bf-daa1-458f-8e53-63beecb04797_1456x1048.jpeg" width="1456" height="1048" data-attrs="{&quot;src&quot;:&quot;https://substack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/0b5151bf-daa1-458f-8e53-63beecb04797_1456x1048.jpeg&quot;,&quot;srcNoWatermark&quot;:null,&quot;fullscreen&quot;:null,&quot;imageSize&quot;:null,&quot;height&quot;:1048,&quot;width&quot;:1456,&quot;resizeWidth&quot;:null,&quot;bytes&quot;:1370518,&quot;alt&quot;:null,&quot;title&quot;:null,&quot;type&quot;:&quot;image/jpeg&quot;,&quot;href&quot;:null,&quot;belowTheFold&quot;:false,&quot;topImage&quot;:true,&quot;internalRedirect&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/i/213037482?img=https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0b5151bf-daa1-458f-8e53-63beecb04797_1456x1048.jpeg&quot;,&quot;isProcessing&quot;:false,&quot;align&quot;:null,&quot;offset&quot;:false}" class="sizing-normal" alt="" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!2DqG!,w_424,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0b5151bf-daa1-458f-8e53-63beecb04797_1456x1048.jpeg 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!2DqG!,w_848,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0b5151bf-daa1-458f-8e53-63beecb04797_1456x1048.jpeg 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!2DqG!,w_1272,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0b5151bf-daa1-458f-8e53-63beecb04797_1456x1048.jpeg 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!2DqG!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0b5151bf-daa1-458f-8e53-63beecb04797_1456x1048.jpeg 1456w" sizes="100vw" fetchpriority="high"></picture><div class="image-link-expand"><div class="pencraft pc-display-flex pc-gap-8 pc-reset"><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container restack-image buttonBase-tqxFUX" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg aria-hidden="true" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 20 20" fill="none" stroke-width="1.5" stroke="var(--color-fg-primary)" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="icon-noB79L"><g><path d="M2.53001 7.81595C3.49179 4.73911 6.43281 2.5 9.91173 2.5C13.1684 2.5 15.9537 4.46214 17.0852 7.23684L17.6179 8.67647M17.6179 8.67647L18.5002 4.26471M17.6179 8.67647L13.6473 6.91176M17.4995 12.1841C16.5378 15.2609 13.5967 17.5 10.1178 17.5C6.86118 17.5 4.07589 15.5379 2.94432 12.7632L2.41165 11.3235M2.41165 11.3235L1.5293 15.7353M2.41165 11.3235L6.38224 13.0882"></path></g></svg></button><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container view-image buttonBase-tqxFUX" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="2" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" class="lucide lucide-maximize2 lucide-maximize-2 icon-noB79L"><polyline points="15 3 21 3 21 9"></polyline><polyline points="9 21 3 21 3 15"></polyline><line x1="21" x2="14" y1="3" y2="10"></line><line x1="3" x2="10" y1="21" y2="14"></line></svg></button></div></div></div></a><figcaption class="image-caption">"The Floor Scrapers" by Gustave Caillebotte, 1875. Wikimedia Commons, Public Domain.</figcaption></figure></div><p>What is college for and why should the public have confidence that it will fulfill this mission?</p><p>In <em><a href="https://www.amazon.com/College-What-Should-William-Bowen/dp/0691130736?adgrpid=185328955904&amp;hvpone=&amp;hvptwo=&amp;hvadid=748008426930&amp;hvpos=&amp;hvnetw=g&amp;hvrand=14013066299656922457&amp;hvqmt=&amp;hvdev=c&amp;hvdvcmdl=&amp;hvlocint=&amp;hvlocphy=9008187&amp;hvtargid=dsa-1595363597442&amp;hydadcr=&amp;mcid=&amp;hvocijid=14013066299656922457--&amp;hvexpln=m-dsad&amp;tag=googhydr-20&amp;hvsb=Media_d&amp;hvcampaign=dsadesk">College: What It Was, Is, and Should Be</a></em>, Columbia University historian Andrew Delbanco tries to answer the first part of this question, arguing that higher education serves three purposes. The first is economic: providing individuals with marketable skills. The second is civic: cultivating what he calls a &#8220;well-functioning bullshit meter&#8221; that inoculates people against specious arguments. The third is personal: developing an inner life rich enough that, as former Barnard College president Judith Shapiro puts it, &#8220;the inside of your head is an interesting place to spend the rest of your life.&#8221;</p><p>The public broadly endorses each of these purposes. According to <a href="https://www.newamerica.org/insights/varying-degrees-2025-americans-find-common-ground-in-higher-education/">a 2025 poll</a> conducted by New America, the vast majority of Americans said colleges should equip students with the necessary skills to succeed in their chosen fields (96%), develop their critical thinking (93%), prepare them as informed citizens (91%), and expose them to diverse ideas (84%).</p><p>Yet <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2025/10/15/growing-share-of-americans-say-the-us-higher-education-system-is-headed-in-the-wrong-direction/">recent surveys show</a> that the same public doesn&#8217;t think colleges and universities are fulfilling this mission. There are a number of reasons for this loss of trust, but one underexamined factor is a lack of clarity among the public about just what universities are and aren&#8217;t accomplishing. Indeed, higher education is now publicly accountable for only the economic component (i.e. will my degree help me find a job in my chosen field?) of its broader mission.</p><p>But while prospective students can compare nearly every school in the country on graduate earnings and debt through the <a href="https://collegescorecard.ed.gov/">College Scorecard</a>, no comparable resource exists for civic and formative outcomes. The lack of data is surprising because colleges and universities routinely promise to cultivate critical thinking, foster intellectual humility and prepare students to engage across ideological and other differences. But a prospective student currently has no way of assessing whether a school&#8217;s graduates leave campus better on any of these crucial formative dimensions than when they arrived.</p><p>Transparency about economic outcomes cannot underwrite confidence in the whole enterprise as long as civic and formative promises remain unverifiable. What the Scorecard really proves then is that standardized, mandatory public reporting can render at least part of higher education&#8217;s mission legible to the public. But if colleges and universities want confidence to extend beyond their economic mission, they will need to make their civic and formative missions publicly accountable as well.</p><h3><strong>Make the Curriculum Verifiable</strong></h3><p>If colleges and universities are truly serious about civic formation and exposure to diverse perspectives, their curricula should make those commitments clear. Currently, many do not. In <a href="https://www.city-journal.org/article/universities-dei-civics-education">one analysis</a> of general education requirements at 120 nationally prominent schools, none required students to take economics and only 15% required them to study U.S. government or American history. But 51% mandated that students complete diversity, equity, and inclusion coursework. This particular curricular balance is difficult to reconcile with the claim that preparing students for citizenship is a central institutional priority.</p><p>The same problem appears within courses themselves. While colleges and universities say they teach students to engage critically with competing arguments, course content does not always bear that out. A <a href="https://www.persuasion.community/p/we-analyzed-university-syllabi-theres">recent analysis of millions of syllabi</a> from the Open Syllabus Project, for example, found that on contested issues such as criminal justice, the Israel-Palestine conflict and abortion students are often assigned readings that reflect a narrow range of left-wing perspectives and do not engage with scholarly counterarguments. Not every class needs to stage an artificial debate around every question, of course, but institutions claiming to cultivate intellectual breadth should be able to show how and where that breadth is appearing in the curriculum.</p><p>The first step toward fixing this is to mandate a broadly defined, civic education course covering American constitutional government, the history of the American political tradition, and basic economic principles. Requirements alone, however, are not enough. Syllabi for courses used to satisfy these requirements should be publicly accessible. Outsiders should be able to determine whether schools that promise civic formation actually require civic learning, whether courses advertised as exposing students to diverse perspectives actually do so, and whether curricular reforms announced by campus leaders or state legislatures actually reach the classroom.</p><p>To be clear, these reforms should not be interpreted as a license to micromanage every course or prescribe a single canon for every campus. Instead, these changes should be narrowly focused on making the civic curriculum answerable to the public purposes universities already claim to serve.</p><h3><strong>Measure What Colleges Claim To Produce</strong></h3><p>It is worth, however, being very candid about the limits of curricular reform. As American Enterprise Institute senior fellow Samuel Abrams has <a href="https://www.aei.org/domestic-policy/civic-knowledge-is-returning-civic-formation-is-not/">recently argued</a>, gains in civic knowledge (i.e. the growing percent of Americans who can correctly identify the three branches of government) have not been matched by improvements in civic formation (i.e. the small and declining share of Americans who can productively engage across difference and reason in good faith). Changing general education requirements and publishing course syllabi are the easiest part of reforming higher education. Verifying that a school requires civic coursework tells the public what is taught but nothing about whether students were actually transformed by it.</p><p>Colleges and universities must also, therefore, measure and report on the outcomes of their civic and formative efforts. Admittedly, civic and formative outcomes are harder to gauge than graduation rates, eventual earnings, or student debt. But colleges and universities are better equipped than almost any other institution to meet that challenge. After all, they employ faculty who specialize in survey research, measurement, and statistical analysis; administrators experienced in standardized reporting; subject review boards to ensure ethical data collection; and communications teams capable of explaining results to the public.</p><p>And, they would not have to start from scratch. Over the past several decades, higher education has developed a substantial assessment infrastructure devoted to tracking formative educational effects. Some tools, such as the <a href="https://nsse.indiana.edu/nsse/index.html">National Survey of Student Engagement (NSSE)</a> and the <a href="https://www.icpsr.umich.edu/web/ICPSR/series/21">Cooperative Institutional Research Program (CIRP)</a>, track students&#8217; experiences and educational development at scale. Others, including the <a href="https://centerofinquiry.org/wabash-national-study-of-liberal-arts-education/">Wabash National Study</a>, The American Association of Colleges and Universities&#8217; <a href="https://www.aacu.org/initiatives/value">VALUE rubrics</a>, and the <a href="https://cae.org/">Collegiate Learning Assessment (CLA)</a>, measure outcomes such as critical thinking and civic-related gains. More recently, <a href="https://hfh.fas.harvard.edu/academicflourishing">Harvard&#8217;s Academic Flourishing Initiative</a> has developed and tested <a href="https://www.internationaljournalofwellbeing.org/index.php/ijow/article/view/5003">a survey instrument</a> designed to tap dimensions of meaning, character, and intellectual formation among undergraduates.</p><p>While these efforts show rigorous measurement of civic and formative outcomes is possible, they have not accumulated into anything like the kind of public accountability system that tracks the economic mission. For instance, NSSE results typically <a href="https://nsse.indiana.edu/nsse/about-nsse/general-nsse-info-facts/public-reporting-of-student-engagement-results.html">belong to the school that pays for them</a> and are rarely disclosed in standardized form. CIRP functions <a href="https://heri.ucla.edu/why-your-institution-should-administer-the-cirp-freshman-survey/">primarily as an internal research instrument</a> rather than as a public-facing accountability tool.</p><p>The Wabash National Study last <a href="https://centerofinquiry.org/wabash-national-study-of-liberal-arts-education/#1492436667723-315f7e8e-ac86">completed its longitudinal collection</a> in the early 2010s, and VALUE rubrics are adapted for use and scored by each individual school, making them useful for campus assessments but limiting their value as a common public benchmark. The CLA, for its part, has only been <a href="https://cae.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/12/1-CLA-FAQ-120125.pdf">voluntarily adopted</a> among a select group of schools and so yields nothing close to a comprehensive picture of learning across colleges and universities. Despite a considerable effort at measurement, in other words, prospective students still cannot compare their expected civic learning gains or indicators of intellectual formation across campuses.</p><p>What&#8217;s missing is a centralized, public reporting system built on <a href="https://www.unesco.org/en/open-science/about">open science principles</a>. Colleges and universities should preregister what they will measure, which students they will include, how the data will be analyzed, and what results they will publish. Doing so would make it far harder to redefine success after the fact or selectively report only flattering findings. Schools should, of course, be free to add mission-specific measures to their data collection efforts, but a small set of common questions should be mandated so that institutional strengths and weaknesses become visible and, more importantly, so that schools can begin to learn from one another.</p><p>There is no reason this has to be a government undertaking. In fact, a federal mandate may do more harm than good by inviting politically driven standards and by raising the stakes in ways that intensify the temptation that comes with the imposition of any measurement scheme to focus on what is tested rather than on what ultimately matters.</p><div class="pullquote"><p>Higher education&#8217;s economic mission is surrounded by an accountability infrastructure because public legitimacy came to require it. Its civic and formative missions have remained largely exempt from comparable scrutiny because they are inherently harder to measure.</p></div><p>The most credible approach, therefore, would be led by a consortium of colleges and universities themselves or an independent nonprofit clearinghouse modeled on how institutions currently pool data through bodies like NSSE. This approach, of course, would not be easy to implement. It would require coordination across disparate institutions, agreement on shared standards, and a willingness to accept a form of public scrutiny that many campuses have long sought to avoid.</p><p>But the alternative is continued drift in a system that does little to improve public confidence. Imperfect measurement is better than no accountability at all, and the time for deferring reforms has passed.</p><p>Public reporting would also reshape how excellence in higher education is evaluated. Conventional judgments of &#8220;quality&#8221; are heavily influenced by what is easiest to measure (e.g. selectivity, graduation rates, earnings, debt, etc.). As Brendan Case and Tyler VanderWeele have recently <a href="https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2025/10/20/case-vanderweele-harvard-rankings-flourishing/">pointed out</a> in an article in The Harvard Crimson, standard rankings largely omit the broader outcomes colleges and universities promise to deliver. Schools that excel at civic learning or intellectual formation currently have no way to make that excellence legible to prospective students, policymakers, or to the public more broadly.</p><p>Standardized public reporting would change that. Without comparable data on these dimensions, however, the prestige system will continue to reward the outcomes it can measure and ignore the ones it cannot.</p><h3><strong>What Trustworthiness Requires</strong></h3><p>There is a difference between earning public trust and establishing institutional trustworthiness. Trust is an attitude that is shaped by what institutions do but also by polarization, media environment, and forces well beyond any single institution&#8217;s control. Trustworthiness is more directly within institutions&#8217; reach: It belongs to those that verifiably do what they claim they will do. The reforms proposed here cannot guarantee that Americans will trust higher education, but they can help ensure that colleges and universities deserve that trust.</p><p>This distinction matters because distrust of higher education is often dismissed within the academy as a problem caused by conservatives. This deflects from the more fundamental question facing higher education, which is why anyone, regardless of their ideology, should trust an institution that rarely provides outsiders with enough evidence to judge whether it is fulfilling its own promises. When curricular commitments are difficult to verify, syllabi are inaccessible, and civic learning is not systematically measured, skepticism is predictable and hard to dismiss.</p><p>These reforms are not about winning back the support of conservatives. They are about giving institutional legitimacy a defensible foundation for people from across the political spectrum. Regardless of whether they move survey numbers, institutions that claim to form citizens and prepare students for democratic life owe the public evidence that proves those claims.</p><p>Nor do these reforms impose a single telos on higher education. Civic formation can coexist with other educational purposes rather than displacing them. What&#8217;s more, they do not invite federal coercion. In fact, the most credible answer to looming external interference is internal action that makes such coercion less necessary.</p><div class="pullquote"><p>Until recently, higher education received the kind of trust almost no other institution had, namely, trust based on deference to prestige and, at least on its civic and formative claims, largely insulated from public verification.</p></div><p>Higher education&#8217;s economic mission is surrounded by an accountability infrastructure because public legitimacy came to require it. Its civic and formative missions have remained largely exempt from comparable scrutiny because they are inherently harder to measure, because the federal government has not compelled colleges to report on them the way it has compelled reporting on economic outcomes, and because the public has long simply taken universities at their word. If trust, let alone trustworthiness, is to be restored, that exemption is no longer sustainable.</p><h3><strong>We May Not Like What We See</strong></h3><p>What will be revealed when formative measurement does break into public view may not please supporters of higher education. For example, in their book <em><a href="https://press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/A/bo10327226.html">Academically Adrift</a></em>, Richard Arum and Josipa Roksa used data from the Collegiate Learning Assessment to show that a large share of more than 2,300 undergraduates across two dozen schools showed little improvement in critical thinking, complex reasoning, or written communication during their first two years of college.</p><p>But while the book provoked substantial debate within higher education, it failed to produce a durable apparatus for assessing formative or civic outcomes. Indeed, 15 years later, the CLA remains voluntary and there is no centralized public database, website, or dashboard that publishes scores across colleges and universities.</p><p>Work emerging from Harvard&#8217;s Human Flourishing Program also shows what more serious measurement has the potential to reveal. In<a href="https://hfh.fas.harvard.edu/sites/g/files/omnuum8886/files/2025-06/WSJ%20Character%20Questions_Weighted.pdf"> </a>early analyses of &#8220;student formation&#8221; measures, Ivy League scores on meaning, character, intellectual formation, and the capacity to work across differences were not especially impressive despite the schools&#8217; dominance on more conventional measures of academic quality.</p><p>These are the kind of findings that have the potential to build the foundation for institutional trustworthiness. They subject colleges and universities to a serious, repeated, public test against the ideals they claim to serve, and they illuminate patterns that a focus on economics alone can obscure. But reporting one-off survey results is not the same as building a consistent accountability system. Higher education now has the tools to make evidence of this kind routine and comparable. Colleges and universities should take the initiative for this work themselves rather than leaving outsiders to assemble it piecemeal.</p><p>Until recently, higher education received the kind of trust almost no other institution had, namely, trust based on deference to prestige and, at least on its civic and formative claims, largely insulated from public verification. The 2026 <a href="https://president.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2026-04/Report-of-the-Committee-on-Trust-in-Higher-Education.pdf">Yale Committee on Trust in Higher Education report</a>, more than any other development in recent years, signals that this era of deference is over. The only question now is whether universities will build the infrastructure that trustworthiness requires or have others impose it on them.</p><p class="button-wrapper" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/what-higher-education-owes-the-public?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Share&quot;,&quot;action&quot;:null,&quot;class&quot;:null}" data-component-name="ButtonCreateButton"><a class="button primary" href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/what-higher-education-owes-the-public?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share"><span>Share</span></a></p><div><hr></div><div class="subscription-widget-wrap-editor" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/subscribe?&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Subscribe&quot;,&quot;language&quot;:&quot;en&quot;}" data-component-name="SubscribeWidgetToDOM"><div class="subscription-widget show-subscribe"><div class="preamble"><p class="cta-caption">Subscribe to stay <em>inquisitive.</em></p></div><form class="subscription-widget-subscribe"><input type="email" class="email-input" name="email" placeholder="Type your email&#8230;" tabindex="-1"><input type="submit" class="button primary" value="Subscribe"><div class="fake-input-wrapper"><div class="fake-input"></div><div class="fake-button"></div></div></form></div></div>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[The Weekly: Evidence Rules, Or Does It?]]></title><description><![CDATA[Defending the basics in empirical research, plus AI peer reviewers and #HotGirlScience]]></description><link>https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/the-weekly-evidence-rules-or-does</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/the-weekly-evidence-rules-or-does</guid><dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Regnier]]></dc:creator><pubDate>Sat, 24 Oct 2026 16:06:19 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!vRa-!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Faf0cdc53-dc8b-4938-829d-b4009e69d7d7_2720x2102.jpeg" length="0" type="image/jpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="captioned-image-container"><figure><a class="image-link image2 is-viewable-img" target="_blank" href="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!vRa-!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Faf0cdc53-dc8b-4938-829d-b4009e69d7d7_2720x2102.jpeg" data-component-name="Image2ToDOM"><div class="image2-inset"><picture><source type="image/webp" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!vRa-!,w_424,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Faf0cdc53-dc8b-4938-829d-b4009e69d7d7_2720x2102.jpeg 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!vRa-!,w_848,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Faf0cdc53-dc8b-4938-829d-b4009e69d7d7_2720x2102.jpeg 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!vRa-!,w_1272,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Faf0cdc53-dc8b-4938-829d-b4009e69d7d7_2720x2102.jpeg 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!vRa-!,w_1456,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Faf0cdc53-dc8b-4938-829d-b4009e69d7d7_2720x2102.jpeg 1456w" sizes="100vw"><img src="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!vRa-!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Faf0cdc53-dc8b-4938-829d-b4009e69d7d7_2720x2102.jpeg" width="1456" height="1125" data-attrs="{&quot;src&quot;:&quot;https://substack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/af0cdc53-dc8b-4938-829d-b4009e69d7d7_2720x2102.jpeg&quot;,&quot;srcNoWatermark&quot;:null,&quot;fullscreen&quot;:null,&quot;imageSize&quot;:null,&quot;height&quot;:1125,&quot;width&quot;:1456,&quot;resizeWidth&quot;:null,&quot;bytes&quot;:4246773,&quot;alt&quot;:null,&quot;title&quot;:null,&quot;type&quot;:&quot;image/jpeg&quot;,&quot;href&quot;:null,&quot;belowTheFold&quot;:false,&quot;topImage&quot;:true,&quot;internalRedirect&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/i/221932401?img=https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Faf0cdc53-dc8b-4938-829d-b4009e69d7d7_2720x2102.jpeg&quot;,&quot;isProcessing&quot;:false,&quot;align&quot;:null,&quot;offset&quot;:false}" class="sizing-normal" alt="" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!vRa-!,w_424,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Faf0cdc53-dc8b-4938-829d-b4009e69d7d7_2720x2102.jpeg 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!vRa-!,w_848,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Faf0cdc53-dc8b-4938-829d-b4009e69d7d7_2720x2102.jpeg 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!vRa-!,w_1272,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Faf0cdc53-dc8b-4938-829d-b4009e69d7d7_2720x2102.jpeg 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!vRa-!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Faf0cdc53-dc8b-4938-829d-b4009e69d7d7_2720x2102.jpeg 1456w" sizes="100vw" fetchpriority="high"></picture><div class="image-link-expand"><div class="pencraft pc-display-flex pc-gap-8 pc-reset"><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container restack-image buttonBase-tqxFUX" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg aria-hidden="true" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 20 20" fill="none" stroke-width="1.5" stroke="var(--color-fg-primary)" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="icon-noB79L"><g><path d="M2.53001 7.81595C3.49179 4.73911 6.43281 2.5 9.91173 2.5C13.1684 2.5 15.9537 4.46214 17.0852 7.23684L17.6179 8.67647M17.6179 8.67647L18.5002 4.26471M17.6179 8.67647L13.6473 6.91176M17.4995 12.1841C16.5378 15.2609 13.5967 17.5 10.1178 17.5C6.86118 17.5 4.07589 15.5379 2.94432 12.7632L2.41165 11.3235M2.41165 11.3235L1.5293 15.7353M2.41165 11.3235L6.38224 13.0882"></path></g></svg></button><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container view-image buttonBase-tqxFUX" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="2" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" class="lucide lucide-maximize2 lucide-maximize-2 icon-noB79L"><polyline points="15 3 21 3 21 9"></polyline><polyline points="9 21 3 21 3 15"></polyline><line x1="21" x2="14" y1="3" y2="10"></line><line x1="3" x2="10" y1="21" y2="14"></line></svg></button></div></div></div></a></figure></div><p>Last week in this space, I wondered what will happen to academic contestation as AI makes it cheap to scrutinize research. This week, one new paper argues for putting evidence first, while another puts Claude in the peer reviewer&#8217;s seat, and the APA&#8217;s activist stance comes under scrutiny.</p><p>Here are the stories we&#8217;re following at HxA.</p><div><hr></div><h2><strong>Empirical Evidence (and Egalitarian Ends)</strong></h2><p>In a new <a href="https://www.dropbox.com/scl/fi/fsgpflrony7euwdi4gtzq/evidence_essay_draft.pdf?rlkey=l9dao3pb0owotwk3a6if17i6v&amp;st=aeehmfi6&amp;dl=0">working paper</a>, Stanford&#8217;s Tom Clark and Jonathan Mummolo of Princeton make the case for &#8220;Privileging Evidence in Empirical Social Science.&#8221; With a politically balanced set of examples from research on topics including policing, elections, and terrorism, the authors make a classic argument for centering quality evidence with key criteria including <em>contestability</em>. The authors argue:</p><blockquote><p>Researchers must be as transparent as possible with regard to data, methods, and assumptions, and be willing to have their efforts scrutinized, come what may. Just as importantly, other scholars must be interested in and incentivized to contest evidence. &#8230; We support the &#8216;open science&#8217; movement, but all the data repositories in the world will not translate into accountability if critics expect character assassination in return; they will simply abstain from criticism in the first place.</p></blockquote><p>What else would be privileged in empirical work, if not evidence? Clark &amp; Mummolo point to recent proposals to use what they call &#8220;non-evidentiary criteria&#8221; such as the moral quality of the data source, the identity of the researchers themselves, and the assumed political and social impact of the research finding. Using such considerations to limit inquiry, they argue, is an egalitarian-seeming move with inegalitarian consequences: &#8220;When evidence is not allowed to speak, its role is too often supplanted by status, credentials, and rhetorical skill. Evidence, in contrast, is a great equalizer.&#8221;</p><p>Clark &amp; Mummolo don&#8217;t measure how often such &#8220;non-evidentiary&#8221; considerations are put into use, although they suspect that they are not &#8220;prevalent or dominant.&#8221; I&#8217;m not so sure. But that&#8217;s an empirical question that deserves good evidence of its own.</p><div><hr></div><h2><strong>Claude&#8217;s Peerless Peer Review </strong></h2><p>Clark &amp; Mummolo approvingly cite Karl Popper&#8217;s description of science as the &#8220;friendly-hostile co-operation of many scientists.&#8221; But it&#8217;s 2026, so we must ask: is that only <em>human</em> scientists? </p><p>In another paper this week, Harvard&#8217;s Gary King and Steven Worthington <a href="https://gking.harvard.edu/peerless/">tested</a> whether AI can check papers like a human peer reviewer. When three former journal editors blind-evaluated a set of manuscript reviews written by human reviewers and Anthropic&#8217;s Claude, they preferred the AI review in 26 of 30 judgments. The AI reviews also made about a third as many incorrect claims about the manuscripts (5.5% versus 15.9%) and cited no fabricated sources.</p><p>The authors suggest that journals could have authors revise against AI reviews before submitting, publish the prompts their reviews use, or let editors decide from an AI-assisted dossier in place of routine human review. They also warn that scholars who brainstorm with AI can converge on similar ideas, which drift toward what the authors call the &#8220;conventional, orthodox, and majoritarian.&#8221;</p><p>&#8220;AI benefits us individually,&#8221; they write, &#8220;but risks making the collective efforts of science more homogenous and ordinary.&#8221;</p><div><hr></div><h2><strong>APA&#8217;s Future President Is &#8216;Accountably Subjective&#8217;</strong></h2><p>The American Psychological Association is fighting to keep its role accrediting psychology training programs. Last month an Education Department advisory board <a href="https://www.insidehighered.com/news/governance/accreditation/2026/09/25/accreditation-panel-recommends-suspending-apa-punts-aba">voted 7-4</a> to recommend suspending recognition of the APA&#8217;s Commission on Accreditation, after testimony about antisemitism in the field. In a <em><a href="https://www.wsj.com/opinion/the-inmates-run-the-asylum-at-the-psychological-association-5e6538b7">Wall Street Journal</a></em><a href="https://www.wsj.com/opinion/the-inmates-run-the-asylum-at-the-psychological-association-5e6538b7"> op-ed</a> this week, HxA members Colin Wright and Andrew Hartz argue that the allegations reflect a wider failure in parts of organized psychology to separate activism from science.</p><p>This month, the APA <a href="https://www.apa.org/news/press/releases/2026/10/candice-hargons-2028-president">elected</a> Emory psychologist Candice Hargons as its 2028 president; she becomes the official president-elect in January. Hargons&#8217; views are on the record in<a href="https://www.apa.org/about/governance/elections/president-elect-candidate-hargons"> her campaign statement</a>, and they suggest a close coupling of science and activism. &#8220;By uniting against intersectional oppression,&#8221; she writes, &#8220;we will position APA not just as a witness to social change, but as a courageous, unwavering architect of global liberation by collaborating with peer organizations who fight injustice.&#8221;</p><p>Asked how she defines scientific integrity, Hargons writes that she rejects &#8220;the positivist paradigm&#8217;s assertion of objectivity&#8221; and that &#8220;true integrity means being accountably subjective; we don&#8217;t hide who we are or lie to the public about what we find in our research.&#8221; </p><div><hr></div><h2><strong>Positivist or Always Sex-Positive?</strong></h2><p>Since her election, Hargons has been criticized online for her own work, in particular a 2022 article with Shemeka Thorpe entitled <a href="https://journalofpositivesexuality.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/10.51681.1.811_HotGirlScience_Hargons-Thorpe.pdf">&#8220;#HotGirlScience: A Liberatory Paradigm for Intersectional Sex-Positive Scholarship.&#8221;</a> The paper openly calls for researchers to weigh non-evidentiary factors alongside evidence, making it a useful example to consider.</p><p>Read past the hashtags and playful hip hop references, and this paper paints a sympathetic picture: research about Black people and sex has been too ignorant of context, too focused on finding the negatives, and overly serious along the way. (Many HxA members understand that certain fields can grow overly pessimistic. What do these dour sexologists think they are researching, <a href="https://www.progressivepolicy.org/the-distortion-of-american-studies/">American Studies</a>?)</p><p>The positivist approach, following Clark &amp; Mummolo, would be to shine the light of careful inquiry on those possibly overlooked angles in sex research. What <em>is </em>the evidence about pleasure, not just pain? What are the truths that become clear with the benefit of richer context? If race shapes people&#8217;s sex lives in overlooked ways, what are those ways and what evidence tells us? </p><p>Hargons &amp; Thorpe&#8217;s proposed research paradigm takes another path, continuing normal science &#8211; including quantitative data analysis &#8211; but layering in non-evidentiary considerations. For example, instead of universalism, they advocate identity-based particularity: &#8220;Only #HotGirlScience scholars born and immersed in the sexualities they study can use quantitative methodologies and do them justice, because their interpretation is the only justifiable frame for authenticity, fun, and sex positivity.&#8221;</p><p>Instead of methods that are carefully agnostic to outcomes, Hargons &amp; Thorpe&#8217;s paradigm</p><blockquote><p>requires the most loving, sex-positive, nuanced interpretation of the research results. This means that even when the results are negative and not sex-positive or liberatory, researchers acknowledge and state the results but interpret them in meaningful and robust ways that reflect the full context of history and politics that inform the outcomes. Researchers, especially those publishing in academic journals, should ask of themselves: &#8216;How would participants feel if they read what I wrote about them, their sexualities, and their lived experiences?&#8217;</p></blockquote><p>This is science with a commitment to share results, but also an intention to celebrate some results and contextualize others. We can trust such a paradigm to notice what it planned to notice, to safeguard the feelings of research subjects, and maybe even to improve the subjective experience of #HotGirl scientists. Can we trust it to describe the world?</p><p class="button-wrapper" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/the-weekly-evidence-rules-or-does?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Share&quot;,&quot;action&quot;:null,&quot;class&quot;:null}" data-component-name="ButtonCreateButton"><a class="button primary" href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/the-weekly-evidence-rules-or-does?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share"><span>Share</span></a></p><div><hr></div><div class="subscription-widget-wrap-editor" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/subscribe?&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Subscribe&quot;,&quot;language&quot;:&quot;en&quot;}" data-component-name="SubscribeWidgetToDOM"><div class="subscription-widget show-subscribe"><div class="preamble"><p class="cta-caption"><em>Free The Inquiry</em> brings you essays, expert commentary, and conversations about open inquiry in the academy. Subscribe to stay up to date.</p></div><form class="subscription-widget-subscribe"><input type="email" class="email-input" name="email" placeholder="Type your email&#8230;" tabindex="-1"><input type="submit" class="button primary" value="Subscribe"><div class="fake-input-wrapper"><div class="fake-input"></div><div class="fake-button"></div></div></form></div></div><p></p>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Topics Non Grata]]></title><description><![CDATA[In a recent survey, many HxA members say that on campus certain lines of inquiry are off limits]]></description><link>https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/topics-non-grata</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/topics-non-grata</guid><dc:creator><![CDATA[Erin B. Shaw]]></dc:creator><pubDate>Fri, 23 Oct 2026 12:03:44 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!J6UG!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff8c57790-42af-419d-b193-80ddf4a6fa25_725x521.png" length="0" type="image/jpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>HxA has <a href="https://heterodoxacademy.org/blog/why-should-we-care-about-ideological-diversity-in-the-academy-the-definitive-response/">long argued</a> that ideological conformity within the academy suppresses worthy lines of inquiry. Similar concerns have been raised by the much-discussed <a href="https://cdn.vanderbilt.edu/vu-wpfsx/wp-content/uploads/sites/51/2026/06/State-of-Scholarship-CommissionReport-final.pdf">Vanderbilt/Washington University Report</a> and the <a href="https://president.yale.edu/sites/default/files/2026-04/Report-of-the-Committee-on-Trust-in-Higher-Education.pdf">Yale Report</a>, both of which identify ideological conformity as a threat to open inquiry. But identifying the specific topics, questions, and perspectives that have been stifled is a challenging task, requiring disciplinary expertise and an intimate understanding of how each field operates.</p><p>Fortunately, nearly 350 HxA members hailing from a variety of institutions, disciplines, and sub-fields recently allowed us to pick their brains on what might be called &#8220;topics non grata.&#8221; In collaboration with University of Buckingham political scientist <a href="https://www.buckingham.ac.uk/directory/professor-eric-kaufmann/">Eric Kaufmann</a>, and psychologist <a href="https://hartzpsychology.com/about">Andrew Hartz</a>, we surveyed these members to better understand these areas of missing and neglected scholarship. The question at the heart of the survey: &#8220;Are there any topics you feel have been inappropriately neglected in your own discipline for ideological reasons?&#8221;</p><p>What did HxA members tell us? Broadly speaking, topics relating to race, sex, religion, and politics were all identified as unfairly neglected within respondents&#8217; disciplines. These findings, though not representative of entire disciplines or comprehensive in their coverage, support the suggestion that some topics are perceived to be off-limits because they are broadly considered to be ideologically unpalatable rather than lacking in scholarly merit.</p><p>To better understand these responses, we used Claude Opus 4.8 to identify general recurring themes in the dataset, and then developed a list of search terms for each. Responses were assigned to a theme based on the terms they contained. Of the 348 member responses we received, 141 (41%) affirmatively named at least one topic in their field that they felt was neglected. About 54% of respondents left this question blank, and another five percent said that they didn&#8217;t think any topics were neglected in their field. (The share naming a topic varied significantly by discipline, with 30% of STEM faculty and 34% of arts/humanities faculty affirmatively naming a neglected topic compared to 45% of social science faculty.)</p><p>About a quarter of those who named a neglected topic mentioned issues relating to <strong>race or group disparities</strong>. Named topics in this area (loosely paraphrased) included subjects such as &#8220;differential crime rates across racial groups,&#8221; &#8220;challenges in LGB families,&#8221; and &#8220;impacts of family structure on child wellbeing.&#8221;</p><p>Some scholars <em>do</em> grapple with these questions, but often at a cost. For instance, <a href="https://fryer.scholars.harvard.edu/publications/empirical-analysis-racial-differences-police-use-force">research</a> that bucked common narratives about police shootings and race created considerable <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rHDhj7Bua1Q">backlash</a> for Harvard University economist Roland Fryer. A <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23017845/">study</a> that found worse outcomes for adult children of parents who had same-sex relationships earned University of Texas sociologist Mark Regnerus considerable <a href="https://familyinequality.wordpress.com/2012/06/29/200-researchers-respond-to-regnerus-paper/">scorn</a>, even resulting in an <a href="https://www.chronicle.com/blogs/percolator/controversial-gay-parenting-study-is-severely-flawed-journals-audit-finds">audit</a> of the paper&#8217;s peer-review process. And a <a href="https://press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/T/bo205550079.html">book</a> on the importance of two-parent households on child development was <a href="https://www.thecollegefix.com/economists-findings-vindicate-truism-two-parent-families-are-better-for-kids/">opposed</a> by a reviewer on moral rather than scientific grounds, according to the book&#8217;s author, University of Notre Dame economist Melissa Kearney.</p><p>Naming these particular topics and perspectives is not the same as endorsing them. At HxA, we are less interested in the advancement of specific academic claims than ensuring that the environment for scholarship remains intellectually rich and unencumbered by artificial restrictions on inquiry. That&#8217;s because any attempt to improve society and create conditions that allow people to flourish requires reliable knowledge, which scholars can&#8217;t produce when they feel pressure to steer clear of certain areas of inquiry.</p><p>The Fryer, Regnerus, and Kearney examples illustrate that the pursuit of ideologically unwelcome topics may not necessarily result in total academic ruin; after all, these three professors are well-known and continue to produce research in their fields. Still, even for these well-established scholars there was a price to pay, as evidenced by the varying degrees of controversy and in some cases institutional pushback that their work generated. Moreover,  we don&#8217;t know how many other scholars and their ideas never made it through ideological or partisan gauntlets. And so, it&#8217;s impossible to know what the state of scholarship would look like without the immense pressure <em>not</em> to explore unpopular ideas.</p><p>The controversy surrounding political scientist Bruce Gilley&#8217;s &#8220;<a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/01436597.2017.1369037">Case for Colonialism</a>&#8221; is a good example of how the perceived hostility towards certain politically heterodox perspectives can lead to ideas and arguments being suppressed. Gilley&#8217;s article, which argued that colonialism often led to improved quality of life, was withdrawn from publication after several of the journal&#8217;s board members stepped down in protest and the journal&#8217;s editor received threats of violence.</p><h3>Off-Limits</h3><p>Much of the rest of the affirmative responses in the survey also dealt with topics that can easily be seen as too controversial to consider.  For instance, about 25% of responses to this question mentioned topics related to <strong>sex / gender differences &amp; biology</strong> such as &#8220;gender identity&#8221; and &#8220;gender dysphoria,&#8221; areas <a href="https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0214157">with</a> <a href="https://retractionwatch.com/2023/05/24/after-backlash-publisher-to-retract-article-that-surveyed-parents-of-children-with-gender-dysphoria-says-co-author/">no</a> <a href="https://callieburt.org/2021/04/23/context-ebremoval/">shortage</a> of <a href="https://www.city-journal.org/article/anatomy-of-a-scientific-scandal">academic</a> <a href="https://mindingthecampus.org/2024/02/15/carole-hooven-why-i-left-harvard/">controversies</a>. Likewise 18% of responses mentioned topics relating to <strong>religion, tradition, and meaning</strong> such as &#8220;the role of religion in public life&#8221; and &#8220;virtue ethics,&#8221; and about 17% of responses mentioned topics relating to <strong>markets, political economy, and the political right</strong>, such as &#8220;conservative political theory&#8221; and &#8220;the value of social cohesion.&#8221;</p><div class="captioned-image-container"><figure><a class="image-link image2 is-viewable-img" target="_blank" href="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!J6UG!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff8c57790-42af-419d-b193-80ddf4a6fa25_725x521.png" data-component-name="Image2ToDOM"><div class="image2-inset"><picture><source type="image/webp" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!J6UG!,w_424,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff8c57790-42af-419d-b193-80ddf4a6fa25_725x521.png 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!J6UG!,w_848,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff8c57790-42af-419d-b193-80ddf4a6fa25_725x521.png 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!J6UG!,w_1272,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff8c57790-42af-419d-b193-80ddf4a6fa25_725x521.png 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!J6UG!,w_1456,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff8c57790-42af-419d-b193-80ddf4a6fa25_725x521.png 1456w" sizes="auto, 100vw"><img src="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!J6UG!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff8c57790-42af-419d-b193-80ddf4a6fa25_725x521.png" width="601" height="431.89103448275864" data-attrs="{&quot;src&quot;:&quot;https://substack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/f8c57790-42af-419d-b193-80ddf4a6fa25_725x521.png&quot;,&quot;srcNoWatermark&quot;:null,&quot;fullscreen&quot;:null,&quot;imageSize&quot;:null,&quot;height&quot;:521,&quot;width&quot;:725,&quot;resizeWidth&quot;:601,&quot;bytes&quot;:null,&quot;alt&quot;:null,&quot;title&quot;:null,&quot;type&quot;:null,&quot;href&quot;:null,&quot;belowTheFold&quot;:true,&quot;topImage&quot;:false,&quot;internalRedirect&quot;:null,&quot;isProcessing&quot;:false,&quot;align&quot;:null,&quot;offset&quot;:false}" class="sizing-normal" alt="" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!J6UG!,w_424,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff8c57790-42af-419d-b193-80ddf4a6fa25_725x521.png 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!J6UG!,w_848,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff8c57790-42af-419d-b193-80ddf4a6fa25_725x521.png 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!J6UG!,w_1272,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff8c57790-42af-419d-b193-80ddf4a6fa25_725x521.png 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!J6UG!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Ff8c57790-42af-419d-b193-80ddf4a6fa25_725x521.png 1456w" sizes="auto, 100vw" loading="lazy"></picture><div class="image-link-expand"><div class="pencraft pc-display-flex pc-gap-8 pc-reset"><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container restack-image buttonBase-GK1x3M" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg aria-hidden="true" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 20 20" fill="none" stroke-width="1.5" stroke="var(--color-fg-primary)" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="icon-noB79L"><g><path d="M2.53001 7.81595C3.49179 4.73911 6.43281 2.5 9.91173 2.5C13.1684 2.5 15.9537 4.46214 17.0852 7.23684L17.6179 8.67647M17.6179 8.67647L18.5002 4.26471M17.6179 8.67647L13.6473 6.91176M17.4995 12.1841C16.5378 15.2609 13.5967 17.5 10.1178 17.5C6.86118 17.5 4.07589 15.5379 2.94432 12.7632L2.41165 11.3235M2.41165 11.3235L1.5293 15.7353M2.41165 11.3235L6.38224 13.0882"></path></g></svg></button><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container view-image buttonBase-GK1x3M" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="2" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" class="lucide lucide-maximize2 lucide-maximize-2 icon-noB79L"><polyline points="15 3 21 3 21 9"></polyline><polyline points="9 21 3 21 3 15"></polyline><line x1="21" x2="14" y1="3" y2="10"></line><line x1="3" x2="10" y1="21" y2="14"></line></svg></button></div></div></div></a></figure></div><p>In a follow-up question, we asked respondents what was the main reason for academia&#8217;s neglect of topics, this time offering a list of choices as well as a free response option. The top two reasons selected were that topics were viewed as &#8220;too controversial&#8221; (29%) and that they were &#8220;overlooked due to the intellectual focus of faculty&#8221; (29%), followed by being &#8220;viewed as old-fashioned/no longer relevant&#8221; (11%). Nearly a third of respondents (31%) wrote in answers such as &#8220;all of the above,&#8221; that the themes are seen as &#8220;un-progressive&#8221; (or, in the words of one respondent, &#8220;gross&#8221;), or that academia incentivizes conformity over intellectual risk-taking.</p><p>Among the 55 (29%) respondents who answered that the topic was seen as &#8220;too controversial,&#8221; we asked where they thought the ideological pressure was coming from. Respondents ranked ten possible sources of pressure, including students, the media, politicians, and other professors. Other professors were ranked among the top three sources of pressure by 74% of these respondents, followed by university administrators (45%), and professional associations (38%).</p><div class="captioned-image-container"><figure><a class="image-link image2 is-viewable-img" target="_blank" href="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!TZLm!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F48775c96-48e4-43ad-ba4f-7bcc78c0c8d9_2048x1280.png" data-component-name="Image2ToDOM"><div class="image2-inset"><picture><source type="image/webp" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!TZLm!,w_424,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F48775c96-48e4-43ad-ba4f-7bcc78c0c8d9_2048x1280.png 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!TZLm!,w_848,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F48775c96-48e4-43ad-ba4f-7bcc78c0c8d9_2048x1280.png 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!TZLm!,w_1272,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F48775c96-48e4-43ad-ba4f-7bcc78c0c8d9_2048x1280.png 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!TZLm!,w_1456,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F48775c96-48e4-43ad-ba4f-7bcc78c0c8d9_2048x1280.png 1456w" sizes="auto, 100vw"><img src="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!TZLm!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F48775c96-48e4-43ad-ba4f-7bcc78c0c8d9_2048x1280.png" width="600" height="375" data-attrs="{&quot;src&quot;:&quot;https://substack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/48775c96-48e4-43ad-ba4f-7bcc78c0c8d9_2048x1280.png&quot;,&quot;srcNoWatermark&quot;:null,&quot;fullscreen&quot;:null,&quot;imageSize&quot;:null,&quot;height&quot;:910,&quot;width&quot;:1456,&quot;resizeWidth&quot;:600,&quot;bytes&quot;:null,&quot;alt&quot;:null,&quot;title&quot;:null,&quot;type&quot;:null,&quot;href&quot;:null,&quot;belowTheFold&quot;:true,&quot;topImage&quot;:false,&quot;internalRedirect&quot;:null,&quot;isProcessing&quot;:false,&quot;align&quot;:null,&quot;offset&quot;:false}" class="sizing-normal" alt="" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!TZLm!,w_424,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F48775c96-48e4-43ad-ba4f-7bcc78c0c8d9_2048x1280.png 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!TZLm!,w_848,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F48775c96-48e4-43ad-ba4f-7bcc78c0c8d9_2048x1280.png 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!TZLm!,w_1272,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F48775c96-48e4-43ad-ba4f-7bcc78c0c8d9_2048x1280.png 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!TZLm!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F48775c96-48e4-43ad-ba4f-7bcc78c0c8d9_2048x1280.png 1456w" sizes="auto, 100vw" loading="lazy"></picture><div class="image-link-expand"><div class="pencraft pc-display-flex pc-gap-8 pc-reset"><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container restack-image buttonBase-GK1x3M" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg aria-hidden="true" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 20 20" fill="none" stroke-width="1.5" stroke="var(--color-fg-primary)" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="icon-noB79L"><g><path d="M2.53001 7.81595C3.49179 4.73911 6.43281 2.5 9.91173 2.5C13.1684 2.5 15.9537 4.46214 17.0852 7.23684L17.6179 8.67647M17.6179 8.67647L18.5002 4.26471M17.6179 8.67647L13.6473 6.91176M17.4995 12.1841C16.5378 15.2609 13.5967 17.5 10.1178 17.5C6.86118 17.5 4.07589 15.5379 2.94432 12.7632L2.41165 11.3235M2.41165 11.3235L1.5293 15.7353M2.41165 11.3235L6.38224 13.0882"></path></g></svg></button><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container view-image buttonBase-GK1x3M" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="2" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" class="lucide lucide-maximize2 lucide-maximize-2 icon-noB79L"><polyline points="15 3 21 3 21 9"></polyline><polyline points="9 21 3 21 3 15"></polyline><line x1="21" x2="14" y1="3" y2="10"></line><line x1="3" x2="10" y1="21" y2="14"></line></svg></button></div></div></div></a></figure></div><p>HxA members likely differ in meaningful ways from the general faculty population, making it difficult to draw definitive conclusions from these findings about what the broader professoriate thinks about these same questions. For instance, our sample was more <a href="https://heterodoxacademy.org/reports/how-politically-diverse-are-university-faculty/">politically diverse</a> than the general professoriate, with about half of respondents identifying themselves as politically moderate, 30% as conservative, and 20% as liberal. Our sample also skews more male than the general population.</p><p>As with much qualitative data analysis, there may be different ways to code or categorize the data. And while the survey size and parameters make it impossible to draw the broadest conclusions, these results point to a shared sense among at least some faculty that certain topics are unwelcome in their disciplines, particularly those topics involving contested issues and certain political perspectives.</p><p>While the survey falls well short of being an exhaustive list of missing scholarship, we hope that it will help prompt faculty to push worthy understudied topics toward the spotlight. As evidenced by the internal and external momentum for reform, the appetite for open inquiry is clearly growing &#8212; it just needs the right conditions to flourish.</p><p class="button-wrapper" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/topics-non-grata?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Share&quot;,&quot;action&quot;:null,&quot;class&quot;:null}" data-component-name="ButtonCreateButton"><a class="button primary" href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/topics-non-grata?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share"><span>Share</span></a></p><div><hr></div><div class="subscription-widget-wrap-editor" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/subscribe?&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Subscribe&quot;,&quot;language&quot;:&quot;en&quot;}" data-component-name="SubscribeWidgetToDOM"><div class="subscription-widget show-subscribe"><div class="preamble"><p class="cta-caption"><em>Free The Inquiry</em> brings you essays, expert commentary, and conversations about open inquiry in the academy. Subscribe to stay up to date.</p></div><form class="subscription-widget-subscribe"><input type="email" class="email-input" name="email" placeholder="Type your email&#8230;" tabindex="-1"><input type="submit" class="button primary" value="Subscribe"><div class="fake-input-wrapper"><div class="fake-input"></div><div class="fake-button"></div></div></form></div></div><p></p>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Tom Ginsburg and John Wilson on Institutional Neutrality]]></title><description><![CDATA[A University of Chicago law professor and an AAUP blog editor agree that neutrality should restrain administrators, and split over departments, expertise, and the pressure on universities right now.]]></description><link>https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/tom-ginsburg-and-john-wilson-on-institutional</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/tom-ginsburg-and-john-wilson-on-institutional</guid><pubDate>Thu, 22 Oct 2026 12:01:56 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://api.substack.com/feed/podcast/221516636/d517247ea0b26517b83c6fe09dcf1359.mp3" length="0" type="audio/mpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Does a university protect free speech by staying neutral, or silence it? In this Heterodox Conversation at Indiana University&#8211;Bloomington, Tom Ginsburg of the University of Chicago and John Wilson, co-editor of the American Association of University Professors&#8217; </em>Academe Blog<em>, take up the question. Ginsburg opens with what academic freedom means, from nineteenth-century Germany to the AAUP in 1915 and the University of Chicago&#8217;s 1967 Kalven Report, and argues that a university should be a home for critics, not a critic itself. Wilson says he is there to praise institutional neutrality, then pushes back on how it is usually understood, from an 1894 Wisconsin statement to Indiana University&#8217;s own neutrality policy.</em></p><p><em>The two agree on more than you might expect: neutrality is there to hold back administrators, not to silence faculty or students. They split on whether it should reach academic departments, on whether professors should hold back outside their expertise, and on how to read the pressure on universities now. More than half the event is audience questions from students, faculty and a retired professor, on divestment, departmental statements, state pressure on Indiana, faculty email, the Johnson Amendment and student protest. A transcript of the conversation follows below.</em></p><div><hr></div><p><strong>Tom Ginsburg:</strong> Well, thank you all so much for having us here. These are really important topics, and in my experience, they&#8217;re not very well understood. The term institutional neutrality, what does that mean? Academic freedom. I can tell you, many of you look like your students, but if you were to ask your professors, most of them have no idea what academic freedom is. It&#8217;s something that people only turn to when they are aggrieved, when something is, you know, when their academic freedom is threatened, and then even then it&#8217;s not well understood. So I think it&#8217;s really important to talk about these things, and what I want to do first in the first couple minutes is just get those terms clear.</p><p>So academic freedom in the Western tradition, and we are of course only one intellectual tradition, is usually associated with a German thinker, Wilhelm von Humboldt, from the early 20th century, 19th century, when he set up the Humboldtian University, as we say. And he said that everyone needed freedom to learn and freedom to teach. There were two components. The teacher should be free to organize the class as they wanted to, and they had the freedom to learn, but that also implies, by the way, that students might have some academic freedom interest, freedom to learn somehow.</p><p>As it came forward when the German research university was copied here in the United States, including at the University of Chicago, the idea was crystallized in 1915 by the American Association of University Professors, which John has some relation. And they basically said it was three things: freedom of research, freedom of teaching, and this is an interesting addition, condition, freedom of extramural utterance, by which they mean what we would call free speech. And that they did that because the ideas of free speech that we all hold so dear in this country were still very nascent at that time. The first Supreme Court cases upholding freedom of speech didn&#8217;t come until after that point.</p><p>And so they said, you know, the professor should be able to speak out about issues that they want to, issues of the day, and not suffer academic consequences. So if, as happened at the University of Chicago in the 1890s, a proto-socialist professor said, you know, socialism is the best thing and capitalism is bad. And, you know, when he did that, there was pressure from donors to come: well, what are you doing? You&#8217;re teaching godless communism. You have to fire that guy. And the theory of extramural utterances is such a professor cannot suffer an academic punishment for that. You can&#8217;t be fired. You can&#8217;t be removed from your classes. You get to say what you come to in the pursuit of knowledge as best you see it.</p><p>And that turns out to mean that we do have a lot of freedom, academic freedom, freedom to research and teach as we want, but it&#8217;s bounded by collectivity. So it&#8217;s somewhat of&#8212;this is why it&#8217;s so complicated. It&#8217;s a little bit of an individual right. I have a right against my dean from firing me if I say something, or if I&#8217;m teaching law in a way he doesn&#8217;t want me to. However, it&#8217;s also a collective right. My freedom is bounded by academic disciplines. So my example here is, I can teach constitutional law however I want, but if I went into my class and said I&#8217;m teaching the laws of physics every day, I would be fired. I could be fired, because that&#8217;s not the subject I was hired to teach. So it&#8217;s not a matter of academic freedom. In that case, the university, by firing me, is actually defending academic freedom. The university can be sometimes acting to defend academic freedom by preserving the collectivity, the right of the discipline, if you are, the power of the discipline to bound knowledge.</p><p>There&#8217;s also an important collective right, which is very relevant here, vis-&#224;-vis politicians. From time immemorial, universities have faced external constraints: the church, politicians, others who say you shouldn&#8217;t do this, we want to regulate what you do. And in that case, the university has the duty of protecting academic freedom from such interference. So you can see it&#8217;s kind of a complicated idea.</p><p>Now, institutional neutrality. Let me get that on the table. It is typically associated with something called the Kalven Report at the University of Chicago, which was adopted in 1967. I think it&#8217;s a really great report, but it&#8217;s contested, as we&#8217;ll see. And what did that report say? Well, first of all, what brought it to life was that there was pressure from students to divest from the war machine in the Vietnam War: this is immoral, we have to remove the university funding from this. And so what the university president did is he appointed a committee, and the committee of faculty members. So that&#8217;s an important point. This was adopted by faculty. This wasn&#8217;t some top-down legislated imposition. The faculty kind of got together, looked at our own traditions at our university, and discovered that we had a long tradition of what we would call institutional neutrality. And they used that term.</p><p>The university itself is not the critic. It is a&#8212;the instrument of dissent and criticism is the individual faculty member. The university is the home and sponsor of critics. It is not itself the critic. So it&#8217;s sort of a conception of the university not taking positions on issues of the day, precisely so that every member of the university community can say whatever they want without being chilled by the idea of the center adopting an orthodoxy.</p><p>And it turns out that goes back actually to almost the founding of the University of Chicago. The incident I was referring to, with the proto-socialist professor saying, you know, we should all be socialists, and the donor saying, no, no, no, you got to fire that guy. The university president, William Rainey Harper, said, no, the institution&#8212;when the individual faculty member speaks, they speak for themselves. The institution does not take positions on the issues of the day. And that&#8217;s from the early 20th century or late 19th century he said that. So that&#8217;s kind of a conception of the university as just a very thin administrative apparatus. Its only role is to be a place where you get a lot of smart people to debate and discuss.</p><p>Now, are there any exceptions? Yes. And this is really important, and this is why I think it&#8217;s absolutely clear from my point of view that institutional neutrality both is very important for free speech on campus, but also is really important for academic freedom. What are those exceptions? Well, the most important one, and again, I&#8217;ll quote the Kalven Report here, is that from time to time, instances will arise in which the society, or segments of it, threaten the very mission of the university and its values of free inquiry. In such a crisis, it becomes the obligation of the university as an institution to oppose such measures and actively to defend its interests and values.</p><p>Okay, so that&#8217;s the main exception which is relevant here. In other words, the university is a very thin apparatus. Individuals debate things however they want. Any question that presents itself, they should be free to debate. But if we are threatened with an attack on the university itself or the free inquiry itself, a law, for example, that was trying to prohibit what you could say in a classroom, well, then it&#8217;s not just optional that the universities speak; it must speak. And that&#8217;s part of institutional neutrality too. Maybe the most important word here is institutional. We&#8217;re defending the institution of higher learning, of exchange, but we are not itself, as a university administration, taking positions on issues of the day.</p><p>Now, why is this important? Obviously, it&#8217;s important for ensuring free speech, because otherwise, imagine the alternative world, which is what we&#8217;ve been living in for about the last decade and a half, where university presidents see themselves as moral leaders who get to speak out on whatever issue they feel enough political pressure from inside the community to speak out about. What does that do when, for example, Harvard&#8217;s president, Larry Bacow, flies the Ukrainian flag when Ukraine was invaded? Now, I&#8217;m as pro-Ukraine as anybody, but what does it mean when the university&#8212;who elected him to tell us that there&#8217;s one right answer here in this conflict? When a president does that, it sort of discourages the incentive for each individual to go and apply. And by the way, if there&#8217;s some Russians on campus, they might feel pretty uncomfortable. They might start to hide their Russian identity, things like that.</p><p>It&#8217;s even worse, and this is a really important point. I think a lot of people now agree that the university president should keep their mouth shut about things that don&#8217;t affect the university. But what about departments? And here we get into somewhat of a battle, in my view. Many disciplines, which, remember, have a really critical role for ensuring academic freedom because they bound what you can say&#8212;what is law professor? What is anthropology? What&#8217;s not? Many disciplines have themselves become political entities in recent years, and they feel the need to speak out about all kinds of things.</p><p>And I don&#8217;t know if there&#8217;s any anthropologists in the room. Ethnography is a super important method, but boy, the American Anthropological Association has been ground zero for a lot of really silly stuff, all kinds of foreign policy statements: we, the anthropologists, condemn X and Y. Departments do this too. Oh, you guys are anthropologists? Oh, okay. I thought you were&#8212;I thought you were like, yes. You were either objecting or what. That&#8217;s great. So, and I won&#8217;t belabor the point, but it&#8217;s pretty embarrassing if you delve into that, what the association&#8212;not the actual anthropology as a field, not the scholars, but the association, the disciplinary association&#8212;is doing in terms of pronouncing orthodoxies.</p><p>Departments. There&#8217;s a question that arises in these discussions. Does institutional neutrality apply just to the university administration, or does it also apply to departments? And in my view, it&#8217;s more important that it apply to departments than the university president. Consider yourself a member of, let&#8217;s say, the Asian American Studies Department at Northwestern University, which, after the October 7 attack, announced that this was all the Israelis&#8217; fault and got some factual errors in their statement, while also stating that they stood with a certain race of students and not others. That&#8217;s what they said.</p><p>Now, imagine you&#8217;re a graduate student in this department, Asian American Studies, as I said, who knows nothing about this conflict. What is your incentive to actually inquire and learn about what&#8217;s going on in the news? Not very much. And if you do inquire and you disagree with what the departmental leaders have voted on by majority vote, well, you&#8217;re going to keep your mouth shut. And so in a way, what that does is it sort of pre-decides issues for the most vulnerable members of the community, the graduate students who need the stipend, the junior faculty who need to get tenure.</p><p>So departments&#8212;it&#8217;s very important to me that departments not speak out about things that they don&#8217;t know about. And one of the problems with disciplines these days is you have some disciplines which have very expansive and capacious claims about their expertise. We are experts in power, says anthropology; we can talk about basically anything. That&#8217;s a problem. The disciplines need to be very humble about these things. And I think it&#8217;s very important that we remember that learning really happens at the level of the individual and the group, and scholars talking together and debating multiple positions. The idea that you would have sort of orthodoxies pronounced by university leaders has been a real mistake.</p><p>And I&#8217;m going to say one last thing, if I have a second. Now, institutional neutrality, which is kind of this University of Chicago thing&#8212;I sometimes call myself a Calvinist preacher. I really like the Kalven Report. But it&#8217;s spread all around the country, I think including Indiana University. And one of my problems is actually, I think a lot of places are adopting it, but without the sort of sense of the deep cultural structures which are necessary to make it work. And so it&#8217;s possible that these principles can be misused, in which case I would answer the question negatively. Institutional neutrality as misused, if it&#8217;s used to silence the individual student or the individual faculty member, that&#8217;s then bad for free speech and academic freedom.</p><p>But in the Kalven framework, I think it&#8217;s an unequivocal good, and it rests on this kind of commitment of every member of the university community to a few sort of basic ideas, the core of one of which is: I think this, but I might be wrong. And if I&#8217;m wrong, I need to learn from other people. And that just basic thing has been lost in many universities around the country. Thank you very much.</p><p><strong>John Wilson:</strong> I wanna thank you all for having me here, BridgeUSA and Heterodox Academy. I want to thank Tom for doing all the heavy lifting of trying to describe some of these concepts that are very complicated. I do want to mention, on the issue of free speech in particular, earlier today, the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education, FIRE, released its annual free speech rankings. And Indiana University, which last year was ranked 255 out of 257, the third-worst university in the country, has now dramatically increased its ranking to 256 out of 261. You are now the sixth-worst university. Congratulations. The tiniest possible steps really was all the other universities somehow managing to be worse than Indiana.</p><p>And I should mention that I wrote a guest column this week in the Indiana Daily Student about the enormous attacks on free speech by the administration at Indiana in the past few years, from censoring art to firing&#8212;trying to censor the student newspaper, firing faculty for having a chart in their class about white supremacy&#8212;all of these things that are really terrible restrictions. And one of the things I also want to&#8212;and so I urge you to go to the Indiana Daily Student, or to my Substack, John K. Wilson, to read that. But I want to talk specifically about some of the dangers involved with the institutional neutrality policy at Indiana University, which I think is particularly terrible.</p><p>But I do want to begin by noting that I&#8217;m not here to bury institutional neutrality. I&#8217;m here to praise it. And so there may be people in the room, I hope there are, in the Q&amp;A, who morally are opposed to institutional neutrality. I&#8217;m not one of them. I support the concept. But I want to deeply challenge the way that it is commonly understood, including the way Tom understands it.</p><p>And to do that, I want to go back, like Tom did, a little bit to the history, to what I see as the origins of institutional neutrality, which is one of these cases from the 1890s when universities were firing economics professors for being too left-wing. There was a case at the University of Wisconsin in 1894, when a professor named Richard Ely, economics professor, was accused of supporting labor strikes and boycotts and socialism by a state official. And so the Board of Regents at the University of Wisconsin investigated. They found that he hadn&#8217;t actually done anything wrong. He was falsely accused of these things. But rather than just dismiss the case, they issued this extraordinary statement. I&#8217;m just going to read you the primary paragraph of it. Quote: &#8220;As regents of a university with over a hundred instructors supported by nearly two millions of people who hold a vast diversity of views regarding the great questions which at present agitate the human mind, we could not for a moment think of recommending the dismissal or even the criticism of a teacher even if some of his opinions should, in some quarters, be regarded as visionary.&#8221; End quote.</p><p>And to me, this is really the first statement by a university about institutional neutrality, about academic freedom, even though it doesn&#8217;t use those terms. It says the university, because we have all these diverse viewpoints that the state represents, we can&#8217;t take a stand on these politics. In particular, we can&#8217;t take a stand by firing professors who are deemed to have controversial views. In fact, we can&#8217;t even criticize them. We have to stay silent and neutral on these matters and allow people to freely express these views. And this is really an extraordinary kind of statement for the time. It&#8217;s extraordinary even today. I don&#8217;t think anybody&#8217;s ever come up with a better statement than this.</p><p>Now, 73 years down the road, you had the Kalven Report at the University of Chicago in 1967, which in my view sort of extends this principle, and it says, well, if you&#8217;re not supposed to fire professors for their views or denounce them for their views, maybe you shouldn&#8217;t affirmatively express some political views by the university, because that might have the effect of making professors who disagree feel silenced, feel like they don&#8217;t have the right to disagree, feel like they might be punished for disagreeing with what the university says. And even though I regard this kind of statement neutrality as very much the lesser part of institutional neutrality&#8212;the true lesser neutrality is you don&#8217;t fire professors for their political views. You don&#8217;t denounce students or professors because of their political views. The whole idea of raising a flag is something, frankly, I don&#8217;t care much about, and I don&#8217;t see as particularly important compared to those kinds of things.</p><p>Now, when universities abuse institutional neutrality to try and silence faculty, staff, and students and compel them to be neutral, they&#8217;re actually violating what institutional neutrality really means. They&#8217;re trying to impose a political perspective by imposing neutrality. And this is the case with the Board of Trustees at Indiana University and the institutional neutrality policy they adopted in 2024 in response to the State Act 202. And I should note, I think the Board of Trustees really needs to rewrite this entire institutional neutrality&#8212;first of all, because it has a spelling mistake, and someone needs to tell the trustees that when you use &#8220;its&#8221; as a possessive, it is not a contraction and you don&#8217;t put an apostrophe in it. So for that reason alone, there needs to be a rewrite of the institutional neutrality policy.</p><p>But there are the deeper, I think, political flaws in this kind of policy. One of the things is, it doesn&#8217;t actually talk about the institution being neutral. The policy actually says that, well, the Indiana University gets to say what it wants to its students and to the public, as long as it&#8217;s not breaking the law, which, of course, no university is doing that by saying&#8212;expressing its opinions. The sole focus of the institutional neutrality policy is not on the institution. It&#8217;s on the university community members, which includes faculty, staff, alumni, volunteers, and yes, you students. You are part of the problem, according to this policy, and you need to have neutrality imposed on you.</p><p>And so one really terrible aspect of this policy is that these kind of limits are placed on university community members. And the policy says that all of you, quote, &#8220;should assume that they are representing the university when they conduct official and assigned functions, responsibilities, and duties, including but not limited to communicating in university contexts, using university email accounts, websites, social media channels, public fora, and related channels of communication.&#8221; So this is really dangerous: the idea that anybody who&#8217;s teaching a class, anybody who&#8217;s speaking in a public forum or using a university email account, is automatically presumed to be speaking for the university unless they go through some incredible verbal gymnastics of proving that they&#8217;re not speaking for the university.</p><p>And so these kind of things&#8212;and the university actually says you need to use disclaimers. You need to say you&#8217;re not speaking for the university. And this is a problem also I see with the university&#8217;s free speech website, which I encourage you to go to and read, which includes an FAQ about institutional neutrality. And one of the things that it says in there, and I&#8217;ll read it for you&#8212;quote, if the faculty&#8212;it says, can faculty talk about their work? And it says, quote, &#8220;If the faculty member is expressing their personal views on a social, political, or moral issue, they should identify themselves as an individual.&#8221; End quote.</p><p>And this makes me wonder, maybe we could all get together and think of a way that we could all identify ourselves as individuals. I&#8217;m just spitballing ideas here, but what if we each had personal names and personal email accounts that when you&#8212;or if we were individual people, like me&#8212;so that when you saw a person or read their name or got an email from them, you would know they were an individual and not the university. For example, my name is John Wilson. I am not a university. In particular, I&#8217;m not Indiana University. But that&#8217;s true of everybody here.</p><p>There is also, you know&#8212;I think it&#8217;s even clearer when you&#8217;re up here speaking. For example, some of you might think, hey, is that Indiana University up there at the podium speaking? What a handsome and brilliant university we have. No, you&#8217;re thinking, who is this schlub giving his personal opinions up here? Because you, unlike the trustees, can distinguish between an individual and the institution.</p><p>Now, what are the dangers of this disclaimer, beyond the fact that it&#8217;s ridiculous, in my view, and a complete waste of everybody&#8217;s time to go around saying my ideas are my own, my ideas are your own? Of course your ideas are your own. How could it be any other way? Why would you need to issue disclaimers to say that? But these institutional kind of neutrality policies and requirements of disclaimers actually can get enforced in really terrible ways. There&#8217;s a case in 2021 at Collin College, a public college in Texas, where an education professor was fired because she had signed an open letter calling for the removal of Confederate monuments. And because she signed her name with her institutional affiliation of Collin College, they said, you&#8217;re trying to speak for the university, and therefore we&#8217;re going to fire you. So there are some incredible abuses that come about from badly done institutional neutrality policies.</p><p>So what&#8217;s the alternative? What else could Indiana University do in replacing its spelling-mistake-prone policy about institutional neutrality? Well, one of the things it could do is adopt what Purdue University did, which is to adopt the Kalven Report, which in my view is much, much better than what Indiana University has come up with. One of the reasons is, I think the Kalven Report has a lot of very good aspects to it that need to be recognized.</p><p>One is that the Kalven Report is not enforced by anyone. It doesn&#8217;t have an enforcement mechanism. It provides no pathway for people to use it to censor. It says, we persuade people. We have a heavy presumption against the institution speaking. It is an effort to persuade the administration not to speak out on this. In my view, in that sense, it&#8217;s not a tool to censor departments, as the University of Chicago has used it to censor websites, ban land acknowledgments, and all of these other things that are not actually, in my view, part of the Kalven Report. The Kalven Report also says that a faculty committee should oversee and interpret what institutional neutrality means, that it shouldn&#8217;t just be the administration dictating institutional neutrality to all of us. So I think that&#8217;s a great thing that Indiana University should do. There&#8217;s also a provision in Ball State University&#8217;s institutional neutrality policy which says that individuals are free to express themselves and identify as members of the institution. It just simply takes care of the whole problem. You don&#8217;t have to issue disclaimers. You don&#8217;t have to worry about who you&#8217;re speaking for, because you don&#8217;t speak for anyone except yourself.</p><p>Now, so why then do I support&#8212;and I want to bash neutrality a lot here. As a concept, I think neutrality is a scam. Objectivity doesn&#8217;t exist. This kind of whole idea that the university should be neutral is a fiction and a farce, but it&#8217;s a useful fiction. In particular, it&#8217;s useful because we live under the reign of corporate universities, where the president is the head of this hierarchy that has enormous power over us. And so to me, the question is, why would you want a university president, an overpaid professional fundraiser typically hired by a group of corporate executives and political hacks, to speak for you, to take away your voice and replace it with his own? Why do you imagine that our dear leader will be a better advocate of your values than your own? Why do you want to sort of give up that voice?</p><p>And maybe if we had truly democratic universities, there would be an argument for getting rid of institutional neutrality and expressing views. But until we do, I think institutional neutrality as a restraint on the central administration, and not when it&#8217;s abused as a tool of censorship&#8212;I think that kind of institutional neutrality is a valuable thing. Rather than turning to our corporate leaders, our presidents, to be our moral and intellectual guides, I think we should all speak for ourselves and listen to each other. And I hope we&#8217;ll do that today. Thank you.</p><p><strong>Organizer:</strong> All right, we are now having time for Q&amp;A. So if you would like to ask a question, or you have something for discussion, please raise your hand, and we&#8217;ll come to you with the mic.</p><p><strong>Audience Member:</strong> So you said that the original&#8212;</p><p><strong>Organizer:</strong> Can you introduce yourself?</p><p><strong>Audience Member:</strong> My name&#8217;s Connor. I&#8217;m a student at Maurer, the law school. You talked about the original emphasis for the Kalven Report was student protests involving investments that ended up funding the Vietnam War. I&#8217;m wondering, then, if you consider investments that fund highly contested causes to fall within this scope of institutional neutrality. I think of examples like apartheid South Africa that were a big deal, where it&#8217;s like, does investment funding fit within that neutrality standard?</p><p><strong>Tom Ginsburg:</strong> Thank you. That&#8217;s a great question. So I actually think investments are really distinct context, in which most of the logic I was giving doesn&#8217;t actually apply. There&#8217;s no neutral investment policy. You&#8217;re in Coke or Pepsi. You&#8217;re in X or Y, you know. So there&#8217;s&#8212;but then there&#8217;s the question of how pragmatically we go about doing it. Do we hire a bunch of professionals to maximize returns, which arguably nonprofit law might require, or do we use our investment policy to make statements about the world? And as you pointed out, there&#8217;s a lot of examples of movements that do so.</p><p>And I will say that if I&#8217;m a graduate student in East Asian studies and the university divests from fossil fuels or South Africa, that doesn&#8217;t really affect my incentive to inquire in the way that it would if my department issued an orthodoxy. So I think it&#8217;s quite a distinct context. I myself generally oppose divestment movements, for the following reason: I don&#8217;t want to spend all my time arguing with my colleagues about what our investment policy should be. If you want a politicized investment policy, you can choose. You can have higher tuition or lower salaries, or maybe both. But that&#8217;s just my personal view. And if the powers that be in the university came up with a different scheme, I wouldn&#8217;t really have a strong basis to criticize it, as I do for the other things, the statements.</p><p><strong>John Wilson:</strong> I would say I also&#8212;along with Tom, I opposed divestment of any kind. But I don&#8217;t think it&#8217;s political to do&#8212;and it&#8217;s all&#8212;divestment policy and all investment policies are political. You&#8217;re not more political if you support divestment. Just because I disagree with you doesn&#8217;t make you political and me neutral. It&#8217;s all a choice that we make for various reasons. The important thing about the Kalven Report is it does have these very broad exceptions for the corporate activities of the university, the things that the university does that it has to take responsibility for, that it has to, in some sense, take a stand.</p><p>And so, for me, what&#8212;and it&#8217;s important to note, in the history of the Kalven Report, what actually was at stake at the University of Chicago were called the rank protests. These were where the Selective Service was demanding that all universities rank their students so they could make the lower half of the ranked students take a test in order to avoid being drafted in Vietnam. And so there were protests, because the University of Chicago did not rank its students. And so the protesters were not demanding divestment from the war. They were saying, just keep the policy the way it is and don&#8217;t serve the war machine by ranking students. And the university wanted to help serve the war machine, arguably take a stand, change its policies in order to do that, which it eventually did. And so the idea that the university was neutral and the protesters weren&#8217;t is actually the reverse of, in some ways, the way it really was.</p><p>These are all positions. And so in any kind of&#8212;all these disputes, these arguments about, for example, the universities making statements after George Floyd&#8212;in my view, that&#8217;s a perfect example of where the Kalven Report has a clear exception that allows for university statements. If you want to make a statement about police violence and racism, well, that kind of makes sense, because if you look at the universities, they actually have armed police forces. And so it&#8217;s completely relevant to their corporate activities that you would discuss police violence, for an institution that has an armed police force. And an institution that has an anti-discrimination policy against racism is perfectly entitled to talk about racism as a larger issue, in my view.</p><p>So the Kalven Report doesn&#8217;t solve these problems. It really opens them up, as to the question of what is really appropriate for the university. And that&#8217;s why the Kalven Report needs&#8212;institutional neutrality needs to be something that is not imposed on universities, that is in particular not imposed on departments or programs, because it is so ambiguous. You need to let people&#8212;even if you believe in this heavy presumption against making statements, which I share, you still need to let individuals, individual departments, individual universities, individual circumstances determine when you make those kind of statements.</p><p><strong>Audience Member:</strong> Hello. My name is Michaela Wolfork. I&#8217;m from Detroit, Michigan, and I&#8217;m a law and policy major. My question is especially with Professor Wilson. You said that, why do we give our voice away, especially when it comes to neutrality? So my question is, what advice do you give to students who are at institutions where students aren&#8217;t being represented by their institution administration&#8212;yeah&#8212;along with administration who aren&#8217;t chosen by the students? How do we get them to act when the students do not want neutrality?</p><p><strong>John Wilson:</strong> Well, I think that, first of all, I&#8217;m not a professor. No university is obviously going to hire a crackpot like me, or a visionary like me, to discuss these things. But I think that what students can do is make their voices heard. You can write for the student newspaper. You can hold events. You can speak out. You can hold protests. You can do all these different kinds of things to communicate with other people without making it a demand of the university, that we demand the university to speak for us. You can speak for yourself. You can have these student organizations and individual students expressing these ideas, communicating through groups like BridgeUSA to debate and argue some of these ideas. And I think that&#8217;s the most important thing. It&#8217;s not necessarily the idea that we need someone to decide this for us, what a statement is going to be for all of us to agree with. It&#8217;s that we need to continue having the conversation and having the argument. And that&#8217;s the danger of university statements, is that they can tend to squelch that.</p><p>Now, there&#8217;s also a danger on the other side, which the dean mentioned in the introduction, that sometimes silence can be a form of repression as well. If the university says, we never speak on these things, that can send a message to everyone else: you&#8217;re not supposed to take political stands, and you&#8217;re not supposed to speak. So what we need to do is we need to understand that the purpose of institutional neutrality is not to make the university more neutral. It is to allow everyone else at the university to not be neutral, to express their ideas.</p><p><strong>Tom Ginsburg:</strong> Can I just add one little point, which is, it&#8217;s an orthodox idea of academic freedom that academic decisions have to be made by academics. In other words, a political appointee at the center who happens to be running the place can&#8217;t decide, and shouldn&#8217;t really decide, who&#8217;s going to be hired and fired on the basis of their scholarly work. Academia is a profession, and indeed, these ideas we&#8217;re talking about emerged at the same time as many of the American professions emerged as well: medicine and law and such, accounting. Academics were self-judging because we had expertise. Now, the modern university has, as was referred to, has become a very big corporate thing. And it&#8217;s interesting that most of the governance systems reflect basically boards of trustees who are technically the sort of responsible for the direction, and often picking the leaders without much input, even from the professors, much less the students. So I think there&#8217;s better and worse ways to run these processes, but the core idea is that you have to have academics&#8212;you have to have the ideas, the people who produce the ideas, represented.</p><p>The other point I want to make is that academia, if you think about it, is not something that&#8212;we don&#8217;t decide which ideas are correct by majority vote. We don&#8217;t. We don&#8217;t want to have a vote about, you know, I don&#8217;t know, what&#8217;s a controversial idea, you know, is climate change real or something. It&#8217;s important to preserve the ability of dissident scientists in every field, because sometimes those dissidents turn out to be right. An environment of very open communication is what has allowed some major discoveries to happen. And so we have to tolerate the dissident, if you will. And so you can&#8217;t be thinking of the university like a democracy, but it certainly needs input from those who are stakeholders, if I could use the term.</p><p><strong>Audience Member:</strong> I&#8217;m from West Lafayette. I intend to study public policy analysis next year. I&#8217;m currently a business student. Professor Ginsburg, earlier you mentioned this point where the Harvard president raised the flag of Ukraine during the Russian invasion of the country. Would you say the same thing&#8212;would you say that would be also wrong if it was for the raising of the Polish flag during the Nazi invasion of Poland? My question is essentially, where does the line for this neutrality actually get drawn? This is the question that can be extended to Professor Wilson as well.</p><p><strong>Tom Ginsburg:</strong> Yeah, I sometimes get the question, you&#8217;re like, well, shouldn&#8217;t the University of Chicago issued a statement about the Holocaust? And my answer is no. What does a statement do? You think&#8212;let&#8217;s take Netanyahu. You think that Benjamin Netanyahu reads a condemnation from some department somewhere, said, oh my God, you know, now the anthropologists have told me I&#8217;m wrong, I&#8217;m going to change my mind? We need to&#8212;universities need to act in ways that are serious. And what we happened to do at the University of Chicago during the Nazi regime is open up our campus to scholars who were fleeing Nazi Germany. And that&#8217;s important. That&#8217;s an action, which, by the way, many of the big, East Coast, important universities didn&#8217;t do. We did that because that was consistent with the values.</p><p>Now, I think your question raises a really important point: the word neutrality. It&#8217;s very triggering now for a lot of people. There&#8217;s no neutrality. You know, everyone has read their Foucault, and we&#8217;re really suspicious of that term. And so I guess&#8212;I&#8217;m actually thinking a lot about that, because I think, you know, we&#8217;re not neutral in our actions. We&#8217;re pursuing knowledge, and we can&#8217;t be neutral about that. We need to protect our values and such. We have values. I&#8217;m now actually experimenting with another term, which I think might be better than institutional neutrality. And the one I&#8217;m using, and you guys are the first to hear it, is impartiality. That is, the university should be impartial with regard to external things that don&#8217;t affect it.</p><p>You wouldn&#8217;t want a judge in a case to be flying the Ukrainian flag in the courtroom, right? And you want the judge to be neutral as among the parties, who then present evidence, and the best evidence wins. And that&#8217;s kind of like what a university is. We already have values of impartiality in many of our processes. A tenure process is to be decided on the basis of the academic merit, not on external considerations, not on, you know, your politics or something like that. And so I think it&#8217;s maybe a better way of getting what we&#8217;re doing. What we&#8217;re really talking about is institutional statements. And so no, I don&#8217;t think we should have flown the flag or issued a statement when Poland was invaded in 1939.</p><p><strong>John Wilson:</strong> Yeah, I sort of like that idea of impartiality. I&#8217;m&#8212;again, I think neutrality is not a great thing, but there are things that you can sort of come close to in terms of neutrality. The concepts of academic freedom and these things can approximate a kind of neutrality. You&#8217;re never going to achieve a perfect neutrality in assessing, but it is the idea that the university lets all of these ideas be expressed and doesn&#8217;t take a stand by trying to suppress those views. So that&#8217;s a kind of neutrality. Where it becomes dangerous is when it then becomes used as, well, nobody&#8217;s allowed to take positions, should be taking positions about anything; nobody should be expressing views. The point again, as I said, of neutrality as an institution is to try and protect these structures. I wish everybody was focused more on not firing faculty rather than not flying flags. But I hope that people can move on to that and understand that&#8217;s the essence of what institutional neutrality should be: that it&#8217;s liberating us to express our ideas.</p><p><strong>Audience Member:</strong> So, yeah, my name is John Summerlot. I work here at the university, adjunct faculty member. I&#8217;m also one of the university historians, which would be apparent here in a second. So in 1861, when South Carolina seceded, the South Carolina secession flag flew over the university campus that morning. And the president ripped it down, and the faculty marched downtown. They burned the flag, and they denounced secession, taking what was probably the first political stance of the university, in 1861.</p><p>So that being said, moving forward: I came in the early 2000s. There was a lot of anti-military sentiment on campus. On a weekly basis, there was an anti-military, anti-war march that occurred through campus. We had deans and departments all the way up to the provost sending out messages saying that we understand the military is not welcome on campus as recruiters, or the ROTC program, which we also had on campus, but we have to let them because of federal funding. The university remained neutral. President, Board of Trustees took no stance on this. But across campus, including the department I worked in as a veteran, having recently come out of the military, they said, military and veterans aren&#8217;t welcome here, because we know how you feel about LGBTQ people because of Don&#8217;t Ask, Don&#8217;t Tell&#8212;which was a pretty broad assumption on who I was.</p><p>So, but anyway, listening to what you&#8217;re saying, I understand the idea that the institution not having an opinion is one thing. When groups of faculty, when groups of students get together through their own free associations, as a student organization, as a student body, as a department, and the tyranny of the majority kicks in, and they say, we don&#8217;t want these people in our department anymore, we don&#8217;t want these people in our school, we have an opinion about these people&#8212;how, to each of you, does that differ from your individual right as a faculty member or student to say, I have this opinion, versus, we have collectively voted as a department or an organization to say we don&#8217;t want these people in our organization?</p><p><strong>Tom Ginsburg:</strong> Yeah, I think the basic principle is the university keeps its mouth shut. Individuals and groups get to contest things. And there will be many illiberal groups in a pluralist society. And so you can&#8217;t help a group of students who are intolerant and even coming together. The question I sometimes get is just about statements. What if all the faculty members of the Department of X sign a statement and then put it up? Is that different than the department putting it up? And I do think that formal distinction does matter, because when the formal department puts it up, then you really are endorsing it as an institution, whereas if every faculty member does, not so. You know, the method&#8212;the remedy for what you&#8217;re talking about is really counterspeech and organizing, in your case groups of veterans, perhaps, that say, no, you guys are treating us unfairly and unjustly.</p><p>I will add one other thing here, which is, all of academic freedom and free speech and all the stuff we talk about is constrained, of course, by Title VI and by anti-discrimination law. And the courts have set a very high bar there. You really have to show a persistent and pervasive kind of harassment in order to meet a test for holding the university liable for such a thing. But the kind of ordinary give-and-take, if you will, that you describe, I think, is part of life in a plural society, unfortunately. We should all be tolerant, of course.</p><p><strong>John Wilson:</strong> Now, I would say that I think there&#8217;s some important distinctions to be made between what is a person&#8217;s opinion&#8212;people can have anti-military opinion. What happens if they use their power to enforce their opinion in a way that violates the rights of others? For example, a professor saying, I don&#8217;t allow military cadets in my class to take my classes; I&#8217;m going to give them a failing grade if they wear an ROTC uniform to class. These kinds of things are illegitimate, in the sense that they&#8217;re taking what might be your personal opinion as a professor and they&#8217;re intruding it into your professional work. And that would be kind of the distinction that&#8217;s made.</p><p>The question is, are statements and that kind of thing a part of the professional work? And I don&#8217;t think so, particularly because in this case, I think people were generally objecting to the discriminatory aspects of recruiting, and not to the fact that there are military on campus. Then maybe there are some people who object to that, but I think those were&#8212;at least what I know of the protests against Don&#8217;t Ask, Don&#8217;t Tell in the 1990s, they were about discrimination by the military and the university&#8217;s obligation to not allow discrimination on campus, rather than being forms of discrimination against the military by departments. In that&#8212;now, you can have dangerous elements where sometimes that can extend over. That&#8217;s true of whether it&#8217;s anti-military speech or speech about Israel or all these other things, where people can express their views strongly, even views that are hostile or even hate speech in some ways, as long as they&#8217;re not implementing those views in a way that discriminates against people in their educational activities.</p><p><strong>Audience Member:</strong> Hi, my name is Heather Reynolds. I&#8217;m in the Department of Biology, and thank you for this conversation. It&#8217;s very productive and helpful. My question is, I&#8217;ve been trying to figure out where you two disagree, if at all, because it seems like there&#8217;s a lot of overlap, productive overlap, between you. And&#8212;but I&#8217;m wondering if a place you might disagree is in the area of boundedness. Whereas, if I&#8217;m hearing you right, John might say a faculty should be able to say whatever they want, whereas Tom might say, no, your expressions need to be bounded by your expertise. So regardless of whether you&#8217;re affiliated&#8212;if you&#8217;re affiliated yourself with the university, well, when you are part of the university, your speech needs to be bounded by your expertise. Is that an area of disagreement? Am I picking up that right? And can you clarify how we should think about this?</p><p><strong>Tom Ginsburg:</strong> Why don&#8217;t you say why we disagree? We used to disagree about departments.</p><p><strong>John Wilson:</strong> Oh, we still disagree about departments. Now, the issue is departmental&#8212;well, I&#8217;ll get to boundedness in a second. Departmental academic freedom is what I call it, that departments have the right to express themselves. And so Tom has this idea that departments are covered as part of the administration under the Kalven Report. I argue that institutional neutrality policies in the Kalven Report applies to the central administration alone. It does not apply to all the constituent elements of the university. It is the central administration alone that has the supreme power, and much greater power than departments have. The central administration gets to fire you, gets to ban you from campus. The departments can&#8217;t do that. It gets to deny you tenure, even. The administration does that technically, not the department. They just make recommendations. The power in the university is in the hands of the central administration. That&#8217;s where the real danger is.</p><p>And if you have this concept of departmental neutrality, which I actually would support&#8212;I don&#8217;t like collective statements. I don&#8217;t sign group letters. I don&#8217;t like this stuff. So I would prefer departments not to do that. But you need to persuade them to do it, just as the Kalven Report says you need to persuade the central administration to do this. So what becomes dangerous is when the Kalven Report, institutional neutrality, is misused, in my view, by the central administration to control faculty speech. The purpose of the Kalven Report is that the faculty are free to speak. And so that includes collective statements, just as individual freedom of religion includes the right to be part of a church and to express yourselves as part of a church. The right of individuals to speak also includes the right to get together and say things. And while there may be some limits to the departments on what they can do, and while I would urge departments not to speak out so much and not to say so many stupid things, I think the Kalven Report says we have to persuade them to do that, not have the administration control them to do that.</p><p><strong>Tom Ginsburg:</strong> So, I mean, that&#8217;s obviously a point of disagreement. I think the departments exercise much more power, and thus are more suspect, and also the site of disciplinary orthodoxies, which have crystallized. And actually, a lot of our disciplines are in big trouble over some of these things. You know, another area&#8212;I don&#8217;t know if we disagree about this, but here&#8217;s the dirty little secret: professors have more speech rights than anyone in the society, in the following sense. You are perfectly free to say David Reingold is a schmo and the university&#8217;s a colonial institution, and attack it very viciously. And that is understood in our tradition as being part of the internal ability to critique for the governance of the university. If you worked at, let&#8217;s say, Wendy&#8217;s, and you said your boss was, you know, a fool, you could be fired tomorrow. We&#8217;re in a country of at-will employment.</p><p>And the reason I think this is important is because at this moment&#8212;you know, back in 1890, when the socialist professor put something in the newspaper, well, a few people in Chicago read that newspaper. Now, a professor who says something really stupid that has nothing to do with their expertise, that doesn&#8217;t just stay in the university. That goes viral globally. And it&#8217;s endangering us in some sense, right? And I&#8217;m not saying that those professors should have more limited rights at all. I am saying that I think it&#8217;s time for us, self-governing professionals, to insist on a little bit of professionalism from our colleagues sometimes. Like, if you&#8217;re not an expert in something, maybe you shouldn&#8217;t be on Twitter all the time like you&#8217;re a 15-year-old living in their parents&#8217; basement.</p><p>You know, just&#8212;and I think we need to do that because professions are in trouble, not just our profession. Lots of professions are in trouble. They&#8217;re under attack. Think about what&#8217;s going on with the military as a profession right now, law firms. Professions are very fragile in our polarized country, and I think it&#8217;s time for us to return. We can&#8217;t survive unless we return to some ideas of, yeah, we have the right to speak and to inquire, and we&#8217;re going to insist on that. We&#8217;re going to fight you to the death for that right. But it&#8217;s also the case of, if you don&#8217;t know something about something, maybe you ought to keep your mouth shut. Let the students act like the students.</p><p><strong>John Wilson:</strong> I disagree with that. I think we shouldn&#8217;t be discouraging people from expressing their free speech. And faculty have academic freedom in the sense that they get to speak in the classroom and have this special freedom on the job that maybe a lot of other people don&#8217;t necessarily have, that&#8217;s essential to their work. But they also have to have the freedom, the same rights as anyone else, to speak out, to exercise their freedom of speech without being punished for their political views, which is what the University of Wisconsin realized back in 1894. Not only do we need to protect the rights of people to speak up, but we also need, as universities, to avoid the danger of intervening to fire controversial faculty, as well as we need to stop criticizing them and telling them to shut up.</p><p>I think that whole approach of, well, please shut up on Twitter, is wrong. I think we need to have the perspective, let&#8217;s encourage more people to speak up, and let&#8217;s try and persuade people to adopt a position of academic freedom and free speech, and start saying, well, if someone says something offends me, maybe I should argue with them rather than try to get them fired. I think that&#8217;s the kind of ethical position we should be promoting, rather than the position, you need to shut up and go to work, shut up and teach. I don&#8217;t regard that as being the message we need to send to professors. I think we need to, as much as possible, expand the freedom to speak.</p><p><strong>Tom Ginsburg:</strong> Well, it&#8217;s very hard for ordinary Americans. Is Debbie Cohen here? And I grew up in Berkeley, California, and there was a restaurant there called Top Dog&#8212;you&#8217;ll remember that&#8212;on Durant Avenue, a hot dog place that was open all hours of the night. Turns out that there was a guy who worked at the Top Dog who was later&#8212;who was in the Charlottesville antisemitic, anti-Black, racist, you know, march, and that person was fired. Now, ordinary employees of Top Dog can be fired for things they say and do. How can such people&#8212;first of all, I think that seems appropriate. You&#8217;re going to act like a fool and bring embarrassment to your employer? That seems appropriate. I&#8217;m not saying that universities should do this. I&#8217;m saying that we professors should have a standard of professionalism, that if we&#8217;re going to claim the benefits of being a profession, and having academic freedom is grounded in ideas of professionalism, you&#8217;ll agree, then we ought to encourage our colleagues to act like it. That&#8217;s all. I&#8217;m not saying that the administration gets to fire you like the Top Dog boss.</p><p><strong>Audience Member:</strong> I don&#8217;t need a microphone. Okay. Hi, I&#8217;m Caroline Smothers. I&#8217;m a law and public policy major. Recently, the high school that I attended was put on Facebook for having different inclusivity flags hung, and it was specifically called out by the Attorney General of Indiana. I also want to connect this to&#8212;the Indiana trustee board was recently replaced by all people that might be unappointed. How can we as students feel like we can be represented by an institution claiming neutrality whenever opinions are expressed and the government above us suppresses them?</p><p><strong>Tom Ginsburg:</strong> Yeah, well, I think John said very well that this is a misconstrual of neutrality, that, you know, this isn&#8217;t about neutrality at all. It&#8217;s about taking one side of political aisle and enforcing its views on everybody else, and there&#8217;s nothing neutral about that in any sense of the word. What do you do about it? I don&#8217;t&#8212;I&#8217;d be interested if you have ideas for what people in the room can do in such an environment that is really, you know, one of the most repressive in the United States in this regard. Texas, Indiana, Florida: these are the states in which the legislatures are competing to adopt the most repressive set of rules for academics.</p><p><strong>John Wilson:</strong> Well, yeah, and it&#8217;s important to note that we&#8217;re seeing in America the worst attack on academic freedom in the history of American higher education, what you have had from the combination of the Trump administration, state Republican officials in various states trying to repress free speech, as well as universities themselves engaging in amazing amounts of repression. One thing that&#8212;so it&#8217;s an incredibly difficult environment. One of the things I think we can appeal to, we can try to appeal to, is this idea of a principled academic freedom. Because even though a lot of the Republican officials, a lot of university administrators, have been repressing academic freedom left and right, they still pretend that they support it. And so I think there is a pathway by which you can say, let&#8217;s enact real policies that protect academic freedom. Let&#8217;s have universities speak out in defense of academic freedom.</p><p>You know, the whole issue of institutional neutrality: it&#8217;s not that you can never speak out, is that you only should speak out about your values. And so the university presidents, administrators, should be speaking out and saying, we don&#8217;t punish professors for their speech. They should be adopting things like the 1894 Wisconsin statement and saying, we don&#8217;t dismiss faculty for their political views. We don&#8217;t criticize them, even, for their political views. That, I think, is one way in which you can do that.</p><p>Another concept I want to bring up is the concept of shared governance, the idea that one thing we need to have at universities is not this hierarchical system where the political hacks run the board of trustees, they order the university administrators to do things, and the administrators order everybody on campus to do this. Not only do you need freedom, but you need a system where students have a voice, where faculty have a voice, where staff have a voice, where they&#8217;re involved in making policies. Because if you have faculty and students and staff involved in making an institutional neutrality policy, maybe you wouldn&#8217;t have had such a terrible policy enacted by the Board of Trustees. Maybe somebody would have spotted the spelling error, among other things.</p><p>So I think that&#8217;s one thing that&#8217;s essential for the universities, to have those kind of protections, as well as protections like tenure and having explicit policies that say universities protect these values. That, I think, is part of what you can do. Part of it is about changing&#8212;about bringing, you know, inviting university leaders to speak to events about these things, so that you can communicate that you want to have these kind of free&#8212;to have this free speech, or whatever your other values are, to express that. Try and do that directly to these people. Invite the board of trustees to your events, and invite them to campus to debate these ideas, and challenge them to argue about it rather than to impose it on you.</p><p><strong>Audience Member:</strong> Hey, I&#8217;m Carl Weinberg, ex-professor from History and PACE, happily retired, but glad to be here. Thanks for the conversation. In spring of 2013, a group of IU students staged a protest strike, and they recruited some faculty to do a series of sit-ins about the history of protest activity on campus and things like that. I was one of a bunch of faculty who took part. We communicated about this on the faculty email listserv. And in the middle of that conversation, the dean then of the College of Arts and Sciences, Larry Singell, stepped in and told us we were not allowed to use the faculty listserv to talk about being part of this strike movement. He was wrong. There was no policy against this. A number of us pushed back, and he was then forced to walk back this statement and say, never mind. Although in his email, he said, &#8220;I was actually quite heartened by the willingness of faculty to confront what they believed to be an incorrect or unjust application of policy.&#8221; I don&#8217;t believe really he was heartened. I think he was kind of humiliated and bummed out that we actually stepped forward and asserted our rights.</p><p>Now, one of the policies lurking behind this episode, and some of the policy that John very helpfully quoted from IU, hasn&#8217;t been mentioned, so I just wanted to throw it into the mix. It&#8217;s called the Johnson Amendment, passed by U.S. Congress in 1954. It does say that tax-exempt organizations, including IU, public universities, may not endorse political candidates for office. If they do, they will lose their tax-exempt status if the IRS acts. And basically, I think the former dean was somehow imagining we were doing that, when we weren&#8217;t. Although that&#8217;s currently the law, from what I&#8217;ve read, it&#8217;s not being enforced, and even the IRS itself has weighed in in a recent case to basically say, we don&#8217;t even believe in this. I don&#8217;t know what the future of it is. I think it&#8217;s worth knowing about, because it may be invoked by the administration, and any students here, anybody involved in organizing, should know what that legal terrain is, so they can&#8217;t be bamboozled. Any comments on this would be welcome.</p><p><strong>Tom Ginsburg:</strong> Yes. So it&#8217;s a classic authoritarian tactic at public universities to kind of get in and say, well, you can&#8217;t use your email for this. All of us are using our email to shop on Amazon, and no one seems to be bothered by that. I&#8217;m telling you a story just to tell you the stakes. I have a friend named Benny Tai, who was a Hong Kong university professor, who is in jail for the rest of his life. And the charge was using his university email account to help organize the Umbrella protest there in 2014. And so what I would caution&#8212;and I think the students probably know this better than you and me&#8212;is, if you&#8217;re doing stuff in this environment, it&#8217;s not bad to be on Signal. It&#8217;s not bad to have, like, some group things. Just, why not? Because everything you put in text and did in bytes is always gonna be there.</p><p>And at the same time, I wanna respond to one of the earlier points and say, it&#8217;s not clear to me that this attack on higher ed is particularly popular. I don&#8217;t know if this is really gonna keep going. You know, they tried to cut the NIH budget. It turns out most people like cancer treatment, you know. Even oligarchs might get it. And so I don&#8217;t know. It depends, obviously, what happens with politics, but I think a lot of this might just be the overplaying of their hand, in some sense. And that internal organization stuff is just something, you know&#8212;is a pragmatic matter. Not bad to be careful. But I can see no principled reason why a university would not allow such things.</p><p>I should say one other thing about protests. Protest is a critical part of democratic governance. We talk a lot about freedom of speech. We don&#8217;t talk very much about freedom of assembly, and it&#8217;s not very well developed legally. Really, there&#8217;s, like, time, place, and manner restrictions are essential to the functioning of an institution. A university can put on time, place, and manner restrictions. But I would always advise, as a matter of policy, to be very generous in recognizing that you want to facilitate student protest and freedom of speech, and not do things like say, you know, there&#8217;s no expressive activity between the hours of 12 and 8 in the morning on the quad&#8212;something facially illegal, which was the earlier policy. So, you know, it&#8217;s a matter of developing policies that facilitate people to have this conversation. That&#8217;s the other side. It&#8217;s not just a negative thing, that the university has to keep its mouth shut. It has to actively cultivate the ability of all of us to speak. I often say free speech isn&#8217;t free. It&#8217;s actually really costly to develop such structures and to encourage people to do it and help understand what the principles are. So that&#8217;s what I&#8217;d like to see our universities turn to in this fraught moment.</p><p><strong>John Wilson:</strong> Yeah, and I would recommend people look at the University of Chicago Center on Free Inquiry and Expression, which Tom runs, as a model for what you should do at Indiana University. You should create your own, ideally faculty-run, even student-run institution that is devoted to expanding free speech, defending free speech, talking about free speech. And so I think that&#8217;s one practical thing, and ideally try and get the university to pay for it. But, you know, a lot of these things, conversations you can have, that are actually not&#8212;they don&#8217;t require a lot of institutional investment to engage people in argument and debate.</p><p>Now, I would say, on the politics of the matter, I am much more cynical. I think a lot of people like censorship. They like repressing the views that they oppose. And so I am not&#8212;and it doesn&#8217;t really matter, even in terms of the Trump administration, whether it&#8217;s popular or not. They&#8217;re going to repress free speech no matter what. They don&#8217;t care if it&#8217;s popular, if they think they&#8217;re going to pay a political price. They want to defund and destroy their enemies, and they regard higher education as one of their enemies.</p><p>The popularity of it, I think, is important. I think it is important. Some forms of free speech are very unpopular. People use hate speech. It&#8217;s very hard to defend a lot of those people. I spend a lot of time defending horrible people who say horrible things, and it doesn&#8217;t really make me popular. But I think it is important, and it is important to have these kind of principled stances. I think there are some forms of free speech that are very popular. For example, one of the things I work on is Banned Books Week, which is coming up October 4th through the 10th. I would encourage everybody&#8212;because this is one of the most popular aspects of free speech, is opposing the banning of books. And so you should get together and do readings of banned books and speak out and do events that students can do. You can make your voice heard by doing this kind of thing, and you can contribute to that kind of culture of free speech that you really ought to be creating, and not wait for the administration, not wait for some program to give you permission to start speaking out in favor of free speech and organizing. Go to groups like BridgeUSA, create your own groups to do these kind of things. That, I think, is very much a feasible thing.</p><p><strong>Tom Ginsburg:</strong> By the way, it&#8217;s okay to try out ideas you don&#8217;t agree with, you know, just for the sake of argument. It&#8217;s a kind of&#8212;we&#8217;re in the social media era. The social media is basically&#8212;a lot of it, not all of it, obviously, but a lot of it is just like, you know, let&#8217;s mob on someone who said something that was inappropriate, or we think was. And that spread into universities. We had cancel culture in universities that led to more firings before Trump than during the entire McCarthy period. And don&#8217;t get into the denominator, boy. That&#8217;s a serious thing. That was happening within our own culture, and social media really pushes it. So it requires, like, you guys just get together and talk to people without the phones and try out some ideas and, you know, just see what happens. It&#8217;s a little bit&#8212;requires some trust, right? But it&#8217;s really important.</p><p><strong>John Wilson:</strong> Yeah, and I think one of the&#8212;and this goes back to the listserv and all of that&#8212;the danger is that we&#8217;re all living under a panopticon. We&#8217;re under surveillance now in ways that had never been possible before. Professors are on Zoom getting recorded. Video phones are recording everything you say. You&#8217;re on social media. People are spouting this. There&#8217;s a lot more information being spread, which is a good thing, contrary to what Tom says. It&#8217;s a good thing to express all these ideas, even if they&#8217;re stupid. But the danger is, we have a system that sort of was built up on privacy: the idea that professors wouldn&#8217;t get fired because nobody could prove what dumb things they said in the classroom. And now they can be proved to have said something dumb in the classroom, and a lot of them are getting fired, or say some dumb thing on Twitter, whereas a private conversation in the past would have never happened like that.</p><p>So we need to be much more careful. That applies even to your listservs. I strongly defend the right of people to use university emails to engage in political activism, to endorse political candidates, which is all perfectly legal. But I would encourage you to maybe use private emails, because there are people using the emails of public university professors to spy on organizations like the AAUP, where they will just look for keywords about anything they want to investigate. The Manhattan Institute has been doing this. And they will literally use Freedom of Information Act requests to get all the emails from a professor who would mention a particular topic or have talked about something. And so there is that real danger there, that you&#8217;re under constant surveillance. And maybe you want to reserve a personal privacy by using a personal email to engage in these kind of activities.</p><p>But what&#8217;s more important, I think, is for all of us to try and create a culture where we&#8217;re not going after people just because they said something stupid, where we&#8217;re not trying to get them fired, we&#8217;re not trying to get them punished by the university, we&#8217;re not turning them in to the authorities because they said something we don&#8217;t like, where instead we should try and educate and counter what they say rather than seek to punish them for it.</p><p class="button-wrapper" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/tom-ginsburg-and-john-wilson-on-institutional?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Share&quot;,&quot;action&quot;:null,&quot;class&quot;:null}" data-component-name="ButtonCreateButton"><a class="button primary" href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/tom-ginsburg-and-john-wilson-on-institutional?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share"><span>Share</span></a></p><div><hr></div><div class="subscription-widget-wrap-editor" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/subscribe?&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Subscribe&quot;,&quot;language&quot;:&quot;en&quot;}" data-component-name="SubscribeWidgetToDOM"><div class="subscription-widget show-subscribe"><div class="preamble"><p class="cta-caption"><em>Free The Inquiry</em> brings you essays, expert commentary, and conversations about open inquiry in the academy. Subscribe to stay up to date.</p></div><form class="subscription-widget-subscribe"><input type="email" class="email-input" name="email" placeholder="Type your email&#8230;" tabindex="-1"><input type="submit" class="button primary" value="Subscribe"><div class="fake-input-wrapper"><div class="fake-input"></div><div class="fake-button"></div></div></form></div></div><p></p>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[How I Learned To Teach Socialism at Berkeley]]></title><description><![CDATA[Fairness looks different when you&#8217;re the one giving things up]]></description><link>https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/how-i-learned-to-teach-socialism</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/how-i-learned-to-teach-socialism</guid><dc:creator><![CDATA[Neil Gilbert]]></dc:creator><pubDate>Wed, 21 Oct 2026 15:01:18 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!Si4K!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe6003b02-a115-40f9-9206-f956e81fdd11_1456x1048.jpeg" length="0" type="image/jpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="captioned-image-container"><figure><a class="image-link image2 is-viewable-img" target="_blank" href="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!Si4K!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe6003b02-a115-40f9-9206-f956e81fdd11_1456x1048.jpeg" data-component-name="Image2ToDOM"><div class="image2-inset"><picture><source type="image/webp" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!Si4K!,w_424,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe6003b02-a115-40f9-9206-f956e81fdd11_1456x1048.jpeg 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!Si4K!,w_848,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe6003b02-a115-40f9-9206-f956e81fdd11_1456x1048.jpeg 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!Si4K!,w_1272,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe6003b02-a115-40f9-9206-f956e81fdd11_1456x1048.jpeg 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!Si4K!,w_1456,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe6003b02-a115-40f9-9206-f956e81fdd11_1456x1048.jpeg 1456w" sizes="100vw"><img src="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!Si4K!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe6003b02-a115-40f9-9206-f956e81fdd11_1456x1048.jpeg" width="1456" height="1048" data-attrs="{&quot;src&quot;:&quot;https://substack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/e6003b02-a115-40f9-9206-f956e81fdd11_1456x1048.jpeg&quot;,&quot;srcNoWatermark&quot;:null,&quot;fullscreen&quot;:null,&quot;imageSize&quot;:null,&quot;height&quot;:1048,&quot;width&quot;:1456,&quot;resizeWidth&quot;:null,&quot;bytes&quot;:735706,&quot;alt&quot;:null,&quot;title&quot;:null,&quot;type&quot;:&quot;image/jpeg&quot;,&quot;href&quot;:null,&quot;belowTheFold&quot;:false,&quot;topImage&quot;:true,&quot;internalRedirect&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/i/213037092?img=https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe6003b02-a115-40f9-9206-f956e81fdd11_1456x1048.jpeg&quot;,&quot;isProcessing&quot;:false,&quot;align&quot;:null,&quot;offset&quot;:false}" class="sizing-normal" alt="" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!Si4K!,w_424,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe6003b02-a115-40f9-9206-f956e81fdd11_1456x1048.jpeg 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!Si4K!,w_848,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe6003b02-a115-40f9-9206-f956e81fdd11_1456x1048.jpeg 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!Si4K!,w_1272,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe6003b02-a115-40f9-9206-f956e81fdd11_1456x1048.jpeg 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!Si4K!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fe6003b02-a115-40f9-9206-f956e81fdd11_1456x1048.jpeg 1456w" sizes="100vw" fetchpriority="high"></picture><div class="image-link-expand"><div class="pencraft pc-display-flex pc-gap-8 pc-reset"><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container restack-image buttonBase-tqxFUX" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg aria-hidden="true" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 20 20" fill="none" stroke-width="1.5" stroke="var(--color-fg-primary)" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="icon-noB79L"><g><path d="M2.53001 7.81595C3.49179 4.73911 6.43281 2.5 9.91173 2.5C13.1684 2.5 15.9537 4.46214 17.0852 7.23684L17.6179 8.67647M17.6179 8.67647L18.5002 4.26471M17.6179 8.67647L13.6473 6.91176M17.4995 12.1841C16.5378 15.2609 13.5967 17.5 10.1178 17.5C6.86118 17.5 4.07589 15.5379 2.94432 12.7632L2.41165 11.3235M2.41165 11.3235L1.5293 15.7353M2.41165 11.3235L6.38224 13.0882"></path></g></svg></button><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container view-image buttonBase-tqxFUX" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="2" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" class="lucide lucide-maximize2 lucide-maximize-2 icon-noB79L"><polyline points="15 3 21 3 21 9"></polyline><polyline points="9 21 3 21 3 15"></polyline><line x1="21" x2="14" y1="3" y2="10"></line><line x1="3" x2="10" y1="21" y2="14"></line></svg></button></div></div></div></a><figcaption class="image-caption">"Girls, Come to the Tractor!" by P&#225;l Gy&#246;rgy, c. 1950s. Hungarian National Museum / Europeana, Public Domain.</figcaption></figure></div><p>New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani&#8217;s appeal to young progressives is as unsurprising as a lecture on intersectionality at Berkeley. Indeed, his plans to offer free public transportation, universal housing, and government grocery stores resonate through college classrooms across the country where equity is routinely invoked in the name of social justice.</p><p>For nearly half a century, I&#8217;ve been teaching social policy at the University of California, Berkeley to students who arrive with these and other predictable opinions on issues of the day. In 2025, they&#8217;re all for forgiving student loans, firmly against privatizing Social Security, and eager to expand rent control. Work requirements for welfare recipients strike them as unjust and welfare benefits for undocumented immigrants as a moral imperative. When it comes to guaranteed incomes, they&#8217;re ready to sign on yesterday.</p><p>These views are less the product of critical reflection than the expression of youthful idealism nourished in the social sciences and humanities by progressive professors, whose tenure shields them from the destructive consequences of social engineering. Wielding the power of language, many faculty cast capitalism as red in tooth and claw: privileging wealth over need, individualism over solidarity, and the market over social welfare. It doesn&#8217;t hurt that such convictions also attract grant funding and publishing opportunities in the softer sciences. The classroom becomes not just a site of learning, but a greenhouse for cultivating the seeds of democratic socialist activism.</p><h3><strong>Ideals Without Costs</strong></h3><p>Few of my students give serious consideration to the costs of generous welfare transfers or where the limits of redistribution might lie. Why would they? Most have paid little or nothing in taxes. Many have received student loans, scholarships, health insurance subsidies, and food stamps. The redistributive state has been their benefactor, not their burden.</p><p>When they speak of &#8220;social justice,&#8221; it is from the lived experience of benefits that come without costs. Their faith in the fairness of redistribution derives from the conventional view of equity, which demands that everyone deserves roughly the same share of society&#8217;s wealth. Aristotle characterized this egalitarian perspective as &#8220;numerical equality,&#8221; an attractive but flawed vision that fails to reward individual contributions to the creation of worldly goods. In contrast, he argued that distributive justice was based upon &#8220;proportional equality,&#8221; which involved differential rewards for merit&#8212;in essence, exploiting the language of equality to endorse the justice of inequality.</p><div class="pullquote"><p>Wielding the power of language, many faculty cast capitalism as red in tooth and claw: privileging wealth over need, individualism over solidarity, and the market over social welfare.</p></div><h3><strong>From Theory to Practice</strong></h3><p>Recently, I wondered how I might bring the egalitarian and meritarian views of distributive justice down from the clouds of abstraction into the tangible world of consequential experience. After weeks spent analyzing social policies and their underlying assumptions, costs, and benefits, I posed a thought experiment in the final class of the semester: I asked the students to imagine that they were founding members of a small agrarian commune. Each family started with identical resources: 50 acres of fertile farmland, a few animals, seeds, and basic tools. They then had to decide how to distribute the harvest. Three principles were on the table:</p><ol><li><p><strong>Egalitarian</strong> &#8212; Pool everything and divide it equally.</p></li><li><p><strong>Need-based</strong> &#8212; Allocate according to health and appetite.</p></li><li><p><strong>Meritocratic</strong> &#8212; Each family keeps the fruits of its labor, contributing a modest tithe for those unable to work because of illness or misfortune.</p></li></ol><p>As one might expect, after some deliberation a consensus emerged in favor of the egalitarian option. It was just, they said. It fostered solidarity. No one should suffer for being weaker or less efficient than their neighbor.</p><p>Then came the real test. If theoretically as farmers they would be inclined to redistribute the fruits of their labor so that the community&#8217;s members all had an equal share of the harvest, in practice would they be disposed to engage in similar behavior to advance solidarity and social justice in the classroom? Would they be willing to redistribute their grades on the final exam? It was a classroom experiment in applied socialism that offered an opportunity for experiential learning.</p><p>I asked if they would like to participate in a communal grading pact, voluntarily, of course. There would be no penalties, no incentives, and full confidentiality. Those who wished to join the &#8220;commune&#8221; were invited to email me before the exam and would receive the group&#8217;s average score. An &#8220;A&#8221; student might lose a few points; a struggling classmate might gain a few. Together, they would create an egalitarian community&#8212;one that traded individual contribution for collective welfare in grade point averages.</p><div class="pullquote"><p>Few of my students give serious consideration to the costs of generous welfare transfers or where the limits of redistribution might lie. Why would they? Most have paid little or nothing in taxes.</p></div><p>Although a simple test with low stakes, the communal grading option highlighted the tangible consequences of redistribution. The opportunity to experience these consequences firsthand offered a meritarian challenge to the egalitarian perspective on social justice, at least as far as marginal academic rewards were concerned. As the emails came in, the egalitarian consensus withered; only about half the class joined the commune.</p><p>Grappling with the tension between the principle of communal wellbeing and individual self-interest, with small but still real consequences at stake, proved a sobering experience for many. The point of this experiment wasn&#8217;t to expose hypocrisy, but to encourage critical reflection on the normative assumptions about equality and social justice, which are rarely questioned within the intellectual bubble of campus life. These were intelligent, well-meaning students, whose embrace of socialist ideals was sincere though largely theoretical, shaped in an environment where scarcity is abstract and trade-offs are academic. For most, the costs of idealism are safely deferred until after graduation.</p><h3><strong>The Wider Lesson</strong></h3><p>In an age when campus culture cultivates moral certainty over intellectual humility, the exercise in experiential learning serves to remind students that policies have trade-offs, social values compete with one another, virtue often comes with personal sacrifice, and that fairness looks different when you&#8217;re the one on the giving side of the redistribution.</p><p>Welfare generosity can cushion the poor but may also discourage work. Rent control helps low-income tenants but inevitably shrinks the housing supply, ultimately raising prices for many. Forgiving student loans relieves debtors but transfers costs to taxpayers, some of whom could not afford college because they didn&#8217;t want to assume the debt. I introduced the egalitarian experiment to test the convictions of social justice warriors who see the world through a Manichaean lens of oppressed vs. oppressor, rich vs. poor&#8212;a comforting perspective that allows for no ambiguity.</p><p>Which brings us back to Mayor Mamdani. Speaking the language of social justice, equity, free public transportation, rent control, and government groceries, he strikes a chord with this generation of college students. He sounds like their activist professors. Playing on their untested values, he doesn&#8217;t talk much about what things cost or who pays for them, beyond making vague references to billionaires&#8212;many of whom are already packing their bags for Florida. Making no mention of shared sacrifice, he is the ideal political leader for a generation long on ideals and short on experiential learning.</p><p>After all, flirtation with socialism is exciting&#8212;as long as someone else picks up the tab. But in the world beyond the gates of Berkeley and other college campuses, ideals meet limits, trade-offs, and unintended effects. A teacher&#8217;s job is not to quash their students&#8217; idealism, but to inculcate a respect for evidence and a disposition to question prevailing assumptions.</p><p class="button-wrapper" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/how-i-learned-to-teach-socialism?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Share&quot;,&quot;action&quot;:null,&quot;class&quot;:null}" data-component-name="ButtonCreateButton"><a class="button primary" href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/how-i-learned-to-teach-socialism?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share"><span>Share</span></a></p><div><hr></div><div class="subscription-widget-wrap-editor" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/subscribe?&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Subscribe&quot;,&quot;language&quot;:&quot;en&quot;}" data-component-name="SubscribeWidgetToDOM"><div class="subscription-widget show-subscribe"><div class="preamble"><p class="cta-caption">Subscribe to stay <em>inquisitive.</em></p></div><form class="subscription-widget-subscribe"><input type="email" class="email-input" name="email" placeholder="Type your email&#8230;" tabindex="-1"><input type="submit" class="button primary" value="Subscribe"><div class="fake-input-wrapper"><div class="fake-input"></div><div class="fake-button"></div></div></form></div></div>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[The Weekly: The Coming Swarm of AI-Enabled Research]]></title><description><![CDATA[Math is getting solved. What about the rest of academic truth-seeking?]]></description><link>https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/the-weekly-the-coming-swarm-of-ai</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/the-weekly-the-coming-swarm-of-ai</guid><dc:creator><![CDATA[Michael Regnier]]></dc:creator><pubDate>Sat, 17 Oct 2026 12:03:15 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!KDWp!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fd52e6174-b6fd-4483-8e4d-d016647304e9_5079x3696.jpeg" length="0" type="image/jpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="captioned-image-container"><figure><a class="image-link image2 is-viewable-img" target="_blank" href="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!KDWp!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fd52e6174-b6fd-4483-8e4d-d016647304e9_5079x3696.jpeg" data-component-name="Image2ToDOM"><div class="image2-inset"><picture><source type="image/webp" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!KDWp!,w_424,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fd52e6174-b6fd-4483-8e4d-d016647304e9_5079x3696.jpeg 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!KDWp!,w_848,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fd52e6174-b6fd-4483-8e4d-d016647304e9_5079x3696.jpeg 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!KDWp!,w_1272,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fd52e6174-b6fd-4483-8e4d-d016647304e9_5079x3696.jpeg 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!KDWp!,w_1456,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fd52e6174-b6fd-4483-8e4d-d016647304e9_5079x3696.jpeg 1456w" sizes="100vw"><img src="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!KDWp!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fd52e6174-b6fd-4483-8e4d-d016647304e9_5079x3696.jpeg" width="1456" height="1060" data-attrs="{&quot;src&quot;:&quot;https://substack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/d52e6174-b6fd-4483-8e4d-d016647304e9_5079x3696.jpeg&quot;,&quot;srcNoWatermark&quot;:null,&quot;fullscreen&quot;:null,&quot;imageSize&quot;:null,&quot;height&quot;:1060,&quot;width&quot;:1456,&quot;resizeWidth&quot;:null,&quot;bytes&quot;:3497024,&quot;alt&quot;:null,&quot;title&quot;:null,&quot;type&quot;:&quot;image/jpeg&quot;,&quot;href&quot;:null,&quot;belowTheFold&quot;:false,&quot;topImage&quot;:true,&quot;internalRedirect&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/i/220789228?img=https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fd52e6174-b6fd-4483-8e4d-d016647304e9_5079x3696.jpeg&quot;,&quot;isProcessing&quot;:false,&quot;align&quot;:null,&quot;offset&quot;:false}" class="sizing-normal" alt="" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!KDWp!,w_424,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fd52e6174-b6fd-4483-8e4d-d016647304e9_5079x3696.jpeg 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!KDWp!,w_848,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fd52e6174-b6fd-4483-8e4d-d016647304e9_5079x3696.jpeg 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!KDWp!,w_1272,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fd52e6174-b6fd-4483-8e4d-d016647304e9_5079x3696.jpeg 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!KDWp!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fd52e6174-b6fd-4483-8e4d-d016647304e9_5079x3696.jpeg 1456w" sizes="100vw" fetchpriority="high"></picture><div class="image-link-expand"><div class="pencraft pc-display-flex pc-gap-8 pc-reset"><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container restack-image buttonBase-GK1x3M" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg aria-hidden="true" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 20 20" fill="none" stroke-width="1.5" stroke="var(--color-fg-primary)" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="icon-noB79L"><g><path d="M2.53001 7.81595C3.49179 4.73911 6.43281 2.5 9.91173 2.5C13.1684 2.5 15.9537 4.46214 17.0852 7.23684L17.6179 8.67647M17.6179 8.67647L18.5002 4.26471M17.6179 8.67647L13.6473 6.91176M17.4995 12.1841C16.5378 15.2609 13.5967 17.5 10.1178 17.5C6.86118 17.5 4.07589 15.5379 2.94432 12.7632L2.41165 11.3235M2.41165 11.3235L1.5293 15.7353M2.41165 11.3235L6.38224 13.0882"></path></g></svg></button><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container view-image buttonBase-GK1x3M" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="2" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" class="lucide lucide-maximize2 lucide-maximize-2 icon-noB79L"><polyline points="15 3 21 3 21 9"></polyline><polyline points="9 21 3 21 3 15"></polyline><line x1="21" x2="14" y1="3" y2="10"></line><line x1="3" x2="10" y1="21" y2="14"></line></svg></button></div></div></div></a></figure></div><p>The math is math-ing, as the kids say. But are the human math professors cooked? Over the past two weeks, the most dramatic story about academic inquiry has been about how AI models are disrupting it, in math research and beyond.</p><p>Here are some of the stories we&#8217;re following at HxA.</p><div><hr></div><h2><strong>OpenAI upended the field of mathematics. </strong></h2><p>It&#8217;s been eleven days since the AI tech company released <a href="https://openai.com/index/sharing-ai-progress-in-mathematics/">hundreds of math research papers</a> produced by an &#8220;internal frontier model&#8221; that your ChatGPT subscription can&#8217;t buy. The papers included solutions and progress on many longstanding problems. (Three papers were withdrawn the next day due to errors.)</p><p>The <em>New York Times</em> <a href="https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/08/science/mathematicians-respond-openai-release.html">led its coverage</a> with Rutgers math chair (and HxA member) Alex Kontorovich assessing one of the papers: &#8220;If a human did this, it would be an instant Fields Medal, no questions asked.&#8221; Economist Joshua Gans <a href="https://joshuagans.substack.com/p/openai-drops-a-bomb-on-maths?r=oc6a&amp;utm_campaign=post&amp;utm_medium=web">called</a> October 6 &#8220;probably the biggest day of scientific advancement in history.&#8221; Einstein had a <a href="https://asd.gsfc.nasa.gov/blueshift/index.php/2015/11/25/100-years-of-general-relativity/">relatively good</a> Thursday back in November 1915, but we take the point: this is an earthquake. Progress in uncovering mathematical truths may be AI-driven from now on.</p><p>Math-oriented humans had widely varied reactions to the OpenAI math-drop. Fields Medalist Hugo Duminil-Copin <a href="https://x.com/hsu_steve/status/2108364887605018884?s=20">called it a &#8220;massacre&#8221;</a> and noted with alarm that the OpenAI model had not only solved problems but even <em>selected problems to solve</em> from the existing literature. In a popular video, educator Grant Sanderson <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LKrwhjOI8Nc&amp;t=1s">calmly argued</a> that &#8220;there&#8217;s never been a better time&#8221; to enter the field. A <a href="https://proofsandprompts.com/2026/10/08/100-reactions-to-100-solutions/">collection of over 100 other reactions</a> from the field shows every shade of emotion.</p><div><hr></div><h2><strong>AI disruption is coming for more fields and more aspects of the scholarly profession.</strong></h2><p>The raging discourse about AI math highlights, again, how much the <em>status quo</em> of academic research is a complex economy of information, money, and status. And scholars, in math and in other fields, are asking similar questions about how that economy will change.</p><p>If frontier findings can be AI-generated, how do humans share in the credit? What signals mastery if not <a href="https://www.chronicle.com/article/has-ai-destroyed-the-doctoral-dissertation">a dissertation</a>? How can academic fields incentivize quality explanations when being &#8220;first&#8221; with a result is <a href="https://mathadjacent.com/p/the-big-reset-in-mathematics">no longer so meaningful</a>?</p><p>But AI won&#8217;t stop at frontier findings. Ethan Mollick predicts <a href="https://x.com/emollick/status/2107964764316209326?s=20">two academic revolutions</a> from AI: &#8220;Novel discoveries will start to come fast,&#8221; as in math, but also &#8220;Everything ever published will be re-read and re-judged in ways that human scientists never anticipated.&#8221; Indeed, there are multiple efforts underway to use AI to vet scholarly publications at great scale, checking for statistical errors, plagiarism, inflated claims, or other concerns. What will scholarship look like in a world where papers can be so hotly and automatically scrutinized by anyone with access and some cheap computing power?</p><p>For that matter, what will academic freedom look like? Those of us who favor transparency about what colleges teach must admit that it opens a door to AI-driven surveillance that may be put to illiberal use. At <em>The Atlantic</em>, <a href="https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/2026/10/texas-university-censorship-free-speech/688827/?gift=bKIN6C_qOSLZXJIbbZb-aiHejVsf7D_mWE2sNY6AxnI">Adam Serwer uncovers</a> an AI angle to Texas censorship trends that have been frequently criticized in <em>Free the Inquiry</em>, explaining that &#8220;Texas Tech&#8217;s approach to censorship is notable for being both onerous and clumsy, in part because it relies so heavily on artificial intelligence.&#8221; What&#8217;s worse than classroom censorship? Classroom censorship based on AI hallucinations.</p><div><hr></div><h2><strong>When bot swarms seek the truth, what will they find?</strong></h2><p>HxA was formed out of concern for rigorous, scholarly contestation about ideas. As Jon Haidt <a href="https://heterodoxacademy.org/blog/welcome-to-heterodox-academy/">explained</a> at our founding: &#8220;We academics are generally biased toward confirming our own theories and validating our favored beliefs. But as long as we can all count on the peer review process and a vigorous post-publication peer debate process, we can rest assured that most obvious errors and biases will get called out.&#8221; Haidt argued that the absence of diverse viewpoints, and a fearful climate in which they are not expressed, are both problematic because they threaten that vital contestation process. </p><p>Enter the contestation-bots, and the researchers &#8212; professional and amateur &#8212; who will direct them. Especially as we work out the appropriate incentives, one hopes that such AI tools will be a net benefit to truth-seeking, as they notice errors, re-run analyses, and conceive and test promising ideas to help us grasp more of our world. </p><p>But we must not be na&#239;ve. Especially when the research is about issues more controversial than a mathematical proof, we can see the dangers to truth-seeking as well. The design of corporate chatbots may <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s44271-026-00428-5">flatten scientific imagination</a> and drive up homogeneity, or re-create the political and other <a href="https://davidrozado.substack.com/p/have-we-been-measuring-ai-political">biases</a> of human writers and trainers. AI-enabled research may <a href="https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adw3000">overwhelm systems of human review</a>, paradoxically leading editors to rely even more on status signals from their human in-groups. The AI models may solve math, but we humans and our institutions are still daunting puzzles.</p><p class="button-wrapper" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/the-weekly-the-coming-swarm-of-ai?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Share&quot;,&quot;action&quot;:null,&quot;class&quot;:null}" data-component-name="ButtonCreateButton"><a class="button primary" href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/the-weekly-the-coming-swarm-of-ai?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share"><span>Share</span></a></p><div><hr></div><div class="subscription-widget-wrap-editor" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/subscribe?&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Subscribe&quot;,&quot;language&quot;:&quot;en&quot;}" data-component-name="SubscribeWidgetToDOM"><div class="subscription-widget show-subscribe"><div class="preamble"><p class="cta-caption"><em>Free The Inquiry</em> brings you essays, expert commentary, and conversations about open inquiry in the academy. Subscribe to stay up to date.</p></div><form class="subscription-widget-subscribe"><input type="email" class="email-input" name="email" placeholder="Type your email&#8230;" tabindex="-1"><input type="submit" class="button primary" value="Subscribe"><div class="fake-input-wrapper"><div class="fake-input"></div><div class="fake-button"></div></div></form></div></div><p></p>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[If Political Polarization Broke College, How Do We Fix It?]]></title><description><![CDATA[A focused review of higher ed reform angles from Neil Gross&#8217;s 2026 book What Happened to College?]]></description><link>https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/if-political-polarization-broke-college</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/if-political-polarization-broke-college</guid><dc:creator><![CDATA[Justin McBrayer]]></dc:creator><pubDate>Fri, 16 Oct 2026 13:03:01 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!dnr7!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0fa24ca0-cabb-465f-bc9b-fe7cecc82512_1100x630.png" length="0" type="image/jpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="captioned-image-container"><figure><a class="image-link image2 is-viewable-img" target="_blank" href="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!dnr7!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0fa24ca0-cabb-465f-bc9b-fe7cecc82512_1100x630.png" data-component-name="Image2ToDOM"><div class="image2-inset"><picture><source type="image/webp" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!dnr7!,w_424,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0fa24ca0-cabb-465f-bc9b-fe7cecc82512_1100x630.png 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!dnr7!,w_848,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0fa24ca0-cabb-465f-bc9b-fe7cecc82512_1100x630.png 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!dnr7!,w_1272,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0fa24ca0-cabb-465f-bc9b-fe7cecc82512_1100x630.png 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!dnr7!,w_1456,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0fa24ca0-cabb-465f-bc9b-fe7cecc82512_1100x630.png 1456w" sizes="100vw"><img src="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!dnr7!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0fa24ca0-cabb-465f-bc9b-fe7cecc82512_1100x630.png" width="1100" height="630" data-attrs="{&quot;src&quot;:&quot;https://substack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/0fa24ca0-cabb-465f-bc9b-fe7cecc82512_1100x630.png&quot;,&quot;srcNoWatermark&quot;:null,&quot;fullscreen&quot;:null,&quot;imageSize&quot;:null,&quot;height&quot;:630,&quot;width&quot;:1100,&quot;resizeWidth&quot;:null,&quot;bytes&quot;:260197,&quot;alt&quot;:null,&quot;title&quot;:null,&quot;type&quot;:&quot;image/png&quot;,&quot;href&quot;:null,&quot;belowTheFold&quot;:false,&quot;topImage&quot;:true,&quot;internalRedirect&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/i/220593568?img=https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0fa24ca0-cabb-465f-bc9b-fe7cecc82512_1100x630.png&quot;,&quot;isProcessing&quot;:false,&quot;align&quot;:null,&quot;offset&quot;:false}" class="sizing-normal" alt="" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!dnr7!,w_424,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0fa24ca0-cabb-465f-bc9b-fe7cecc82512_1100x630.png 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!dnr7!,w_848,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0fa24ca0-cabb-465f-bc9b-fe7cecc82512_1100x630.png 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!dnr7!,w_1272,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0fa24ca0-cabb-465f-bc9b-fe7cecc82512_1100x630.png 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!dnr7!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F0fa24ca0-cabb-465f-bc9b-fe7cecc82512_1100x630.png 1456w" sizes="100vw" fetchpriority="high"></picture><div class="image-link-expand"><div class="pencraft pc-display-flex pc-gap-8 pc-reset"><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container restack-image buttonBase-GK1x3M" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg aria-hidden="true" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 20 20" fill="none" stroke-width="1.5" stroke="var(--color-fg-primary)" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="icon-noB79L"><g><path d="M2.53001 7.81595C3.49179 4.73911 6.43281 2.5 9.91173 2.5C13.1684 2.5 15.9537 4.46214 17.0852 7.23684L17.6179 8.67647M17.6179 8.67647L18.5002 4.26471M17.6179 8.67647L13.6473 6.91176M17.4995 12.1841C16.5378 15.2609 13.5967 17.5 10.1178 17.5C6.86118 17.5 4.07589 15.5379 2.94432 12.7632L2.41165 11.3235M2.41165 11.3235L1.5293 15.7353M2.41165 11.3235L6.38224 13.0882"></path></g></svg></button><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container view-image buttonBase-GK1x3M" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="2" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" class="lucide lucide-maximize2 lucide-maximize-2 icon-noB79L"><polyline points="15 3 21 3 21 9"></polyline><polyline points="9 21 3 21 3 15"></polyline><line x1="21" x2="14" y1="3" y2="10"></line><line x1="3" x2="10" y1="21" y2="14"></line></svg></button></div></div></div></a></figure></div><p>I have two boys in college, and their university experiences are very different from the one I had in the 1990s. While many of those changes are for the better, some are for the worse. And on the whole, I would be reluctant to trade my experience for theirs. If you are reading this essay, most likely you know about many of the concerning trendlines in higher education. I resigned my full professorship to work for Heterodox Academy to do something about it.</p><p>But fixing something requires having a good handle on the problem. If you don&#8217;t know why a system broke down, it will be difficult to bring it back online. Neil Gross, a sociology professor at Colby College, has an answer: universities have been caught in the crosshairs of political polarization.</p><p>If you don&#8217;t know Professor Gross&#8217;s work, you&#8217;ve been missing out on one of the most honest and thoughtful observers of higher education. His 2013 book, <em><a href="https://www.hup.harvard.edu/books/9780674059092">Why are Professors Liberal and Why do Conservatives Care?</a></em> is one of the very best takes on faculty ideology that I&#8217;ve read.  He argues that the current political imbalance in faculty is the result of political typecasting. A historical contingency--the need for universities to pivot from religious institutions to knowledge-producing ones--created a long-lasting stereotype of professors as liberals. That stereotype affects how students see the occupational options open to them with liberals seeing it as a live option and conservatives not taking a professorship seriously.</p><p>In his <a href="https://www.porchlightbooks.com/products/what-happened-to-college-neil-gross-9781668200445">new book</a>, Gross relies on years&#8217; worth of survey and interview data to paint a picture of university life. And from the students to the faculty, everyone views college through a political lens in a way they weren&#8217;t only a decade ago. A student&#8217;s political ideology, values, and interest in politics increasingly influence each of the following:</p><ul><li><p>Where the student applies to college</p></li><li><p>Where the student decides to attend college</p></li><li><p>Which major the student selects</p></li><li><p>Which clubs the student joins</p></li><li><p>Who the student rooms with or dates</p></li><li><p>Whether the student speaks up in class.</p></li></ul><p>Faculty are also far more likely to allow their political ideology to shape everything from their decision to go to graduate school to how activist they are in their classrooms. Gross concludes that &#8220;the restructuring of undergraduate life along political lines is at the core of the current crisis, turning the university into valuable and contested territory in the ugly fight between left and right. Students are paying the price&#8221; (217).</p><p>If polarization is the problem, what is the solution? Professor Gross sketches six concrete changes universities could make to turn down the political heat on campus. Here are the key moves:</p><p><strong>Change admission standards.</strong> Professor Gross recommends that admissions committees go beyond markers of intelligence and achievement to probe applicants&#8217; commitment to reasoned debate. Gross also recommends that admissions committees build incoming classes that are more politically diverse. In particular, holistic admissions criteria that focus on an applicant&#8217;s overall &#8220;fit&#8221; are likely to perpetuate the politics and bias of whomever is judging the fit. Instead, let&#8217;s charge admissions directors at elite universities to shape incoming classes in ways that foreground constructive dialogue and increase opportunities for engaging with &#8220;the other.&#8221;</p><p><strong>Improve students&#8217; constructive dialogue skills.</strong> Honing students&#8217; constructive dialogue skills will make cross-ideological encounters more pleasant and productive. Professor Gross urges universities to collaborate to determine which interventions are most effective and incentivize faculty to add constructive dialogue skills into the learning outcomes of their courses. The <a href="https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/09567976241230005">empirical evidence</a> shows that we consistently overestimate how unpleasant conversations about political issues will be, and college campuses are a great place to recalibrate those expectations.</p><p><strong>Intentionally structure campus life in ways that foster cross-ideological interactions.</strong> This includes randomizing roommate assignments and sponsoring events and activities that bring together student groups that don&#8217;t ordinarily intersect. Given how much political polarization undermines the serendipitous interactions and alignments that generate friendships, this strikes me as a vital suggestion. I was a faculty in residence on my campus, and over five years of living in the residence hall made it clear to me how important the college experience outside the classroom really is. As HxA President John Tomasi <a href="https://www.furman-free-speech.com/p/what-is-the-future-of-free-speech">put it</a>, the real test of intellectual vitality on campus is whether students are having free-ranging conversations about hard topics on a Tuesday night in the dorm.</p><p><strong>Make space for faculty to have explicit conversations about good teaching in the age of polarization.</strong> Professor Gross acknowledges how little teaching training most of us receive in our PhD programs, and he calls on academic administrators to provide professional development on how to handle controversial topics, how to design courses that attract a wider breadth of students, and how to build a general education that provides students with a common intellectual foundation. Intrepid administrators will make space and funding available for this sort of professional development.</p><p><strong>Increase the political diversity of faculty.</strong> Professor Gross&#8217;s final recommendation is to increase viewpoint diversity across the faculty. Even if the political imbalance is the result of benign factors, it contributes to the overall politicization of campus. He calls on us to remove ideological thumbs on the scale when hiring, to broaden the academic tent by investing in underrepresented but academically important topics, and to nurture a pipeline of graduate students from across the ideological spectrum.</p><p>It&#8217;s remarkable how many of these suggestions align with Heterodox Academy&#8217;s own recommendations. HxA&#8217;s <a href="https://heterodoxacademy.org/open-inquiry-u/">Open Inquiry U</a> agenda calls for the elimination of ideological sorting in all university processes, explicitly mentioning admissions, and the fourth pillar of the agenda focuses on constructive disagreement skill-building. To that end, HxA has developed a constructive disagreement <a href="https://heterodoxacademy.org/resources/enabling-practicing-constructive-disagreement-on-campus/">resource guide</a> and a <a href="https://heterodoxacademy.org/resources/on-constructive-disagreement-video-playlist/">constructive disagreement hub</a> with tools and resources, including a great lineup of YouTube videos. And, of course, the importance of viewpoint diversity in the faculty has been at the core of HxA&#8217;s reform efforts from the earliest days, emphasized in our very <a href="https://heterodoxacademy.org/blog/one-telos-truth-or-social-justice-2/">first blog post</a> by Jonathan Haidt and standing as the third pillar in our <a href="https://heterodoxacademy.org/open-inquiry-u/">Open Inquiry U</a> agenda. It&#8217;s encouraging to see these recommendations echoed by a leading scholar of higher education.</p><p>In all, Professor Gross&#8217;s book offers anecdotal illustrations, wide-ranging data, and a compelling explanation for the polarization taking place on campus and a range of HxA-aligned suggestions for how to do better. I recommend the book not just to those working in higher ed reform but also those of us who have children in college. Our family has had several good conversations about how political tribalism confounds my boys&#8217; life on campus, and this book will shape the next round of conversation over Thanksgiving dinner. I&#8217;m particularly interested to know whether my sons&#8217; experiences of friends, roommates, and dates mirrors the polarized trends sketched in the book &#8212; that feels really different from my own undergraduate experience 30 years ago.</p><p class="button-wrapper" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/if-political-polarization-broke-college?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Share&quot;,&quot;action&quot;:null,&quot;class&quot;:null}" data-component-name="ButtonCreateButton"><a class="button primary" href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/if-political-polarization-broke-college?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share"><span>Share</span></a></p><div><hr></div><div class="subscription-widget-wrap-editor" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/subscribe?&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Subscribe&quot;,&quot;language&quot;:&quot;en&quot;}" data-component-name="SubscribeWidgetToDOM"><div class="subscription-widget show-subscribe"><div class="preamble"><p class="cta-caption"><em>Free The Inquiry</em> brings you essays, expert commentary, and conversations about open inquiry in the academy. Subscribe to stay up to date.</p></div><form class="subscription-widget-subscribe"><input type="email" class="email-input" name="email" placeholder="Type your email&#8230;" tabindex="-1"><input type="submit" class="button primary" value="Subscribe"><div class="fake-input-wrapper"><div class="fake-input"></div><div class="fake-button"></div></div></form></div></div><p></p>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Should We Genetically Modify Human Embryos? A Philosopher and a Biologist Work Through Four Cases]]></title><description><![CDATA[Where they agree, where they split, and where each is unsure.]]></description><link>https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/should-we-genetically-modify-human</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/should-we-genetically-modify-human</guid><pubDate>Thu, 15 Oct 2026 13:05:01 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://api.substack.com/feed/podcast/220428651/c6addb9b7198392ec50bd93660f3d531.mp3" length="0" type="audio/mpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><em>Where would you draw the line on editing human embryos? Joseph Vukov, a philosopher, and Michael Burns, a biologist, have been colleagues at Loyola University Chicago since faculty orientation ten years ago, and they come at this question from different starting points &#8212; one drawing on Catholic thought, the other on a secular, left-of-center view. In this <a href="https://heterodoxacademy.org/heterodox-conversations/">Heterodox Conversation&#8482;</a> at Johns Hopkins University, Burns first explains how CRISPR-Cas9 cuts and edits DNA, including an FDA-approved CRISPR therapy for sickle cell disease. Vukov then lays out why most ethicists accept treating body cells while nearly everyone opposes editing embryos today, along with the practical and moral objections.</em></p><p><em>The four cases run from editing embryos with today&#8217;s technology, to a world where no one can have children, to cheap and safe &#8220;strip mall&#8221; genetic engineering, to treating eggs and sperm before conception. After audience members weigh in on each, Vukov and Burns show where they land &#8212; including where they agree, but for entirely different reasons. The conversation closes with audience questions. A transcript of the conversation follows below.</em></p><div><hr></div><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> All right, good evening everyone. I&#8217;m going to be presenting today, as has already been said, on in what cases is it ethically permissible to genetically modify human embryos. So we wanted to start out with just a little bit about ourselves. We represent a couple of different ways of coming at this question. I am a philosopher by training, did a PhD in philosophy, currently work in a lot of ethics of technology, and because this is relevant for the discussion tonight, I am a Catholic who tries to be a pretty by-the-books Catholic and lean a little bit more conservative when it comes to ethical issues like what we&#8217;re going to be discussing tonight. And Burns is on the exact same page, right buddy?</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> That is absolutely not true my name is Dr. Michael Burns. I am in the biology department and bioinformatics program at Loyola University Chicago. I&#8217;m an associate professor there. I&#8217;m also the director of the artificial intelligence and human flourishing program &#8212; brand new minor program. And it says artificial intelligence, since you must be like, oh, you love data centers. I mentioned there&#8217;s a second part of it, which is human flourishing. Okay, so there&#8217;s like a part of it we&#8217;re like, care about people. Anyway, you have a whole bunch of other titles, don&#8217;t you?</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> I do. So I also am an associate director for, we&#8217;ve got this place called the Hank Center for Catholic Intellectual Heritage. So I help direct that center as well.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> The other piece, so you mentioned he&#8217;s a Roman Catholic and vaguely conservative. I&#8217;d say you&#8217;re pretty conservative, Joe.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> I&#8217;m pretty conservative, yeah.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> I&#8217;m an atheist.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> I got my best conservative suit on.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> That&#8217;s right. Yes. We tried to look the part. We also don&#8217;t wear suits very often, by the way. This is all code switching. I&#8217;m an atheist. I lack a belief in any gods. And I&#8217;m also pretty left-leaning.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> You&#8217;re very left-leaning.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> I&#8217;m basically like your stereotypical, awful, I&#8217;m going to indoctrinate you children into being communists professor. That&#8217;s me.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> Yeah. So we&#8217;re going to dive right in. But just one other thing is that so Michael and I, even though we come from very different disciplinary perspectives, very different political and ethical orientations, we go way back in doing collaboration. So in fact, we go way back to day number one. We both started at Loyola University Chicago 10 years ago. Not our births.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> Not our births. We&#8217;re not born on the same day.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> Although it turns out we both were raised in southern Minnesota, about 30 miles away from each other. So the accents are very similar that you might pick up on. When we go back to day one at Loyola, we actually met at faculty orientation. And from that day forward, started doing first extracurricular stuff. We now teach a class together and end up, we&#8217;ve done fellowships, like residential fellowships together at different places. So we&#8217;ve ended up hanging out a lot together and traveling the country and doing these kinds of talks. Yes.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> Anyway, take it away, Joe. What&#8217;s the proposal?</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> So here&#8217;s the proposal. There are circumstances in which it is morally permissible to design human embryos. And I want to note that we&#8217;ve sort of made a few little changes to the initial title of the talk. So one thing is that instead of just talking about genetic engineering, We&#8217;re going to widen things up just a little bit. Genetic engineering of human embryos is still going to be our primary focus. We&#8217;re also going to gesture to a couple of other ways in which it&#8217;s possible to design human embryos. That&#8217;s the first thing. The other thing that we want you to get to by the end of the discussion today, and we really do want this to be a discussion. So we&#8217;ll have some things to say to you.</p><p>We&#8217;ll be giving you sort of some lecture content for the next while. But by the end, this is a fair warning, is we want you all talking with each other and with us as well. So we&#8217;re going to have some interactive portions to the presentation by the time we get to the end of it. And what we want you to see, among other things, is that when it comes to thinking about ethical issues, especially ethical issues that have to do with emerging technologies, it&#8217;s very typically unproductive to think about answering those issues in a yes or no or black and white kind of way.</p><p>Instead, what we want to do is to introduce you to the issue of genetically modifying human embryos in such a way that we can identify different kinds of circumstances such that the ethical considerations might be different, the science might be different, and the context might be different that might actually change where you lie on that issue. And we&#8217;re going to demonstrate the way in which it changes the place that we lie on that issue. It turns out there are places where Michael and I completely agree with each other, places where we completely disagree, and places where both of us kind of put our hands in the air and are a little bit undecided.</p><p>It also explains sort of that nuance that we wanna get to you to, also explains how we&#8217;ve structured our discussion with you tonight. So what we wanna do is we want to introduce you, first of all, to the relevant science. So we think it&#8217;s really important that to tackle an issue like this, you can&#8217;t just go into this as the ethicist. So I&#8217;m the ethicist, the humanist guy in the room without knowing about the science. So it&#8217;s one reason why Michael and I love presenting together is that he keeps me honest about the science and he&#8217;s going to keep us honest about the science.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> Don&#8217;t believe anything Joe says about science.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> No, you absolutely shouldn&#8217;t. You absolutely shouldn&#8217;t. And that&#8217;s why Burns is here. On the flip side, don&#8217;t believe anything Burns tells you about ethics. That&#8217;s my job is to tell you about the most relevant ethical considerations that you have to do to make decisions about genetically engineering human embryos. And then only then will we get to actual case studies. So again, what we want to get you to is to see it&#8217;s not black and white to say, yes, I&#8217;m in favor of genetically engineering embryos. No, I&#8217;m not in favor of it. Rather, you need to look at very specific case studies and we have some realistic ones. We have some more science fictional ones.</p><p>The idea will be to tease apart your ethical intuitions, your ethical reasons, to see where you land and to see where you differ than me and Michael and where you might be on the same page. So as Michael said, without further ado, you do not want to hear about science from me. So I&#8217;m going to turn the clicker over to Dr. Burns.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> All right. Hello, everybody. Just out of curiosity, how many of you are like STEM, biology, biomedical students and/or faculty? Okay, that&#8217;s a pretty healthy chunk of you. That&#8217;s good. And these people in the house &#8212; hey, they exist. Excellent. So what we&#8217;re gonna talk about is some of the science. So just as a heads up, this is going to be for a general audience. So for those of you who have most recently are currently taking genetics, I know that you know the difference between non-homologous end joining and homology-directed repair. We&#8217;re going to gloss over that for today. Okay, this is going to be important. All right, first off, the genome is a very big place.</p><p>And when I say the genome is a very big place, I mean it is a very big place in that when we say the word big, we basically mean the size of it is actually not intuitively understandable to you. Okay? It turns out that human brains are not very good at depicting very large and very small things. So in this context, this is capital B. In order to try to put this in context, a typical human cell will have 46 chromosomes, so just 46 pieces of DNA. And if you took those 46 pieces and you stretched them out and then stitched them all together into one giant piece of DNA and stretched it out, it would be about two meters long, so a little bit taller than me. So all the way from here, all the way down to the floor would be one DNA molecule.</p><p>That&#8217;s the DNA that you find in one cell. Now it would be incredibly thin because a double helix of DNA cannot be visualized with even light microscopy. Some extra fancy techniques if you want to see it. And then you take all that, you can ball it back up and you stuff it inside the nucleus of a cell, which you probably do need a microscope to see. And that&#8217;s going to be relevant in a moment. All right. Again, for those of you who just need a brief refresher on this, What we&#8217;re talking about here is a human cell, because we&#8217;re focusing on humans tonight. All human cells contain the same DNA in your body, with an asterisk. Okay, there&#8217;s a couple asterisks.</p><p>One of them to bring up, for instance, is that one of the most common types of cells, I think the most common cell type in your body, are your erythrocytes, which are red blood cells. Red blood cells don&#8217;t have any DNA. There&#8217;s no DNA in red blood cells, which is always funny because you watch like a true crime show and they see a blood stain, like, ah, we got to swab the blood stain and we&#8217;re going to figure out who it is. All the red blood stuff that&#8217;s in there, that&#8217;s just a contaminant. You have to work to get rid of it because you&#8217;re actually going to focus on the cells that actually have DNA in there, which are going to be mostly immune cells. Immune cells have them. All right. So red blood cells don&#8217;t, but all the rest of your cells do.</p><p>There&#8217;s the cell. There&#8217;s a thing in the middle called the nucleus. The nucleus contains all the chromosomes and there&#8217;s little regions of the DNA in the genome that are the genes which do stuff. So here&#8217;s the central dogma of biology, which I&#8217;m sure you&#8217;ve all been exposed to before, but we have DNA. It encodes the genes in a series of A&#8217;s and C&#8217;s and T&#8217;s and G&#8217;s. These are the alphabet of DNA. It can be transcribed into messenger RNA and other types of RNA. Messenger RNA gets translated into protein. And proteins are the little nanomachines that get stuff done. Okay? So proteins are the things that get stuff done in a cell and, therefore, in your body.</p><p>If you care about changing the function of your body or your cells, like, well, we need to change what these little nanomachines do. And how are we going to do that? You don&#8217;t want to just target the protein. You&#8217;re going to go all the way back here. You&#8217;re going to identify a gene. You change the gene. You change the RNA that gets made from it. And you change the protein. Okay? This is just setting the stage for everything that we&#8217;re going to talk about here. All right. So how can we alter it? How can we do it? Well, it turns out that human cells spend a lot of effort maintaining their genomes. Okay, we&#8217;re going to anthropomorphize them and say that they care very much about keeping their genomes intact.</p><p>And I also highlighted that each individual cell contains an actually a huge amount of DNA, right? Again, this big, huge, long string of DNA. And your cells want to keep that in. They don&#8217;t want it to get cut. They don&#8217;t want it to get tangled up. They don&#8217;t want to lose track of it. They don&#8217;t want to make more copies of it than they need. So they spend a lot of energy surveilling it and making sure everything&#8217;s hunky-dory with it. And it turns out that these two ladies, Jennifer Doudna and Emmanuel Charpentier, discovered that there are ways that you can hijack it. So they&#8217;re the pioneers of the CRISPR-Cas9 technology, which some of you may have heard of. They won the Nobel Prize in 2020 for that work.</p><p>If you&#8217;re interested in scientific soap operas, you can dig into this particular story. The good news is that these two actually did discover this. They got the Nobel Prize for it. But I believe there are still lingering court cases related to the patents because a bunch of dude bros at the Broad attempted to sort of steal valor from these two by sneaking the patent out from underneath them. Anyway, CRISPR-Cas9. So what we can basically do is we&#8217;re going to take the cell&#8217;s energy while it&#8217;s trying to maintain the genome and hijack that effort to change it. All right. So we&#8217;re going to start with something simple. Here&#8217;s a piece of DNA, double-stranded DNA. These little lines in the middle here indicate A&#8217;s and C&#8217;s and T&#8217;s and G&#8217;s. Those are some DNA.</p><p>And we&#8217;re going to have another piece that we put in here. This is something that you can make in the laboratory. It&#8217;s called a guide RNA. It&#8217;s a short piece of RNA. We talked about RNA before. It&#8217;s different than DNA, but it&#8217;s also made up of letters. And this guide RNA, when you make it synthetically in the laboratory, you get to pick what the letters are that you put in here. And what you&#8217;re going to try to do is if you say, I want to target a gene that&#8217;s got a sequence of A&#8217;s and C&#8217;s and T&#8217;s and G&#8217;s. All you have to do is make a guide RNA that is complementary. It basically has the same sort of sequence that&#8217;s going to match there. You also introduce a Cas9 protein. Again, a protein that&#8217;s a little nanomachine that does something.</p><p>In this case, the protein binds to this guide RNA and will sort of follow it around in the cell. If there&#8217;s a region of the DNA that your guide RNA matches with, Because again, you&#8217;re hoping that this is going to match here. What happens is the Cas9 that it brought along for the ride is going to make a cut right at that spot. It&#8217;s going to cut the DNA at that spot. And then bing, bang, boom, you have a cut in the DNA. Who cares? What does this have to do with editing the genome? It turns out, remember, cells are paying very close attention to what&#8217;s going on with the DNA because there&#8217;s so much of it needs to make sure that it&#8217;s nice and intact. What ends up happening is three different possible outcomes.</p><p>Once the DNA is cut, the first thing that can happen is the cell just repairs that cut correctly. But CRISPR, the CRISPR guide RNA and the Cas9 haven&#8217;t gone anywhere. So they&#8217;re just going to cut it again. And then the cell will repair it. And then it&#8217;ll just get cut again. And then your cell will repair it and it&#8217;ll just get cut again. It&#8217;ll just keep going back and forth. That&#8217;s how that works. And that&#8217;s really boring. The interesting stuff starts happening is when the cell makes a mistake.</p><p>So if the cell tries to fix it, but can&#8217;t quite fix it, and it changes the sequence, it changes the letters that are here, the A&#8217;s and C&#8217;s and T&#8217;s and G&#8217;s don&#8217;t quite work out, this one no longer matches to your guide RNA, which means that the cutting cycle stops, and you have introduced a mutation into the cell. There&#8217;s another even fancier, kind of harder way to do this, where in addition to your guide RNA and your Cas9 nuclease, which is just an enzyme that cuts DNA, you can actually introduce some DNA that&#8217;s like a new gene, for instance, that you want, that you would like to incorporate into the genome, and the cell can at some level introduce this as a type of mutation.</p><p>So you&#8217;ve actually introduced a new function into this part of the genome using this technology, and because this region now no longer has the sequence of the guide RNA, this also will stop the cycle. So these are three different outcomes that you can get from a CRISPR-Cas9 event. And this also explains why it&#8217;s so efficient, because if it doesn&#8217;t do it the first time, it&#8217;s gonna just keep going over and over again until there&#8217;s a change. This is groundbreaking. This is the reason, there&#8217;s a reason they won the Nobel Prize. When I was in graduate school, I actually made transgenic animals, but it was before the CRISPR era, which means I did it the old fashioned way, and it sucked. It took forever. It was incredibly tough to do.</p><p>I would have been much faster if I had access to the CRISPR technology. All right. Now that we have this, it turns out this is actually pretty cheap, pretty straightforward, pretty easy to do. Again, there&#8217;s a reason they won the Nobel Prize. It turns out that one of the hard parts is actually how do you get all this crap inside cells? How do you get this Cas protein and the guide RNA and then maybe some extra DNA into a cell? How do you deliver it? Here are a couple different ways. There are more ways than this. Is just a couple. One of them is using an approach called ex vivo manipulation. So ex vivo just means outside of the organism. So if you&#8217;re talking about humans, maybe there&#8217;s a human who has some sort of an immune disorder that&#8217;s genetic.</p><p>So you&#8217;re going to take some immune cells out of the person. You&#8217;ll pull their blood out. You&#8217;ll filter out the immune cells. And then you can manipulate them in cell culture, which is much easier to do than in the context of doing it inside their body. So you can manipulate them there. You can use a viral vector. So in this case, a viral vector is just using a virus to carry something. That&#8217;s what the vector is. You may have heard, like, there&#8217;s all sorts of interesting science articles and pop-sci news things where they&#8217;re like, scientists cure brain cancer using herpes virus. And you&#8217;re like, that doesn&#8217;t sound right. I don&#8217;t know what&#8217;s going on with that one. They&#8217;re not actually using literal herpes virus.</p><p>What they&#8217;ve done is it turns out that viruses infect specific cell types. And that means that they probably have like a spike protein or a surface protein that will only infect, for instance, neurons. It&#8217;s not going to infect any other cell type; it&#8217;ll infect neurons. And scientists are likely going to steal that piece of the virus, and then the other pieces of the virus they&#8217;re going to replace with stuff that they want. Okay, so that&#8217;s an example of a viral vector. In this case, you could make a virus &#8212; for instance, like, you could steal the surface protein from hepatitis virus, for instance, that infects liver cells, and then have it deliver whatever you want.</p><p>And the thing that maybe you want to deliver is a CRISPR-Cas9 toolkit to a bunch of liver cells. And therefore you&#8217;re using a virus to carry that into your body. There are problems with this one, which we might talk about later. The other one is direct embryo injection. All right, so this is where you literally just say, there&#8217;s one cell that amounts to roughly what&#8217;s going to turn into a whole human being. Let&#8217;s just inject that, okay? Turns out this one&#8217;s the easiest. And here&#8217;s an example. Here&#8217;s a video. So this is a fertilized egg. This is an embryo. It&#8217;s being held by a pipette. So there&#8217;s a little vacuum here that&#8217;s sort of grabbing it.</p><p>And then there&#8217;s a little itty bitty glass needle that they&#8217;re using and they&#8217;re injecting it straight in there. It goes. Baby&#8217;s first vaccine. It&#8217;s not a vaccine. We&#8217;re just delivering it directly to where it needs to go. And then now 100% of the cells that are formed from this particular embryo will have that genetic change carried forward. Easy peasy, right? In other words, it&#8217;s easier to manipulate just one big cell because it turns out that human egg cells are actually pretty big. You can actually see them with the naked eye if you were to find one. That&#8217;s the hard part. Versus the 30 trillion or so cells that make up a human body. Okay. An adult human is literally roughly 30 trillion cells if you&#8217;re just counting the human cells.</p><p>If you start including bacteria and all the other stuff, it gets up to 60, 70 trillion. So one cell versus several trillion cells, which brings us to an ethics break.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> A quick ethics break, folks, brought to you by the philosopher. Sorry, there you go. So the distinction Michael just introduced between these two methods of doing genetic modifications, right? So on the one hand, you have modifying either a group of cells or a targeted tissue, and the other one you&#8217;re modifying an embryo directly. It turns out for reasons that will become apparent as we continue talking, but that&#8217;s one of the most crucial distinctions not only for the science, but also for the ethics of doing genetic modifications to human cells. Because it turns out that when we are doing modifications to groups of cells or to targeted tissues, sometimes called somatic genetic modification in contrast to embryonic or germline modification.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> Somatic just means body cells. And germ cells are? This is a pop quiz. No, it&#8217;s sperm and eggs. Sperm and eggs and then fertilized together will make germ cells. Yeah.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> Yeah, so it turns out that modifying tissues or modifying collections of cells is almost universally agreed upon to be ethically permissible as long as you meet certain conditions. We&#8217;re gonna work through these more as we go, but number one, it&#8217;s permissible as long as, again, it&#8217;s somatic. You&#8217;re doing it to clusters of cells, to tissues, not to human embryos. Number two, it&#8217;s therapeutic. So you&#8217;re doing it to try and fix some genetic disorder or to solve some disease, and you&#8217;re not doing it for the sake of increasing height or making somebody more intelligent. We&#8217;re gonna get to that as well. Something you could totally do, but people will say, well, no, that&#8217;s a little bit dicier.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> Some of those things you can actually do.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> Some, yeah, it&#8217;s a little iffy whether it actually works, but people promise that they can do that. They do. And then finally, if it is in fact well-regulated. So it turns out that when it comes to therapies, we have very good mechanisms already in place by which to approve certain therapies. Think here just about FDA regulation and approval process. And most ethicists will say, look, as long as you are just targeting tissues, as long as you are doing it for therapeutic and not enhancement reasons, and as long as it&#8217;s properly regulated, totally fine ethically. Again, ethicists are a weird bunch. You could probably find somebody who&#8217;s against it, but for the most part, all the humanists&#8212;</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> You guys are the worst</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> Exactly. Everyone lines up on one side of the room and says, yeah, we&#8217;re fine with that. And it&#8217;s a good thing, too, because it turns out that the therapeutic cases of somatic genetic modification are absolutely not just a hypothetical thing, not a thing that we could do that ethicists are saying, oh, that&#8217;s okay, we should do that. It&#8217;s actually something that&#8217;s going on right now. And Michael&#8217;s going to introduce you to one application here that is currently FDA approved.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> Yeah, so this is one that&#8217;s FDA approved. There are several other that are currently in trials for FDA approval, but this is using CRISPR-Cas9 technology to treat a disorder. Okay. This is the website for the pharmaceutical, which is apparently normal. It&#8217;s called exagamaglaginatotimil. I can&#8217;t say it. Doesn&#8217;t matter. That&#8217;s the brand name. It&#8217;s totally fine. It&#8217;s a CRISPR-Cas9 approach. Okay. It&#8217;s treating sickle cell disorders. So sickle cell disorders are like people, for instance, that end up with sickle cell anemia will often have a mutation in a gene that is responsible for the shape and function of red blood cells. We remember red blood cells from before, right? It turns out that red blood cells don&#8217;t have DNA.</p><p>So this becomes tricky, because you&#8217;re like, how in the heck are you gonna treat red blood cells with CRISPR-Cas9 if red blood cells don&#8217;t have DNA? The trick is they&#8217;re not going to. What they&#8217;re going to do is they&#8217;re gonna go back a couple steps, and they&#8217;re going to apply an ex vivo approach and target stem cells. So they&#8217;re gonna target the progenitor cells or the cells that themselves are not red blood cells, but as they grow and divide and mature, they turn into red blood cells. So for patients with this disorder, what they do is they&#8217;re going to stimulate the release of a bunch of these hematopoietic stem cells into the bloodstream. They&#8217;ll collect them by filtering them out of their blood.</p><p>Once they have enough of them, they will genetically modify them with the CRISPR technology outside of the patient&#8217;s body. While that&#8217;s happening, they&#8217;re going to take the patient and treat them with a chemotherapy drug not because they have cancer, but they&#8217;re going to treat them with a chemotherapy drug to basically kill off any of the remaining hematopoietic stem cells. So they&#8217;re going to clear out the compartment that these cells live in to make a nice home so that when they transplant the engineered cells back in, that the transplanted cells engraft, and then when they make new red blood cells, they&#8217;re able to function slightly better. This is not a cure because it&#8217;s not a cure.</p><p>They&#8217;re not actually specifically targeting the mutation that&#8217;s found in the red blood cells. They&#8217;re targeting a regulatory switch that makes it so that these patients have a higher quality of life. And all for the low cost of $2.2 million. It is an incredibly expensive therapy. The chemotherapy is also no joke. It is very unpleasant. But it is an option. And it is an FDA-approved therapy for these sickle cell diseases.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> All right. So another ethics pause. If on the one hand, interventions like that are largely thought to be ethically problematic by most ethicists, again, I&#8217;m sure you could find a naysayer, but most ethicists would say, look, it&#8217;s FDA approved, it&#8217;s a therapy, we&#8217;re improving somebody&#8217;s quality of life, seems a-okay. On the other end of the spectrum, again, for reasons that will become more apparent as we go through this, when it comes to modifying germline cells, when it comes to modifying human embryos, nearly everyone stands opposed to it. So it doesn&#8217;t matter if you&#8217;re progressive or conservative or libertarian or take your pick of ethical or political orientation.</p><p>Basically, everyone right now thinks that going in, and like Michael showed you the video, is using genetic modifying techniques directly on human embryos is an ethical no-go. We&#8217;re going to get to some of the reasons why this is the case and why most cellulose synthesis are totally fine with tissue modification, with somatic modification, and why they&#8217;re totally not okay with embryonic modification. The good news is that no one, right Burns, has attempted to modify human embryos yet.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> Except for this guy, Joe. Yeah. This guy. This guy actually - Anyone seen this guy before? Yeah. He Jiankui, I&#8217;m probably saying his name wrong, genetically modified a couple human embryos. And he didn&#8217;t hide it. He actually released a YouTube video in the year of our Lord 2018 he&#8217;s like you should watch the video that&#8217;s great kind of</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> See the smug smile there you can tell the dude thought I am getting a Nobel Prize like yesterday yeah that&#8217;s the way it turned out right Burns</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> Very strange. Yeah, so he had a YouTube video, he presented at some conferences, and basically he almost squeaked by. Okay, it&#8217;s one of those things where I believe at the time there was not, like, this strict&#8212; like, there wasn&#8217;t a law that said that, you know, you can&#8217;t modify&#8212; well, it was the point where there&#8212;</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> Was such consensus that no one thought you needed laws or actual moratoriums because everyone thought it was a horrible idea until this guy did it like</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> Why would you do it? So he basically almost squeaked by on, like, the <em>Air Bud</em> version of science, for like, there&#8217;s no rule that says that dogs can&#8217;t play basketball, so therefore a dog can play basketball. That&#8217;s a very dated reference, sorry. Anyway, but it turns out that he did go to prison for three years. But he went to prison not specifically because he genetically engineered a human embryo, or two, or three. It&#8217;s because he committed a whole bunch of ethics violations, where he didn&#8217;t fill out the appropriate ethics paperwork. He lied, either directly or by omission, to the donors and the parents of these children, which is a no-no. Yeah. He spends three years in jail, is a huge fine, etc. We&#8217;ll circle back around to this guy.</p><p>It turns out that even though that was the state of the field, again, about eight years ago, the field is still moving quickly. So there are still researchers who are really interested in improving the technology &#8212; not that, of course, we would ever use it on embryos, but they are interested in looking at this technology. This paper came out yesterday, although there was a preprint, for those of you who know what a preprint is, that have been on for several months. But what this research group ended up doing was an advanced version of CRISPR in human embryos. But this is a special type of embryo that&#8217;s not able to be re-implanted and form a person. They&#8217;re just using it as a model system to demonstrate proof of principle.</p><p>And what they ended up doing was taking that little molecular machine that is the Cas9 protein, again, the thing that&#8217;s the scissors, and what they did was they took the part of it that actually is the cutting part, took that off and threw it in the garbage, and they replaced it with something that instead of cutting the DNA into two pieces, all it does is it chemically modifies the letters at that specific site. So it will change an A to a T or a C to a G. So it actually doesn&#8217;t cut the DNA. It just changes what the letter is. And it turns out that&#8217;s actually much less dangerous for a cell because it&#8217;s not as catastrophic as actually breaking the DNA. And they demonstrated that it actually works and seems to be somewhat safer.</p><p>There&#8217;s fewer off target effects as they call them with that new technology. So the field is moving forward. This is done by academics, but don&#8217;t worry. Industry is to the rescue. Industry is paving the way forward. There&#8217;s a company called Preventative, which was formed last year. This one is interesting because one of the co-founders of this is Jennifer Doudna, the aforementioned 2020 Nobel Laureate for discovering the CRISPR-Cas technology. She actually has been very vocal in her skepticism toward using this in human embryos. She&#8217;s very like, there&#8217;s obviously ethical challenges here. We&#8217;ve got to slow roll this. So it&#8217;s interesting that she&#8217;s involved in this industry effort. But I think that could be a good sign.</p><p>You have people who seem to be thinking clearly about this also working in the space with industry groups to work on that. In contrast, we also have two groups. This one&#8217;s called Bootstrap Bio. This one started in 2024. They openly claimed that they were aiming at enhancing intelligence and strength in embryos. So this is not therapeutic. This is just boutique stuff.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> Not doing it, to be clear.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> Not doing it, of course. They&#8217;re just aiming at hypothetically making a product that would do this, which is why the FDA shut them down this year. And then Manhattan Genomics, which was originally named the Manhattan Project.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> I love how they did not consult with their marketing team before branding that project.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> I think they do. I think tech bros for some reason haven&#8217;t quite figured out that when you name your company, you don&#8217;t want to name it after something catastrophic. Palantir, right?</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> I mean, that was a great name.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> Palantir. Meta, for any of you who have read Neal Stephenson&#8217;s book <em>Snow Crash</em>. Yeah, anyway, they basically named themselves after the bad guys for some reason. Anyway, this is funded by a Peter Thiel fellow. Again, this was around for a very short period of time. Basically doing the same thing. Interesting. So, good thing there&#8217;s no problematic designer babies that are on the market, right, Joe? Except for these ones. Okay. So, there&#8217;s other designer babies that are out here. These are just three examples of companies. One&#8217;s called Orchid. One&#8217;s called Nucleus. One&#8217;s called Herisite. There are others, I&#8217;m sure, that are out there. These ones are not doing genetic modification. They&#8217;re not going to use CRISPR. They&#8217;re not going to do anything.</p><p>They&#8217;re gonna do, like&#8212; I just&#8212; as a big loop around to try to get a byproduct that they want. So, for instance, if you&#8217;re like, &#8220;I would like to have a kid, and I want my kid to be really tall, I want to make sure that we get rid of all autism in the field&#8221; &#8212; like, let&#8217;s do that, let&#8217;s figure this out. There&#8217;s a couple things I want to highlight. These are claims that are being made. Some of these guarantees are really far fetched. The likelihood that they will be able to do this is questionable. Even though Herisite, for instance, I believe they have like a I don&#8217;t know if it&#8217;s a money back guarantee or something. So don&#8217;t quote me on this.</p><p>But I believe they in some of their documents, they&#8217;re like, we guarantee that if you select intelligence as a product, your child will have a nine IQ point higher difference than what? I don&#8217;t know. Maybe they have you have twins and then you&#8217;ve got to figure out which one is the smart one? I don&#8217;t know. Anyway, how do they do it? So what they end up doing is when you normally end up having in vitro fertilization, which is what all these companies rely on, they will collect sperm, which is a pretty trivial process. And you can collect a lot of them. That&#8217;s fine. Collecting the eggs is substantially more involved.</p><p>It involves getting hormone treatments and then having eggs drop and then getting a saline flush of the uterus, et cetera, so that they can collect a whole bunch. So they&#8217;re not just going to collect one. They&#8217;re going to get a whole bunch of eggs. What these companies will do is do in vitro fertilization, not for just one egg with one sperm. They will do a panel. So they&#8217;ll do a whole bunch of eggs and a whole bunch of sperm. And then once they have a whole bunch of these embryos, they&#8217;ll allow them to divide once, twice, not very many times. They want to keep them still in the embryonic stage, but they will harvest one or two cells from them and then do single cell whole genome sequencing.</p><p>One from each one of the different embryos that they have, and then they will use the genome information there to try to figure out which traits are correlated with which one of these embryos. So they&#8217;re doing, it&#8217;s called a polygenic score because you&#8217;re not just looking at one gene, you&#8217;re looking at all of the different genes that you&#8217;ve sequenced at the same time. And then as a parent, you get to go to a web form and make your pull-down menu of whatever you want, and then that one gets implanted. It. I believe Elon Musk, for instance, had several children using the Orchid company for doing this stuff.</p><p>So again, not genetic engineering, but is an interesting way to get designer babies without having to deal with the monkeying around with the genome.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> All right. So now that Michael has introduced you to the science of all this, I want to run through not all of the ethical considerations in the same way that Michael didn&#8217;t give you all the scientific background you might need to do to answer some of these questions, but rather kind of give you an ethics 101 crash course in what you need to know to start deciding where you land in the genetic engineering of human embryos. And I&#8217;ve divided up these comments. I&#8217;m going to give you four ethical considerations. The first two are what I&#8217;m going to call practical objections to genetic engineering of human embryos.</p><p>And these are practical in that, as you&#8217;re going to see, they are real ethical considerations, because they have real-world effects of some of the things being proposed. Yet at the same time, they are things that ultimately could be practically solved. So we&#8217;re going to see what we mean in just a second. But there are things that have to do, for instance, with the risks of the procedure, such that if we were to mitigate those risks, then the ethical objection would go away with it. So that&#8217;s really the first one, is this idea that germline gene editing, so again, the gene editing of human embryos, carries significant individual level and population level risks. So where do these come from?</p><p>Michael&#8217;s already introduced you to where these risks come from. So remember that when we go in and modify a cell, whether it&#8217;s a tissue cell or whether it&#8217;s an embryo, there&#8217;s the off chance that rather than affecting the change that you were trying to affect, you instead end up with a random mutation in that cell. Remember that slide where he showed you? At the individual level, that&#8217;s a real risk. I might go in and try and modify an embryo that&#8217;s characterized by Huntington&#8217;s disease or something like that, and I&#8217;m trying to fix it. And I do that, I get the genes out, but in the process, I introduce a novel mutation that in fact is way worse than Huntington&#8217;s would have been. So that&#8217;s an individual level risk.</p><p>What&#8217;s even more important in these conversations, though, are the population-level risks of this kind of procedure. Why? Well, think about it. So if you&#8217;re merely modifying tissue, those modifications could have adverse effects for the individual, but they stay with the individual because it&#8217;s only a localized tissue that&#8217;s been modified. If you go in and modify embryos, every cell in that organism is going to have that modified DNA, which means that their gametes are going to have that modified DNA, which means that if that child eventually grows up and reproduces, and if that child had genetic mutations that were problematic, all of a sudden, all of those mutations enter into the gene pool.</p><p>Now, multiply that by several generations and even, like, a couple of hundred genetically modified babies. All the sudden, you could have hundreds of genetic mutations into the gene pool, and you&#8217;ve got a real problem on your hands on the population level. So if there is no other reason against genetic engineering human embryos, this is the reason near everyone points to and says, that&#8217;s way too risky. Whenever we do new research, we always do some form of cost-benefit analysis, and nearly everyone, again, except for our buddy, Dr. John Cui, has pointed to this and been like, you do the cost-benefit analysis.</p><p>If this goes south even a little bit, and all of a sudden, all these genetically modified babies start reproducing, and they pass along these mutations, we could have species-wide chaos in the gene pool. Better not to start down that path until we get things perfected. So that&#8217;s one significant objection. In some ways, the most significant, because it&#8217;s the reason why we&#8217;ve seen such consensus in the ethical community against genetic modification of human embryos is the huge risk at the population level. There&#8217;s also though a different kind of risk at the population level. And it&#8217;s one that&#8217;s illustrated well by this picture. Now you might look at this picture and wonder why are Joe and Michael showing us a whole bunch of people in their underwear?</p><p>Anyone know what this picture is of or any guesses? You might not recognize any of these people, but what might you guess these individuals have in common? That wasn&#8217;t just rhetorical, any guesses? Yes. Exactly. Not only are they athletes, they are in fact Olympians. And Michael and I were talking before this, we don&#8217;t know which year team it is, but it&#8217;s one of, there&#8217;s a javelin thrower in here. So it&#8217;s a summer Olympic team. I don&#8217;t know which year it was. Maybe you recognize some of the Olympians. And as you look at these people, what stands out very quickly is that this is a genetically diverse group of people, right?</p><p>We have very large people, very small people, very tall people, very short people with very long torsos and very long legs and sort of all over the place, right? As you know, every time you watch the Olympics, part of the reasons people that succeed in the Olympics at that high of a level is genetically determined. So like Michael and I were not destined to be gymnasts.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> I mean, I was in gymnastics for several years when I was very young. Okay. But it did not take, it did not take, and it wasn&#8217;t meant to be. I was only in there because my older sister was there and my mom didn&#8217;t want to drive me anywhere else.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> As a parent of four children, it&#8217;s a classic parenting move. You just, you sign all the kids up for one activity</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> And I was the only boy in the class yeah I got very flexible though it was nice</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> There you go. You had a future, Burns. So what this goes to show is that genetic diversity plays into human achievement, right? If we start modifying human embryos, there&#8217;s inevitably going to be a kind of leveling effect in which certain traits are selected for over others, and certainly certain genetically outliers are not even considered. Well, what&#8217;s a group of Olympians, but a group of genetic outliers in many ways? And this generalizes beyond athletics, right? Many times it&#8217;s precisely genetic outliers in different ways, whether it&#8217;s IQ or ability or nurturing, but there&#8217;s sort of all these different ways where you could look. And it&#8217;s often genetic outliers that for our species, really great benefits across the species.</p><p>It&#8217;s sort of what human achievement looks like a lot of the time. So there&#8217;s also this risk at the population level that if we go down the road of modifying human embryos, we end up eliminating a lot of the benefits that come from genetic diversity. There&#8217;s also a purely evolutionary reason to think that genetic diversity in a population is good. Suppose, for instance, that a superbug comes into this population that selects precisely for really tall people. Tall people are fine. Cataclysm. Yeah. Or selects for really short people. Right? You could pick your trait, but everyone gets wiped out except for one genetic outlier.</p><p>This is precisely why genetic diversity is really important for selective fitness at the population level, is it turns out &#8212; for those of you who have done some evolutionary theory, you know that the more genetic diversity you enjoy in a population, the more that you&#8217;re able to resist selective pressures. So it actually turns out that modifying embryos would have this leveling effect that, at the population level, would have these risks, both associated with introduced mutations, but would also be risky in that it would make our species as a whole more susceptible to outside dangers and selective pressures.</p><p>So all this goes to show, right, is that there&#8217;s these really significant individual, but even more importantly, population level risks of modifying human embryos. They are risks that could be overcome. So there&#8217;s ways that we could figure out to advance the technology and overcome the problems with random mutation. There&#8217;s ways we could try and ensure the right amount of genetic diversity in a population, but there are risks that so far have been significant enough that have basically led everyone with the exception of a few people to say, not a good idea to go down that road. Here&#8217;s a different kind of what I&#8217;m thinking about as practical objections to genetically modifying embryos.</p><p>And that&#8217;s this problem of the fact that genetic modification of human embryos will inevitably be very unfairly and unjustly distributed. Michael mentioned the therapy that is approved and has the $2.2 million price tag. I guarantee you that if we go down the road of starting to do genetic modification on embryos, it&#8217;s not your average person in the street that&#8217;s going to have access to designer baby technology. It&#8217;s going to be the billionaire class, the Silicon Valley class, and the rest of us are left with just our regular old ways of reproducing, which isn&#8217;t actually that bad. But it&#8217;s a technology though that clearly, if it&#8217;s made available, is going to be made available in an unjust and unfair way.</p><p>We&#8217;ve all seen the Netflix mini series about the society in which all the resources and new biological technology are given to one class and everyone else is left down in the streets to scrap whatever they can have. Now, this is a really important ethical consideration. I also, when I teach this to my students, I always emphasize that it&#8217;s not a knockdown argument against genetic engineering. Why? Basically, any technological or medical intervention, sometimes forever, but almost always at its inception, is unjustly and unfairly distributed. When we first had organ transplantation, did everyone get an organ? Of course not. Novel chemotherapies. Do particularly vulnerable populations get them?</p><p>No, it&#8217;s people with really good health insurance that are getting those. Yet we think that it&#8217;s good to develop new chemotherapies. We think that organ transplantation is good and so on and so forth. So this is a really important ethical consideration, but it&#8217;s also one that I really would encourage you to think is not a knockdown one just because there&#8217;s going to be injustice in distribution. It&#8217;s obviously something we should be concerned about. It&#8217;s also something that is true of almost any new intervention, any new technology, any new breakthrough. It winds up being distributed in unfair ways. All right, so those are the first two objections, considerations I want you to think about when it comes to editing human embryos.</p><p>They are also both solvable objections. If we&#8217;re able to mitigate the risks at the individual and population level that come with genetically modifying embryos, and if we&#8217;re able to figure out just patterns of distribution, both of those two objections largely go out the window. So that&#8217;s call purely moral objections to genetically modifying human embryos. So these are concerns that apply even if we were able to mitigate all the risks, even if we were able to figure out ways of justly distributing the technology that still apply nevertheless. They&#8217;re sort of internal to the process itself. Here&#8217;s the first one.</p><p>Is that when we think about the sorts of paradigms and value systems that would inform a society in which we are genetically modifying human embryos, it can get very dark very quickly and very eugenics seeming very quickly. Michael already showed you the slide in which people are selecting for things like intelligence and height. And you could sort of add, right, what other things might people try to select for? Athletic ability, IQ. Maybe people are selecting for things like race and hair color and sort of these other things. And what you end up is this view of human flourishing and view of what you want for your children that ends up being a very reductive and very limited view of what it looks like to have a good human life.</p><p>Potentially winds up being a racist and sexist and ableist view of what it turns out to be a good human life. But it for sure winds up being something very thin and limiting from the sidelines of what might count as a flourishing human life. I actually think this for sure applies to sort of the enhanced designer baby conversation, right? Because, again, the things that won&#8217;t come up in those conversations &#8212; we want athletes who have really high IQs and look in a particular way that&#8217;s a standard of beauty right now &#8212; and that really smacks of eugenics right away. I actually think though that this also applies in therapeutic contexts. What if we start genetically modifying embryos at a large scale and start eliminating things like Down syndrome?</p><p>We start eliminating ADHD, autism, sort of you can go down the list. What does that wind up with? Well, in some ways we&#8217;ve cured some disorders, but we also have this very flat society and a flat way of understanding human flourishing. If you know anyone with Down syndrome, you know that people with Down syndrome are capable of a flourishing life. It&#8217;s maybe a life that looks different from people who don&#8217;t have Down syndrome, but it&#8217;s absolutely still a flourishing life. Think about people with autism who are capable of making great contributions and flourishing as well. So even in therapeutic contexts, I do worry about sort of this flattening effect of modifying embryos that ends up saying, that&#8217;s what we mean by a flourishing human life.</p><p>And all these other kinds of human life, we don&#8217;t want that. And that&#8217;s deeply problematic. Here&#8217;s the last one, and this is probably the most controversial one, so it&#8217;s one I&#8217;m going to spend just a few minutes on. I want to run an objection for you to modifying human embryos that suggests that modifying human embryos genetically is always morally problematic because what it winds up doing is treating human beings as a product or commodity rather than as a bearer of dignity. When we genetically modify human embryos, we quite literally make babies.</p><p>And in doing that, we&#8217;re treating a human being as something to be produced, to be bought and sold on the market, which is something that undermines our status as beings that bear infinite and inherent dignity. So this idea is coming out of my own Catholic tradition and way of approaching ethical issues, but I wanna motivate it for you in just two different ways that might land if you&#8217;re part of that tradition, but also if you&#8217;re outside of it. So the first one comes from our previous Pope Francis, talked a lot about what he called - Not from Chicago. Not the Chicago Pope, in case you&#8217;re wondering. We never cease to tire of reminding people. Chicago Catholics especially, that&#8212; yeah, he&#8217;s&#8212; he&#8217;s our Pope, right?</p><p>Pope Francis, so the previous Pope, talked a lot about the technocratic paradigm, and the technocratic paradigm he thought was a bad thing. It&#8217;s a way of understanding our relationship to technology in the world that we live in that he thought was pervasive in modern culture, and ultimately a very bad part of modern culture. At the heart of the technocratic paradigm is the understanding of ourselves as primarily manipulators of matter. Like what we do as humans is manipulate the world around us, and the world as nothing more than matter to be manipulated. And Pope Francis thought that understanding of ourselves and the world around us is what was at heart of the environmental crisis.</p><p>He also thought it was at the heart of sort of a diminished understanding of ourselves. We ruin the environment because we think it&#8217;s just our thing to manipulate and play with, but we also degrade ourselves because we understand ourselves as merely the people who sort of mess with nature and do what we want with it. I propose that genetically modifying human embryos is the absolute pinnacle of the technocratic paradigm because with genetically modifying human embryos, we both are the manipulator and the matter to be manipulated. We reduce ourselves to nothing more than just matter and genes to be played around with. And in doing so, we turn ourselves into products and commodities and that fundamentally undermines our status as dignified human beings.</p><p>One other analogy, and it is an analogy, it&#8217;s not a perfect one, but I think it&#8217;s one that might get you to think a little bit about this idea that genetically modifying human embryos is always wrong in any case. And that&#8217;s an analogy that we can draw with human slavery. So I think all of us can agree that human slavery is morally horrible, and is so for a number of ways. One of the ways that it&#8217;s horrible is the fact that we think it&#8217;s just simply wrong for one human to be a product or something that can be bought and sold, that&#8217;s a fundamental undermining of our dignity as a human being. Now, suppose, though, that we could imagine someone in a pro-slavery camp. I don&#8217;t even know. That is still a thing, unfortunately, right?</p><p>But you could imagine someone who says something like, but what if, what if I could prove to you that in these conditions, you could be a slave and also live a perfectly happy life? We&#8217;re going to do a whole bunch of psychological measures and prove to you this person is genuinely happy. Moreover, what if this person&#8217;s owners were loving and caring and nurturing? You would, I hope, look at that and say, okay, I guess it&#8217;s better to be happy than not happy, and it&#8217;s good to have loving relationships. Yeah, but that&#8217;s not the problem. The problem here is one person owning another person. That&#8217;s the problem. The problem doesn&#8217;t have to do with psychological flourishing. The problem has to do with treating a person as a commodity or as a product.</p><p>I think you can run a similar argument when it comes to genetically modifying human embryos, right? Because you might run the argument and say, well, what if I could prove to you that a genetically modified child could grow up to have a perfectly happy and flourishing life? What if I could prove to you that we&#8217;re only going to allow parents who are going to love that child and nurture that child and be kind to that child to undergo this process. What I would argue is that&#8217;s a similar kind of argument to the happy slave argument. So, yeah, of course it would be good for someone to be genetically modified and live a happy life and have good parents and all, but that&#8217;s not the point.</p><p>The point is that the process itself treats that person as a product, as a commodity to be bought and sold. So from the very beginning, the process implicitly builds in a demeaning of human dignity and an undermining of human dignity. All right. That is the ethics that we wanted to introduce you to. It is not all the ethical considerations of modifying human embryos, but it&#8217;s enough to get us started. We have now reached the point in our presentation where things get more interactive. So look at the people sitting next to you. You&#8217;re about ready to start chatting with them a little bit. Condolences. Yeah. What we have for you is a series of case studies that start out more realistic and get progressively maybe a little bit weirder.</p><p>What we hope that they do is that they&#8217;re able to both tease out where Michael and I are on the same page as each other and differ from each other. Because it turns out, again, kind of go back to the framing, we not only come from different disciplines but very different political and ethical orientations. We don&#8217;t agree with each other on a lot of these cases. But also, just as importantly, for you to tease out where you think you lie to see, oh, I agree with those two guys, or I disagree with both of them, or I agree with one, I&#8217;m team Joe or team Michael. So we really want you to discern where you lie on some of these cases as well. We&#8217;re going to start out with an easy one and one in which you do not have to discuss.</p><p>And that&#8217;s this case, which is in some ways, maybe the case you thought you were going to come here to hear about, which is right now, as in given current technology, we should start tomorrow, like over at the hospital, we&#8217;re going to do this. We&#8217;re going to do this tomorrow. And right, we&#8217;ve got the tech. We absolutely could do it. It&#8217;s been done before. We&#8217;re going to start modifying human embryos right this second. The reason that we&#8217;re not giving you this as an actual case study is that, here we have some pictorial depictions of Michael and I and our buddy, Dr. He Jiankui, is that when it comes to this question, for reasons that you now understand, basically everyone except Dr. He is against it.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> By the way, he&#8217;s back. I mentioned that he got out of prison. He&#8217;s out of prison and then he almost immediately sort of got his hands on about $10 million in dark money.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> So somebody is into this and is giving him money, but we don&#8217;t know who these people are.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> Either he&#8217;s crowdsourcing this and there&#8217;s a whole bunch of people giving him five bucks, or there&#8217;s like one or two tech billionaires that are just funding development of this tech. He&#8217;s made, I think, three announcements in the last several years about starting a laboratory. No new baby announcements. But nothing&#8217;s really actually materialized.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> Although he&#8217;s learned what happens when he makes the baby announcement is it&#8217;s not a good outcome for him. So he might be keeping it under wraps.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> No more YouTube videos for him.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> Yeah. So this is, again, maybe the question you thought you were coming here to discuss, but hopefully what we&#8217;ve said so far is enough to show you that basically everyone agrees that this is just not a good idea right now. And Michael and I, for reasons that we&#8217;ve gone over, if nothing else, for the reason of the tremendous population level risk that this would cause, are against it. And we don&#8217;t even need you to discuss this one, because we assume that, based on what we&#8217;ve done so far&#8212; I don&#8217;t know, if you&#8217;re really for it, we&#8217;d love to talk to you&#8212; but we assume that you will stand with, like, 99% of the world&#8217;s population and say, seems like a really bad idea to do that right now. Yeah.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> One other point to put on this is that Joe just finished up the ethics discussion, which is very convincing, Joseph. I do disagree with him on a bunch of that stuff. Even in the cases where we agree, we&#8217;re hoping that what we&#8217;re going to get across to you is that even when we agree, oftentimes we agree but for totally different reasons. And this is actually one of them.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> So actually, the risk thing I obviously think is important, but the train already left the station, because I think it&#8217;s just always wrong, and Burns thinks that it&#8217;s sometimes okay, maybe. As we&#8217;re gonna see, there&#8217;s gonna be some cases that tease us apart a little bit. Okay, so that&#8217;s case number one. We&#8217;re just gonna skip over the rest of it. Case number two: the reason Michael and I are in the middle is not that we&#8217;re wishy-washy, it&#8217;s that we want you to discuss where you lie before we do the grand reveal and show you where we are at. Yeah.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> So this one &#8212; has anybody ever seen the movie <em>Children of Men</em>? It&#8217;s about 10 years old now. It&#8217;s a really good movie.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> All of our cultural references&#8212;</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> We&#8217;re getting too old. I apologize. They need to splice it up into a whole bunch of little teeny TikToks or YouTube Shorts, and then you can watch it. That&#8217;s a ding against your generation. Anyway, in the movie <em>Children of Men</em> &#8212; spoiler &#8212; the population has hit a catastrophe, and the catastrophe is that no one is having babies anymore, not because they don&#8217;t want to, but because everyone, for some mysterious, serious reason, is suddenly sterile. Like they just can&#8217;t have babies. They can&#8217;t figure it out. The population is aging, but like no one&#8217;s having any babies. Okay. This is a population level threat as in like humanity is going to go extinct because at some point, if you don&#8217;t have kids, there&#8217;s no replacement. Suppose this is us. Yeah.</p><p>Suppose this is us. And then hypothetically, if you&#8217;re a biological scientist, you&#8217;re like, we have the technology. We could probably fix this. We can do all sorts of, we actually skipped over some of the more wacky stuff that we can do. For instance, they&#8217;ve made, they&#8217;ve had mice where they actually have had mice that have had two mothers, which is an interesting thing to think about. And they do that by doing all sorts of interesting swapping of nuclei and genetic material and so forth. So we can do all sorts of cool stuff. We just don&#8217;t because of the cost benefit analysis in terms of risk. Let&#8217;s say that hypothetically some scientists figured out a way to make babies happen by genetically modifying embryos. Bing, bang, boom, problem solved.</p><p>What we would like for you to do is turn to the person next to you and sort of chat and see do you think that is a good idea? We should do that to save the population. You don&#8217;t know or absolutely not. This is a terrible idea.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> And one thing to emphasize here is this is given current technology. So all the risks remain the same. All the stuff remains the same that we just talked about. It&#8217;s just that if we don&#8217;t do it in this case, the species is likely toast. Yeah.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> All right. Chat with your neighbors. You might want to say hello. What&#8217;s your name, et cetera. Yeah. All right. We&#8217;re going to come back together and we&#8217;re going to figure out what the actual true correct answer is for this one.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> Do we have any volunteers? We&#8217;ll tell you what Michael and I think, but we want to hear from at least one or two people first. We want to hear from you folks to see if you get it right.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> Any hands. This is the important thing. Yes.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> Yeah, whatever you talk about.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> And again, I&#8217;m being sarcastic about saying what&#8217;s right or wrong. A lot of this is just sort of like, what did your group think and maybe why? Where did you folks land?</p><p><strong>Audience Member:</strong> Okay, so there was four of us and we&#8217;re split 50-50.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> Perfect.</p><p><strong>Audience Member:</strong> So I said against just because that argument you made at the end where in general, like if you could, obviously this is a very grim circumstance and no one would want the human race to end. But if you employ that technology and actually use it just to make us happier and to feel better about the human race continuing, you are still at the end of the day, treating other humans like a commodity and making them to fulfill your own pleasure. And yeah, I think that just undermines inherent dignity. So I would say against even though that would suck</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> Good. So you also layered in, sort of, you&#8217;re making very important decisions for somebody else based on your own, like, &#8220;I want to see my species continue.&#8221; Good. Did we have anyone that either disagreed on the total opposite or had a different take? Yes, there&#8217;s a microphone back there</p><p><strong>Audience Member:</strong> So we discussed the sociological impacts of an entire our species going extinct. So you kind of see this in populations where they have an aging population and no new generation to replace the workforce. So what would the sociological impacts be if we all knew we were going extinct? Would there be new resource wars? Would there be an extreme&#8212;</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> You should watch the movie.</p><p><strong>Audience Member:</strong> I think I&#8217;ve seen it. Oh, you have? Hugh Jackman?</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> It is somebody that is the same flavor of actor, yeah. Okay.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> Same kind of era too.</p><p><strong>Audience Member:</strong> Yeah, but what kind of hedonism might happen? We can be very self-destructive. We&#8217;re destroying the Earth right now. If we all knew we were going to go extinct, what would happen to the rest of the planet?</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> Yeah, good. And I think too, sort of the sociological angle is one that we didn&#8217;t touch on here. The sociology of having, in this case, a whole generation of designed children, but even sort of injecting some design children into society &#8212; it is sort of&#8212; I think you could argue either direction, potentially, but there&#8217;s definitely going to be sociological changes if all of a sudden new generations are relating to previous generations in a way that they know they were designed by them, right? Very strange stuff. Do we want to do the reveal, Burns?</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> Sure, let&#8217;s see.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> This might not be that surprising. Yeah. Ah, and we were very careful about exactly where we put our floating heads here. So again, I&#8217;m against it, for reasons that should already be clear. I just think there&#8217;s&#8212; there&#8217;s basically no justification for it, and this is even population-level extinction. I think we can never justify the end by saying&#8212; we can never justify the means by point looking to the end. And if the end here is some sort of violation of human dignity, we shouldn&#8217;t go there. Burns, why are you where you&#8217;re at?</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> I would argue that it is acceptable but not required. So I&#8217;d say if people are like, yes, we should do it, that&#8217;s fine. And the reason that I would bring this up is because people aren&#8217;t doing it for boutique reasons. They&#8217;re not doing it for design reasons. It&#8217;s for survival of the species, which is literally already why people oftentimes will end up having kids, is that they would like to have offspring. They would like the continuation to happen, which makes, in this context, making it a fancy version of reproduction and not the same type of thing that you would see if you were doing other types of in vitro fertilization coupled with genetic engineering. That&#8217;s my argument anyway.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> New case study. So in this case, we are going to fast forward. We&#8217;re not worried about <strong>Children of Men</strong>. So we&#8217;re going to sideline that one. We are no longer facing a species-level extinction event. This is just plain old us. And we&#8217;re going to fast forward two or three decades, to the point&#8212; to, our number one, we have mitigated the risks. So it&#8217;s probably not CRISPR-Cas9 anymore; we&#8217;ve figured out a better technology that doesn&#8217;t have the same individual or population-level risks. We also have sort of controlled for genetic diversity, so we make sure that we&#8217;re not going to have sort of a very, you know, just one kind of person, and we&#8217;re going to make sure we&#8217;re safe at the population level.</p><p>And we&#8217;ve also developed a technology far enough that it is wildly inexpensive. So the idea, I think, Michael and I had here coming up with this scenario: this is like the strip mall genetic engineering, where you go to your local strip mall and you pop into Chipotle, you get your burrito, then you pop into the next store. Is there a Hot Topic? I don&#8217;t know if Hot Topic&#8212; it was a big thing when I was in high school. You&#8217;re going to Hot Topic, and then you go to the next door, and somebody gives you an iPad when you walk in. It says, oh, you want a baby? Here you go. You get to select your features, and you can select, yeah, medium height, strong, that sounds good. And, oh, we get some, like, bonus options: I want my kid to have some feathers. Yeah.</p><p>Pick whatever you want, right? You basically can select your kid from an iPad. It&#8217;s wildly inexpensive. And however many months later, there the kid shows up on your door from your new Amazon delivery guy. So this is the next scenario. Wildly inexpensive, wildly accessible. And we&#8217;ve solved the basic risk kind of problems. Are you OK with this one or not? I&#8217;m going to give you, again, just like two or three minutes. You can just turn to the same group and chat about what you would do with this one.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> All right. Let&#8217;s come on back together. And we&#8217;re going to, again, figure out what the justifications for or against this might be.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> We need a couple more volunteers. Anyone have a hot take? Or even if you don&#8217;t want to share your take, what somebody else in your group said that you thought was particularly insightful.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> Yeah, if somebody next to you said something funny, you should do it. Yeah, there you go.</p><p><strong>Audience Member:</strong> So when I was thinking about this question, I think of a lot of modern technological advancements and the fact that they do happen. So if I am in favor for it or against it, that&#8217;s not really a huge consideration. What I think of more is that a society&#8217;s values. You were talking about the idea of, I forget the exact term, but the idea that we are manipulating matter. If we&#8217;re in, you know, a couple of decades out, we&#8217;re in a society that views, you know, ourselves as like we&#8217;re imposing our will and manipulating matter, then no, I would be against this sort of technology.</p><p>But if we&#8217;re able to develop as a society to have something more, maybe, empathy-based, where it&#8217;s, let&#8217;s design the baby based on empathy for its future experiences and how it&#8217;s going to live, I feel like in that sort of society I would be very much in favor of it.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> So are you saying&#8212; and I&#8217;m just going to echo back to you what I think I heard you say&#8212; which is, if the technology is here and there are people using it, could be that the underlying motivations and how it&#8217;s implemented, like the rationale for it, might really color where you&#8217;re&#8212; you&#8217;re going to land on this. Yeah.</p><p><strong>Audience Member:</strong> Cause if you have like Hollywood type, make everyone look hot and that&#8217;s not hot. Exactly. But if you have an idea where it&#8217;s, you know, certain conditions like sickle cell anemia, that&#8217;s never going to improve someone&#8217;s life. It&#8217;s only ever going to really&#8212;</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> Giant asterisk. Good. There&#8217;s&#8212; yeah. Good.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> Good. So, I mean, we, again, we can imagine the Netflix series of both those directions, right? The one where it&#8217;s like, this is sort of with a super dark gloss and there&#8217;s this sort of eugenics-tinged kind of strip mall genetic engineering. But you can imagine the one that&#8217;s maybe not as fun to watch, but the one that you&#8217;d be more willing to embrace. The one that&#8217;s like, no, everyone&#8217;s got benevolence and we want to get pass on as good of traits as we can to the next generation. And we&#8217;ve defined those good traits in a way that&#8217;s empathetic and not sort of smacking of all the bad sort of stuff.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> By the way, this is actually epitomized by the contrast between <em>Brave New World</em> and <em>1984</em>. If any of you are science fiction nerds. Yeah. Any other volunteers? We&#8217;ll get one more. Another one over here. Hey, there we go. Easy peasy.</p><p><strong>Audience Member:</strong> So I was thinking, like, to me, this question kind of boiled down to natural selection versus artificial selection, which I think helps me figure out my overall view on the topic. But to me, when I think of like, natural selection, and if I compared that to like the type of artificial selection that&#8217;s in this situation, I would think like nature is so much wiser because nature chooses based on survival, whereas, you know, artificial selection or sexual selection is, you know, more prone to features that are not necessarily going to benefit us as a species. And so for that reason, that makes me think that we should try to preserve natural selection over artificial selection.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> Good. Yeah. And it turns out that the science bears this out. This is, don&#8217;t take my word with science, but I love that I have Burns here to correct me if I&#8217;m getting it wrong. Don&#8217;t worry, I&#8217;ll tell you when you&#8217;re wrong. Yeah, good. But it turns out that a lot of traits that you might think were selectively advantageous or desirable turn out not to be. So being very tall turns out to have bad effects on like your hips it actually kind of sucks</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> I mean I say that I actually like being tall but my back hurts all the time but</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> Yeah, it turns out that&#8212; it also turns out that one hypothesis of why Homo sapiens beat out Neanderthals is that Neanderthals had too much muscle and that they took more caloric intake. Is this true?</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> There are hypotheses that Homo&#8212; well, there&#8217;s a couple&#8212; oh my god, how do I not go off on a wild tangent here? Neanderthals were way more muscular and higher bone density, which means they would require a higher caloric intake, which means they were at a slight disadvantage in one of the more recent ice ages, when it was harder to get calories. Okay.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> So all I have to say is that like being taller and super ripped might be something that people would want to choose, but I think this is the point that you were making, right? Where nature is actually wiser and says, actually those two traits have some advantages, but they also carry disadvantages as well.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> Maybe you need short svelte people with low muscle mass because you&#8217;re easy to maintain. Your back probably doesn&#8217;t hurt.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> So where do we lie Burns? Here&#8217;s where we&#8217;re at. It turns out we&#8217;re basically, we&#8217;re more aligned on this one. So again, my reasons are pretty boring. I just think it&#8217;s always bad. Burns, why are you over in my camp for this one?</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> Mostly, I think probably related to some of the stuff that you were saying and a little of the stuff that you were saying. So we hit on both of these. The big one I think has to do with what it looks like for the population. One of the arguments I have against it that I don&#8217;t like is because it&#8217;s&#8212; it&#8217;s, on its surface, it&#8217;s just kind of superficially gross, and it would look gross. Because you know how there&#8217;s this weird thing where people talk about, like, Boomers and Millennials and Gen Z? Imagine if&#8212; what that would look like when you&#8217;re ordering boutique babies as a generation. Like, the generations would literally be physically, genetically distinct.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> Yes when you called somebody a millennial or because they had like giant eyebrows or something because that was in for a couple there would be some weird</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> Thing that popped up, which is probably going to be a strange thing for society. That is a kind of a trivial superficial thing. I think the bigger one is that it&#8217;s the same reason why the eugenicists are wrong and have been wrong forever. The reason the eugenicists are wrong is because they&#8217;re presuming that they know what the optimal human being looks like. And the piece that they&#8217;re leaving out is the optimal human being under what circumstances in which environment. And if you may have heard like evolution has stopped or the idiocracy theory where like evolution has stopped because every human being, no matter how bad your vision is or whatever weird thing is going on with you, they&#8217;re just in the population now, evolution&#8217;s not doing its job.</p><p>And that is completely backward. Evolution is absolutely doing its job, which is when there are not selective pressures, when like you don&#8217;t have half the population dying at childbirth. The thing that evolution does is it diversifies. You diversify the population as much as possible. You want every kind of weirdo you can get in the population because you don&#8217;t know what the next selective pressure is going to be. If we do this type of stuff, we&#8217;re probably going to be introducing some weird artificial selections to reduce the diversity of the population, which means as a society, as a species, we&#8217;re probably setting ourselves up for failure.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> And here&#8217;s where I actually agree with Michael on the overall conclusion, and even agree sort of with the framing, but maybe disagree with the reasons. So I&#8217;m less concerned about selective pressure, even though I think that&#8217;s a real thing. I am more concerned with the idea of the flattening of accounts of human flourishing to just certain kinds of lives and certain kinds of individuals. So even if the selective pressure thing wasn&#8217;t there, I would still say I think you can flourish as someone who might be selected out of this kind of framework, right? Again, somebody with Down syndrome, or somebody with autism, or something. I would say, no, there&#8217;s multiple kinds of human flourishing.</p><p>And the danger here is that we have one particular kind of human flourishing that we&#8217;re selecting for and then eliminating all the diversity of human flourishing from the picture. Okay.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> I just want to, before we move on, just one thing. I want to make this very clear. When people talk about diversity in modern society right now, especially in the news, oftentimes they use the term diversity derisively, like, oh, stupid diversity, blah. What they don&#8217;t understand is that from a functional perspective, diversity is actually a superpower for biological organisms. The fact that we have diverse populations is the reason that we&#8217;re able to even exist in the first place. That&#8217;s it. You want case study foreburns? Sure. All right, we&#8217;re going to fast forward again. We can genetically engineer gametes with a therapeutic cocktail.</p><p>So when prospective parents reproduce naturally, so there&#8217;s no in vitro fertilization here, there&#8217;s no monkey in with stuff in a petri dish, they pass these protections on to their offspring. So a couple pieces. It&#8217;s therapeutic only. So we&#8217;re not going to do any boutique stuff. And then the second thing is when we say engineer gametes, that means that I would go to the doctor and say, fix my boy parts so that when I have babies, the babies now have repaired whatever the hell is wrong with me. And same thing for ladies. You go in, get your ovaries fixed so that all of the eggs that you have now have that so that when you have babies, again, you have fixed that in the population.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> Yeah, so this is a bit of a twist because we&#8217;re no longer modifying embryos, we&#8217;re modifying gametes, and we&#8217;re no longer doing anything enhancing. We&#8217;re just, you know, we&#8217;re gonna go in, no more Huntington&#8217;s, we can kind of eliminate all these things that are nasty genetic diseases. And maybe like, you know, include some like immunity to the flu and COVID and stuff too, why not? All right, what do you think about this one? Take another three minutes. Chat away. Yes, question.</p><p><strong>Organizer:</strong> We&#8217;ve got five minutes left.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> All right, we&#8217;re going to go real quick here because the last one&#8217;s a doozy. We got this one and then one more. Does anybody have any strong opinions about this one? Yes, no, yay, nay? One volunteer. This fella over here.</p><p><strong>Audience Member:</strong> Okay, I think for me this was one of the easier ones to say yes to, or even come up with a position in the first place, because I think the restriction that it&#8217;s strictly therapeutic, with none of the boutique stuff, is really, like, narrows down the problems I would have with this. So I am fairly in favor of this, because I imagine this as, like, if it&#8217;s like kind of genetic counseling plus steps. You know how a lot of people, before having kids, have like a marriage genetic counseling to figure out if there&#8217;s a risk that their kids might have some genetic disease or the other? So this is like, oh, they might have this, but you can, like, get this injection, get fixed before you have kids, so that they don&#8217;t have this genetic disease.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> True.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> Good. Yeah, and actually, I think maybe for this reason, this is the one where I am maybe okay with this one. It strikes me like, in this case, you&#8217;re primarily treating parents rather than creating children. So I have to think about this one more. Burns and I were kind of coming up with these scenarios, but this is the only one where I thought, maybe I&#8217;d be okay with that. Yeah.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> This is a tough one. Yeah. Let&#8217;s do one more and then see what you... Oh, sure. What&#8217;s the question?</p><p><strong>Audience Member:</strong> Yeah. I was just thinking about that as this... I do have a little bit of an issue. I think if this was done in a widespread way, you would eradicate certain disabilities, which might be various ways of human flourish. So I do take a little bit of pause on this one.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> My suspicion would be that there would be an awful lot of ethical wrangling by ethics boards in the same way that there were for the somatic CRISPR cell therapies that are already available. So for instance, sickle cell disease might be something that they target with this type of thing. I don&#8217;t know a lot of people are gonna be like, no, it&#8217;s vitally important that we keep this disease. In the population. And there are probably a short list of diseases that fall within that category, but the stuff that&#8217;s at the gray area where we might not quite know whether or not it&#8217;s a good idea to get rid of would be where there&#8217;s a lot of argument.</p><p><strong>Audience Member:</strong> That seems right.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> Okay, do we wanna do the last one or do a couple questions, Burns? We&#8217;re basically at time. So we had one more that&#8217;s really fun, but we&#8217;re gonna save it. If anyone&#8217;s really interested, we can tell you about it.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> We&#8217;ll have a real juicy one if you stick around afterwards.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> But if anyone has a question or two, we&#8217;re also gonna hang out. We&#8217;re from Chicago and are not spending the night in Chicago tonight so we can stick around and chat with anyone who wants to stay</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> All night long because our flight is at 6 o&#8217;clock in the morning it&#8217;s gonna be great strategy there just don&#8217;t go to bed. Also we both woke up at 4 o&#8217;clock this morning.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> All right any one or two questions we have time for officially but unofficially we will linger afterwards. Yes.</p><p><strong>Audience Member:</strong> Well I thought your position in favor of this case study was quite interesting because I would, I guess the Catholic Church says that is against the domination of technology over the creation of human life. So if any tinkering happens with that creation process, regardless of whether it is, for example, IVF, which includes two gametes coming together, they would be opposed to that. So I&#8217;m just trying to hear your rationale for being in favor of this proposition as a Catholic.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> Yeah, thank you. So this is where I think I would have to wrestle with it more.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> Defend thyself.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> Yeah, no, I think my initial take is that you are not actually, you are more like vaccinating gametes than you are interfering with reproduction in ways that the Catholic Church is opposed to. I don&#8217;t know. So I don&#8217;t know if Catholic ethicists have weighed in on this to see like, is this actually permissible given the framework that&#8217;s been defined so far? And I try to be as faithful as I can to those teachings. I just, this strikes me as more of a case of treating parents and then allowing them to naturally reproduce in ways that the Catholic Church hasn&#8217;t explicitly taught against.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> Well, the next time the Pope&#8217;s in town, you can ask him.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> I can ask him. Yeah, everyone in Chicago knows each other, so we&#8217;re buddies. But it actually does go to the comment in the back is my worry here is less about those teachings almost and more about the respect for human dignity across the board that might sort of be implicitly rejected by certain of these applications. So if we sort of, again, level the genetic pool, I think the church would have things to say about why that would be possible.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> That&#8217;s a tricky one. Last question, then we&#8217;re gonna have to call it quits formally.</p><p><strong>Audience Member:</strong> So this goes off of a question and then that dialogue you had about where you draw the line with certain conditions like autism and Down syndrome. And it got me thinking, and this is more just a question because I&#8217;m curious where you both stand on this, but the difference when the mind is introduced to the question where it&#8217;s like if you have something that affects them on like dementia, Alzheimer&#8217;s, I mean you could go like ALS, Parkinson&#8217;s, that sort of route where it&#8217;s still technically the mind. Do you think that sort of deserves its own question compared to more non-mental diseases and conditions?</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> Yeah, that&#8217;s a great question and I think what you brought up is something that is actually a pretty striking difference between Joe and I from our ethical frameworks. You are a, how do you, deontologist? I don&#8217;t know what I want. He&#8217;s more of a deontologist for those of you who are nerds, which he believes that there are rules and we follow the rules for the rules sake and you&#8217;re not, and that&#8217;s basically it. They&#8217;re good rules though, they&#8217;re good rules. Right, I fall more along the utilitarian perspective, which means that I would be more concerned about like, what is the level of suffering that you are either causing or reducing as a function of these technologies. And those inform how we think about these things.</p><p><strong>Joseph Vukov:</strong> I mean, I would also say in response to that is when it comes to specifically mental disorders or disabilities, I think this isn&#8217;t like a perfect test, but there are certain things where you would say, when I got the treatment, I&#8217;m more fully myself, right? So you would think that like, you know, I had depression or whatever, and then I went to medication and I felt like for the first time in years, I was back to being fully myself. I think it&#8217;s a nice test versus other kinds of things that might affect mental life. So again, something like Down syndrome affects your psychological life, but you&#8217;re altering who the person is, right? It&#8217;s not like they become more fully themselves by getting rid of that. I don&#8217;t know.</p><p>It&#8217;s not a perfect test case, but I would say that&#8217;s one of the things I ask: is the treatment making them more fully who they are, or is it changing them into somebody else? And I&#8217;m more okay with when it&#8217;s restoring personhood and less okay when it&#8217;s undermining that.</p><p><strong>Michael Burns:</strong> We are at time, so we&#8217;re going to formally call it. But like I said, we&#8217;re not leaving &#8212; we&#8217;re not leaving, so we&#8217;re gonna stick around. If you have questions and stuff, feel free to check &#8212; thank you very much for coming.</p><p class="button-wrapper" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/should-we-genetically-modify-human?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Share&quot;,&quot;action&quot;:null,&quot;class&quot;:null}" data-component-name="ButtonCreateButton"><a class="button primary" href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/should-we-genetically-modify-human?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share"><span>Share</span></a></p><div><hr></div><div class="subscription-widget-wrap-editor" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/subscribe?&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Subscribe&quot;,&quot;language&quot;:&quot;en&quot;}" data-component-name="SubscribeWidgetToDOM"><div class="subscription-widget show-subscribe"><div class="preamble"><p class="cta-caption"><em>Free The Inquiry</em> brings you essays, expert commentary, and conversations about open inquiry in the academy. Subscribe to stay up to date.</p></div><form class="subscription-widget-subscribe"><input type="email" class="email-input" name="email" placeholder="Type your email&#8230;" tabindex="-1"><input type="submit" class="button primary" value="Subscribe"><div class="fake-input-wrapper"><div class="fake-input"></div><div class="fake-button"></div></div></form></div></div><p></p>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Calling Your Opponents "Fascists" and "Murderers" Teaches Us That Disagreement is Hate]]></title><description><![CDATA[If universities want to help combat polarization, they must work to fix political bias on campus]]></description><link>https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/how-universities-normalized-calling</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/how-universities-normalized-calling</guid><dc:creator><![CDATA[Christian J. Pulver]]></dc:creator><pubDate>Wed, 14 Oct 2026 15:00:58 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!9-pX!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fb80d378d-e012-4bd0-828a-be1dced805ab_1456x1048.jpeg" length="0" type="image/jpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="captioned-image-container"><figure><a class="image-link image2 is-viewable-img" target="_blank" href="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!9-pX!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fb80d378d-e012-4bd0-828a-be1dced805ab_1456x1048.jpeg" data-component-name="Image2ToDOM"><div class="image2-inset"><picture><source type="image/webp" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!9-pX!,w_424,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fb80d378d-e012-4bd0-828a-be1dced805ab_1456x1048.jpeg 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!9-pX!,w_848,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fb80d378d-e012-4bd0-828a-be1dced805ab_1456x1048.jpeg 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!9-pX!,w_1272,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fb80d378d-e012-4bd0-828a-be1dced805ab_1456x1048.jpeg 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!9-pX!,w_1456,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fb80d378d-e012-4bd0-828a-be1dced805ab_1456x1048.jpeg 1456w" sizes="100vw"><img src="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!9-pX!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fb80d378d-e012-4bd0-828a-be1dced805ab_1456x1048.jpeg" width="1456" height="1048" data-attrs="{&quot;src&quot;:&quot;https://substack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/b80d378d-e012-4bd0-828a-be1dced805ab_1456x1048.jpeg&quot;,&quot;srcNoWatermark&quot;:null,&quot;fullscreen&quot;:null,&quot;imageSize&quot;:null,&quot;height&quot;:1048,&quot;width&quot;:1456,&quot;resizeWidth&quot;:null,&quot;bytes&quot;:1376156,&quot;alt&quot;:null,&quot;title&quot;:null,&quot;type&quot;:&quot;image/jpeg&quot;,&quot;href&quot;:null,&quot;belowTheFold&quot;:false,&quot;topImage&quot;:true,&quot;internalRedirect&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/i/213036483?img=https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fb80d378d-e012-4bd0-828a-be1dced805ab_1456x1048.jpeg&quot;,&quot;isProcessing&quot;:false,&quot;align&quot;:null,&quot;offset&quot;:false}" class="sizing-normal" alt="" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!9-pX!,w_424,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fb80d378d-e012-4bd0-828a-be1dced805ab_1456x1048.jpeg 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!9-pX!,w_848,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fb80d378d-e012-4bd0-828a-be1dced805ab_1456x1048.jpeg 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!9-pX!,w_1272,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fb80d378d-e012-4bd0-828a-be1dced805ab_1456x1048.jpeg 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!9-pX!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2Fb80d378d-e012-4bd0-828a-be1dced805ab_1456x1048.jpeg 1456w" sizes="100vw" fetchpriority="high"></picture><div class="image-link-expand"><div class="pencraft pc-display-flex pc-gap-8 pc-reset"><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container restack-image buttonBase-tqxFUX" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg aria-hidden="true" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 20 20" fill="none" stroke-width="1.5" stroke="var(--color-fg-primary)" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="icon-noB79L"><g><path d="M2.53001 7.81595C3.49179 4.73911 6.43281 2.5 9.91173 2.5C13.1684 2.5 15.9537 4.46214 17.0852 7.23684L17.6179 8.67647M17.6179 8.67647L18.5002 4.26471M17.6179 8.67647L13.6473 6.91176M17.4995 12.1841C16.5378 15.2609 13.5967 17.5 10.1178 17.5C6.86118 17.5 4.07589 15.5379 2.94432 12.7632L2.41165 11.3235M2.41165 11.3235L1.5293 15.7353M2.41165 11.3235L6.38224 13.0882"></path></g></svg></button><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container view-image buttonBase-tqxFUX" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="2" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" class="lucide lucide-maximize2 lucide-maximize-2 icon-noB79L"><polyline points="15 3 21 3 21 9"></polyline><polyline points="9 21 3 21 3 15"></polyline><line x1="21" x2="14" y1="3" y2="10"></line><line x1="3" x2="10" y1="21" y2="14"></line></svg></button></div></div></div></a><figcaption class="image-caption">"The Uprising (L'&#201;meute)" by Honor&#233; Daumier, 1848 or later. Wikimedia Commons, Public Domain.</figcaption></figure></div><p>It&#8217;s no secret that a majority of Americans have lost trust in universities. Survey research from <a href="https://news.gallup.com/poll/695003/perceived-importance-college-hits-new-low.aspx">Gallup</a> and <a href="https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2025/10/15/growing-share-of-americans-say-the-us-higher-education-system-is-headed-in-the-wrong-direction/">Pew</a> points to similar causes, including unfair admissions practices, high tuition costs, limited job opportunities for many graduates and, most importantly, extreme political bias. As universities across the country seek to address these concerns, I&#8217;d like to make a suggestion: Start at the heart of the matter and fix the political bias first. By doing so, universities can signal their commitment to institutional neutrality and take the lead in decreasing the political polarization that plagues U.S. politics and culture.</p><p>Since the 1960s, university faculty have consistently leaned liberal, but never to the extremes we see today. Nationwide survey data from the &#8220;<a href="https://president.yale.edu/posts/2026-04-15-report-of-the-committee-on-trust-in-higher-education">Report of the Yale Committee on Trust in Higher Education</a>&#8221; shows that over 90% of college and university faculty are registered Democrats. Granted, there is a range of beliefs within this large of a group, but it&#8217;s a glaring disparity, and it certainly doesn&#8217;t reflect the <a href="https://news.gallup.com/poll/15370/party-affiliation.aspx">actual political makeup of the United States</a>. The current homogeneity of thought on campuses has created a political monoculture that actively discourages viewpoint diversity, compels conformity, and divides society into tribes typically based on racial or gender identities.</p><p>No doubt, the suite of current progressive ideas about identity and culture are well intentioned, but as they&#8217;ve played out in institutions throughout the country over the past decade, it&#8217;s clear they&#8217;ve profoundly exacerbated polarization in the United States. There are many examples one could point to, but I&#8217;d argue the most harmful and far-reaching has been the normalization of <em>hyperbolic hate</em>.</p><p>The word &#8220;hyperbole&#8221; comes from the ancient Greek word to &#8220;throw beyond.&#8221; It is common in everyday speech. We hyperbolize when we exaggerate the details of a story (&#8220;I walked five miles to school, uphill both ways&#8221;) or when we feel passionately about something (&#8220;It&#8217;s the worst movie I&#8217;ve ever seen!&#8221;). Aristotle (384-322 BCE) considered hyperbole to be primarily a stylistic device orators used to express strong emotion. A few centuries later, Roman rhetorician Quintilian (35&#8211;100 CE) expanded this definition to emphasize how hyperbolic language subverts the truth:</p><blockquote><p>It is enough to say that hyperbole lies, though without any intention to deceive. But we must be careful to notice how far hyperbole is permissible... for if it goes beyond the proper bounds, the effect is lost, and the figure becomes ridiculous.</p></blockquote><p>For Quintilian, effective hyperbole was a kind of controlled fib that exceeds the truth without exceeding the credibility of the claim. Taken too far, hyperbole becomes &#8220;ridiculous.&#8221;</p><div class="pullquote"><p>The current homogeneity of thought on campuses has created a political monoculture that actively discourages viewpoint diversity, compels conformity, and divides society into tribes typically based on racial or gender identities.</p></div><p>While exaggerating a point can be rhetorically effective in the right situation, the stakes grow larger when the object of hyperbole is <em>hate</em>&#8212;the deliberate, exaggerated use of extreme language to malign the motives and beliefs of people who disagree with us. When we place this penchant for exaggeration into a media environment driven by profit and algorithmic control, hyperbolized hate becomes not just ridiculous but dangerous. Research on social media shows that extreme opinions on culture and politics <a href="https://www.annualreviews.org/content/journals/10.1146/annurev-psych-022123-110258">go viral more often</a> and circulate longer than more moderate content.</p><p>This is especially true of <a href="https://www.nature.com/articles/s41562-023-01582-0">inflated expressions of moral outrage</a> that exaggerate hate to denounce ideological opponents and unduly attribute harm where it doesn&#8217;t exist. Conservative groups that oppose abortion claim that pro-choice liberals are &#8220;murderers!&#8221; while progressive groups who support transgenderism claim that conservatives are &#8220;fascists!&#8221; It&#8217;s one thing to exaggerate how far you had to walk to school; it&#8217;s another to label someone&#8217;s motives as hateful because they disagree with your political and/or moral beliefs.</p><p>Universities are, in part, responsible for the rise of hyperbolic hate. Beginning with the shift to identity politics and critical theory in the 1960s, new &#8220;systemic&#8221; frameworks were developed for the study of culture. These frameworks focus on structural questions of power and inequity in search of the root causes of oppression in Western, capitalist, liberal societies. While they certainly can be an indispensable tool for studying social and cultural dynamics, systemic frameworks are rife with methodological and knowledge-based problems that ultimately encourage hyperbolic expressions of hate. In particular, their emphasis on vague, abstract &#8220;systems&#8221; of power makes those who embrace these ideas prone to erasing individual agency and the rich pluralism of real groups in favor of monolithic identity tribes.</p><p>This <a href="https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-experimental-political-science/article/abs/tribalism-in-america-behavioral-experiments-on-affective-polarization-in-the-trump-era/9587F190ADE5C838F709FCF460BFCB98">process of tribalization</a> intensifies polarization by persistently distorting our perception of citizens who disagree with us. When coupled with the reach and speed of modern social media, the use of these &#8220;systemic&#8221; frameworks to make extreme claims about ubiquitous racism or misogyny leads us all into a kind of mental inferno where hate is present everywhere and at all times.</p><p>Nothing could be worse for the mental health of our society than hyperbolized hate. Psychologists who study hate have shown that excessive exposure to hateful discourse leads to an array of social problems including <a href="https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32527858/">elevated threat perception</a> and more frequent <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/332288890_Partisan_Dehumanization_in_American_Politics">cycles of dehumanization</a> between opposing groups. Such inflated perceptions of hate are known to contribute to <a href="https://www.researchgate.net/publication/395694890_The_Cost_of_Saying_I_Hate_Linguistic_Hyperbole_Cognition_and_Emotional_Distortion">chronic stress and excessive catastrophizing</a> in individuals.</p><p>According to clinical psychologist John P. Kline, as more perceived hate circulates, it creates a noxious loop that &#8220;activates stronger affective response than warranted... [and] biases perception toward negativity.&#8221; It also escalates conflict, spreads hostility, and erodes trust, Kline adds. In such emotionally elevated environments, <a href="https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10011534/">the brain&#8217;s empathy response</a> toward opponents is known to shut down. Stuck in an empathy vacuum, we begin to perceive politics as a mortal struggle that, over time, conditions us to experience political and moral disagreement as a form of hate.</p><p>If universities are ever to help mitigate the polarization that plagues our society, they must renew their commitment to traditional liberal values of civil debate, free speech, open inquiry, and viewpoint diversity. This is only possible in an environment where we prioritize our common humanity over the echo chambers of our different identity tribes. By promoting a culture of shared optimism and hope over one of hate and division, higher education can begin the long process of restoring the public&#8217;s trust.</p><p class="button-wrapper" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/how-universities-normalized-calling?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Share&quot;,&quot;action&quot;:null,&quot;class&quot;:null}" data-component-name="ButtonCreateButton"><a class="button primary" href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/how-universities-normalized-calling?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share"><span>Share</span></a></p><div><hr></div><div class="subscription-widget-wrap-editor" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/subscribe?&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Subscribe&quot;,&quot;language&quot;:&quot;en&quot;}" data-component-name="SubscribeWidgetToDOM"><div class="subscription-widget show-subscribe"><div class="preamble"><p class="cta-caption">Subscribe to stay <em>inquisitive.</em></p></div><form class="subscription-widget-subscribe"><input type="email" class="email-input" name="email" placeholder="Type your email&#8230;" tabindex="-1"><input type="submit" class="button primary" value="Subscribe"><div class="fake-input-wrapper"><div class="fake-input"></div><div class="fake-button"></div></div></form></div></div>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[The Modern University Barely Needs Students Anymore]]></title><description><![CDATA[With the arrival of the digital tsunami, universities have lapsed into a crisis of authority]]></description><link>https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/the-university-may-not-survive-the</link><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/the-university-may-not-survive-the</guid><dc:creator><![CDATA[Martin Gurri]]></dc:creator><pubDate>Thu, 08 Oct 2026 12:02:00 GMT</pubDate><enclosure url="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!EQ37!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F8640a8b0-6dee-49d8-aeec-59860e324b72_1456x1048.jpeg" length="0" type="image/jpeg"/><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="captioned-image-container"><figure><a class="image-link image2 is-viewable-img" target="_blank" href="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!EQ37!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F8640a8b0-6dee-49d8-aeec-59860e324b72_1456x1048.jpeg" data-component-name="Image2ToDOM"><div class="image2-inset"><picture><source type="image/webp" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!EQ37!,w_424,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F8640a8b0-6dee-49d8-aeec-59860e324b72_1456x1048.jpeg 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!EQ37!,w_848,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F8640a8b0-6dee-49d8-aeec-59860e324b72_1456x1048.jpeg 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!EQ37!,w_1272,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F8640a8b0-6dee-49d8-aeec-59860e324b72_1456x1048.jpeg 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!EQ37!,w_1456,c_limit,f_webp,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F8640a8b0-6dee-49d8-aeec-59860e324b72_1456x1048.jpeg 1456w" sizes="100vw"><img src="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!EQ37!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F8640a8b0-6dee-49d8-aeec-59860e324b72_1456x1048.jpeg" width="1456" height="1048" data-attrs="{&quot;src&quot;:&quot;https://substack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com/public/images/8640a8b0-6dee-49d8-aeec-59860e324b72_1456x1048.jpeg&quot;,&quot;srcNoWatermark&quot;:null,&quot;fullscreen&quot;:null,&quot;imageSize&quot;:null,&quot;height&quot;:1048,&quot;width&quot;:1456,&quot;resizeWidth&quot;:null,&quot;bytes&quot;:1660003,&quot;alt&quot;:null,&quot;title&quot;:null,&quot;type&quot;:&quot;image/jpeg&quot;,&quot;href&quot;:null,&quot;belowTheFold&quot;:false,&quot;topImage&quot;:true,&quot;internalRedirect&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/i/213036058?img=https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F8640a8b0-6dee-49d8-aeec-59860e324b72_1456x1048.jpeg&quot;,&quot;isProcessing&quot;:false,&quot;align&quot;:null,&quot;offset&quot;:false}" class="sizing-normal" alt="" srcset="https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!EQ37!,w_424,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F8640a8b0-6dee-49d8-aeec-59860e324b72_1456x1048.jpeg 424w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!EQ37!,w_848,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F8640a8b0-6dee-49d8-aeec-59860e324b72_1456x1048.jpeg 848w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!EQ37!,w_1272,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F8640a8b0-6dee-49d8-aeec-59860e324b72_1456x1048.jpeg 1272w, https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!EQ37!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F8640a8b0-6dee-49d8-aeec-59860e324b72_1456x1048.jpeg 1456w" sizes="100vw" fetchpriority="high"></picture><div class="image-link-expand"><div class="pencraft pc-display-flex pc-gap-8 pc-reset"><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container restack-image buttonBase-GK1x3M" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg aria-hidden="true" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 20 20" fill="none" stroke-width="1.5" stroke="var(--color-fg-primary)" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" class="icon-noB79L"><g><path d="M2.53001 7.81595C3.49179 4.73911 6.43281 2.5 9.91173 2.5C13.1684 2.5 15.9537 4.46214 17.0852 7.23684L17.6179 8.67647M17.6179 8.67647L18.5002 4.26471M17.6179 8.67647L13.6473 6.91176M17.4995 12.1841C16.5378 15.2609 13.5967 17.5 10.1178 17.5C6.86118 17.5 4.07589 15.5379 2.94432 12.7632L2.41165 11.3235M2.41165 11.3235L1.5293 15.7353M2.41165 11.3235L6.38224 13.0882"></path></g></svg></button><button class="pencraft pc-reset pencraft icon-container view-image buttonBase-GK1x3M" tabindex="0" type="button"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 24 24" fill="none" stroke="currentColor" stroke-width="2" stroke-linecap="round" stroke-linejoin="round" class="lucide lucide-maximize2 lucide-maximize-2 icon-noB79L"><polyline points="15 3 21 3 21 9"></polyline><polyline points="9 21 3 21 3 15"></polyline><line x1="21" x2="14" y1="3" y2="10"></line><line x1="3" x2="10" y1="21" y2="14"></line></svg></button></div></div></div></a><figcaption class="image-caption">"Ship on Stormy Seas" by Ivan Aivazovsky, c. 1858. Wikimedia Commons, Public Domain.</figcaption></figure></div><p>Much of the trust crisis that has engulfed higher education stems from the fact that in the minds of a growing number of Americans, universities have been implicated in many of the intellectual maladies that afflict the present moment. Indeed, the academy, particularly at its most prestigious institutions, is increasingly seen as a breeding ground for anti-democratic elites as well as ground zero for the spread of the cult of identity, which aims to abolish history and even learning on behalf of perfect &#8220;equity&#8221; among victim groups.</p><p>Meanwhile, a significant number of university faculty promote the postmodernist notion that truth and science are empty constructs wielded by oppressors, which must be rejected by all right-thinking people. As if this wasn&#8217;t enough, universities have also been charged with training a generation of students to fear the clash of ideas as &#8220;harm&#8221; and to demand &#8220;safe spaces&#8221; from disagreeable opinions.</p><p>At the same time, and not coincidentally, the academy has been battered by the turbulence inherent to the digital age. A feudal institution reformed along rigid German lines more than a century ago, the university confronts an environment of instant communication and collapsed categories, defined by a deafening cacophony of voices and a near-infinite supply of information. This development, more even than concerns about &#8220;wokeism&#8221; and the like on campus, poses the greatest threat to the future of higher education.</p><p>The leading institutions of the 21st century received their structural form in the 20th, and based their authority on the possession of information when this was a rare commodity. With the arrival of the digital tsunami, institutions have lapsed into a crisis of authority&#8212;and the university is no exception. In the last century, academic scholarship mapped out many domains for general discussion, in economic and constitutional affairs, for example.</p><p>Today, everything gets shouted out in the Babel of the web. Every institutional failure, too, is exposed to the eyes of a mistrustful public&#8212;from corrupt university admissions policies to actual research fraud. Academics who speak <em>ex cathedra</em> are mocked without mercy for their pretension. Those who claim to be scholars or experts either get buried alive in the digital din or learn to scream along with the amateurs.</p><p>The hemorrhage of authority, on the face of it, appears surprising. An institution dedicated to learning and research should be expected to thrive in a &#8220;knowledge economy&#8221; and an age of information. However, the digital landscape favors speed and fluidity, and the university remains frozen in an inflexible industrial model driven by funding and growth, which must prioritize relations with patrons in the great hierarchies of government and business.</p><div class="pullquote"><p>A feudal institution reformed along rigid German lines more than a century ago, the university confronts an environment of instant communication and collapsed categories, defined by a deafening cacophony of voices and a near-infinite supply of information.</p></div><p>Typically, in the U.S., the president of a university isn&#8217;t a beacon of scholarship but a proficient and well-connected fundraiser. The university, as an industry, does still manage to produce the &#8220;meritocratic&#8221; elites that populate our society&#8217;s hierarchies; otherwise, students are almost incidental to its functions.</p><p>At many universities, the average American student has become a mere conduit for massive government largesse: federal loans that inflate the system to<a href="https://educationdata.org/student-loan-debt-statistics"> the tune of $1.8 trillion</a> (2026). These universities take the money but make no commitments regarding the quality or usefulness of their product; in fact, they are resistant to most efforts to quantify the value of their credentialing. The student is guaranteed only the debt. The federal government also<a href="https://www.aau.edu/newsroom/leading-research-universities-report/university-investments-research-continue-grow"> bestows $65 billion</a> on academic research grants (2024). Corporate and private &#8220;endowments&#8221; to universities&#8212;gifts with strings attached&#8212;reached<a href="https://www.highereddive.com/news/down-92-colleges-see-drop-in-new-gifts-to-endowments/812028/"> a market value of $944.3 billion</a> in 2026. At $1 billion per year, the income extracted from the performance of unpaid student athletes amounts to pocket change.</p><p>The current purpose&#8212;if not quite the mission&#8212;of the university is increasingly focused on the accumulation of large sums of money, which are lavished on magnificent construction projects and a fast-growing army of administrative drones. Success is highly skewed. On the far tail of the power curve, 521 U.S. colleges closed or merged during the last 10 years. At the top, Harvard, whose<a href="https://finance.harvard.edu/endowment"> endowment of nearly $57 billion</a> is more than double the gross national product of Nicaragua, increasingly seems to be less a place of learning than a miniature but pleasant nation-state, like Monaco or Dubai. If Harvard so wished, it could easily dispense with students altogether.</p><p>The marginalization of the student in the digital age has brought the university to a moment of reckoning. Because of access to easy federal money, the cost of attending a four-year school has doubled since 2000. The ballooning student debt burden has become a political scandal. The economic sacrifice is now prolonged and often futile: <a href="https://completecollege.org/news/a-commencement-season-reminder-far-too-many-students-never-complete-college/">nearly 4 out of 10 students</a> never graduate, and those who do take an average of six years to earn a four-year degree. Not surprisingly, overall enrollment peaked in 2010 and has since declined by more than 10%. An ever-expanding array of other choices, often involving online education, are both available and affordable.</p><div class="pullquote"><p>At the top, Harvard, increasingly seems to be less a place of learning than a miniature but pleasant nation-state, like Monaco or Dubai. If Harvard so wished, it could easily dispense with students altogether.</p></div><p>So far, the decline has been relatively gentle. Students are marginalized but not yet alienated. Despite the cost and the institutional indifference, there has been no revolt or mass migration away from the university system. However, much of the perceived value that lures 20 million young Americans to campus every year depends on two uncertain and increasingly dubious propositions. One is that the university offers a gateway to truth and can initiate individuals into the methods of science and wisdom. The other is that college networking and degrees are necessary for material success in the modern world.</p><p>Neither claim conforms to current reality. The wisdom of the Western tradition that might have served as an anchor to young minds in the midst of the digital storm has largely been repudiated in favor of a robotic activism on behalf of the great progressive omnicause. For the same reason, the only networking that is considered legitimate runs along racial, sexual, and other identitarian lines.</p><p>Sitting atop a mountain of money, prestige universities increasingly play with the sanity of students they no longer really need. The other schools, though less privileged, follow their lead. This can&#8217;t last. The old norms of higher learning have been abandoned by its practitioners. A revolt may soon be coming that will sweep aside what remains.</p><p>Whether it comes from the abused and indebted students, the parents who often pay exorbitantly for the miseducation of their children, or new schools with more adaptive norms and curriculums&#8212;or all of the above&#8212;I&#8217;m in no position to say. But a glimpse at the present system should be enough to see that the American university is moribund, and that without a major reassessment of its mission and methods, what we now call higher education might no longer exist in a few decades time.</p><p class="button-wrapper" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/the-university-may-not-survive-the?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Share&quot;,&quot;action&quot;:null,&quot;class&quot;:null}" data-component-name="ButtonCreateButton"><a class="button primary" href="https://www.freetheinquiry.com/p/the-university-may-not-survive-the?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email&utm_content=share&action=share"><span>Share</span></a></p><div><hr></div><div class="subscription-widget-wrap-editor" data-attrs="{&quot;url&quot;:&quot;https://www.freetheinquiry.com/subscribe?&quot;,&quot;text&quot;:&quot;Subscribe&quot;,&quot;language&quot;:&quot;en&quot;}" data-component-name="SubscribeWidgetToDOM"><div class="subscription-widget show-subscribe"><div class="preamble"><p class="cta-caption">Subscribe to stay <em>inquisitive.</em></p></div><form class="subscription-widget-subscribe"><input type="email" class="email-input" name="email" placeholder="Type your email&#8230;" tabindex="-1"><input type="submit" class="button primary" value="Subscribe"><div class="fake-input-wrapper"><div class="fake-input"></div><div class="fake-button"></div></div></form></div></div>]]></content:encoded></item></channel></rss>